Factors of 2 or 3 in specific power and efficiency are possible. Due to the rocket equation, this could yield vastly longer range and more efficient aircraft (1/10 the weight, 10x the range, 10x the efficiency, 2x the speed...).
In particular, you point out the limitations of the Brayton cycle and material limitations. However, there are other cycles that are much closer to Carnot efficiency, or match it in the ideal case. There's a lot you can do when isothermal compression is possible. Additionally, if there is a thermal limitation, you can do isothermal combustion, such that much more heat addition is at the maximum temperature of your materials, and you can even design efficient reheating.
It's not a jet -- you want to pair this with a driven fan system or at least have high bypass, but it's fundamentally more thermodynamically efficient.
For supersonic applications, scramjets remain possible, but challenging. And rocketry + high altitude flight remains extremely exciting and potentially more efficient than standard jetliner transport. Just difficult.
So yes, there are physical limitations. But they are not what most people think they are, and they do not mean what people think they mean.
But: a) all that is risky and extremely expensive (and as the semiconductor example shows us, often exponentially so); and b) whatever technology you use, you will always be pushing up against physical limits--that's just the nature of the physical engineering disciplines.
These are novel concepts in a world where we see "technological progress" as the evolution of the internet from AOL in 1995 to Facebook in 2010 and wonder why other areas don't improve so fast.
PS) I'd be quite interested to see any specific papers you had in mind vis-a-vis alternative cycles for jet engines.
I don't usually work from the literature (it is hard to access papers outside of academia, and they're usually weird, abstract, hard to read, and miss the point anyway) so I work from the first principles.
But at a high level, imagine either an Ericsson or Carnot cycle, (dependent on materials), where high temp, high pressure heat addition is contiguous combustion during expansion, and the isothermal compression is a secret sauce :-)
Amazing.
Say what you will about HN, but comment threads about seemingly impossible technical challenges that end in this make me immensely happy to be here :D
[1]: http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2011/0...
I note that in it, Stephenson makes a prediction, as if it were a known fact, that I think we now have significant reason to doubt.
He says "Rockets are as close to perfect as they're ever going to get. For a few more billion dollars we might be able to achieve a microscopic improvement in efficiency or reliability, but to make any game-changing improvements is not merely expensive; it's a physical impossibility."
I think we now have reason to believe that for around a billion dollars ($1b is the estimated total R&D budget as of a year ago), SpaceX has already made better-than-microscopic improvements in efficiency. But more interestingly, there's reason to believe that with little or no additional outside investment (i.e. working on profits), SpaceX is pretty likely to soon make a very large improvement in efficiency, with Grasshopper &c. Rockets are probably not as perfect as they're ever going to get.
Still a very impressive achievement, but looking at the performance of SpaceX's engines circa 2012 and comparing them to what the Soviets built in 1960 or 1970 helps put the pace of the industry into context.
The relevant efficiency, to me, is "awesomeness achieved per human effort and non-renewable resource", and the useful proxy for this is "awesomeness per price". Arguably SpaceX rockets are cheaper (per given mass to given orbit, obviously) that most or arguably all of the competition. I say "arguably cheaper" because it's a little tough to figure out how to price the shoulders of giants on which they stand.
And really I only picked the word "efficiency" in the context of Stephenson's "efficiency or reliability".
Anyway, hopefully this explains why I think that true reusable rockets, Musk's often-stated ambition, qualify as a "very large improvement" in efficiency. Specific impulse is not expected to significantly improve, right?
Also, I apologize in advance for my legion failings in the area of comprehending aerospace engineering.
Do you think think it's unreasonable to call "payload per cost" a relevant "efficiency"?
1. There are people it would inspire, and
2. There are people whose expectations would be shaken up
The latter group needs as much help as the former.
The important difference is that there are now millions of black American kids no longer growing up in a world where they just "know" as a first principle that "black people can't be president". That sort of example simply changes people's outlook. Inspiration and aspiration matter.
That's precisely the shakeup the world needs - to realise that whatever skin colour, male or female, people are people and you shouldn't judge them negatively or positively on how much melanin or testosterone they produce :P
In practice, the kinds of people that can discuss ideas that push the state of the art forward are so rare that you should be grateful that your society gets any, and not worry so much about their genitalia.
Effect of estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone on cognition.
> Factors of 2 or 3 in specific power and efficiency are possible. Due to the rocket equation, this could yield vastly longer range and more efficient aircraft (1/10 the weight, 10x the range, 10x the efficiency, 2x the speed...).
I'd like to hear about these, assuming they produce comparable amounts of thrust as jet engines while being a reasonable size (so as not to increase drag excessively).
The main one that comes to mind is nuclear fusion... The power of the sun. We see and rely on it every day. We know it's possible to create with a trivial set-up: lot's of crap thrown together. We haven't figured out how to control it yet but once we do, it'll change everything.
