But: a) all that is risky and extremely expensive (and as the semiconductor example shows us, often exponentially so); and b) whatever technology you use, you will always be pushing up against physical limits--that's just the nature of the physical engineering disciplines.
These are novel concepts in a world where we see "technological progress" as the evolution of the internet from AOL in 1995 to Facebook in 2010 and wonder why other areas don't improve so fast.
PS) I'd be quite interested to see any specific papers you had in mind vis-a-vis alternative cycles for jet engines.
I don't usually work from the literature (it is hard to access papers outside of academia, and they're usually weird, abstract, hard to read, and miss the point anyway) so I work from the first principles.
But at a high level, imagine either an Ericsson or Carnot cycle, (dependent on materials), where high temp, high pressure heat addition is contiguous combustion during expansion, and the isothermal compression is a secret sauce :-)
Amazing.
Say what you will about HN, but comment threads about seemingly impossible technical challenges that end in this make me immensely happy to be here :D
[1]: http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2011/0...
I note that in it, Stephenson makes a prediction, as if it were a known fact, that I think we now have significant reason to doubt.
He says "Rockets are as close to perfect as they're ever going to get. For a few more billion dollars we might be able to achieve a microscopic improvement in efficiency or reliability, but to make any game-changing improvements is not merely expensive; it's a physical impossibility."
I think we now have reason to believe that for around a billion dollars ($1b is the estimated total R&D budget as of a year ago), SpaceX has already made better-than-microscopic improvements in efficiency. But more interestingly, there's reason to believe that with little or no additional outside investment (i.e. working on profits), SpaceX is pretty likely to soon make a very large improvement in efficiency, with Grasshopper &c. Rockets are probably not as perfect as they're ever going to get.
Still a very impressive achievement, but looking at the performance of SpaceX's engines circa 2012 and comparing them to what the Soviets built in 1960 or 1970 helps put the pace of the industry into context.
The relevant efficiency, to me, is "awesomeness achieved per human effort and non-renewable resource", and the useful proxy for this is "awesomeness per price". Arguably SpaceX rockets are cheaper (per given mass to given orbit, obviously) that most or arguably all of the competition. I say "arguably cheaper" because it's a little tough to figure out how to price the shoulders of giants on which they stand.
And really I only picked the word "efficiency" in the context of Stephenson's "efficiency or reliability".
Anyway, hopefully this explains why I think that true reusable rockets, Musk's often-stated ambition, qualify as a "very large improvement" in efficiency. Specific impulse is not expected to significantly improve, right?
Also, I apologize in advance for my legion failings in the area of comprehending aerospace engineering.
Do you think think it's unreasonable to call "payload per cost" a relevant "efficiency"?
1. There are people it would inspire, and
2. There are people whose expectations would be shaken up
The latter group needs as much help as the former.
The important difference is that there are now millions of black American kids no longer growing up in a world where they just "know" as a first principle that "black people can't be president". That sort of example simply changes people's outlook. Inspiration and aspiration matter.
That's precisely the shakeup the world needs - to realise that whatever skin colour, male or female, people are people and you shouldn't judge them negatively or positively on how much melanin or testosterone they produce :P
In practice, the kinds of people that can discuss ideas that push the state of the art forward are so rare that you should be grateful that your society gets any, and not worry so much about their genitalia.
Effect of estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone on cognition.
> Factors of 2 or 3 in specific power and efficiency are possible. Due to the rocket equation, this could yield vastly longer range and more efficient aircraft (1/10 the weight, 10x the range, 10x the efficiency, 2x the speed...).
I'd like to hear about these, assuming they produce comparable amounts of thrust as jet engines while being a reasonable size (so as not to increase drag excessively).
Factors of 2 or 3 in specific power and efficiency are possible. Due to the rocket equation, this could yield vastly longer range and more efficient aircraft (1/10 the weight, 10x the range, 10x the efficiency, 2x the speed...).
In particular, you point out the limitations of the Brayton cycle and material limitations. However, there are other cycles that are much closer to Carnot efficiency, or match it in the ideal case. There's a lot you can do when isothermal compression is possible. Additionally, if there is a thermal limitation, you can do isothermal combustion, such that much more heat addition is at the maximum temperature of your materials, and you can even design efficient reheating.
It's not a jet -- you want to pair this with a driven fan system or at least have high bypass, but it's fundamentally more thermodynamically efficient.
For supersonic applications, scramjets remain possible, but challenging. And rocketry + high altitude flight remains extremely exciting and potentially more efficient than standard jetliner transport. Just difficult.
So yes, there are physical limitations. But they are not what most people think they are, and they do not mean what people think they mean.