News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by DanielBMarkham on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:20PM (#5815677)
I love UFO stories, and I love history, and I love pseudo-science. Hell, I even like counter-factuals. What if Lee had won at Gettysburg? What if Patton had actually commanded the Normandy invasion? And so forth.

But these things are the province of speculation, not knowledge.

Think for a minute about what this essay is asking "What if action X did not end the war in the Pacific?"

Well dang, Action X could be just about anything. The fact of the matter is that all of the actions, taken together, were the reason for the war to end. Yes, Stalin played a big role. But it's not an either-or situation; it's an amalgam. The logical structure of trying to support a statement such as "The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan" is flawed. It's like saying the landing on Tarawa didn't beat Japan. Well no, and yes. The assertion itself is flawed.

While I love all sorts of semi-non-fictional essays, I have a little warning bell that goes off when I'm mostly through an essay and the essayist starts telling me a story about how I've been misled. Smells of a political agenda and manipulation.

Japan was threatened on many fronts and made the best choice it could. That much is clear. Atom bombs did not cause as much building and population damage as the fire-bombing did. That's also clear. But atom bombs represented one thing that Stalin and fire-bombing did not: the end of Japanese culture. A few dozen atom bombs would not only have made huge holes in the landscape, it would have erased the culture of Japan.

Nobody is finding comfort in simplistic stories. In fact, the more details people know, the happier I am. But dropping the bombs on Japan saved millions of both Japanese and allied lives. It served as a quick end to a long war, and it saved thousands of allied prisoners whom the Japanese were ready to execute. It also allowed the great Japanese culture to continue.

Most serious historians don't get into counter-factuals, except maybe as fiction. It just doesn't work.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:42PM (#5816555)
This comment is contentless. It doesn't address a single specific thing the article says. Instead it offers woolly generalities ("Japan was threatened on many fronts and made the best choice it could. That much is clear") and platitudes ("all of the actions, taken together, were the reason for the war to end. Yes, Stalin played a big role. But it's not an either-or situation"). It sounds like it's saying something; indeed, it sounds like it's saying something wise and avuncular. But I've read it three times and can't find a single part that is saying anything at all, other than where it repeats exactly the bromide about how the Pacific war ended that the OP is critiquing ("dropping the bombs on Japan saved millions of both Japanese and allied lives. It served as a quick end to a long war")—ironically, right after it says "Nobody is finding comfort in simplistic stories". If you're going to respond to a critique, shouldn't you answer what it actually says?

It's unfair to put the article in the same bucket as "UFO stories". No one who has read it (and is being fair) would describe it as "speculation". It isn't anything like counterfactual fan fiction. Almost the entire piece does nothing but cite facts, such as: the dropping of the nuclear bombs does not figure significantly in historical records of the Japanese leadership's discussion about surrender; the Japanese war council decided on August 8 not even to discuss the Hiroshima bombing; damage to Hiroshima and Nagasaki was not out of scale with the earlier fire-bombings of other cities; Japanese leaders had expressed a willingness to sacrifice their cities if necessary; Japan's war strategy was predicated on the Soviets staying neutral; and so on. Are these wrong? If so, how? Are there other, more important facts omitted? If so, what are they?

The negative responses to this article so far are so insubstantial that they form a defense of it by omission. I'm very curious now to hear a credible counterargument. Surely there is one?

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by ekianjo on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:20PM (#5816952)
I agree with your feeling. Reading through this thread of answers and seeing so many poorly written comments, all supporting the "official patriotic version of American History of the World" is pretty sad.

For those who disagree with the article, why don't you ask Japanese what they think, instead of speculating about these two bombs ending the war? It was clearly obvious that these two bombs were, just like the article said, just another two drops in a long history of bombing on Japan that has destroyed most of the largest cities. Come to Japan and see from yourself how little is left of Old Japan. All cities are built of concrete here, because there was nothing left of what they were before. And check Japanese litterature of the time - there was ample suffering and hardship without even talking about the atomic bombs.

There's nothing "revisionist" about these claims.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by supercanuck on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:40PM (#5817022)
I find it frustrating that someone so prominent in their field to merit an audience at the UN and British Parliament and to be published in Foreign Policy is able to be so easily dismissed on Hacker News as not "a serious historian."
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by twic on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @09:13AM (#5819178)
To be fair, he's being dismissed as such by people who are not serious hackers.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by montagg on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:38AM (#5818157)
The last section of the article actually argues against the article's stated conclusion, and it supports the statement you've replied to. This section, in particular:

> Attributing the end of the war to the atomic bomb served Japan's interests in multiple ways. But it also served U.S. interests. If the Bomb won the war, then the perception of U.S. military power would be enhanced, U.S. diplomatic influence in Asia and around the world would increase, and U.S. security would be strengthened. The $2 billion spent to build it would not have been wasted. If, on the other hand, the Soviet entry into the war was what caused Japan to surrender, then the Soviets could claim that they were able to do in four days what the United States was unable to do in four years, and the perception of Soviet military power and Soviet diplomatic influence would be enhanced. And once the Cold War was underway, asserting that the Soviet entry had been the decisive factor would have been tantamount to giving aid and comfort to the enemy.

Logically, this section asserts that the atomic bomb, though not successful in doing physical damage, actually created a political situation that allowed graceful surrender, and it aligned with the Japanese government's desire to preserve Japan's culture and forms of government. It's very difficult to speculate what the Japanese response would have been at this point had Hiroshima and Nagasaki been destroyed with conventional weapons. However, their way of life would have been more at risk without a clear way to appease the enemy, which we have evidence to suggest was on their minds.

It's important to note that the entire last section is speculation and offers no facts at all to support the claim that Japan consciously blamed the atomic bomb with these goals in mind. Yet, this is the crux of the article -- the idea that the atomic bomb won the war singlehandedly is a myth supported in part by the Japanese government's desire for self-preservation.

