News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by simonsarris on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:10PM (#5745528)
Most people I know who own a PS3 consider it essentially a blu-ray player.

Most people I know who own an Xbox consider it essentially a Netflix player.

These people bought games, but they don't really play them.

I've got naught but my anecdata, but I think attempting to bill this new console as an entertainment system that happens to also play some great games is a very, very good idea.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Legion on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:42PM (#5746316)
At least on the Xbox side, it has a lot to do with their systematic dismantlement of the machine's GUI, which was originally a joy to use, and geared towards being, you know, a game playing machine. Now it's like webTV for the 2010s.

I used to rave about the old Blades interface and how, OMG, Microsoft made a great user experience, and how weird it was for me to feel so strongly positive about a Microsoft consumer product. So of course they destroyed everything about that interface that was so great.

When Steam put Big Picture mode in beta, I knew I was done with consoles. I got a cube-shaped PC case that was big enough for a full-size video card, put said video card with a nice Ivy Bridge i5 CPU in it, and my consoles got the permanent shut-down.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by zanny on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:45PM (#5746342)
I am concerned though about the lack of any new info on the steambox in the last, what, year? They announced their intention to create a Linux distro with Steam to run on hardware to a spec, but they haven't moved forward with it at all.

I think Valve would crush the console scene if they actually had anything to show for the hype.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Legion on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:51PM (#5746393)
> I am concerned though about the lack of any new info on the steambox in the last, what, year?

Everything I saw about the "Steam Box" suggested to me that it would be an underpowered machine for more casual games.

But the great part about Steam is that I could build my own damn hardware and use Steam and Big Picture Mode on it. So now I have a legitimate mid-range gaming PC hooked up to my TV and launching Big Picture on startup.

As a Linux user and lover, the idea of an eventual Steam box running on Linux is an exciting idea, but in the meantime, I'm running my own box on Windows.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by gcr on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:41PM (#5746676)
But they have moved forward. Portal, Half-Life 2, and (I think) Left 4 dead 2 all now work under Linux as of a few weeks ago. That's quite an achievement.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by macspoofing on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:02PM (#5746808)
To each his own I suppose, but to me the old Blades interface was atrocious. I like the current UI, though the organization could be a little smarter (e.g. frequently used apps should be more accessible)
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by incision on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:50PM (#5745876)
I own both a PS3 and a 360 and had those same use cases. Then I bought a Roku on whim at Costco one day. As a result, I've used the PS3 once in the last year, I haven't used the 360 at all.

I bought both of those consoles when they were new and collected a bunch of $60 games that I "don't really play". For several years now, the vast majority of gaming I do comes via games bought for a steep discount to console prices on Steam.

I stopped buying DVD/BDs when I realized how few of them I'd actually watch repeatedly. These days, a single $4 stream of a new release on Amazon is the norm.

I think it says something that a person like myself, who could previously be counted on to buy each new generation of console is unmoved by Xbox One.

At the same time, I expect the more mainstream customer might be just fine playing games and watching movies on the smartphone/tablet they almost surely already own.

I don't think this is a bad idea, but I do think it might be too late.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by danielweber on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:25PM (#5746161)
I think it says something that a person like myself, who could previously be counted on to buy each new generation of console is unmoved by Xbox One.

Maybe you just got old? It takes a lot to get me to play a video game these days.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by incision on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:51PM (#5746389)
>Maybe you just got old?

Oh, I definitely did, in a way that's the point.

The product appears to be aimed at my changed tastes, it's just arriving late.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by mtgx on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:39PM (#5745803)
Most of those people got one because of gaming. And then used it as a Netflix machine or blu-ray player.

But why would they pay hundreds of dollars more for a "new" Netflix machine? And if they own none of them, and just want a Netflix machine, why not buy a much better (for media) $100 Roku? Or even an Apple TV?

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by bryne on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:45PM (#5745840)
We haven't seen pricing information. Rumors surrounding a subsidized model (as some versions of the Xbox 360 were sold) have been thick.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by jiggy2011 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:08PM (#5745997)
Still, I'd be amazed if it's less than $300 new.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by yoster on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:47PM (#5746361)
I received an Xbox 360S 4GB for free from my company at the time. Bought another one for $150 along with some bootleg Hdd's from Ebay. I am going to wait a year for the price drop and to steer clear from any first gen issues.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by untog on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:18PM (#5745597)
Agreed- I will be very tempted to buy one if it handles live TV well. Right now I have a PC sat under my TV running Windows Media Center and it's awkward and showing it's age. I might buy a game too, who knows.

