News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by tripzilch on Monday June 17, 2013 @10:47AM (#5893461)
Oooh, this one from the article comments, one that tptacek will be happy about ;) (and it's a good question, to settle):

> Define in as much detail as you can what "direct access" means.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by mikeevans on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:29AM (#5893712)
Unfortunately he didn't really answer it.

"More detail on how direct NSA's accesses are is coming, but in general, the reality is this: if an NSA, FBI, CIA, DIA, etc analyst has access to query raw SIGINT databases, they can enter and get results for anything they want. Phone number, email, user id, cell phone handset id (IMEI), and so on - it's all the same. The restrictions against this are policy based, not technically based, and can change at any time. Additionally, audits are cursory, incomplete, and easily fooled by fake justifications. For at least GCHQ, the number of audited queries is only 5% of those performed."

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by thrownaway2424 on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:40AM (#5893789)
No, he did answer the question, with the biggest walk-back in the history of whistle-blowing. He defined it as "direct access" to internal databases of shit the NSA has already collected. Absolutely not the same as what Snowden was selling the newspaper reporters a week ago, which was "direct access" to Google servers.

Also, by the way, 5% auditing is an very high rate. With a 5% audit rate, you'll catch evil-doers in no time at all.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by retube on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:33PM (#5894117)
Yes, and the guardian actually published a (tiny) retraction to this effect. So tiny I can't find it, but yes the central, core, money-shot claim is actually patently not true.

edit: I found this on the issue: http://www.zdnet.com/the-real-story-in-the-nsa-scandal-is-th...

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by codeulike on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:52AM (#5893870)
But the picture I'm getting is that they 'collect' everything (via fibre intercepts etc), because they've interpreted the rules as being "collect everything but then ask permission to look at it"
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by thrownaway2424 on Monday June 17, 2013 @03:42PM (#5895423)
"Collect everything; analyze later" is not a feasible strategy. Nobody has that kind of storage, and even if they did, nobody has the CPUs to ingest the stream. I think it goes without saying that you need a Google-scale computer to ingest Google-scale network traffic, and that's just one of the companies in question, on top of all the public transit bandwidth. Nobody has presented any evidence that the NSA has computing facilities on that scale. The only one we know of is not yet built, and way too small.

I think it is completely feasible that the NSA would or does collect all or a great deal of voice traffic, because that's a tiny piece of network traffic these days.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by logn on Monday June 17, 2013 @09:24PM (#5897010)
I've always assumed the US gov't does have this computing power and that's why we spend so much on national defense. Besides, when you employ more mathematicians than anyone else, I'm sure you can come up with some smart ways to store big data. Also, I think it would be fairly cheap to just write everything out to tapes or disk and dump them in a closet, even if you don't have the money to load them all in a database (so that you can put them online when technology improves or you have more budget/time). Further, I haven't seen where Snowden clearly retracted his 'direct access' assertion. You might keep some identifiers in a database and the whole dataset on a user can be ingested on demand from Google or whichever company (even if that means sending an automated request to Google which automatically responds by dumping data to FTP).
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by brown9-2 on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:59AM (#5893910)
Which still doesn't mean that the NSA has "direct access" to any server owned by Google/Facebook/Microsoft.
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by grey-area on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:17PM (#5894012)
Did Snowden say "direct access" in his interview or elsewhere? I thought that was an extrapolation of journalists writing about his story afterward (who also got details like the salary slightly wrong), taken from the wording on the slides, and reinforced in people's minds by the denials from Google et al which talked of backdoors etc? I don't think he made any claims about direct access, only that he could access all account details including emails etc if he had 'the proper authorities' as he puts it (which is pretty consistent with the slides and with the Google claims).

I don't remember him using that particular phrase at all at least in his initial video - I remember him talking about the ease with which they could access data using a 'selector' like an email address, not making claims about specific connections to servers or anything similar. He's not responsible for what journalists say, and we can't expect them to clearly restate it all the time, but what we do know about the extent of surveillance is disturbing. It's still unclear exactly what is recorded, when and how and I'm sure we'd all love to know more, but in the meantime it's not very useful to try to discredit his claims based on the interpretations of others.

https://eslkevin.wordpress.com/2013/06/10/edward-snowden-int...

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by brown9-2 on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:33PM (#5894113)
Yes, it's an extrapolation from the slides.