I think that's what the original reply author means when he says "all taken together." The atomic bomb clearly did not put a dent in the Japanese leadership's attitude, but, according to the article's speculation, it did allow them to make a life-saving decision more easily.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by vidarh on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @05:11AM (#5818395)
The article presents the bomb as being a useful excuse for both the Japanese and the US after the decision to surrender. E.g:

> 'During the early days of the occupation, many Japanese officials worried that the Americans intended to abolish the institution of the emperor. And they had another worry. Many of Japan's top government officials knew that they might face war crimes trials (the war crimes trials against Germany's leaders were already underway in Europe when Japan surrendered). Japanese historian Asada Sadao has said that in many of the postwar interviews "Japanese officials... were obviously anxious to please their American questioners." If the Americans wanted to believe that the Bomb won the war, why disappoint them?'

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by asperous on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:15PM (#5816722)
>"Think for a minute about what this essay is asking "What if action X did not end the war in the Pacific?"

I think it was addressing the overall idea of speculation in historical events.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by parennoob on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:04PM (#5817265)
What meaning of speculate do you mean? There are two that are nearly the opposite of each other (making this an almost-Janus word):

1. To meditate on a subject; reflect. 2. To engage in a course of reasoning often based on inconclusive evidence.

If you mean 2., the article doesn't do anything of the sort. It lays out specific pieces of evidence based on observed historical fact and draws specific conclusions from them. On the other hand, the top-level comment above is pretty vague in its rebuttal.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by dspeyer on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:50PM (#5817605)
In talking about causality, the article makes two counterfactual claims: had the Soviets not invaded Manchuria, Japan would not have surrendered and had the bombs not been dropped, Japan would have surrendered. (In my opinion, the first claim is well-defended, the second less so). Since the bombs were dropped and the Soviets did invade, any discussion of these possibilities is a little speculative.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:27AM (#5818010)
This seems reasonable—thanks. Can you quote where the article actually claims those two things? I'm curious, and I don't disbelieve you, but I really don't want to have to go back and comb through the whole thing again :)
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by montagg on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:46AM (#5818175)
This section, primarily, argues that the atomic bomb created a political out for the Japanese government:

> Attributing the end of the war to the atomic bomb served Japan's interests in multiple ways. But it also served U.S. interests. If the Bomb won the war, then the perception of U.S. military power would be enhanced, U.S. diplomatic influence in Asia and around the world would increase, and U.S. security would be strengthened. The $2 billion spent to build it would not have been wasted. If, on the other hand, the Soviet entry into the war was what caused Japan to surrender, then the Soviets could claim that they were able to do in four days what the United States was unable to do in four years, and the perception of Soviet military power and Soviet diplomatic influence would be enhanced. And once the Cold War was underway, asserting that the Soviet entry had been the decisive factor would have been tantamount to giving aid and comfort to the enemy.

It basically argues, yeah, both Stalin AND the bomb likely contributed to a surrender. This part is not cited as well, however. It relies on implication based on the dissonance between records before the surrender and statements by the Japanese government after the surrender.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:28PM (#5820835)
Sure, but that passage is about the political uses of the causal argument that happened to win (and that the OP thinks is incorrect). It makes no counterfactual claims.

dspeyer's point is a good one if (but only if) the article actually does make the two claims he mentioned. Does it? I don't remember.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by msvan on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:55PM (#5816871)
Which is essentially dismissing the entire subject of history. How can arguing about things that happened seventy years ago not be speculation? History is not hard science. We speculate, we argue, but we never reach perfect certainty.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by ScottBurson on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:06PM (#5817273)
Agreed, and thank you for your posts. The amount of knee-jerking visible in this discussion is astounding and disappointing.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by na85 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:20AM (#5818118)
>I'm very curious now to hear a credible counterargument.

Well, Hirohito himself mentioned the bomb and its 'incalculable' destructive potential in his formal announcement of surrender.

So at the very least the bomb played a very substantial role in ending the war in the Pacific.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by crash78 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:41AM (#5818162)
At the end of the article the author describes how (assuming his previous arguments are true) Japan's leaders would still have publicly cited the bomb as a strong reason for their surrender as it "served to deflect blame" from themselves.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:32PM (#5820855)
Yes, and the question is, how can you really separate these things out? But now that I think of it, there may be a way to actually test this. Did the Japanese leaders' private deliberations diverge significantly from their public statements? If we have access to them and they did, that would be evidence in favor of the face-saving interpretation.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:29AM (#5818140)
Thanks. It would be interesting to hear Ward's take on that; he must surely address it in the book the article was taken from.

On the other hand, according to [1], Hirohito also cited the Soviet invasion when convening the council to discuss surrender.

[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/u6qqo/there_h...

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by alexqgb on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:56PM (#5817082)
Did you even read the article, Daniel?

Contrary to your assertion, the essay is not asking "What if action X did not end the war in the Pacific?". It is stating - categorically - that the commonly accepted narrative is based on an insufficient accounting of the facts, and that this narrative is unsustainable in the face of a more complete record of what actually happened.

Here's the key passage:

"It didn't take a military genius to see that, while it might be possible to fight a decisive battle against one great power invading from one direction, it would not be possible to fight off two great powers attacking from two different directions. The Soviet invasion invalidated the military's decisive battle strategy, just as it invalidated the diplomatic strategy. At a single stroke, all of Japan's options evaporated. The Soviet invasion [of Manchuria] was strategically decisive -- it foreclosed both of Japan's options -- while the bombing of Hiroshima (which foreclosed neither) was not."

