News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by tptacek on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:02PM (#5526855)
Don't worry! It won't ever fall below its intrinsic value!
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by clicks on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:10PM (#5526912)
Serious question: Is that really a fair criticism of BTC? Because afterall, our beloved US currency is fiat based, and often subject to whims of geopolitical games.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by bdr on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:27PM (#5527476)
Actually, you can set a price floor on Bitcoin. It's the dollar value of the transaction float at The Silk Road.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by richardwhiuk on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:33PM (#5527078)
USD are backed by the fact that US citizens have to pay in USD to pay their taxes. Bitcoins have no such imperative.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:31PM (#5527506)
My Econ 101 understanding is that the value of USD is not primarily due to taxes, i.e. if the government stopped collecting taxes (or started forcing people to pay taxes in gold or Euros) the value of the dollar would not tank. Instead, we're in a Nash equilibrium where we're all accepting dollars as a means of exchange and it would be costly and have little benefit for individuals to defect. The intrinsic value of the dollar is roughly set by the value of all good and services exchanged in a given time period divided by the number of dollars in circulation.

That said, the tax part does add a bit of stability in the form of an additional friction to any hypothetical plan for everyone in the US to coordinate to start exchanging gold or Euros in lieu of dollars.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by nhaehnle on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:39PM (#5528391)
You are talking about slightly different things. A lot of the reason why fiat money has value is obviously circular logic: You can use it to buy money at the store, because the store needs to pay its suppliers in the same currency, who needs to pay its employees in the same currency, who are happy (more or less) to work for the same currency because they can use it to buy the things that they need.

The vast volume of why the value is there is clearly because of such thinking, so you are right.

But the parent post is also right, because circular logic tends to be awfully inadequate at explaining things. This is where taxation comes in, because it serves as the "induction base case", so to speak. Taxation is what sets the wheel in motion initially; the additional momentum then builds gradually, but the continued existence of the base case is what gives it stability.

Take taxation away, and the wheel will still continue because loan repayment acts as a "secondary base case". But once that secondary base case disappears as well, it is just a matter of time until collapse - kind of like the cartoon characters that keep running over the edge of the cliff, until they look down and notice gravity.

So if you want to understand why money has value in the first place, the parent comment gives the better answer. But that doesn't mean your reply is wrong, either.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:15PM (#5528572)
OK, I kind of agree. I think "circular logic" is a very bad term here, because it suggests a mistake in logical reasoning, when in fact you just mean that the Nash equilibrium is only meta stable. Similarly, "induction base case" is bad because it again suggests reasoning, but I think here you recognize that and put it in quotes to show that it's just an analogy (and a neat one at that).

But I disagree that you need taxation as a bootstrap to get you to the equilibrium. Indeed, in the actual history of the US it was the backing by gold that established the dollar; initial taxation was minimal. Now that backing has been removed, and the dollar still functions. Then, I infer, you would argue that taxation has replaced gold-backing as the stabilizer.

Your penultimate paragraph is an interesting suggestion, but I'm not convinced. Could you point me toward some place where it was fleshed out? I can easily imagine a world where people keep writing new contracts denominated in dollars, whose street value is set by the process that I described. Where is the motivation for people to defect? One answer is that a new currency (like Bitcoin) comes along that has special properties that make it useful enough for people to absorb transaction costs and to start exchanging alongside the original fiat currency. Then things could unravel. And indeed, taxation could suppress this by providing additional friction like I mentioned in my original comment. But in the absence of such a new currency I don't expect the dollar to spontaneously start to unravel on its own simply because there are no taxes. People would continue to need a medium of exchange and the dollar is very good.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by betterunix on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:00PM (#5529251)
"My Econ 101 understanding"

Go just a bit past Econ 101, and you'll discover that economists do not universally agree on these things. That being said, here is one popular view:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_monetary_theory

From wiki:

"[Knapp] argued the state could create pure paper money and make it exchangeable by recognising it as legal tender, with the criterion for the money of a state being "that which is accepted at the public pay offices"."

Or in other words, taxes, torts, and other laws give money its value.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by chii on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:32AM (#5531472)
> Or in other words, taxes, torts, and other laws give money its value.

i think legitimacy is more correct than value - value is a result of what people demand in exchange for their goods/services. Legitimacy is the trust that people have on the currency (ie, the trust that others woudl also accept the currency).

