Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by ezl on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:42AM
(#5718557)
so the real reason why prostitutes use linked in isn't to FIND new clients or to create networks of whores on linked in -- it's to verify that their clients aren't cops.
in a lot of places, prostitution is illegal, and clients and "service providers" alike are worried about the repercussions of getting caught. some are regular people who are trying to make money, or like their side alter ego, but don't particularly want their friends or family to find out.
getting busted is scary for both parties. in order to protect themselves, they resort to ID verifications of sorts and a variety of other practices to help them increase the odds that the person they're spending their time with is not an officer of the law.
a busy linked in profile, business cards, and a drivers license that all point to the same person is a pretty good sign that that person ACTUALLY has the job they claim and they're not a cop.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by kbenson on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:53PM
(#5719610)
I wonder what they call themselves, and what they would be comfortable with if it wasn't used in a derogatory way.
I can imagine if I a few co-workers worked at a horrible oppressing conglomerate, perhaps Veridian Dynamics, and we referred to ourselves as "drones" to denote our feelings, if management said we were no longer allowed to use this term, it would not be uplifting, it would be yet another instance of management oppression by taking away another form of expression.
This example is, of course, extremely contrived, and I can see positives in removing a term from popular use as it may shift attitudes, but I wonder how that compares with the negatives to the group itself.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by ezl on Thursday May 16, 2013 @10:04AM
(#5718650)
best job ever. just kidding. obviously, no law enforcement officer has ever engaged in sexual activity with a sex worker. that's just historical fact.
No actual sex has to happen for a crime to be committed.
Solicitation is a crime. just agreeing to submit or receive payment in exchange for sexual activity is the crime.
So law enforcement officers can set up situations where they get sex workers to agree to do things in exchange for payment, then they're busted. Confirmation through linkedin, place of business, business cards, referrals, calling clients' mothers, etc can be used to mitigate the risk that their counterparty is a cop.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by dsr_ on Thursday May 16, 2013 @11:33AM
(#5719145)
Especially since a quick Google will confirm that police officers often end up taking an unexpected retirement after complaints that they didn't pay for their sex.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by ChuckMcM on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:29PM
(#5719779)
Yes it is, there was a great piece in the Sunnyvale Sun (a local paper) about the months and months the Public Safety department spent investigating a local club to determine if there was any illegal activity going on. I thought the reporter perfectly walked the line between 'serious' and 'yeah right.'
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @10:03AM
(#5718644)
"a busy linked in profile, business cards, and a drivers license that all point to the same person is a pretty good sign that that person ACTUALLY has the job they claim and they're not a cop."
It would seem almost trivial to create a believable linkedin profile that could fool anybody. I get linkedin requests all the time from people who I don't know who are trolling to build up a profile.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by ezl on Thursday May 16, 2013 @10:07AM
(#5718660)
i don't think anyone is under the delusion that it is foolproof.
Obviously, cops can fake all that stuff. But if you're just an average sex worker, the law probably doesn't have it out specifically for you, and it's a lot lower hanging fruit to just go for the careless sex workers who don't even verify.
The amount of time/effort they would have to spend (while not necessarily a lot) wouldn't be justified by the probably non-existent increase in the total busts, unless they had an axe to grind against a specific provider for some reason.
source: i moonlight as a male prostitute. and i disappoint a lot of women.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by loup-vaillant on Thursday May 16, 2013 @11:23AM
(#5719080)
Wait a minute: does the lack of quotes after "source:" mean you are speaking from personal experience? (Genuine question. At first, I though you were citing the title of some book.)
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:49PM
(#5719589)
"wouldn't be justified by the probably non-existent increase in the total busts"
Interesting thought. Almost similar to why cops don't do a better job of trapper speeders. And why they don't even catch speeders they sometimes just lurk in plain site to slow down traffic.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by carlob on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:30AM
(#5718501)
Call me old fashioned, but I still don't get these articles that consist of 10 copy-pasted tweets. Where's the content? Other than the press release and some comments from random people, this has 0 information content.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by patmcguire on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:53AM
(#5718606)
It's a lazy version of Man on the Street, which news used to do a lot. The difference being 1) laziness and 2) the ability to cherry pick to a much greater extent.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:35AM
(#5718525)
I had never thought of it before, but LinkedIn is a brilliant place for a escort to market their services. Lots of business travellers, who are often a middle-aged man travelling alone. The marks should have money, are likely to be disease and drug free, and probably these exchanges occur in a low risk environment such as a business traveler's hotel.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by larrys on Thursday May 16, 2013 @12:51PM
(#5719598)
I suspect that they also troll as follows. Friend a business person with a professional looking profile with a picture. Interact a bit. Then go for the sale.
I guess that seems like to much work but in a sense it might yield a completely virgin market (business people traveling who would never think to read an ad or make pro active contact.) Almost like the bar honeypot.
Add: And be able to charge a premium rate because those contacted don't have any clue of the going rate and they have been enticed before they are able to pull back (not having any viable alternatives).
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by virtualritz on Thursday May 16, 2013 @11:18AM
(#5719043)
The problem seems to me that sex work is stigmatized and, as a direct result of that, still not legalized and regulated in too many 1st world countries.