Again, that's not "speculative" or "pseudo-historical" writing. And there's no way an attentive reader of good will could characterize it as such. Now, you may dispute the veracity of the facts. Or you could bring additional facts to bear. And you may reasonably disagree with the writer's conclusions. But for a guy who is ostensibly adverse to arguments that "smell of a political agenda and manipulation", you do yourself no favors by (a) seriously misrepresenting the basic nature of what's being said, and (b) responding to your straw man in the most inappropriately condescending manner possible. (Seriously, lumping this in with UFO conspiracies, as though the Soviet military were what? A figment of unreliable imagination?)

If you want to see some real slimeball rhetoric, sir, look no further than your own remarks. The only good thing about dishonesty of this sort of is the amusingly ironic dearth of self-awareness that it also represents.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by jbooth on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:01PM (#5817444)
It's also noteworthy that the Japanese troops in Manchuria were, from most accounts I've seen, their most veteran land-based army. And the soviets, having fought the Germans for the past 6 years, basically cut through them like butter. That will make you reconsider your position.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Asterick6 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:51AM (#5818190)
^except that's wrong. The best of the Kwangtung army stationed in Manchuria was already shifted to Kyushu and the southern islands of Japan to prepare for the possible US invasion.

>"Most of Japan's best troops had been shifted to the southern part of the home islands. Japan's military had correctly guessed that the likely first target of an American invasion would be the southernmost island of Kyushu. The once proud Kwangtung army in Manchuria, for example, was a shell of its former self because its best units had been shifted away to defend Japan itself."

It wasn't that the best troops were defeated; just that Japan couldn't fight a war on two fronts. Once the Soviet Union invaded, they had no other viable options other than surrender or fight a losing battle.

However, even if the author's analysis is correct, I still think it best to believe that the nuclear weapons were the main cause but the other variables also influenced the outcome.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by jbooth on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @11:03AM (#5819773)
Thanks, I didn't know that.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by mcantelon on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:33PM (#5815793)
>But these things are the province of speculation, not knowledge.

Here's the opinion of the leader of the US military at the time.

"It is my opinion that the use of this barbarous weapon at Hiroshima and Nagasaki was of no material assistance in our war against Japan. The Japanese were already defeated and ready to surrender because of the effective sea blockade and the successful bombing with conventional weapons." -Fleet Admiral William Daniel Leahy (May 6, 1875 – July 20, 1959), the senior-most United States military officer during th Second World War

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_D._Leahy#Atomic_bomb

The bomb was dropped not to win the war, but to intimidate the USSR.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:03PM (#5816005)
When I read these revisionist pieces, I often see the same phrase you quoted: "ready to surrender." If someone is "ready to surrender," what does that mean? Well I'll tell you what it certainly doesn't mean: It doesn't mean that they've _actually_ surrendered.

What a lot of revisionist writings gloss over is that yes, certain parts of the Japanese leadership were "ready to surrender." But it is well documented that some were only ready to surrender if conditions X and Y were met. Others were only ready to surrender with conditions Z and A. And of course others weren't ready to surrender at all.

Yet until a credible leadership figure actually _offered_ unconditional surrender, it was going to be war as usual.

And so if this phrase, "ready to surrender," is taken alone (notwithstanding its distinguished source), then it is facile in that it deliberately ignores both the wide diversity of opinion which existed within Japanese leadership, and the complex process which was necessary for the leadership to converge and make a firm, unified political decision.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by SiVal on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:03PM (#5816354)
Here's the opinion of the leader of the US military at the time

Yes, later Leahy apparently said, "It is my opinion," not, "At the time we all believed" ["that the Japanese were defeated and ready to surrender...."]

I'm willing to believe that some, maybe including Leahy, thought the US had only to stand back and wait for the inevitable surrender, with no ratcheting up of force necessary. But, at the same time, somebody [not including the Fleet Admiral?] was also preparing for a full boots-on-the-ground invasion of the Japanese mainland, which (going by the US death tolls of previous island invasions) would have sent thousands of Americans to their deaths.

Unless that invasion plan was entirely fake--something nobody is suggesting--there were obviously plenty of people at the top who thought that the Japanese might not be ready to surrender.

Suddenly a middle option appeared between just waiting and hoping and sending thousands of Americans to their deaths: drop atomic bombs. Even though an atom bomb would actually kill fewer people than the firebombings, it would represent an even greater threat of what could happen if they didn't surrender immediately.

Maybe the Japanese were about to surrender. Maybe they would keep fighting and Americans would keep dying. Maybe the atom bombs would convince them to surrender. Or maybe not. Maybe nothing short of a full invasion would be required. Maybe even that wouldn't be enough to end it quickly, and the dying would continue for a very long time. The Japanese in many places had gone on fighting until they were dead without ever surrendering.

In that context, with no benefit of hindsight, to say that the bomb was not dropped to win the war but just to intimidate the USSR is nonsense.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by cema on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:10PM (#5816698)

  In that context, with no benefit of hindsight, 
  to say that the bomb was not dropped to win the war 
  but just to intimidate the USSR is nonsense.
Not just nonsense, but also part of a propaganda war. I cannot read it otherwise (unless the comment had offered a more profound historical analysis, which it has not).
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by SiVal on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:24AM (#5818003)
I'm willing to give the HN commenter above the benefit of the doubt that he/she might just be parroting something picked up on campus, but I agree with you that this claim has been part of leftist propaganda for decades.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hef19898 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:56PM (#5821755)
And that's because only leftist engange in propaganda? Sorry, couldn't help it.... but for the theory that the ONLY reason the bomb was dropped to intimidate the Sowjets is as wrong as the oppossite view point that it soley anded the war and saved millions of lifes. it's both propagande, just from different camps.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by jcnnghm on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:45PM (#5817222)
Estimated casualties were thought to be up to a million people. The US ordered 500,000 Purple Hearts in anticipation of that, so many that those ones are still being given out today.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by lmm on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @04:33AM (#5818280)
It bears remembering that a million is small in comparison to the number of casualties the soviet union had already taken at that point.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by celoyd on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:43PM (#5816220)
Yet until a credible leadership figure actually _offered_ unconditional surrender, it was going to be war as usual.