Alternately, I'd love to be able to put Linux on that box and make it a MythTV box. Sadly, my cable provider locks all their channels. For better or worse, MS are one of the few that could create a set top box that legally decrypts all these channels and has a great UI.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by AdrianRossouw on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @10:31PM (#5748478)
you still need to plug a (supported) cable box with hdmi output into the xb1.

my bet is they are going to make use of [1] HDMI-CEC.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HDMI#CEC

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Irregardless on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:19PM (#5746093)
Why? They just alienated gamers while showing non-gamers that they've been overpaying for a glorified Netflix machine.

I've been a diehard Xbox fan since I first got my hands on the original, but this makes me want to switch back to Playstation.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by sreyaNotfilc on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:56PM (#5746421)
The way I see it is that every new gaming console is going to do gaming better than the generation before it. Shouldn't that be a given?

Microsoft's job, as far as the Xbox, is the following... 1) Go lobby for components from various manufactures to meet the next-gen specs (whatever that may be) 2) Create tools and APIs for developers to understand the platform for which they are building 3) Improve existing services so that gamers have a consistent and enhanced experience

Its a lot of work, but its no rocket science either. Every console does this. Which goes to my point... When it comes to the games, these consoles are basically the same thing (especially the ps4 and xboxOne). Sure, some platforms may have an exclusive here and a different game there. Overall, the ps4 and the xboxOne will be matching one-for-one the basic gameplay mechanics.

What Microsoft did was say "alright, lets not focus on the redundant, but lets take a look at what separates this console from the other one (ps4)".

This is just an unveiling of what the console is. Don't worry, the games are still here. They will always be here. They could've made a presentation with nothing but demos. Sure, gamers would be delighted. But, if you think of it, it doesn't make sense to do so. Especially that E3 will be coming in only a couple of weeks. There will be plenty of games there.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by nightski on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:44PM (#5746692)
It is not really a given at all. What matters are the games, not the technology behind the console. Showing off a new COD and Madden is pretty sigh worthy at best.

My limited circle of friends who game have moved back to PC gaming and given up on consoles. We all own them, but they became glorified Netflix boxes. That was until MS decided to charge $59.99 a year for Xbox Live. Then we all bought Roku devices instead.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by jonny_eh on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:21PM (#5746925)
MS has always required you to have Xbox Live Gold to access Netflix, no? I only first got Netflix when it came to Canada, so maybe they changed it by then.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by nightski on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:55PM (#5747907)
You are probably right, but I could of sworn there was a period where Netflix did not require a Gold subscription. Maybe I just had a Gold subscription at the time for playing games online and did not think twice about it...
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by path411 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:29PM (#5746197)
What more do you want them to tell you as a gamer about the new system? They released specs and talked about the cloud gaming capabilities. Having more 3rd party game makers demo games for the system doesn't really improve my appeal to the console.

I already knew the new xbox would be the next gaming console. It seems like they went for the non-obvious, and wanted to talk about the other features. The games are going to be the draw for gamers, and I'm sure those will be just fine.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by simba-hiiipower on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:47PM (#5746357)
agreed. people make it sound like they removed some essential features, just because they didn't emphasize them enough (or because they emphasized others more).

from what i've seen this appears to match the ps4 in every way - even down to the architecture. the only difference is they glossed-over all that and decided to focus on the ways its differentiated..

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by jonny_eh on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:22PM (#5746935)
They removed the ability to buy, sell, and lend games. You have to pay an undisclosed fee to "install" a game that has already been installed, which is mandatory.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by simba-hiiipower on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @06:29PM (#5747421)
the rumor you're basing that on doesn't appear to be entirely accurate [1]. either way, i don't think its fair to draw judgment one way or another until they actually explain how that will be handled..

also, this issue is nothing new and is certainty not unique to microsoft or the xbox. i think its fairly well understood that there's going to be a change in this area as the way content is distributed continues to evolve..

whatever the actual implementation is, i'm pretty sure it wont be as bad as you're implying (... removed the ability to buy, sell, and lend games) and will probably be standard across the industry - and structured in a manner as not to totally decimate the second-hand market..

