Being an underinformed naysayer isn't any worse than being an underinformed cheerleader. The only difference is that the naysayers appear to have been wrong in this case for this earnings period. I wouldn't be surprised if many were over influenced by skepticism about a company run by a large personality. It is easy to err in the other direction, too.
Solyndra sold a highly fungible commodity in a saturated market. Tesla is selling a machine that, when any skeptic sees it in a showroom, starts to impress in a way that is visceral. My conservative, rural father got in one at a showroom I took him to. He was blown away by the build quality. He knows cars, he knows metal, and he knows engineering. He told me that, mechanically, it is the best built car he has ever seen. He is a car guy, and used to drag me to car shows constantly as a kid.
His only objection was that he couldn't use one where he lives because of the two miles of dirt road he has to traverse to get to his home. I told him they were coming out with an SUV. He now owns stock.
Some quick math for fun's sake:
If the TechCrunch[1] article is still accurate, Musk owns 28.4% of TSLA. His paper-worth on this ownership this morning was $1.8B. If things stabilize at $70/share, his paper-worth tomorrow morning will be $2.3B.
A notional profit of $500 million in 24 hours isn't too shabby.
0.284 * $7.5 billion = $2.13 billion
His gain, assuming a 20% jump, is about $300 million.
At market close TSLA's market cap was $6.39 billion.
It's not a 24 hours profit. He didn't buy that stock yesterday, nor could he have without making the price go a lot higher than 70$. You can't judge his profit on the short term.
It's clear he doesn't have an extra $500mm in a checking account.
Edit: here's an article referring to the change http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=f8c96f0e-832c-...
I believe OP was wrong with regards to a restriction on when information can be released relative to earnings. Elon could have tweeted it a few days ago and it wouldn't have made a difference to the SEC in regards to the timing of the release.
Another issue is making sure that material information is disclosed properly. Elon was essentially hinting that they were going to have a really good quarter. That kind of information is material and would likely need to be disclosed properly to all investors at once. However, I believe disclosing that information has nothing to do with the timing of earnings release. A company can disclose any information it would like at anytime, so long as it does so properly.
If I'm wrong, please let me know in reply. I'm very curious about whether I am making a mistake.
What likely happens is the company releases the material information through proper channels and then company representatives use that information as talking points during an interview. Some new information could be given during the interview but it's likely to be minor stuff like specifics on features for a product.
EDIT: My mistake, this was said much longer ago (September 2012). I just read it recently. Thanks to batbomb for pointing this out. My apologies.
“It’s doing pretty well actually given that we’re such a huge short position. In fact I think the short position may be as high as one can actually go. They literally hit the ceiling on the short position. The shorts are in it to the hills. I think it is very unwise to be shorting Tesla, it’s very unwise. There is a tsunami of hurt coming for the short."
http://www.siliconbeat.com/2012/09/13/video-elon-musk-tells-...