But it wasn’t. The A-bombs were quite unusual. They were extraordinary weapons, and would have required extraordinary justifications to use on the military, let alone on civilians.

(To the argument that it wasn’t possible to target the military apart from civilians: that’s exactly why nuclear weapons are so problematic.)

it deliberately ignores both the wide diversity of opinion which existed within Japanese leadership

An alternate interpretation is to not take it alone, and to see it as deliberately summarizing the wide diversity of opinion which was already going through the complex process that you rightly point out. News of Nagasaki’s destruction interrupted a meeting by the Japanese Supreme War Council, not so much about whether to surrender as about how. I don’t think it’s facile at all to call this, in context, “ready to surrender”.

The US did not know the details of the meeting, of course, but they chose to spend 70,000 human lives on an assumption with no particular justification, while under no special immediate military threat – at that point, Japan was relatively contained, and the fear was that if left alone it would reach out again in a matter of months or decades, not weeks. The threat was diplomatic: that Japan might surrender to the USSR. That seems worth presenting as something other than the rueful conduct of justified, proportional warfare as an absolute last resort.

As an American, sometimes I look at other countries that haven’t come to terms with major war crimes – the Armenian Genocide, for example, or indeed Imperial Japan’s crimes in China – and I shake my head.

Then I remember that the US has the A-bombs on our record, and we’ve made it almost 70 years now without admitting as a nation (meaning in standard textbooks, in mainstream entertainment, etc.) that these were, by any sensible definition, crimes against humanity of the highest gravity.

There’s this objection people sometimes raise: that it’s easy to say these things if you weren’t there, if you weren’t under the pressures of command, knowing your nation’s people were dying by the day. That’s true. I don’t know what that was like. It’s easy for me to moralize from a distance. But that argument isn’t actually justifying the act of the A-bombings, merely moderating judgment on the people who did it. Saying they didn’t really know what they were doing is very different from it was a good idea.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by greedo on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:28PM (#5817177)
You have the privilege of tarring the commanders of US forces as war criminals "of the highest gravity" because of the sacrifices US soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines made during WW2.

If you haven't already, do some research on how the Japanese fought at Okinawa. At the defensive plans they had in place for defending the Home Islands. The toll of an invasion would have been horrendous for both sides. This is without dispute by serious historians.

Your idea that the Japanese were "relatively contained," implying that there was no need to do any further action is almost laughable as a military or political strategy.

When you go to war, you should go to war til the other side cries "Uncle."

Furthermore, the idea that war should be "proportional" is also a sophomoric argument without merit. War is hell for a reason. If someone engages you in war, you fight them to the death. You don't go back and forth in a tit for tat manner that negates all of your advantages and magnifies theirs.

And to lump the A bombs with what Japan did to China? Read up on the Rape of Nanking. Or find out how many Chinese civilians the Japanese Army killed on the mainland. Or how they treated POWs during the Bataan Death March.

War is hell.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by levosmetalo on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:56AM (#5818058)
> Furthermore, the idea that war should be "proportional" is also a sophomoric argument without merit. War is hell for a reason. If someone engages you in war, you fight them to the death. You don't go back and forth in a tit for tat manner that negates all of your advantages and magnifies theirs.

Did you just agree that people, army and paramilitary forces of Afghanistan are right to go to total war "to death" with the USA, USA army and USA civilians. Because even one innocent dead man in Afghanistan can justify action of, for example, poisoning NYC water supplies?

Or this "unproporional" punishment of enemy is justified only if it's the USA that is doing it, not when it suffers it?

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by greedo on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @07:26AM (#5818744)
I think it's entirely justifiable for any afghani to be joining the Taliban and fighting to kick out a foreign invader from their soil. Everyone has a right to defend their country's sovereignty.

I personally wouldn't advocate targeting civilians; but if there was no alternative, and my culture, country and way of life was being destroyed, I could see a rational actor choosing to do so.

The US would have been far better served by simply conducting a punitive raid in AFG to knock over the original Taliban and let the assorted tribes learn not to stir the hornets nest. Instead we've decimated the country without creating any real change. And we've also grown accustomed to a sanitized style of warfare where drone operators in Creech, Nevada plink small targets without working up a sweat.

War should be hell, lest we grow to like it too much.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by kalms on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:56AM (#5818203)
The United States dropped two very big bombs on cities. Cities, not military installations. That's very close to being a war criminal in my opinion, realities of war be damned.

Edit:

> You have the privilege of tarring the commanders of US forces as war criminals "of the highest gravity" because of the sacrifices US soldiers, sailors, airmen and marines made during WW2.

In reality, we Europeans have the privilege because of United Kingdom, Soviet, United States, Canada, Finland, and countless volunteers and freedom fighters from the occupied areas. I appreciate the sacrifices, suffering and determination from a nation I so admire; in fact we celebrate it once a year, but please remember that United States were never alone in the fight.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by greedo on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @07:19AM (#5818721)
I didn't mean to imply that the US was the sole combatant; I was responding to the parent who was an American.

War is still hell. The Romans razed Carthage, a war crime? The Germans in WW1 bombed London, war crime? The British torched Dresden, war crime? The Nazis bombed Rotterdam, war crime?

It's far too easy to conflate "war" with war crime. Some feel that the two are synonymous. I think each generation has a tendency to feel superior and more advanced than the previous generation; I think this is naive and ill informed. We're all savages of a sort.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by kalms on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:34PM (#5827583)
"Now we are all sons of bitches." — Kenneth Bainbridge

Yes, yes, yes and yes.

I'm not even saying that I would act differently if I were a military commander. War is hell, granted. But that doesn't make it right, and we should be honest with ourselves. It's not right. Killing innocents is not okay; using civilians as leverage in an act of terror is never okay.