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by crapshoot101 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:13PM (#5527818)
correct in a sense- the US dollar is backed by the full faith and credit of the US Government, nothing more. Would I still have that faith in the US $ if the government did not collect taxes / did not seem like a stable entity? Probably not, but your point is still valid
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by mcherm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:52PM (#5528462)
Um, no. The US dollar is backed by US law guaranteeing that it must be accepted as payment for all debts and by US law requiring taxes to be paid in USD. All of which, as the parent post points out, is dwarfed by the backing provided by all the merchants, banks, and consumers in the world who are using USD today. The corner grocery store in Pottsville, PA backs the USD by accepting it as payment for frozen pizza and toothpaste. The drug dealer in Venezuela backs the USD by accepting payment in $100 USD bills. These are the most important backing for the USD (the "Nash equilibrium" that the parent post mentioned.

And that kind of backing is what the community is TRYING to build for BTC.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:27PM (#5528630)
> The US dollar is backed by US law guaranteeing that it must be accepted as payment for all debts

I believe this doesn't stop people from creating special obligations through contracts that are denominated in other currencies. It more means that if I run over your mailbox and a judge orders me to compensate you, I can use dollars.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by mcherm on Thursday April 11, 2013 @01:50PM (#5533541)
Precisely. It means that if you sue me for ANY reason (including failure to live up to my end of a contract) the state will allow me to pay in dollars.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Friday April 12, 2013 @05:11PM (#5541036)
Ahh, this is a good point. Thanks.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by danudey on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:46PM (#5529011)
> The US dollar is backed by US law guaranteeing that it must be accepted as payment for all debts

If you're referring to the 'legal tender for all debts public and private' clause on the notes themselves, that means that it can be used for such purposes, not that it must be accepted. If we agree that I'll do your deck and you'll give me your car, you can't just say 'I want to keep my car, here's some cash instead'.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by mcherm on Thursday April 11, 2013 @01:56PM (#5533589)
> it can be used for such purposes, not that it must be accepted

Before the contract is agreed to, the parties can make any arrangement they want, including agreeing to pay in bitcoins. But if one party fails to deliver and they wind up in court, then the court (as kragen pointed out) will almost never require them to deliver the item, the court will instead require that the victim be compensated and will allow dollars to be used to compensate them.

Now, if bitcoins were worth $250 each at the time the deck got painted and are only worth $160 each by the time the court case completes, there is a fairly good chance that the court will demand the $250 price be used to determine what the compensation should be.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by kragen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:56PM (#5529466)
Generally speaking, if I say that and you take me to court to get my car, the court will award you damages, which I can pay with some cash. The alternative, where the court orders me to give you my car, is called "specific performance" and is very rare.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:47PM (#5528052)
> the US dollar is backed by the full faith and credit of the US Government

Huh? What does this mean? This phrase can be applied to government bond ("The US gov't promises to pay you back") or to FDIC insurance ("The US gov't promises to refund your money if your bank closes"). But it doesn't have any meaning for dollars, unless it were to mean that the gov't would exchange it for gold, which of course is false.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:21PM (#5528275)
Not true. The fact that you're somewhat informed on these matters is working against you here.

If the US Gov't stopped collecting taxes -- or had some other substantial liquidity crisis -- the very real issue is debt service. Since the USD is the global reserve currency, we are in the rather unique situation of having our debt denominated in our own currency under control of our own central bank. This is where the "full faith and credit" of the USA enters the discussion of our currency. If we had issues servicing our public debt, the government has the option of devaluing our currency. In other words, inflating away our debt. In such a scenario, the value of USD plunges against foreign currencies, and there would be a massive effort by everybody with substantial USD holdings to sell.

This, among other reasons, is why Keynes envisioned a super-national reserve currency traded among central banks. If the US public debt was denominated in Bancor, the option of inflating it away wouldn't exist.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:01PM (#5528509)
First, I think the interesting question is just about fiat currencies, not the US in particular. The global reserve currency aspect is a secondary effect. Let's concentrate on a generic fiat currency issued by a government.

So you're saying that "full faith and credit" just means "The gov't promises not to crazily inflate the money by printing lots of it". Fine. (That doesn't explain what process determines the street value, it just acknowledges that the government can destroy it.)

I don't really see how the rest of what you are talking about applies to my comment. Are you claiming that fiat currencies are impossible in countries without debt?