[1] http://www.polygon.com/2013/5/21/4348916/xbox-used-games

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by sreyaNotfilc on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:58PM (#5746442)
Should've read your post before I wrote mine. You wrote it better.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Caskman on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:29PM (#5746198)
How did they alienate gamers? Gamers know first and foremost that XBox is a gaming console. They should especially know that after being shown the demo of CoD Ghost. This really is a great move for them, as gamers see the benefit of additional functionality and non-gamers see an intriguing entertainment platform.

I'm a diehard PC fan though so I probably won't get a console anyways

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by benbeltran on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:54PM (#5746410)
The event's games presentations were oriented to what is usually called the "Bro gamer" demographic (e.g. Madden/FIFA/CoD) ... It focused on TV, for which many of the core gamers don't care. Contrast this to the PS4 announcement, which had many developers and a lot of talk about how the platform is going to be more "open" for the small guys, and it felt really passionate about the "for-gamers" features. As a gamer, I feel like the PS4 is where the real passion for games is, where someone actually cared to provide tools for the "indie" crowd (who, arguably, are doing the good games these days) ... Meanwhile, microsoft is showing a TV machine, has forgotten the indie channel and has killed XNA. If you don't understand why this was dissapointing for gamers, it's most probably because you are not a gamer yourself I guess. Honestly it felt passionless, pointless and underwhelming. It wasn't a blunder or anything, of course. It was just meh.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by eclipxe on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:34PM (#5746640)
"what is usually called the 'bro gamer' demographic"?

Just because I like Madden, I'm a "bro gamer" now? Get over yourself.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by benbeltran on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:13PM (#5746874)
Chill out dude. I didn't say you were a bro gamer, I didn't say I agreed with the term. I tried to answer Caskain's question on "how did they alienate gamers", and yes, part of it is the sentiment of catering to bro gamers. But notice the usage of quotes. Follow your own advice.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by eclipxe on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:22PM (#5747766)
Okay "hipster gamer". Notice the usage of quotes.

The point you're making is essentially that people that might enjoy popular franchises or particular genres of games aren't "real gamers" but a lower, subclass of gamers.

The point I'm making is that just because someone enjoys playing Madden (or football) does not mean that they don't also enjoy smaller, independent games ('yeah, most people have never heard of it'). We can be "gamers" too you know...

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by nightski on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @08:02PM (#5747937)
No your logic is just incorrect. This is simple propositional logic. If P -> Q does not imply If Q -> P. Bro gamers tend to like games like Madden & CoD. Because you like Madden & CoD does not make you a bro gamer.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by eclipxe on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:32PM (#5748703)
What is the defining characteristic of a "bro gamer" then?
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by benbeltran on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @08:14AM (#5750204)
It's bros... that are gamers.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by cobrausn on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:11PM (#5746867)
'bro gamer' is just a term used by some gamers to feel superior to the CoD demographic (which is everybody). It seems to me to be a kind of signaling used to mark themselves out as 'serious' gamers who think about 'serious' issues while they blow stuff up and shoot zombies.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by zurn on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:56AM (#5748960)
It's not a a stretch to call FPS games low brow.

I don't play FPS games, but I know smart and sensitive people who do. They don't pretend it's not a badly justified gorefest though, just like smart people who listen to Manowar don't.

A lot of people are very let down by games that get reviews just gushing over the plot and the atmosphere and puzzles but end up being 90% gore and FPS (like Bioshock for example).