We should strive to be better than that.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by greedo on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:45PM (#5827681)
Striving is fine, but as some sage once said, "your enemy always has a vote." We're limited in how we act by how our opponents behave. And despite what Fukuyama said, I think that we'll see more conflict in this century than anyone expects.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by vidarh on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @05:58AM (#5818505)
Their actions can be necessary, and still war crimes and/or abhorrent. These are not mutually exclusive.

We can be grateful for the outcome and many sacrifices and still speculate about whether or not specific actions were necessary and justifiable.

And we can actually recognise the atrocities committed by the Japanese military and question actions by the allies at the same time.

It is understandable that a lot of decisions were taken that had horrible outcomes, and that many of them were taken in good faith and probably the only viable decisions despite how atrocious they might seem in retrospect. That does not mean we should just gloss over everything.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hga on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:01PM (#5816342)
"The A-bombs were quite unusual. They were extraordinary weapons, and would have required extraordinary justifications to use on the military, let alone on civilians."

Extraordinarily efficient, one plane, one bomb, one city, but we'd already methodically bombed pretty much every other city (along with Kyoto for political reasons, the A-bomb targets and their alternates were reserved), with e.g. the firebombing of Tokyo killing a conservative 100,000.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by GauntletWizard on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:25PM (#5816467)
To view anyone in Japan, or more accurately, anyone in any of the great powers as a "civilian" during the wartime of WW2 - is pretty naive. All of Europe, Japan, and America were in a state of Total War - Every available resource was being put towards the production of munitions, every able-bodied man was being drafted, every spare cent was being spent on the war.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:16PM (#5816431)
Yes, I sometimes wonder what a veteran of the American Revolutionary War thought when he first saw the Gatling gun.

What would be unusual is if weapon technology _didn't_ increase exponentially in lethality over time.

Given enough time even Little Boy will, to future generations, look to be nearly as puny as a flintlock. Hope we don't do ourselves in.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Dylan16807 on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:53PM (#5816609)
If you want to bomb a target smaller than a city then you have to design smaller bombs.

If you want to target cities then you keep making city-sized bombs.

If you want to target larger areas, you're probably going to be most efficient by targeting the cities in that area; go back to the previous step of city-sized bombs.

What's the incentive to increase lethality? If you make huge nukes or equivalently powerful weapons, they overkill your target and have negative side effects back on the homeland.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by svachalek on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:50PM (#5817234)
Even sub-city-sized weapons like the ones dropped on Japan are too large to actually launch in the modern world; the political repercussions are much too great. The only use for a nuclear arsenal is to promise Mutually Assured Destruction, and it really doesn't take much for that.

The dangerous super-weapons of the future are small, simple ones that can kill just the right person, anywhere, anytime. That arms race is happening right now, and progress is rapid.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hga on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @11:34AM (#5820030)
"Yes, I sometimes wonder what a veteran of the American Revolutionary War thought when he first saw the Gatling gun."

Compared to e.g. canister shot from canons I don't think it would have awed them that much (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canister_shot).

Since at least the Napoleonic Wars, which followed shortly after our Revolutionary war, artillery has generally been the biggest killer on the battlefield.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by vidarh on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @05:47AM (#5818475)
> But it wasn’t. The A-bombs were quite unusual. They were extraordinary weapons, and would have required extraordinary justifications to use on the military, let alone on civilians.

They were extraordinary weapons, but as the article points out: The bombing campaigns were not, other than in doing the damage with much fewer bombs. Japan had seen similar levels of destruction in dozens of cities that summer, and was running out of larger undamaged cities.

With that context, they should require extraordinary justification to use, but no more so than the previous months of firebombing, and the focusing on the use of a nuclear bomb vs. "just" the fire bombing is detracting from the issue of how much of that overall bombing should have been acceptable and how much of it was necessary or served much purpose.

I don't want to excuse the A-bombs, but the article does make a compelling argument that they were not qualitatively different in the suffering caused.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by emmelaich on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:57PM (#5817087)
I stunned that you compare the atomic bombing with the Armenian genocide.

The atom bombs saved millions of Japanese lives because the alternative was a protracted brutal ordinary war.

Reminder: the firebombing that preceded the atomic bombs killed a lot more.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hga on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:45PM (#5816239)
You also have to factor in that long before then, the Japanese had developed a culture of political assassination, see for example the end of this section: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isoroku_Yamamoto#1920s_and_1930.... That substantially raised the barrier to getting to the "ready to surrender" point of the group that was making the decisions. And that decision did not meet with universal acclaim, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrender_of_Japan#Attempted_mi...
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by refurb on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:02PM (#5816904)
I have to agree. Remember there were TWO bombs dropped. Japan didn't surrender after the 1st one.

The only thing that matters is that Japan surrendered. That they were "thinking" about it or "close to it" is pretty much irrelevant.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:38PM (#5817011)
Remember there were two bombs dropped. Japan didn't surrender after the 1st one.

But they convened the council to discuss surrender before the second one. The timeline given by the article is:

  Hiroshima bombed
  Soviet declaration of war
  Surrender council convened
  Nagasaki bombed
  Surrender
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:27PM (#5820820)
They should have discussed faster.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by DanielBMarkham on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:26PM (#5817171)
Agreed.

The cherry-picking on this topic is extreme. One guy claims Lehey was the leader of the U.S. Military during WWII. He was not. He was the senior-serving military official, who worked as chief of staff to Roosevelt. You could call him an early CJCS, or you could just use his title: chief of staff. Marshall was probably the closest we had to a senior person actually running the war, as anybody with a modicum of WWII history can tell you. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Marshall The only reason to pump up Lehey is to add authority to the quote, which was made years later during a completely different political situation. When you see this kind of thing, it never bodes well for the argument.