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:20PM (#5528589)
No, you don't have to have debt to have good credit.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:55PM (#5528766)
It sounds like you are suggesting that fiat currency functions like debt, but I've never understood this claim.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by khuey on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:38PM (#5528381)
That situation is not rather unique at all. Most developed nations issue debt in a currency controlled by their central bank, with the notable exception of the Eurozone.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:13PM (#5528561)
Your point is a little misleading I think. How big is the list of "most developed nations" after you remove the US and Euro Zone from the list?

Yes, every country CAN issue national debt. But issuing sovereign debt is more common largely because investors prefer it.

Either way, I didn't mean to sound misleading by calling it "rather unique." Thanks for helping me clarify.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by kragen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:10PM (#5529517)
Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, England, Russia, Canada, Australia, Switzerland, Iceland, Israel, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, New Zealand, and arguably PRC, Brazil, Argentina, Turkey, India, Mexico, Indonesia, Qatar, and Chile, are all developed nations not in the US or Eurozone.

You are, however, correct that most of these countries issue their debt in US dollars ("sovereign debt") rather than their national currencies.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by betterunix on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:05PM (#5529274)
"it doesn't have any meaning for dollars, unless it were to mean that the gov't would exchange it for gold, which of course is false."

It means, "The government will accept it for tax payment," and for the payment of various other debts and fees.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by crapshoot101 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:32PM (#5528338)
it means it is not backed by a hard asset or a promise - the dollar is not redeemable for anything.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by fnayr on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:38PM (#5528969)
As a game theorist, I got happy when you used Nash equilibrium in your explanation.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by justatdotin on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:45PM (#5529004)
bullets.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:13PM (#5526933)
US currency isn't backed by gold- it is in a sense backed by the US government. BTC is wholly unbacked.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jacquesm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:48PM (#5527618)
US currency is backed by the land the US is built on and the means to defend that land, as well as the ability of US citizens to expend their time in a productive way.

And to some extent it is currently based on the ability of the United States to protect its interests overseas, the trading of oil in the US dollar and significant trade partners accepting the US dollar as a means of exchange for goods shipped to the US.

And that works as long as significant portion of the world continues to believe in all of the above, if that should ever stop I hope I won't be there to watch the carnage. That's the kind of 'interesting times' that one would hope to avoid.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:06PM (#5527768)
I'd like to point out that this is the same for just about every country.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:24PM (#5528300)
Not really. The USD benefits greatly from being the global reserve currency.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by chii on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:40AM (#5531514)
Yes. THis is true because the Fed reserve can print more USD, and an overseas oil vendor would actually sell the goods in exchange for the said USD. However, you noticed that the Fed reserve hasn't actually produced any actual value/productivity - they merely printed some pieces of paper.

There for, the US gov't (or more correctly, the Fed reserve) can print their way out of debt that they owe to third parties, until those third parties all wise up. But then you got 11 air craft carriers paroling the world, untold number of submarines and missiles, massive air force etc, and if the US gets a whiff that you are no longer denominating your goods (e.g., oil) in USD, you might find yourself being called the axis of evil.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by camus on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:55PM (#5527665)
when Europe falls things will change eventually.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by bjcubsfan on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:10PM (#5528198)
Bitcoin is backed by a faith in the algorithms that enable Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by slg on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:14PM (#5526940)
The same geopolitical games also back the US currency. So it is no longer gold back but ICBM backed.
[deleted]
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by hcho on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:41PM (#5527127)
And what's the backing of US citizens paying taxes? If all of the population decided to not pay taxes tomorrow, what power US government has to make them pay up? Government itself operates on the backing of people's consent. That's not too different from Bitcoin users' consent.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:15PM (#5527377)
> If all of the population decided to not pay taxes tomorrow, what power US government has to make them pay up?

If all the population did that, that would mean the government had decided that. The population and the government aren't disjoint sets.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by hcho on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:31PM (#5527503)
So you too are saying government is there by populations consent. Taxes and USD are by products of that consent. So is bitcoin, or any other medium of exchange really.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jerf on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:15PM (#5527837)
No, it's not just backed by mere consent. Try not paying your taxes. It's backed by the people who will make good on those promises by force.

It is true that nothing absolutely guarantees the value of the US dollar in the strongest absolute sense, but that's true of absolutely everything. There are no absolute stores of value that are guaranteed. (This bothers a lot of people, but it's true.) But there's a qualitative difference between being backed by the US government and being backed by nothing at all, a very substantial one.