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by sixbrx on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @09:24AM (#5750604)
But the referent of the "bro gamer" slight is not the game as you seem to be arguing, but the gamer.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by teamonkey on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:08PM (#5747684)
It's not everybody. CoD has a very large demographic and it encompasses a significant chunk of the console and hardcore PC gaming market, and they're better games than people give credit for, but they're far from universal appeal.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Uhhrrr on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:49PM (#5747151)
Well, if you only like Madden, you probably are. It's like if you collected art, but only art with football players in it.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by eclipxe on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:17PM (#5747727)
You sir or madam have just given me my next startup idea.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Uhhrrr on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:53PM (#5747898)
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by socialist_coder on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:32PM (#5747016)
It's true =\
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by eclipxe on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:18PM (#5747738)
I appreciate your honesty ;-)
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by cobrausn on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:06PM (#5746839)
E3 is in three weeks. They didn't want this event to focus on games, because then they'd have nothing to show at E3. But they still showed some games just to prove it had working hardware.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by estel on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @08:40PM (#5748061)
But the focus for the respective presentations could be be said to be reflective of each company's priorities for their new machine?
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by cobrausn on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @10:01AM (#5750856)
Agreed. I don't think Microsoft has to focus on the 'game' aspect of the new Xbox - the people making games for it will do that, and we know the hardware is sufficient for the next console iteration. They are focusing on the rest of the experience, which is completely under their control. I think it's a smart play and the standard gaming media is missing the point really hard.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by macoughl on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:07PM (#5746494)
That announcement trailer felt like a car commercial
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by GVIrish on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:41PM (#5746305)
Well, they announced that games would require an install to the HDD, and Wired got a confirmation from MSFT that one would have to pay a fee to install the game to another Xbox. So now people who sell their games will have their resale value reduced and people who take games to their friends' house will have to pay for the privilege.

Not exactly gamer friendly.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by matwood on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:15PM (#5745577)
I agree as long as it doesn't sound like a jet taking off in my living room. I gave up on using the 360 as a NF player because it was simply too LOUD. The ATV I have streams NF fine and is silent.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by cobrausn on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:14PM (#5746041)
A rumor I had read (can't find where now, take with many grains of salt) is part of the reason the thing is so large and, well, xbox huge, is that the cooling solution for the box is nearly silent and to do that necessitated the size.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by sk5t on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:19PM (#5745605)
The "slim" Xbox 360 made since ~summer 2010 is nice and quiet. I strongly agree that all previous versions were hatefully loud.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by potatolicious on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:21PM (#5745628)
First-gen 360 or the Xbox 360S? The first-gen made my apartment sound like a damn international airport, but the second-gen, while not whisper silent, is pretty quiet.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by minimaxir on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:13PM (#5745557)
Since the Xbox One has Blu-Ray, it'll be the best of both worlds! :)
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by Scriptor on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:24PM (#5745661)
PS3 has had Netflix for a long time as well.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by ebbv on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:55PM (#5745896)
And without requiring paying $50/year as well.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by jlgreco on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:58PM (#5745921)
You have to pay for Live if you are just using your ISP to hit netflix?
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by ebbv on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:59PM (#5745928)
Yep. Awesome, eh?

I own a 360 but I don't use it anymore.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by imissmyjuno on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:26PM (#5746170)
Is this true for Xbox One as well?
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by ebbv on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:30PM (#5746203)
Not announced yet but I'd be surprised if they give up that cash cow.

The only thing they said is that Xbox Live will continue to be based around the subscription you have now. So, Xbox Live will still cost $50/year. What services require Xbox Live on the Xbox One is not announced yet but based on the 360 the answer is probably almost everything.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by jlgreco on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:30PM (#5746206)
I would be stunned if it was. It seems entirely unjustifiable unless it is just an artifact of the 360 software being designed with only with online services that use Microsoft servers in mind. They clearly know that isn't the case anymore though, it would be pretty damn shitty of them to keep ripping people off like that.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by ebbv on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:31PM (#5746212)
Netflix on the 360 requiring Xbox Live is not an artifact. It's just a cash grab.

The 360 was the first console to offer Netflix and they had exclusivity for a while so they could do it. Once the exclusivity ended they didn't make it free because they felt no need to because lots of people continued to pay up.

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by estel on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:00PM (#5746461)
Allegedly this was a reason that BBC's iPlayer took so long to arrive on the 360. The BBC's charter was somehow contrary to MSFT's insistence that iPlayer was available only to XBL Gold members, so the release of iPlayer on 360 was delayed by years.

http://www.techradar.com/news/gaming/consoles/bbc-we-d-still...

Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by jlgreco on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:40PM (#5746304)
Ugh, that is awful. I wonder if they think they will be able to keep that up with a new console. Probably so I guess.
Re:Xbox One: Microsoft's All-In-One Home Entertainment System by rajanikanthr on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:35PM (#5747040)
I second that.. I used to play lot of games on PC.. I bought xbox and some games , but mostly I will be playing youtube videos thru my android youtube app remotely or play a movie in netflix :)