But you beat down one red herring and three more pop up. It's like talking to those 9-11 guys. They already know the answer. Just a matter of selectively arranging facts in a convincing narrative.

The author gives it away towards the end "...There is real resistance to looking at the facts. But perhaps this should not be surprising...They fill an important psychic need."

Well there you go. From the author's comments, and those on this board, I take it this is supposed to be some kind of argument between "patriotic" Americans and the facts (as told to us by the revisionists), instead of what it is: rewriting history to suit current fashion.

I actually wish the revisionists well. Maybe they can get their way and we can go through 100 years or so of believing that the A-bomb was not the proximate cause of the end of WWII. Then a new fashion will take hold, and we can come back to believing what 95% of the people at the time it happened believed. The neat thing about this is that people get educated about history. Frankly, if history is your passion and you spend time on this and know your stuff, I could care less which theory you pick. These stories need to be remembered.

Whenever this topic comes up I reminded of this quote:

But perhaps George M. Elsey, a young naval intelligence officer assigned to the Truman White House, provided the best reply to revisionist historians and others who question the decision to drop the atomic bombs. Asked by David McCullough for his biography of the President (Truman, Simon & Schuster, 1992) about the decision, Elsey replied: "Truman made no decision because there was no decision to be made. He could no more have stopped it than a train moving down a track. It's all well and good to come along later and say the bomb was a horrible thing. The whole goddamn war was a horrible thing."

http://hnn.us/articles/44729.html

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:06AM (#5817968)
This is seriously misleading. The OP doesn't even mention William Lehey, let alone include a howler about him. And you accuse other people of red herrings!

Surely if you had found even the tiniest flaw in the OP, you'd have shared it with us by now. Instead your comments are positively incontinent with innuendos and slurs: "UFO stories", "pseudo-science", "revisionists", "9-11 guys", "cherry picking", "selectively arranging facts", "pump up", "add authority", "rewriting history to suit current fashion", "emotional reasoning" (since deleted, unless my memory is playing tricks), and my favorite: "From the author's comments, and those on this board"—as if the two were colluding instead of obviously having nothing whatever to do with each other.

I don't have an opinion about why Japan surrendered in WWII, but when an apparently well-reasoned case provokes this kind of thing, it seems likely that there is something to it.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gbog on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @09:26AM (#5819246)
Knowing a bit about the Asian way to handle conflict, I think it is possible that the bombs gave a good pretext (not the best word) to end the war. It would mean that many in Japan headquarter knew it was foolish to continue the war but it was not possible to change boat without a special new circumstance that can be used to explain the change.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:52AM (#5818045)
I don't even know what you're looking at. He was referring to this message upstream: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5815793
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:20AM (#5818117)
Yes, I know. And then he switched back to the OP as if the two were the same thing, when in fact they're entirely unrelated. That's the dictionary definition of a red herring.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:25PM (#5820805)
Or he had moved his commentary beyond the original piece to include the commenters whose positions he was criticizing, which is how I read it.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by soperj on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:34PM (#5816176)
When they are actively trying to surrender, then they're probably "Ready to surrender". The US wouldn't negotiate because the bombs were on the way.

What were the conditions? Because if they were "you help us rebuild" or "and we get a grill-cheese sandwich" then really they're not much. Plenty of peace treaties have taken place with conditions.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:03PM (#5816355)
"Negotiate?" The US had no appetite for negotiation at that point -- only unconditional surrender was acceptable.

I won't do your research for you, but various factions within the Japanese leadership wanted to put lots of significant things on the table, like maintaining the seat of the emperor, the existing political structure, etc. All were showstoppers to the US.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by fancyketchup on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:29PM (#5816977)
> All were showstoppers to the US.

But that isn't true. The seat of the emperor was maintained, at least nominally, so it clearly wasn't a showstopper. The US may have demanded unconditional surrender before the atomic bombings, but it accepted a conditional surrender after.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by rat87 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @12:19AM (#5817688)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/september/2...

1945: Japan signs unconditional surrender > Japanese officials have signed the act of unconditional surrender, finally bringing to an end six years of world war.

> Under the terms of the ceasefire, Japan has agreed to end all hostilities, release all prisoners of war, and comply with the terms of the Potsdam declaration, which confines its sovereignty to the four main islands which make up Japan.

> Under the terms of the ceasefire, Japan has agreed to end all hostilities, release all prisoners of war, and comply with the terms of the Potsdam declaration, which confines its sovereignty to the four main islands which make up Japan.

> It has also agreed to acknowledge the authority of the US supreme commander. Although Emperor Hirohito will be allowed to remain as a symbolic head of state.

---

I'm pretty sure the surrender was unconditional and later the Allies announced that the Emperor would keep his position(probably mostly to help ease the occupation) ---

> www.history.com/this-day-in-history/japan-accepts-potsdam-terms-agrees-to-unconditional-surrender

At the behest of two Cabinet members, the emperor summoned and presided over a special meeting of the Council and implored them to consider accepting the terms of the Potsdam Conference, which meant unconditional surrender. "It seems obvious that the nation is no longer able to wage war, and its ability to defend its own shores is doubtful." The Council had been split over the surrender terms; half the members wanted assurances that the emperor would maintain his hereditary and traditional role in a postwar Japan before surrender could be considered. But in light of the bombing of Hiroshima on August 6, Nagasaki on August 9, and the Soviet invasion of Manchuria, as well as the emperor's own request that the Council "bear the unbearable," it was agreed: Japan would surrender.

--

> www.history.com/this-day-in-history/japan-accepts-potsdam-terms-agrees-to-unconditional-surrender

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by fancyketchup on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @04:57PM (#5822069)
Yes, I'm familiar with how the end of the war was reported by the popular press. That does not, however, change the facts of history.