I would point out that one of the usual things touted in BitCoin's favor is precisely that fiat currency can be arbitrarily manipulated by governments; this is possible because the backer of a currency can manipulate said currency, in a way that I cannot. On the other hand, I can arbitrarily issue and manipulate JerfDollars, but nobody takes them. (Not even me.) One of the things BitCoin tries to solve is precisely that people don't like what's backing the US Dollar, and they'd rather try something else. If it were indeed a backingless currency precisely like the US Dollar, the entire point of BitCoin goes up in smoke; what's the difference between two backingless currencies? Not much. In trying to claim that the two currencies are identical in this fashion, you may win the battle but you lose the war entirely.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by tomkarlo on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:05PM (#5527752)
Yes, but the implications of not consenting are grossly different. If folks don't consent to taxes and USD, they're essentially giving up on things like Social Security, the value of their homes (both in terms of security and transaction value), the value of their income, etc. ... all kinds of secondary effects. If they give up on Bitcoin, they might lose the value of their holdings (which could be zero) but they don't have those secondary losses.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by khuey on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:39PM (#5528388)
No, if you don't consent to taxes you get put in a cage. If you don't consent to bitcoin you don't get caught up in a speculative bubble.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by chii on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:42AM (#5531525)
if an individual don't consent to paying taxes, they get put in a cage. But if an entire population don't consent to paying taxes, something else is going on.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by aero142 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:16PM (#5526953)
So, what do you think the intrinsic or non-monetary price of gold is?
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by Symmetry on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:43PM (#5527141)
Gold is useful stuff in all sorts of electronic applications... I'd say at least 4x that of Bismuth or around $50/pound.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by akavi on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:47PM (#5527189)
So, about 0.2% of its actual value.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by srbloom on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:35PM (#5527523)
"current" is more precise than "actual"
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dunmalg on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:38PM (#5527539)
more like 0.2% of its actual COST. His point is that he thinks cost and value are out of sync.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jpadkins on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:08PM (#5527786)
actually, wouldn't the cost be the marginal cost to pull gold out the earth? I thought that was around $500/oz.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by andrewljohnson on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:59PM (#5527704)
That's ridiculous. Gold is far more valuable as a mammalian decoration than as a conductor.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by bisrig on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @08:51PM (#5529218)
Gold is a very significant part of electronics manufacturing, especially high end/high rel work. A couple of examples are plating on connectors and switch contacts (corrosion resistance) and ENIG PCB finishes, but there's a lot more where those came from.

So while you may feel its value is higher as jewelry etc., its utility is still quite high in electronics.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by peejaybee on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:03PM (#5526869)
Part of me is pulling for Bitcoin, but dang was that funny.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jjcm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:45PM (#5527596)
In some ways the price is tied to the cost of electricity needed to mine a coin. Granted, the mining "price" is usually about two weeks behind the actual price, and the electricity required is variable based on the current sum of computational power being used by all the miners, so there's certainly some disconnect.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by nwatson on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:21PM (#5527879)
So if I shock a turd with a thousand dollars worth of electricity from my electric utility company, can I sell it for $1,000? Or add some non-intrinsic worth by calling it "art" and sell it for $2,000? Actually, make those figures $1,010 and $2,010 -- my turds also have intrinsic value.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by andrewcooke on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:56PM (#5528103)
no, because throwing electrons at turds doesn't generate currency. in contrast, throwing electrons at a chip does generate bitcoins. that's the relationship being alluded to: there's the possibility of arbitrage between electricity (compute cycles) and currency.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by gph on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:09PM (#5528543)
You explained exactly what the intrinsic value of the currency is: the usefulness of the currency itself. BTCs have value over turds for use as a currency for many obvious reasons. The amount of electricity it takes to create that currency can perhaps be seen as a price floor, which is perhaps corollary to the intrinsic value, but is not the intrinsic value itself.

So if something improbable or drastic happened tomorrow that made the currency not useful (e.g. governments outlawing it, a bug in the code) then the price would fall well below what it costs in electricity to mine it and the currency would become mostly defunct, i.e. it's intrinsic value plummeted because it's usefulness did.

tl;dr the intrinsic value is the usefulness of the currency not how many electrons you pump into it (though there is likely some corollary between them)

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dllthomas on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:37PM (#5528691)
> The amount of electricity it takes to create that currency can perhaps be seen as a price floor, which is perhaps corollary to the intrinsic value, but is not the intrinsic value itself.

