EDIT: My mistake, this was said much longer ago (September 2012). I just read it recently. Thanks to batbomb for pointing this out. My apologies.
“It’s doing pretty well actually given that we’re such a huge short position. In fact I think the short position may be as high as one can actually go. They literally hit the ceiling on the short position. The shorts are in it to the hills. I think it is very unwise to be shorting Tesla, it’s very unwise. There is a tsunami of hurt coming for the short."
http://www.siliconbeat.com/2012/09/13/video-elon-musk-tells-...
Being an underinformed naysayer isn't any worse than being an underinformed cheerleader. The only difference is that the naysayers appear to have been wrong in this case for this earnings period. I wouldn't be surprised if many were over influenced by skepticism about a company run by a large personality. It is easy to err in the other direction, too.
Solyndra sold a highly fungible commodity in a saturated market. Tesla is selling a machine that, when any skeptic sees it in a showroom, starts to impress in a way that is visceral. My conservative, rural father got in one at a showroom I took him to. He was blown away by the build quality. He knows cars, he knows metal, and he knows engineering. He told me that, mechanically, it is the best built car he has ever seen. He is a car guy, and used to drag me to car shows constantly as a kid.
His only objection was that he couldn't use one where he lives because of the two miles of dirt road he has to traverse to get to his home. I told him they were coming out with an SUV. He now owns stock.
Some quick math for fun's sake:
If the TechCrunch[1] article is still accurate, Musk owns 28.4% of TSLA. His paper-worth on this ownership this morning was $1.8B. If things stabilize at $70/share, his paper-worth tomorrow morning will be $2.3B.
A notional profit of $500 million in 24 hours isn't too shabby.
0.284 * $7.5 billion = $2.13 billion
His gain, assuming a 20% jump, is about $300 million.
At market close TSLA's market cap was $6.39 billion.
It's not a 24 hours profit. He didn't buy that stock yesterday, nor could he have without making the price go a lot higher than 70$. You can't judge his profit on the short term.
It's clear he doesn't have an extra $500mm in a checking account.
Edit: here's an article referring to the change http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=f8c96f0e-832c-...
I believe OP was wrong with regards to a restriction on when information can be released relative to earnings. Elon could have tweeted it a few days ago and it wouldn't have made a difference to the SEC in regards to the timing of the release.
Another issue is making sure that material information is disclosed properly. Elon was essentially hinting that they were going to have a really good quarter. That kind of information is material and would likely need to be disclosed properly to all investors at once. However, I believe disclosing that information has nothing to do with the timing of earnings release. A company can disclose any information it would like at anytime, so long as it does so properly.
If I'm wrong, please let me know in reply. I'm very curious about whether I am making a mistake.
What likely happens is the company releases the material information through proper channels and then company representatives use that information as talking points during an interview. Some new information could be given during the interview but it's likely to be minor stuff like specifics on features for a product.
I had never heard of that happening to small individual investors like me, and at that time I looked into it and learned that this was typically done because there was a lot of interest in short sales for the stock and there wasn't enough borrowable stock to cover demands.
I renew the loan agreement on a monthly basis and in March 2013 I was offered an increase from 4% to 6% interest for the loan of my shares, indicating that short-sellers were very eager to get their hands on TSLA stock.
I'm curious to see if today's activities cause my June offer to drop my interest rate or if the offer just expires altogether. I would guess that at minimum I'll see a lower interest rate.
Brokers do charge interest rates and the rates for TESLA really were 45% (current) and 85% (once upon a time) annualized, mostly because of a deficiency in available shares. At that point it was costing 60c per share a week just to keep your short position.
Theres plenty of discussion here: http://www.teslamotorsclub.com/showthread.php/15183-Cost-to-...
I was thinking of this: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/shortinterest.asp
You can see the short interest in TSLA here published twice a month: http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/tsla/short-interest which is very high compared to AAPL's short interest: http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/aapl/short-interest which hovers around one day to cover.
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/op?s=TSLA+Options
...the implication is that unhedged longs are carrying the real risk.
I can somewhat relate to why one would take this strategy, as Tesla is getting a lot of hype, implying that the stock might break out (or already did, currently at $71), but they are also in a fairly precarious financial situation, with a ton of debt. Elon himself warned that if the company didn't get to positive cash flow it was likely they would go under. Still it seems like a high price to pay for a hedge, wouldn't it be simpler (and possibly cheaper) just to reduce your long position?
A straddle involves buying both a call and a put. If a stock is trading at 10, and you buy a PUT at 8 and a call at 12, you make money if the stock goes above 12 or below 8, between that, you eat the option price. Basically a straddle is betting on volatility.
You can also sell a straddle, sell a put and sell a call, and bet that stock will remain at the same price.
What you are describing is a short squeeze, and it's still unclear if that is indeed what we are seeing. Many shorts have been unwilling to cover, even when having to pay up to 85% lending rates for stock. A proper short squeeze would not only spike the price, it will make it explode; Volkswagen became the most valuable company in the world at a share price of 1k$ through a short squeeze (even if only for a short time).
