News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by buro9 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:01PM (#5719302)
> "There's bad news and there's good news," said Cheng in an interview with Ars. "The good news is, we won this case on every point. The bad news is, we're running out of lawsuits. There are fewer trolls for us to fight. I've spent a lot of time over the last seven years figuring out what to do with these guys. There are strategies I think would be really neat and effective that I literally can't execute. I can't make good law because I don't have any appellate cases left. They [the trolls] are dismissing cases against us before any dispositive motions." - Lee Cheng

.

That's a great quote.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by lifeguard on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:13PM (#5720062)
My fav,

""Shareholders of public companies that engage in patent trolling should ask themselves if they're really well-served by their management teams," Cheng added. "Are they properly monetizing their R&D? Surely there are better ways to make money than to just rely on litigating patents. If I was a shareholder, I would take a hard look as to whether their management was competent."

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by mark-r on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:16PM (#5720888)
"Surely there are better ways to make money than to just rely on litigating patents."

All evidence thus far points to the opposite, except for small exceptions such as suing NewEgg. That's why patent trolls are becoming such a huge problem - the process is so absurdly profitable that companies are formed simply to take advantage of it. There's no way their management are going to change their minds.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by lifeguard on Friday May 17, 2013 @11:55AM (#5725105)
Huh? "All evidence"? You are blathering.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by ak217 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:09PM (#5719677)
He should really open a consultancy/firm to specialize in this.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by bjhoops1 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:35PM (#5719812)
That's what I was thinking. Or some sort of non-profit that individuals and tech companies could support with donations. That would be sweet.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by James_Duval on Friday May 17, 2013 @07:12AM (#5723631)
This comment concerns me, as I would get a real "He Who Fights Monsters..." vibe off anyone who created a single-purpose legal for-profit consultancy purely to combat single-purpose legal for-profit consultancies who happen to be doing horrible things at the moment.

I really couldn't see it ending well.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by crag on Thursday May 16, 2013 @08:04PM (#5722016)
Major points for Cheng.

But, look, most trolls don't want to fight it out. They want you to settle. Once word gets out that you will fight to the death, the trolls move on to the next easier target.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by hkmurakami on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:16PM (#5719403)
obsoleting oneself - the mark of the hacker ethos? :)
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by sliverstorm on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:21PM (#5719432)
No, the "bad news" is not him humble-bragging about obsoleting himself. It's the fact that he doesn't have the opportunity to establish precedents with wins in court because he's out of cases and the trolls won't let it go to court.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:34PM (#5719801)
"establish precedents with wins in court "

That's great for him personally. It won't help newegg sell any more product or make it a better company. If I was a stockholder in that company that wouldn't fly with me. It's similar (but not the same) as an ad agency doing a campaign to win an aware for their personal glory as opposed to what is best for the client.

Edit: By "sell any more product" I mean in a meaningful way. Newegg has thousands of customers. The amount that even knows about this and the amount that care isn't significant enough to move the needle. You can always make a case that doing something will increase sales or have a benefit. Would you spend money on advertising in significant dollars without analysis or oversight of the benefits?

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by unreal37 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:00PM (#5719975)
This logic doesn't make sense.

If a kid is bullied in school, is it "more efficient" for him to give in to the bullies and just hand over his lunch money every day? Or should he take a stand over days and weeks, and then never be bothered by bullies again? Which kid grows up to be "better" at life?

I think what Newegg is doing WILL lead to bigger long-term profits in reduced license fees, reduced legal fees when the bullies stop suing them, and increased ability to compete while their competitors are restrained by restrictive licenses and license fees.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:27PM (#5720174)
"If a kid is bullied in school, is it "more efficient" for him to give in to the bullies and just hand over his lunch money every day? Or should he take a stand over days and weeks, and then never be bothered by bullies again?"

I think that depends on the circumstances. In some cases it might be more efficient to not get the shit beat out of you (that is if there aren't other ways to deal with it at the institutional level).

By take a stand you are assuming that the person being bullied can actually stand up to the bully and make him go away.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by tlear on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:43PM (#5720315)
Fighting back often all it takes, making bully pay that is.. you do not need to win every fight you just need to make people think twice about messing with you, there are always easier victims to play with.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by jessaustin on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:58PM (#5721100)
Clearly Cheng and Newegg can pass that test.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by geon on Friday May 17, 2013 @04:54AM (#5723317)
Real life doesn't always work out like Enders Game.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by Avenger42 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:51PM (#5719919)
As Cheng points out, by fighting these trolls, they make themselves a more frightening target for future infringement lawsuits, so to some extent you have to find a way to take that into account. You're spending more now, but you'll save in the long run.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by apalmer on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:15PM (#5720071)
The benefit for the company is they don't have to pay. He is a legal representative of the company who has lead a winning strategy of vigourously defending against patent lawsuits instead of by default paying a licensing fee.