Cost of production should be a price ceiling, not floor: if I can make it for $X, why would I buy it for $Y >> $X?

Edited: To hopefully head off further misunderstandings, by "should" here I mean "it makes the most sense to expect" - not any ethical imperative - and I'm speaking in broad terms, in the long run.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by Jtsummers on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:01PM (#5528791)
There's also the cost of setting it all up, the time in learning the tech involved or hiring those who do. If it cost you $X to produce, why would you sell it to me for less than $X? You'd be losing money on the production side.

The lower bound ought to be at least the cost to the miner that produced the new bitcoin (when they try and sell it or use it in the market).

The upper bound is essentially nonexistent. If I have $3000 to invest in bitcoin, what is the possibility of me getting a decent return on $3000 worth of mining hardware? Vs (based on the recent explosive growth) spend $3000 on BTC directly at $200 a piece and you have 15BTC. If it continues to generally rise in value against the dollar a portion of that can be turned back into USD later and spent on a more worthwhile rig, or just used in the BTC economy itself (to the extent that it exists).

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dllthomas on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:22PM (#5528879)
> If it cost you $X to produce, why would you sell it to me for less than $X? You'd be losing money on the production side.

"Cost of production", in an economic sense, includes opportunity cost - that is, the amount of money I could be making if I did something else with the time instead, which can be more or less taken to mean a reasonable accounting "profit".

Edit: Also, I may sell it to you at a loss because I can't do anything better with it, if the price fell since I produced it.

> The lower bound ought to be at least the cost to the miner that produced the new bitcoin (when they try and sell it or use it in the market).

Yes, if the price of bitcoins falls below the cost of producing them, more won't be produced, but that won't actually prevent the price from falling further.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by Jtsummers on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:49PM (#5529024)
We may have misunderstood each other. I didn't mean to say that there was a strict lower bound on the price of bitcoins. It absolutely could zero out in a worst case scenario (for some people at least). I suppose what I was intending to refer to was a (somewhat) healthy bitcoin economy. Inefficient miners will be driven out of the market as the cost to participate exceeds their returns.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by maxerickson on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:26PM (#5528897)
There isn't any ought to be for the lower bound. (In a successful bitcoin world) There is eventually going to be a clear relationship between the cost of mining and the reward available, but if some miner switches to mining his own variety of digital money, we don't suddenly owe him something for the effort.

If we end up with a very competitive market for using cryptography to clear digital transactions, miners might well face a situation where it is barely worth it to burn electricity.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by Jtsummers on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:45PM (#5529003)
I meant to say that was the per miner cost. A more efficient miner would see a lower production cost for their bitcoins. They'd then be able to either take advantage of their position (sell with a significant margin) or drive the other miners out of business (sell at a small margin that puts bitcoins at an uncompetitively low value). In either case they'd be able to expand their mining operation (or accounting operation once mining itself has low returns) to improve their odds and yield.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by gph on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:00PM (#5528788)
Because not everyone is able to hit the same Cost of Production, or wants to put down the upfront investment in equipment, or has the technical know how, etc. If the cost of production was the price ceiling why would anyone start producing? They'd just break even at best.

Besides people buy things for $Y >> $X everyday simply for convenience. You could go buy ingredients and make a sandwich for $X dollars, but instead you go to the food truck and buy one for $Y dollars because it's convenient. It's not like food truck guy is selling his product at cost.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dllthomas on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:20PM (#5528871)
You read me as being more precise than I'd meant it. But it's basic economics that competition drives the cost down toward the cost of production (including labor cost and opportunity cost), and there's nothing in bitcoins that's preventing people from competing.

And regardless, there's absolutely no conceptual reason cost of production would represent any kind of floor.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by gph on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @08:34PM (#5529155)
>And regardless, there's absolutely no conceptual reason cost of production would represent any kind of floor.

Well no sane/rational entity would want to sell for less than cost of production because that would entail a loss (let's keep this simple and say there aren't any ulterior reasons one would receive gains/benefits from selling at below cost).

Since competition drives the price towards the cost of production it's reasonable to consider it or a price just above it as the floor.