So you're right: there are physical limits and some absolute of course, but we're not at the absolutes yet: it's just going to be a very step-wise function on the way up.
edit: while this may seem tangential to a discussion of jet engines: imagine if we did harness fusion... think about the aeronautical implications. We could probably have helicopter islands like in a Sci-Fi film. :)
"The power production density of the core overall is similar to the metabolic production density of a reptile. The peak power production in the Sun's center, per volume, has been compared to the volumetric heat generated in an active compost heap. The tremendous power output of the Sun is due not to its high power per volume, but rather to its gigantic size." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_core
But if you were able to contain a golf ball of sun, the heat it produced would be able to power far more than a reptile's brain as its heat was transfered to the environment...
_Perhaps_ you're pointing out that the sun's size is what allows it to 'contain' these many otherwise-uncontainable golf-ball size chunks. If so, I hear you... obviously the engineering challenge is developing a system on earth to contain. We've clearly shown with fusion bombs that we can harness this effect for a net energy gain for an instant.
My point was that these are engineering challenges, rather than physical limits.
It is you who is misunderstanding the concept here. A golf ball of Sun produces heat only about as much as the reptile brain. In other way - if you put as many reptile brains in one pile so that the pile will be as large as Sun, you'll get the pile radiating with Sun's black-body radiation temperature and intensity. The trick here is that amount of energy produced is proportional to volume, while radiating surface is just square-proportional, thus black-body radiation temperature (i.e. frequency, ie. energy of a given radiated photon) of a pile of reptile brains (or golf-ball sized chunks of Sun) would be much higher than that of a one brain or the same set of brains (or chunks of Sun) spread around with significant distances between each other.
Edit: it isn't to say that fusion power can't be used as a practical source of energy on Earth. It is just some forms of [stationary] containment are ruled out, mainly by bremsstrahlung (Sun overcomes it precisely because of volume to ratio being big enough). Dynamic forms of containment are proven to be working (net-positive) at least by H-bomb.
I think what you're saying, though, is that if you contain something extremely hot and dense, you cannot get any useful energy out... Because the energy needed to contain it prevents you from getting anything out. Right?
Because I'm coming from a perspective that says: if you can contain something like a small bit of solar core: and if you can let some of that heat leak to the outside environment: you can derive terrific power from the thermal dynamics at work.
The sun exists in the pressure-free vacuum and thus extends to a far less dense outer layer where the heat gradient (the argument against power potential per volume) is low. However if you could contain the sun into a smaller volume, it would have the same massive heat flux but over a much lower surface area and thus with far more power potential per volume.
I assume we're not so much disagreeing: over focusing on different issues. Is it correct that you're saying that the act of containment itself prevents the ability to harness the flux?
People romanticize the notion of Fusion. It's a great thing, no doubt, But to say:
> We could probably have helicopter islands like in a Sci-Fi film.
Feels a little bit to me like people saying the same thing when they first discovered refined petroleum.
Having said that we've made massive progress towards energy positive fusion with both magnetic confinement, and inertial confinement, And it's not crazy to think they may provide good usable power into our grid within our lifetimes.
We have no idea where the theoretical limit is in automatic natuaral language understanding for instance. Yet the rewards of any breakthroughs there would be enormous.
But I'm actually not so sure if hardware and software are really that different in terms of theoretical limits. The incentive to optimize existing approaches instead of exploring completely new directions in hardware may be be a result of much higher capital requirements for anything physical.
It's not really the problem that there aren't very many people working on replacing jet engines. The issue is that the problem domain is full of physical limits. Ask yourself: why are we still using quicksort now, half a century after it was developed? Well, because theory tells us that any sorting algorithm based on binary comparisons is going to require at least O(n log(n)) such comparisons, and that is going to remain the case no matter how much engineering effort you throw at the problem. All you can really do when it comes to sorting algorithms is improve on the constant factors and take advantage of special cases (radix sort for small integer items, etc).
Software engineers don't usually have to think in terms of theoretical limits. But when I was in engineering school, as an aerospace major, every course began with: these are the theoretical limits in this particular area--all you can do is approach them more closely. A Brayton cycle has a certain efficiency at a given pressure ratio and an airfoil has a certain maximum lift-curve slope and there is nothing you can do about it. Improvements are in "hard engineering"--new materials that can withstand higher temperatures and pressures to eke out slightly more efficiency, etc. You're already seeing this in semiconductor manufacturing. As you run into the limits of lithography with ever-smaller wavelengths of light, semiconductor fabrication plants get exponentially more expensive to build.
These physical limits are what give the traditional engineering fields the shape of their "innovation curve." Much more happened in aerospace engineering from 1930 to 1960 than has (and will) happen from 1960 to 2020. The long-hanging fruit is gone, and all that's left is hard engineering.
And of course, this all plays into the "get rich quick" issue the author brings up. If you had a billion dollars lying around, where would you invest that money? A jet engine that's 0.5% more efficient? If you had $100 billion, would you spend it making an alternative to jet engines entirely (in an industry where people will fly on truly shitty airlines just to save $5 on a ticket)?