News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by ars on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:18PM (#5930188)
> danenania's point remains valid if the Israel part is omitted.

You mean "only if". The Muslims who hate Jews (and via extension Israel), are happy to hate America without any help from America's policies.

It makes no difference what Israel does - they will hate Jews and Israel without reservations and without end. The only thing Israel can do is make them scared, which will hopefully keep their hate in theory and not in practice.

Danenania: Are you really naive enough to believe that if Israel makes "peace", and/or gives up land it will help? Israel made peace with Egypt, and gave up tons of land - but the people there still hate Israel and wish for its destruction.

Israel made peace with Jordan and gave up land and water - but the people of Jordan still hate Israel.

You really think it's America's policies that cause the hate? It's not. It's what America stands for - primarily freedom of religion, and the acceptance of secularism.

Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by danenania on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:54PM (#5930308)
Regardless of one's perspective on the Israel-Palestine conflict, the fact remains that providing extensive military support to a nation that is a symbol of oppression in the region greatly increases the risk of terrorist attacks against the US. Save for a tiny elite, there is no corresponding benefit for the American people that justifies this risk, while the costs are many.
Re:Chomsky: spying does not protect you by ars on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:12PM (#5930382)
You mean a symbol of freedom not oppression.

I am aware of how jealous the Arabs are of Israel, and how they wish they could also have those freedoms. It's of course part of the reason that the Arab administrations demonize Israel so much - so that their own people don't complain about their own countries.

But that's exactly why the US should support them so strongly, this is what America was founded on. Even if there is no benefit.

> greatly increases the risk of terrorist attacks against the US.

No it doesn't. America is also a symbol of freedom, just like Israel and they hate America just fine, even without mentioning Israel.

But you are wrong about the benefits though, just for the consumer an enormous amount of technology comes out of Israel. And for America to turn away from Israel would be the same as renouncing the principles America was founded on. I hope to never see a day when America doesn't at least try to uphold these values (even if the actions aren't what they should, at least the ideal is there).

I'm sure you've head the saying about trading security for liberty. And the same is true for ideals. Sometimes you have to fight for your ideals. Even if there is a cost. The downsides of having no ideals at all is just not worth it.