Edit: I guess I should state, I'm not trying to say there is a 'hard' floor in which the price can't possibly drop below. I'm more saying it's a relative benchmark for where the lowest price would tend to settle given a healthy bitcoin market/environment.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dllthomas on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:10AM (#5531371)
A rational entity would absolutely sell at a loss. They would not acquire with the goal of selling at a loss, but once they already have the thing what they paid to get it is a sunk cost, which a sane or rational agent ignores in making future decisions.

If bitcoins were overproduced, say during a bubble, they could well remain low long-term - there is no particular pressure driving them up.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by gph on Thursday April 11, 2013 @09:54AM (#5531946)
>If bitcoins were overproduced, say during a bubble, they could well remain low long-term - there is no particular pressure driving them up.

Well if the cost to produce them was higher than the price, people would simply stop mining. Perhaps my understanding of bitcoins isn't correct, but I thought that if there were no miners then transactions would stop being processed and the currency would basically stop working and die.

I know right now bitcoins are still being created/produced by miners, but at some point in the future that will stop happening and miners will be compensated through transaction fees as a percentage of each transaction. At that point if price of bitcoins falls below the cost to mine we likely will see people stop mining and transactions ceasing until the price rises enough for it to be worthwhile.

Of course bitcoin is a bit special in that there are a lot of fans of it that will likely be completely willing to accept a loss to keep the currency going. As we all know humans don't act as perfect economic-minded rationalists. But I still think the cost of production is a good bottom metric to keep an eye on. If the price falls below that we will know that the currency is in rather dire straits and being artificially propped up by those with an interest in keeping it going.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by kragen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:14PM (#5529544)
If you do this let me know. I want to buy tickets.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by caf on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:34PM (#5529375)
It's the other way around. The cost of electricity needed to mine a coin will tend towards the price that coin can be sold for. If the bitcoin price drops significantly, then the least efficient miners will become unprofitable and drop out, and the difficulty will reduce.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by andrewtbham on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:07PM (#5527779)
The value of gold, and bitcoins is that their scarcity and inflation serve as an accurate proxy for the real economy of goods and services.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by chii on Thursday April 11, 2013 @08:44AM (#5531538)
neither gold nor bitcoins are inflationary. In fact, both are deflationary.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by lurkinggrue on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:38PM (#5527991)
What is it's intrinsic value? Nothing?
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by gdw2 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:11PM (#5526922)
I just thought about something I'd never thought before:

Could it be said that bitcoins _do_ have an intrinsic value equal to the marginal amount of electricity and equipment needed to produce one?

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:40PM (#5527121)
> Could it be said that bitcoins _do_ have an intrinsic value equal to the marginal amount of electricity and equipment needed to produce one?

No, that's an intrinsic cost. It would only be an intrinsic value if that electricity and equipment could inherently be extracted back from the bitcoin. The intrinsic value of gold comes from what you can use gold for other than a medium of exchange. Bitcoin has neither the intrinsic value of commodity currencies nor the sovereign backing of fiat currencies.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:14PM (#5526938)
That isn't an intrinsic value. Waste heat does not have an intrinsic value equivalent to the cost of producing it- it is waste heat.

Intrinsic value is derived from what you can do with something, not what you did to get it.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by aarongolliver on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:05PM (#5527754)
The intrinsic value is the bitcoin protocol which provides a framework where transactions become effectively irreversible in about an hour, you don't have to go through a middle-man to pay someone, and it provides anonymity if you need it.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:19PM (#5527861)
Not sure you can consider that an intrinsic value. I could be wrong, but my understanding of intrinsic value is essentially that it is the value of an item when the market value is zero. The bitcoin protocol does you no good if the market value of a bitcoin is zero.

You do present an interesting conundrum though.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by baddox on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:43PM (#5528411)
> my understanding of intrinsic value is essentially that it is the value of an item when the market value is zero

That seems like a fairly artificial mental exercise. Why would market value be zero if intrinsic value is greater than zero? I suppose the only situations would be if a good has a unique property that can provide utility to you but no one else, like a food that for some reason only provides nutrients for you, or any good in a truly post-scarcity society or region, or if the market is extremely uninformed or irrational.

I think the real problem is with the metaphysical implications inherent in the word "intrinsic." You can always go "one level higher" and say that the value at the previous level was not intrinsic or "as intrinsic." Does an apple have intrinsic value if there are no humans alive anymore, and if not, is the value really "intrinsic" in the apple?

