News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by crapshoot101 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:13PM (#5527818)
correct in a sense- the US dollar is backed by the full faith and credit of the US Government, nothing more. Would I still have that faith in the US $ if the government did not collect taxes / did not seem like a stable entity? Probably not, but your point is still valid
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by mcherm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:52PM (#5528462)
Um, no. The US dollar is backed by US law guaranteeing that it must be accepted as payment for all debts and by US law requiring taxes to be paid in USD. All of which, as the parent post points out, is dwarfed by the backing provided by all the merchants, banks, and consumers in the world who are using USD today. The corner grocery store in Pottsville, PA backs the USD by accepting it as payment for frozen pizza and toothpaste. The drug dealer in Venezuela backs the USD by accepting payment in $100 USD bills. These are the most important backing for the USD (the "Nash equilibrium" that the parent post mentioned.

And that kind of backing is what the community is TRYING to build for BTC.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:27PM (#5528630)
> The US dollar is backed by US law guaranteeing that it must be accepted as payment for all debts

I believe this doesn't stop people from creating special obligations through contracts that are denominated in other currencies. It more means that if I run over your mailbox and a judge orders me to compensate you, I can use dollars.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by mcherm on Thursday April 11, 2013 @01:50PM (#5533541)
Precisely. It means that if you sue me for ANY reason (including failure to live up to my end of a contract) the state will allow me to pay in dollars.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Friday April 12, 2013 @05:11PM (#5541036)
Ahh, this is a good point. Thanks.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by danudey on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @07:46PM (#5529011)
> The US dollar is backed by US law guaranteeing that it must be accepted as payment for all debts

If you're referring to the 'legal tender for all debts public and private' clause on the notes themselves, that means that it can be used for such purposes, not that it must be accepted. If we agree that I'll do your deck and you'll give me your car, you can't just say 'I want to keep my car, here's some cash instead'.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by mcherm on Thursday April 11, 2013 @01:56PM (#5533589)
> it can be used for such purposes, not that it must be accepted

Before the contract is agreed to, the parties can make any arrangement they want, including agreeing to pay in bitcoins. But if one party fails to deliver and they wind up in court, then the court (as kragen pointed out) will almost never require them to deliver the item, the court will instead require that the victim be compensated and will allow dollars to be used to compensate them.

Now, if bitcoins were worth $250 each at the time the deck got painted and are only worth $160 each by the time the court case completes, there is a fairly good chance that the court will demand the $250 price be used to determine what the compensation should be.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by kragen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:56PM (#5529466)
Generally speaking, if I say that and you take me to court to get my car, the court will award you damages, which I can pay with some cash. The alternative, where the court orders me to give you my car, is called "specific performance" and is very rare.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @04:47PM (#5528052)
> the US dollar is backed by the full faith and credit of the US Government

Huh? What does this mean? This phrase can be applied to government bond ("The US gov't promises to pay you back") or to FDIC insurance ("The US gov't promises to refund your money if your bank closes"). But it doesn't have any meaning for dollars, unless it were to mean that the gov't would exchange it for gold, which of course is false.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:21PM (#5528275)
Not true. The fact that you're somewhat informed on these matters is working against you here.

If the US Gov't stopped collecting taxes -- or had some other substantial liquidity crisis -- the very real issue is debt service. Since the USD is the global reserve currency, we are in the rather unique situation of having our debt denominated in our own currency under control of our own central bank. This is where the "full faith and credit" of the USA enters the discussion of our currency. If we had issues servicing our public debt, the government has the option of devaluing our currency. In other words, inflating away our debt. In such a scenario, the value of USD plunges against foreign currencies, and there would be a massive effort by everybody with substantial USD holdings to sell.

This, among other reasons, is why Keynes envisioned a super-national reserve currency traded among central banks. If the US public debt was denominated in Bancor, the option of inflating it away wouldn't exist.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:01PM (#5528509)
First, I think the interesting question is just about fiat currencies, not the US in particular. The global reserve currency aspect is a secondary effect. Let's concentrate on a generic fiat currency issued by a government.

So you're saying that "full faith and credit" just means "The gov't promises not to crazily inflate the money by printing lots of it". Fine. (That doesn't explain what process determines the street value, it just acknowledges that the government can destroy it.)

I don't really see how the rest of what you are talking about applies to my comment. Are you claiming that fiat currencies are impossible in countries without debt?

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:20PM (#5528589)
No, you don't have to have debt to have good credit.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by jessriedel on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:55PM (#5528766)
It sounds like you are suggesting that fiat currency functions like debt, but I've never understood this claim.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by khuey on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:38PM (#5528381)
That situation is not rather unique at all. Most developed nations issue debt in a currency controlled by their central bank, with the notable exception of the Eurozone.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by encoderer on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:13PM (#5528561)
Your point is a little misleading I think. How big is the list of "most developed nations" after you remove the US and Euro Zone from the list?

Yes, every country CAN issue national debt. But issuing sovereign debt is more common largely because investors prefer it.

Either way, I didn't mean to sound misleading by calling it "rather unique." Thanks for helping me clarify.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by kragen on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @10:10PM (#5529517)
Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, England, Russia, Canada, Australia, Switzerland, Iceland, Israel, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, New Zealand, and arguably PRC, Brazil, Argentina, Turkey, India, Mexico, Indonesia, Qatar, and Chile, are all developed nations not in the US or Eurozone.

You are, however, correct that most of these countries issue their debt in US dollars ("sovereign debt") rather than their national currencies.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by betterunix on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @09:05PM (#5529274)
"it doesn't have any meaning for dollars, unless it were to mean that the gov't would exchange it for gold, which of course is false."

It means, "The government will accept it for tax payment," and for the payment of various other debts and fees.

Re:Bitcoin falls from $266 by crapshoot101 on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:32PM (#5528338)
it means it is not backed by a hard asset or a promise - the dollar is not redeemable for anything.