Since some of the fees are between 2-12 million from the article this has real impact on the bottomline of the company.

Overall the strategy seems to have a direct monetary benefit for the company. now the question can be asked if the amount of money they are saving in licenses make up for the legal fees. apparently through these actions overall patent litigators are declining to pursue newegg for these licensing fees and going after easier targets.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by gnoway on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:56PM (#5721442)
So fighting a lawsuit that threatened to cost them money "forever" vs. whatever it cost to fight and win "now," that would not fly with you?

Could you invest in my company please? I like to spend money all the time.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by agent00f on Friday May 17, 2013 @11:36PM (#5727826)
I don't think this comment deserves to be downvoted (it's currently grey, this isn't reddit).

It's entirely a valid point to be likewise concerned if newegg investors have their fiduciary interests served by an expensive fight against injustice. This is a more general concern of tragedy of the commons where it's not in any one retailer's selfish interest to battle it out, but it's in their collective interest to solve the systemic problem.

Newegg might be heroic here in the grand scheme of things, but not necessarily for its shareholders.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by BrandonM on Friday May 17, 2013 @04:25AM (#5723243)
What if NewEgg offered a membership for small tech businesses? The businesses would pay $x for year, and would get either a nominal discount on orders, or cheaper shipping, or faster shipping, or a super-special support contact, or whatever. But the kicker would be that it would include patent defense insurance. Then, anytime one of those small companies would get patent trolled, NewEgg and Cheng could go to bat for them.

I'm not suggesting this should be cheap. Adjust the value of x until the scheme is appropriately profitable for NewEgg, and Cheng can keep fighting the good fight.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by warmwaffles on Friday May 17, 2013 @10:20AM (#5724484)
Until they get stuck with defending someone who is bad PR for newegg.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by fuzzywalrus on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:03PM (#5719319)
All I could think was: "Come at me bro!"
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:32PM (#5719788)
It's a great quote but there's a problem.

Your legal officer, your attorney or anyone at your company should realize that this isn't about them nor is it about (business wise at least) protecting anyone else but the interests of your company. His quote smacks of a challenge that he liked and as such you also have to at least question whether he operated at arms length from the problem at hand.

Newegg's business isn't fighting lawsuits.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by mullingitover on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:42PM (#5719849)
You have to admit, this is fantastic press that gives them incredible amounts of customer goodwill. See also: comment threads all over the internet with people swearing to spend money on NewEgg purchases because of their actions here.

Also, this is good long-term planning that is preventing them from being seen as easy targets by patent trolls. It could end up saving them millions.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by ibrahima on Thursday May 16, 2013 @08:53PM (#5722159)
Agreed. Personally, I had stopped using Newegg for a while because Amazon Prime made things cheaper for me overall, but Amazon is one of the companies that just pays off these patent trolls, so from now on I'm back to Newegg completely for all my hardware purchases. It's refreshing to see a company with this kind of attitude.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:53PM (#5719929)
"incredible amounts of customer goodwill"

It gives them goodwill the question is how much and what is the amount of sales increase? Hackers tend to overestimate the importance of things like this and not take into account those in flyover country or people who aren't aware of things like this. Besides publicity gain isn't a reason to pursue a strategy like this. That's not a gamble that makes sense.

"easy targets by patent trolls. It could end up saving them millions."

Companies have used similar strategies against legal predators for the longest time. Nothing new about doing that. Yet many companies led by responsible legal teams and management also settle and move on. This is not clear cut by any means.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by dasil003 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @03:42PM (#5720673)
> Hackers tend to overestimate the importance of things like this and not take into account those in flyover country or people who aren't aware of things like this.

"Flyover country" is full of hackers, but in any case, you seem to be completely ignoring Newegg's core demographic.

> Yet many companies led by responsible legal teams and management also settle and move on. This is not clear cut by any means.

You might even say most. Which is precisely why this is so interesting.

I find it disturbing to pursue this line of thought of seriously questioning whether fighting and winning against a patent troll is irresponsible leadership in a company. Doing so plays right into the patent trolls hands. So what if the bean counters can't figure a better ROI than simply settling every time? There are gray areas in business and I think it's incredibly harmful to question whether shareholder interests are being maximally served every time a company does something that might be mistaken for altruism. Should we also denounce any company that goes beyond EPA standards or donates to charity beyond what tax law would dictate optimal?