As far as I can tell, the specific term used in finance is based on predictions of the future value that can be derived from the good, regardless of its current market price. Of course, I would suspect that most market participants already make predictions about the future and that those predictions affect the price they are willing to buy or sell a good at. Granted, some people will be able to predict the future more accurately than other people, but does that mean we can only tell what the intrinsic value of something was in hindsight?

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:39PM (#5528699)
I think the real problem is with the metaphysical implications inherent in the word "intrinsic."

There it is, folks. We aren't talking about a simple concept, we are talking about the metaphysical and the deeper implications of words. What is a "word", anyway? Let's take a moment to consider.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by baddox on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:13PM (#5528839)
No, let's not at all consider the meaning of words, because the meaning of words is of no importance in a discussion.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @08:24PM (#5529135)
You've really got in in for me, don't you. You're like half the comments in this comment block.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by baddox on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:19PM (#5526976)
> Intrinsic value is derived from what you can do with something

So then, the market price of any good is its intrinsic value? Under this definition, if I can sell a bitcoin for x USD, then its intrinsic value is x USD.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:27PM (#5527024)
The ability to sell an item for x USD is not one of the "things" you can do with it that contribute to intrinsic value. Let's put it a different way; if the market value for a bitcoin was $0, what could you do with it? Compare that to an apple. If the market value for an apple was $0, you could eat it. Thus (unless someone has a clever use for bitcoins outside of currency) an apple has greater intrinsic value than a bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by icebraining on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:45PM (#5528417)
I'd say that's use-value. Intrinsic implies it's not relative to each person, which clearly isn't true in that case (e.g., I could be allergic to apples, then the value would be nil to me).
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by baddox on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:24PM (#5528614)
...which illustrates the inherent absurdity of the word "intrinsic." If allergies make some quality extrinsic, then doesn't the very existence of humans also make all qualities extrinsic? If humans are extinct, the apple can't even be eaten by any humans, so it must have no intrinsic value.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:40PM (#5528709)
Fine, not water. Apples. Are you allergic to water?
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by baddox on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:10PM (#5528828)
What if I'm not thirsty? What if I have plenty of water already? What if I'm trying to commit suicide by not drinking water?
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by baddox on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:32PM (#5528340)
That's a new definition of "intrinsic," not the one I was responding to.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by ritchiea on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:32PM (#5527066)
Intrinsic value and market price are slightly different. I imagine the difference brings us back to the fact that bitcoin is unbacked by any government. There is a worst case scenario that bitcoins are worthless. Government backed currencies despite not being tied to the standard of a physical good have a sovereign entity responsible for their value thus they are as valuable as your trust in that sovereign.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by stonemetal on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:19PM (#5528259)
What does it mean to trust in a sovereign in this case? If I take a $20 from my wallet down to the county court house, or any other government building you like, what should I trust to happen?
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by ritchiea on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:48PM (#5528438)
Actually when I used the word "trust" I was thinking of countries with their own currency that have unstable governments and/or economies. So imagine country X exists in South America and you have 20 country X dollars. A week ago one country X dollar was worth 2 US dollars. But today country X decided to introduce into circulation hundreds of trillions of dollars in new currency to deal with their massive debts and it completely devalues your 20 country X dollars.

Or today there is a communist coup in country X and the new regime declares the old currency worthless.

That's what I meant by "trust."

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by slg on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:13PM (#5526934)
No, because you can't go from Bitcoin back to electricity in the same way you could smelt a gold coin.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by gdw2 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:18PM (#5526966)
Maybe you could give someone a bitcoin and they'd give you x amount of compute time on their cluster equal to the time they'd need to generate a new bitcoin. ?
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by tomku on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:36PM (#5527100)
That's a transaction based on market value, not intrinsic value. Someone might take you up on that, but it would depend on their valuation of your bitcoin, not some kind of inherent equivalence between bitcoins and other assets.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by kleinsch on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:18PM (#5526967)
Intrinsic value doesn't have anything to do with cost/effort necessary to produce something.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by abentspoon on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @03:02PM (#5527297)
I don't know if intrinsic value is the right term, but I've been thinking along the same line.

A Bitcoin is essentially a tradable hashcash, which has direct value in spam filtering.

"Isn't it enough that I ruined a pony, making a gift for you?