Re:Bitcoin falls from $266
by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @02:27PM
(#5527024)
The ability to sell an item for x USD is not one of the "things" you can do with it that contribute to intrinsic value. Let's put it a different way; if the market value for a bitcoin was $0, what could you do with it? Compare that to an apple. If the market value for an apple was $0, you could eat it. Thus (unless someone has a clever use for bitcoins outside of currency) an apple has greater intrinsic value than a bitcoin.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266
by icebraining on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @05:45PM
(#5528417)
I'd say that's use-value. Intrinsic implies it's not relative to each person, which clearly isn't true in that case (e.g., I could be allergic to apples, then the value would be nil to me).
...which illustrates the inherent absurdity of the word "intrinsic." If allergies make some quality extrinsic, then doesn't the very existence of humans also make all qualities extrinsic? If humans are extinct, the apple can't even be eaten by any humans, so it must have no intrinsic value.
Re:Bitcoin falls from $266
by sliverstorm on Wednesday April 10, 2013 @06:40PM
(#5528709)
Fine, not water. Apples. Are you allergic to water?
What if I'm not thirsty? What if I have plenty of water already? What if I'm trying to commit suicide by not drinking water?