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by chetanahuja on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:28PM (#5720182)
You seem to be somewhat adamant that this obviously major victory for Newegg was actually some sort of a problem for them. And this against an adversary which managed to extract rent from the likes of Intuit, Zappos, Sears and Amazon. NewEgg's strategy was obvious born out of a principled stand to not give in to unethical patent trolls. This also makes them a much more feared opponent for any future trolls... which is a huge win for the company's investors.

"Nothing new about doing that. "

Really.. ? Did you read that article ? Could you point to another instance of a company that's been successful against patent trolls to this extent ?

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by hobs on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:19PM (#5722229)
I see you are getting downvoted a bit, but I think this is a legit point to debate.

Whether or not the bottom line is clear cut, I would say a few things: These lawyers are probably on retainer, and while they could be doing other things. This clearly gets them SOME amount of positive press, and certainly helps their bottom line if you believe that some future trolls will not attempt to sure them. It may also invalidate some laws that hurt their business and innovation which then allows them to potentially develop new products. Lastly, I would definitely argue it helps us a society, and corporations LOVE to buff their image with some hero bullshit story. Before these story, what did you know newegg for? Selling cheap hardware?

What is their new image? Champion of the internet. (and their lawyer is a godamn bawse.) I don't know if you could buy this kind of press.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by jlgreco on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:00PM (#5719976)
> Hackers tend to overestimate the importance of things like this and not take into account those in flyover country or people who aren't aware of things like this.

"'Hacker News' Hackers" also tend to grossly overestimate how well they know what is in the best interests of a company that they personally have little to do with.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:25PM (#5720165)
""'Hacker News' Hackers""

Exactly. Take Godaddy (a competitor of ours) which is one of the most hated companies ever discussed on Hacker News. Yet they continue to do great business and are clearly well liked by many others who have no clue or care about the issues that forum readers care about.

As an aside, companies that are the darling of any online forum can quickly have their name turn to "mud" if they don't continue to acquiesce to what the group thinks is the right thing to do. (Then the question is does that name turning to mud motivate those to actually take action.)

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by tmoertel on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:22PM (#5720135)
> Newegg's business isn't fighting lawsuits.

Correct. Which is why "it's a great quote." By sending the credible signal that they will fight patent trolls to the bitter end, and probably win, they avoid fights.

In terms of game theory, by making public statements of this kind, they make it harder for their future selves to settle with future trolls instead of fight. Future trolls, knowing this, will be less likely to target them. Trolls want settlements, not fights they'll probably lose.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:32PM (#5720222)
"Future trolls, knowing this, will be less likely to target them. "

We can take strategy further though instead of the obvious implementation.

What if you settle in some cases but not all cases?

So a troll sees that you settled with company "x" but upon review you feel that you aren't going to settle with them?

This happens in personal injury cases or other legal matters. Taking a "we don't settle ever stand" sends a signal that you aren't evaluating the merits of the action just taking a flat approach. Consequently nothing can be inferred as far as how you even view the merits of the action. It's all the same. Otoh, taking a "settle when necessary" doesn't imply you will always settle and sends (I would argue) a stronger message when you do fail to roll over that you aren't because you feel particularly strongly in the case before you.

In strategy (that I use for negotiating) I have always found it best to not be predictable.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by tmoertel on Thursday May 16, 2013 @03:45PM (#5720694)
In this case, however, it's better to be perfectly predictable as always fighting trolls.

Consider the game tree, as seen by the Troll considering whether to attack Company X:

        [1.1] troll's payoff = 0
        /            
       / no          
      /              
    (1) Troll: attack Company X?
      \              
       \             
        \ yes     [1.2.1] troll's payoff = +10
         \        /     
          \      / settle
           \    /       
            (1.2) X: fight or settle?
                \          
                 \         
                  \ fight     [1.2.2.1] troll's payoff = -5
                   \         /        
                    \       / drop    
                     \     /          
                     (1.2.2) Troll: fight or drop suit?
                           \           
                            \          
                             \ fight    [1.2.2.2.1] troll's payoff = +100
                              \         /         
                               \       / Troll wins
                                \     /           
                               (1.2.2.2) Nature: Troll wins or loses?
                                      \           
                                       \ Troll loses
                                        \         
                                        [1.2.2.2.2] troll's payoff = -1000
The Troll's business model is predicated on the belief that, for almost all values of X, Company X will decide to settle, should the Troll attack. Therefore, the choice from the Troll's perspective is between outcomes [1.1] with a payoff of 0 and [1.2.1] with a payoff of +10. Strategically, the Troll chooses the +10 and attacks.