The 1st world global cultural gap (between e.g. the US and Europe, or even northern and souther Europe) may seem small when you stroll through your average mall to shop for apparel.
But it is often huge when it comes to views about morale and what is considered ok or not ok.
To someone from northern Europe who is living in a country where sex work is 'ok' in most people's view, legalized anyway and regulated in recent years, this LinkedIn stuff is one of these stories that sound like they're from another, previous century.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by oneandoneis2 on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:26AM
(#5718480)
The reason this got talked about in my workplace was that another article covering it claimed that people were even endorsing prostitutes for various skills on LinkedIn.. the mind boggles :)
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by anxx on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:58AM
(#5718621)
ok, in which countries do sex workers identify themselves with their name and actual profession and it is completely ok? likewho would even create a profile like this?
don't other families don't trash her as a bad mother, doesn't it affect their employment prospects, are their kids or parents not harassed etc?
if there is a country like that i want to live there.
Re:Does LinkedIn have a prostitution problem?
by speeder on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:52AM
(#5718600)
I am speculating that the reason LinkedIn did it, is to get distanced from legal problems, not only in relation to prostitution laws (for example, Brazil says prostitution is allowed, but facilitating prostitution is not... LinkedIn was a facilitator? Also, several other countries have equally, or even more confusing laws on the subject), but also to law enforcement efforts against sex slavery and human trafficking.
I guess LinkedIn don't want the ball thrown on their court and be responsible for checking who is a real prostitute and who is a slave or a scammer.
in a lot of places, prostitution is illegal, and clients and "service providers" alike are worried about the repercussions of getting caught. some are regular people who are trying to make money, or like their side alter ego, but don't particularly want their friends or family to find out.
getting busted is scary for both parties. in order to protect themselves, they resort to ID verifications of sorts and a variety of other practices to help them increase the odds that the person they're spending their time with is not an officer of the law.
a busy linked in profile, business cards, and a drivers license that all point to the same person is a pretty good sign that that person ACTUALLY has the job they claim and they're not a cop.
source: i love hookers.
Can we at least call them prostitues if sex worker is too PC for HN?
"Hey, what's the problem with being a fucking whore?" (Street whore¹ in Dexter –forgot which episode.)
"I have a lot of respect for whores." (witness in a radio documentary —quite moving, by the way.)
[1] I swear I mean no disrespect.
I can imagine if I a few co-workers worked at a horrible oppressing conglomerate, perhaps Veridian Dynamics, and we referred to ourselves as "drones" to denote our feelings, if management said we were no longer allowed to use this term, it would not be uplifting, it would be yet another instance of management oppression by taking away another form of expression.
This example is, of course, extremely contrived, and I can see positives in removing a term from popular use as it may shift attitudes, but I wonder how that compares with the negatives to the group itself.
-- gandhi
No actual sex has to happen for a crime to be committed.
Solicitation is a crime. just agreeing to submit or receive payment in exchange for sexual activity is the crime.
So law enforcement officers can set up situations where they get sex workers to agree to do things in exchange for payment, then they're busted. Confirmation through linkedin, place of business, business cards, referrals, calling clients' mothers, etc can be used to mitigate the risk that their counterparty is a cop.
http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/solicitation-o...
For example, http://boston.com/metrodesk/2013/03/29/boston-detective-arre...
It would seem almost trivial to create a believable linkedin profile that could fool anybody. I get linkedin requests all the time from people who I don't know who are trolling to build up a profile.
And "business cards"?
Obviously, cops can fake all that stuff. But if you're just an average sex worker, the law probably doesn't have it out specifically for you, and it's a lot lower hanging fruit to just go for the careless sex workers who don't even verify.
The amount of time/effort they would have to spend (while not necessarily a lot) wouldn't be justified by the probably non-existent increase in the total busts, unless they had an axe to grind against a specific provider for some reason.
source: i moonlight as a male prostitute. and i disappoint a lot of women.
Interesting thought. Almost similar to why cops don't do a better job of trapper speeders. And why they don't even catch speeders they sometimes just lurk in plain site to slow down traffic.
Describe how you got here!
I guess that seems like to much work but in a sense it might yield a completely virgin market (business people traveling who would never think to read an ad or make pro active contact.) Almost like the bar honeypot.
Add: And be able to charge a premium rate because those contacted don't have any clue of the going rate and they have been enticed before they are able to pull back (not having any viable alternatives).
The 1st world global cultural gap (between e.g. the US and Europe, or even northern and souther Europe) may seem small when you stroll through your average mall to shop for apparel.
But it is often huge when it comes to views about morale and what is considered ok or not ok.
To someone from northern Europe who is living in a country where sex work is 'ok' in most people's view, legalized anyway and regulated in recent years, this LinkedIn stuff is one of these stories that sound like they're from another, previous century.
http://www.theonion.com/articles/area-man-still-searching-fo...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
Have they had a real problem, or is it merely moralistic?
don't other families don't trash her as a bad mother, doesn't it affect their employment prospects, are their kids or parents not harassed etc?
if there is a country like that i want to live there.
I guess LinkedIn don't want the ball thrown on their court and be responsible for checking who is a real prostitute and who is a slave or a scammer.