News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan by hef19898 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @06:51AM (#5818641)
The view point of what I had in history about WW2 and the Cold War in Germany about the use of atomic bombs against Japan was that

1 - Japan was already defeated and it was only a question of time

2 - Atomic bombs didn't drop on Germany because the Third Reich surrendered before

3 - The US needed an actual use case to assert the damage and potential of this as yet unknown weapon

4 - It was as much about threatening the sowjets as it was about ending the war in the Pacific if not more so

What I know about the late days of the second world war is that they were regarded by both the future NATO allies (read the Commonwealth and the US) and the Sowjets as the basically the first days of a future conflict between these parties. Germany and Japan didn't play much of a role in this picture any more.

So what the US got from the use of nuclear weapons was much more than just the japanese surrender. It was a stronger position compared to the Sowjets and the garantee that the war in europe didn't continue on after the German surrender. In order to prevent this, the western allies even slowed their advance to Berlin to allow the Sowjets their successes. Which doesn't mean they didn't have their fair share of it anyway.

But that is just my point of view and I'm no historian.

And finally to the point about saving lives. I've grown tired of nationalistic people stating an unverifiable estimate of probale deaths as the herois reason to kill any number people right know. You don't save people by killing others and it is certainly not heroic. I know that the victors writes the history, but this argument mostly comes up in cases where some really bad things have to reinterpreted.

There are no comments on this comment yet.