But if a Company X can credibly destroy its option to settle, the Troll's expected payoffs for attacking X change to [1.2.2.1] = -5, [1.2.2.2.1] = +100, and [1.2.2.2.2] = -1000, with the +100 payoff being unlikely (because, if it were likely, the Troll's business model wouldn't be to troll). So the most likely payoffs in the Troll's estimation are either -5 (ouch) or -1000 (OUCH!).

Therefore, the Troll's best choice becomes not to attack Company X. That choice has a payoff of 0, but it's greater than the expected payoff should they fight.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @07:36PM (#5721900)
I upvoted your comment but I also note that your background and training is very different than mine is. I look at things from a human nature point of view mostly and by my gut feelings which makes me think the way I do. That has tended to work for me based on past experience. As an aside I don't have a degree in psychology or anything special that qualifies me as someone special other than just plenty of experience and observation over the years. And I happen to be exceptional at negotiation and strategy (not that I can or will prove that so take that for what it's worth). And I've certainly frustrated many attorneys over the years as well.

As a tangible example I had a case where someone wanted something from me and my lawyer said "they have a good case and you will have a really hard time etc. etc.". Legally he was right. However in my view the company that wanted the "something" also had a new facility that was opening in 3 months approx. and I realized that they would rather pay and acquire the item then they would follow a legal route (regardless of outcome or cost).

So while I am not disagreeing with the method to which you look at this it isn't the way that I think.

That said it's entirely possible that the strategy of putting up a fight each and every time could work to the advantage of someone being trolled. But I've seen enough cases of people following different legal strategies to know that it must have drawbacks because not every top legal mind seems to go that route.

As they say ask 10 get 10 opinions.

Lastly, I'm sure you would agree that a lawyer is at least somewhat biased in wanting to follow a "fight everyone" strategy as it (for lack of a better way to put it) lines his pockets.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by wpietri on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:07PM (#5720837)
Does that matter in this case?

Patent trolls are parasites looking for easy money. If Newegg is signaling that no money from them is easy, then that seems to be the best way to fend off all the lawsuits, no matter the level of perceived merit.

That wouldn't be true in the sort of patent lawsuit where somebody is defending against an existential threat. But when you're trying to influence a cost/benefit calculation, signaling "we will maximize your costs and maybe we will sink your whole operation" seems like a great way to get the extortionists to move on to other targets.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @07:45PM (#5721945)
"If Newegg is signaling that no money from them is easy, then that seems to be the best way to fend off all the lawsuits, no matter the level of perceived merit."

I get your point but would you agree that otoh it is entirely possible that a patent troll might decide to take them on in order to show that they won't go away easy as well? (variation of a Moral hazard?)

Additionally we don't really have complete data on every demand made by trolls it's not as if someone who decides to settle (and/or the patent troll) is publicly disclosing all agreements made prior to legal action, right?

We only know about when lawsuits are filed and settled. We don't know about someone settling before a suit is filed at all.

As an example a domain owner might have a publicly stated policy that they will never turn over a domain when someone comes calling even if they file a lawsuit UDRP etc. And in fact there are people that do this (google rick schwartz domain king). But how do we know the times that Mr. XYZ gets approached and does settle? It wouldn't be in his interest to tell the world about that and he could easily have an agreement with the other company that he will only agree if they don't disclose the info.

Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by wpietri on Saturday May 18, 2013 @03:26AM (#5728167)
I don't think that's the case. Trolls don't have to sue anybody in particular. But they have a strong incentive to be able to win any case they start, because, as with this story, a loss can eliminate future shakedowns.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by qq66 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:40PM (#5719836)
Newegg is a private company, so its business is whatever its owners want it to be. I don't think this guy has gone rogue, I'm sure he has the full support of Newegg leadership.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by chenster on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:46PM (#5719881)
He's also making a 'Dont' mess with us.' statement. I don't see anything wrong about he said. He's proud for what he did not just because it's his job but also for righteous reason.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by mey on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:40PM (#5719837)
It could be part of their portfolio. They are obviously willing to fight deeply on issues, nothing preventing someone like Amazon from hiring them for consultancy services.
Re:Newegg nukes "corporate troll" Alcatel in third patent ap... by LekkoscPiwa on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:19PM (#5720911)
I like solid companies. This looks like a solid company (to me). They hired the right guy who does the right thing (and is allowed to do so). This tells me a whole lot about the Neweggs culture and I think I like it (rather a lot).