Remember also that a short squeeze depends on long investors not taking profit. It only worked in VW because the majority of shares were held by institutions unwilling to reduce their stake and of course Porsche, who manufactured the squeeze.
For Tesla: http://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/companyNews?symbol=TSL...
Investing around a short squeeze is out of your control, and I would argue, not worth worrying about. The price will bounce around like crazy and some people will make 30% in a day while others lose much more than that, but in the end, Tesla's price will reflect their ability to turn a profit in the future.
If you feel like the future market cap of Tesla is larger than it is today (with all the usual time-value-of-money caveats), keep your money invested and don't waste your time fretting over the mayhem on Wall St.
Read up on portfolio theory and you will see that it's incredibly difficult (some say impossible) to beat the risk adjusted return of the market (at least not on purpose). It turns out if you are not in many stocks - 40+ (the exact number depends on who you ask), then you are taking more risk than you are being compensated for.
Regardless of solicited or not, I do agree with your advice and if nothing else, hopefully readers who fear to ask such questions gain from friendly advice such as yours
EDIT: grammar
Usually data from there is just parsed from the variety of forms that a public company has to file with the SEC, all/most of which are available to the public via a tool they have called EDGAR. Here's Tesla's filings: http://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany...
EDIT: also, congratulations :) ask a real professional, but if you're tempted to sell be aware your holding period and of the tax difference between long and short term capital gains. Also, if you want to sell tomorrow and re-buy, be aware of wash sale rules.
Shares Short (as of Apr 15, 2013): 30.70M
Shares Outstanding: 114.52M
EDIT - I guess this is more relevant:
Short % of Float (as of Apr 15, 2013)3: 49.20%
EDIT #2: Congrats on the gains today! :-)
This is true in general obviously, but investing specifically is filled with explanations like this that make sense only in hindsight.
If you wanted de-risk your position, you could set up an option straddle or just sell your shares before the announcement and then buy them again next week.
So in other words if you read big news the minute it comes out about a company, automated systems and institutional traders have already made their moves based on the news before retail investors have a chance.
Also, with actively managed strategies, it only takes one or two bad bets to wipe out years of gains, and due to natural biases, individual investors tend to under-report/weight losses and over-report/weight the gains. As such, we always tend to hear how other investors are making a killing on a certain stock or trade, but we rarely hear from the losers, which distorts our perceptions of risk and returns (so far, I have seen a handful of people talk about their Tesla stock holdings on this thread, but I have yet to see a single person talk about haw bad they are getting cleaned out because they shorted the stock).
Back when I lived in NY and worked in bond markets, an interesting study came out evaluating active mutual fund managers. A chance distribution was able to account for all but 2 at a 95% confidence level. Those two exceptions were named Peter Lynch and Warren Buffett.
Peter Lynch unfortunately retired from active investing, and his advice is that people should invest in indexed mutual funds. He also is not unexplainable by chance - the chance of someone having done that well by chance was under 5%, but it was still possible.
At a 99% confidence level, only Warren Buffett was left.
Warren Buffett is unquestionably knowledgeable. But his returns have been boosted over the long term by a couple of major investing advantages. The first is that he likes to buy whole companies, and is reportedly a stellar manager. His management expertise then turns into improved returns for that company, which becomes a good investment. Thus the cause/effect relationship is not clear. The second advantage is that when a company has problems (eg Goldman Sachs in 2008) they tend to call Warren, because they know that if they get him on board then they will restore confidence. But the deal that he gets is significantly better than what anyone else can get from that company.
The study did not include hedge funds like the one George Soros ran because their complex trading strategies can't readily be compared.
Anyways, the professionals can't run funds which beat chance returns. Why do you think will be able to?
(Technical detail. It is possible to beat the averages, and my understanding is that the professionals do on average tend to do so. The problem is that their cost of beating the average is sufficiently high that their funds don't come out ahead. And the results of their research get reflected in the stock price, which is available for everyone to look at.)
Some of them are really not gamblers but man, there are so many many of them willing to play with other people's money.
As long as they have zero-risk (zero responsibility, that is), they will gamble on.
Seeing short squeezes in TSLA and GMCR aftermarket.
High-Level Summary:
There was a ton of short-selling interest on TSLA (due to expectations of a big earnings miss). Almost 27% of the 115mm shares outstanding are currently being borrowed by short sellers. TSLA has more short interest by percentage than 98% of US stocks. Everyone was really expecting the price to go down.
Tesla reported earnings today at $.12/share, and upped their forward guidance. The consensus earnings estimates were $.04/share, so TSLA greatly surpassed expectations.
To short a stock, you have to borrow a share from someone else, and then return that stock to them at a later date. Returning the stock is called 'Covering a short'. All those people who were betting against TSLA are now forced to pile back into the market to cover, but since so many shares were short to begin with, the number of people who have stock to sell is much lower than typical.
This results in a 'short covering rally' where there is a lot of demand to buy shares and a small supply. Econ. 101 takes over and you see a big spike in the price.