From Wikipedia[1]: 'Japan's ambassador to Switzerland, observed that "unconditional surrender" applied only to the military and not to the government or the people, and he pleaded that it should be understood that the careful language of Potsdam appeared "to have occasioned a great deal of thought" on the part of the signatory governments—"they seem to have taken pains to save face for us on various points."'

So it seems that both Japan and the Allies understood that unconditional surrender only applied to Japan's military.

Further: 'That day, Hirohito informed the imperial family of his decision to surrender. One of his uncles, Prince Asaka, then asked whether the war would be continued if the kokutai (national polity) could not be preserved. The emperor simply replied "of course."'

In other words, Japan was willing to continue fighting, even after the atomic bombings, if it didn't get to insist on a few conditions. That doesn't sound like unconditional surrender to me.

I should also point out that the parent of my original post asserted that any and all Japanese conditions were "showstoppers." I pointed out that, whether or not the emperor's seat was a condition explicitly writing into the surrender documents, at least one of Japan's surrender conditions, namely keeping the emperor in place, was clearly not a showstopper.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrender_of_Japan

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by soperj on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:06PM (#5816677)
Yes, that's what I wrote. They wouldn't negotiate because the bombs were on the way. It wasn't unconditional anyway, there were plenty of conditions in the potsdam declaration.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by Scramblejams on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:22PM (#5820788)
You're badly misunderstanding the history. The Japanese didn't participate in Potsdam. The Allies wrote the declaration by themselves as an ultimatum and issued it to Japan, warning the Japanese of complete destruction if they didn't fully accept it.

"Unconditional" doesn't mean "there are no terms." It means that the loser dictates no terms, while the victor dictates all the terms.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hga on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:53PM (#5815942)
By the time Leahy published that, nuclear weapons were an existential threat to the US Navy, see e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolt_of_the_Admirals
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by greedo on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:31PM (#5817186)
William Leahy was not the "leader of the US military at the time." That would be a) Harry S. Truman, or b) George Marshall, depending on whether you consider the Commander in Chief to be the leader.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hkmurakami on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:30PM (#5816155)
Shouldn't we ask some people on the other side of the ocean?
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:18PM (#5816738)
This is a good question. Let's make it more explicit: What do Japanese historians have to say about how and why Japan surrendered in 1945?
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by saraid216 on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:42PM (#5817030)
> What do Japanese historians have to say about how and why Japan surrendered in 1945?

Given Japan's current record on how they engage with World War 2 history, I honestly wouldn't trust any of their claims. Wikipedia has an overview of the subject:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_war_crimes#Debate_in_J...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_history_textbook_contr...

I'm not saying that they would lie, but at this point I think the propaganda war is going to eclipse any useful qualitative data that could be gained.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by gruseom on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:57PM (#5817089)
One really has to be careful with this kind of reasoning. That Japan minimizes its war crimes (as other countries do) and engages in propaganda (as other countries do) does not render irrelevant what Japanese scholars have to say about how and why Japan surrendered in 1945. Indeed, nearly all the important evidence on this is bound to be of Japanese origin (not to mention language), so it's the obvious place to start to learn about it.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by saraid216 on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:11PM (#5817288)
I absolutely agree; I'm not saying that it's irrelevant, but rather that there are still people alive and in power who have a demonstrated interest in lying on the matter. This is far less true in other countries.

What confuses me about this debate is what purpose is serves. Minus patriotism, why does it matter? I've maintained a neutral stance on the matter precisely because I don't understand this. (But I'm also a relatively non-nationalistic person, and I also have seen people who still think we need to get revenge for Pearl Harbor (4srswtf), so maybe it's just me.)

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by mercurial on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:14AM (#5817986)
> What confuses me about this debate is what purpose is serves.

To find out what motivated Japan to surrender? Whatever conclusion you draw from their actual motivation is up to you.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by cema on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:12PM (#5816712)
Japanese or Russians? The answer might differ.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by friendstock on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:44PM (#5817037)
> The bomb was dropped not to win the war, but to intimidate the USSR.

This was actually the essay topic on my US History AP exam.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by emmelaich on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:22PM (#5816958)
It certainly eased the introduction of peace.

If the Emperor had not accepted defeat we might well have a guerrilla war still going today.

Or the equivalent of North and South Korea.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by lsd5you on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:47PM (#5815900)
I think there is a contradiction in one of the things that you say. You say that counter-factuals are speculative and not useful, yet later you say the bomb saved millions of lives - that itself invokes a counter factual. i.e. The millions who would have died if the bomb hadn't been dropped (we speculate).

Is it even possible to imply any causality without a counterfactual? You can obviously take things too far and start speculating on an alternative time line, but the immediate turn of events is surely a legitimate area of speculation (even for 'serious' historians) and I would say the decision to surrender in japan is one of those.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by kybernetikos on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:43PM (#5816224)
When you have the fact that the Japanese had already sent delegations to negotiate a surrender, that everyone who wrote at the time either knew that Japan was trying to surrender or was confident that they would surrender as soon as Russia entered, and that the US Strategic Bombing Survey also concluded that the bombs were unnecessary, we're getting outside the realm of your standard counter-factual here.

It's much more like saying 'well, this body was stabbed through the heart and then burned, but they almost certainly would have been dead even without the burning' than 'some complex series of actions occurred and we have no idea which of them was actually relevant in the resulting outcome'.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by sumodds on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:47PM (#5815894)
I loved the first part of the argument, that many a time causality is not from one source but multiple (often overlapping and even contradictory sources). But towards the end, you sort of do the exact opposite :). The assertion that "But dropping the bombs on Japan saved millions of both Japanese and allied lives". Allied life, I can understand that, but Japanese life. Also the assertion that the bomb somehow magically safeguarded the Japanese culture.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by jokoon on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:58PM (#5816877)
> Nobody is finding comfort in simplistic stories. In fact, the more details people know, the happier I am. But dropping the bombs on Japan saved millions of both Japanese and allied lives. It served as a quick end to a long war, and it saved thousands of allied prisoners whom the Japanese were ready to execute. It also allowed the great Japanese culture to continue.