My beef with the phrase though is that Greenwald keeps repeating it and sticks by the story that the NSA slides said it so it must mean something, without bothering to ask his supposedly very knowledgable source to expand further on the topic.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by nitrogen on Monday June 17, 2013 @03:48PM (#5895457)
Why is "walkback" the term everyone is using?
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by thrownaway2424 on Monday June 17, 2013 @03:56PM (#5895528)
To walk a story back is journalism industry jargon for slowly dropping claims made in your initial story, until there's nothing of substance remaining.

Going from "NSA has direct access to servers of major internet companies" to "Some NSA analysts' database accesses inadequately audited, according to random sysadmin" is a textbook walk-back. Of course you will never see the latter headline on Greenwald's blog.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by morsch on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:47AM (#5893845)
Not necessarily, if those audits are "cursory, incomplete, and easily fooled".
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by ianhawes on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:35PM (#5894132)
I don't think Snowden would have any idea whether the audits were effective or not. An analyst in the position of auditing is likely segregated from the employees whose searches are audited.
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by Amadou on Monday June 17, 2013 @03:46PM (#5895449)
I think it is entirely plausible that a sysadmin would know exactly what logs the auditors inspect and that he would know the things like how often the logs were deleted as well as exactly what information is (and is not) captured in the logs. He may even have had access to the same tools the auditors used so that he could run them himself and see what they flagged and didn't flag.

It is my experience that systems auditors rely heavily on sysadmins to do their jobs. At a minimum the auditors are "just" another set of users and the sysadmins' responsibilities include supporting the auditors even more closely than they support regular users of classified systems. Frequently the auditors themselves do not have systems-level knowledge of the computers they are auditing.

Security on every classified system that I've seen was generally limited to a series of a checklists that some talented specialists once put down in a manual and are left to low-skilled employees to check off each day/week/month - if it isn't specifically on the checklist they have little to no knowledge of it. That includes glaring procedural holes. Essentially security is all CYA, so that everybody involved can say they followed the rules and not lose their job if something goes wrong.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by Spooky23 on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:52PM (#5894262)
He may have guidance about the types of things that auditors are looking for.

For example, checking out your neighbor, girlfriend or a public person's records for curiosity is probably a big red flag.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by chris_mahan on Monday June 17, 2013 @04:58PM (#5895908)
In answer to the first question, he writes:

"...Not only that, when NSA makes a technical mistake during an exploitation operation, critical systems crash. ..."

Well, if they have no access to the actual company servers, how could you then reconcile the above statement?

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by dsuth on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @01:35AM (#5897734)
That statement was in regards to their widespread international network intrusions into potentially critical networks, not authorised access to American companies.
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by discostrings on Monday June 17, 2013 @12:57PM (#5894294)
He answered the question that was asked.

He didn't answer the question that the person asking probably wanted an answer to, which was about direct access in regard to Prism. But that's the fault of the person asking not being precise...

You have to remember there are tons of programs going on. To the people who have been paying attention to the Prism "direct access" debate, it's probably pretty clear what the person asking the question was getting at. But it makes total sense that someone as familiar with the programs as a whole would answer about "direct access" in general.

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by foobarqux on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:51AM (#5893862)
What are the contents of the raw SIGINT databases with respect to telephone audio? Is that audio dragnet? Can an analyst, from a technical perspective, initiate monitoring of a person unilaterally?
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by codeulike on Monday June 17, 2013 @01:25PM (#5894494)
The impression I get is that they collect everything they can. If they want to actually _look_ at what they've collected, they are supposed to ask secret permission from a secret court that gives a secret answer. Of course, we trust that they _always_ ask this secret court.
Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by cgshaw on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:31AM (#5893722)
From the chat -

"Anthony De Rosa 17 June 2013 2:18pm 1) Define in as much detail as you can what "direct access" means.

2) Can analysts listen to content of domestic calls without a warrant?"

Answer (Snowden)

"1) More detail on how direct NSA's accesses are is coming, but in general, the reality is this: if an NSA, FBI, CIA, DIA, etc analyst has access to query raw SIGINT databases, they can enter and get results for anything they want. Phone number, email, user id, cell phone handset id (IMEI), and so on - it's all the same. The restrictions against this are policy based, not technically based, and can change at any time. Additionally, audits are cursory, incomplete, and easily fooled by fake justifications. For at least GCHQ, the number of audited queries is only 5% of those performed."

Re:Edward Snowden Q&A by LiamMcCalloway on Monday June 17, 2013 @11:49AM (#5893854)
I understand "direct access" to be the conflation of 2 different things: the first is the FISA-stamped requests to private companies for their records, and the second is the intercepts of data transmitted over the internet or phone networks by being listening in on the wires/radio-waves themselves (raw SIGINT). This seems overly schematic, however, and I would welcome corrections.