Yeah the US played ball by nuking japan. But saying it saved japanese people and their culture because it quickly ended the war, it's a little fast. I mean we're talking about nukes, not some poker games, those are war decision, you're still talking like the winner won because it took the best decision. Nuking is not a good decision, but it was a necessary one at the time. You're saying it like japan also thought "yeah, you nuked us, that really saved us, thanks !". When I read "bombs saved japanese", it sounds a little weird.

At least the article offer the reader some opportunity to think about the japanese perspective.

> Smells of a political agenda and manipulation.

UFO and conspiracy theories at it again ! The internet is never holding the truth, it's mandatory to not believe everything, it applies especially for this article. Consider the alternative like an opportunity to explore perspectives, not just like another one of those "deviant zealot".

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by anuraj on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:12AM (#5818097)
There is no excuse for killing innocents - in the name of whatever - America lost more than it gained by that single inhuman act of dropping Atom Bomb. War machines are still rattling - world peace is farther - But hope of a humanity not obliterated by the narrow confines of nation states and their propaganda and marching towards the goal of being at peace with itself and the universe lingers and that is what drives people like me.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by contingencies on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @12:12AM (#5817667)
Foreign Policy is the journal of the Council on Foreign Relations, a group summarized as early as 1986 by Noam Chomsky (who won a 2005 poll as the world's top public intellectual, invented modern linguistics, and is an outspoken critic of US government) as essentially the business input to [United States] foreign policy planning. The question, then, is which business interests are served by a given Foreign Policy story?

Speculation may be made in this case if we ascribe significance to the near simultaneous release of The New Digital Age by Eric Schmidt (Google CEO) and Jared Cohen (Council of Foreign Relations member and head of Google Ideas; somewhat spooky in and of itself), which Julian Assange variously described as a startlingly clear and provocative blueprint for technocratic imperialism and an enticement to Western soft power.

One of the advanced praise writers for the book (aside Kissinger, Blair, Clinton, Albright and Bloomberg - who, it must be noted, recently declined presidential candidacy as billionaire and 7th richest American to run New York) was General Keith Alexander, who is the present Director of the NSA (former Deputy Chief of Staff, Army; formerly Commanding General, U.S. Army Intelligence and Security Command; Director of Intelligence, US Central Command; Deputy Director for Intelligence, Joint Chiefs of Staff). Jacob Applebaum (of The Tor Project, also Wikileaks affiliate) described General Alexander as the most powerful man in the world and a fucking liar for claiming to congress that the NSA does not routinely intercept the communications of US citizens.

Why has this article been published by Foreign Policy in the current climate? The author has been developing these ideas awhile (http://cns.miis.edu/staff/wilson_ward.htm).

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by kaonashi on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:39PM (#5815842)
>But dropping the bombs on Japan saved millions of both Japanese and allied lives.

This assumes an invasion of the island of Japan would somehow have been a necessary goal.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by greedo on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @08:27AM (#5818968)
Despite the best efforts of airpower advocates, there's nothing like planting your boots on the soil of an enemy's capitol to demonstrate that you've defeated them.

"You may fly over a land forever; you may bomb it, atomize it, pulverize it and wipe it clean of life – but if you desire to defend it, protect it, and keep it for civilization, you must do this on the ground, the way the Roman legions did, by putting your young men into the mud."

T.R. Fehrenbach This Kind of War, 1963

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by mercurial on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:10AM (#5817974)
I don't know what options US high command were favouring in case the bombs failed for some reason, but if their strategic goal was "unconditional surrender", it is reasonable to expect them to plan an invasion of Japan, considering that firebombing was failing to do the trick.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hef19898 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @06:51AM (#5818641)
The view point of what I had in history about WW2 and the Cold War in Germany about the use of atomic bombs against Japan was that

1 - Japan was already defeated and it was only a question of time

2 - Atomic bombs didn't drop on Germany because the Third Reich surrendered before

3 - The US needed an actual use case to assert the damage and potential of this as yet unknown weapon

4 - It was as much about threatening the sowjets as it was about ending the war in the Pacific if not more so

What I know about the late days of the second world war is that they were regarded by both the future NATO allies (read the Commonwealth and the US) and the Sowjets as the basically the first days of a future conflict between these parties. Germany and Japan didn't play much of a role in this picture any more.

So what the US got from the use of nuclear weapons was much more than just the japanese surrender. It was a stronger position compared to the Sowjets and the garantee that the war in europe didn't continue on after the German surrender. In order to prevent this, the western allies even slowed their advance to Berlin to allow the Sowjets their successes. Which doesn't mean they didn't have their fair share of it anyway.

But that is just my point of view and I'm no historian.

And finally to the point about saving lives. I've grown tired of nationalistic people stating an unverifiable estimate of probale deaths as the herois reason to kill any number people right know. You don't save people by killing others and it is certainly not heroic. I know that the victors writes the history, but this argument mostly comes up in cases where some really bad things have to reinterpreted.

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by auctiontheory on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @03:22AM (#5818119)
But atom bombs represented one thing that Stalin and fire-bombing did not: the end of Japanese culture.

What does that mean, and how is it supported by the historical evidence in the article or elsewhere?

Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by chipsy on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:44PM (#5815879)
I have to agree.

The way the article ends with the bogeyman, "What if we didn't fear nukes as much?" has a circularity to it. What "nuclear warfare" meant in 1945 was obviously different from what it became just 15 years later - a political football that diverted people's attention, vs. an entire strategic doctrine that acted to encourage low-level proxy wars and interventions, while discouraging the "total war" practice that was conventional through the World Wars.