News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by chrisbennet on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:07PM (#5461382)
"As a recruiter I typically handle salary discussions for my candidates, and I know that for most engineers that particular service is considered most valuable. "

When I've worked with recruiters I appreciated the fact that they would negotiate on my behalf. That said, don't forget that when it comes to salary, a recruiter's interest and yours are not really aligned. They don't care about how high a salary they get for you as long as they you get hired.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:18PM (#5461427)
Thanks for the comments, though not necessarily true. As an agency recruiter that represents several companies, typically the recruiter is paid a percentage based on the hire's salary - so actually, their interests and yours are directly aligned in that way. You are correct though that in general, the recruiter wants to simply get a deal done. Getting an extra 10K for the candidate may result in an extra 2K in the recruiter's pocket, but if the deal doesn't happen it's 0K for the recruiter.

These examples are specific to contingency recruiting, which is not the focus of my business (more retained/engaged search).

Re:Why You Make Less Money by wting on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:37PM (#5461521)
There was a study on how real estate agents sell clients' houses vs their own. On average, agents will keep their own properties on the market ~10 days longer.[0]

If a client's house sells for $310k vs $300k, that's an extra ~$10k for the client. On the other hand, spending the additional time negotiating only nets the agent $300.[1]

Typically agents will sell additional houses rather than negotiate prices on sure sales. However their behavior changes when selling their own houses.

---

[0]: From Freakonomics as mentioned by vitalique and roel_v below.

[1]: Real estate agent fees are typically 6%, equally split between buyer / seller agents.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by vitalique on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:55PM (#5461622)
I think this is from Freakonomics by Levitt and Dubner. After the initial publication of the book (and probably before it, since this is just a typical principal-agent case) this point has been raised and discussed numerous times, though. National Bureau of Economical Research has a paper on this topic [0]. From the abstract: "It is not obvious that sellers benefit from those services".

[0] http://papers.nber.org/papers/w13796

Re:Why You Make Less Money by mcguire on Friday March 29, 2013 @04:35PM (#5462897)
Off topic, but from that paper's abstract:

"Our central finding is that, when listings are not tied to brokerage services, a seller’s use of a broker reduces the selling price of the typical home by 5.9 to 7.7 percent, which indicates that agency costs exceed the advantages of brokers’ knowledge and expertise by a wide margin."

Whoa.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Friday March 29, 2013 @05:24PM (#5463121)
The main difference between houses and job candidates are that the houses can't refuse the sale and have no idea of their own worth.

Recruiting is a sales job with a commission typically tied to salary of the hire (similar to commissions for selling houses that are related to sale price) - but where it gets interesting is that the brokered item in 99% of sales situations has no say in the matter. In recruiting, the candidate is to some degree the product of the transaction, and the product can reject the sale. It's an interesting dynamic that makes recruiting unique.

This explanation is rudimentary and hopefully recruiters don't treat candidates like some common 'product' for sale, but it gives some insight into why analogies between recruiters and realtors or other sales/commission jobs are not entirely relevant.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by regerg on Saturday March 30, 2013 @12:13AM (#5464365)
What? The job is what's for sale, not the employee. The hirer and the employee are the seller/buyer (or vice versa, doesn't really matter)
Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Saturday March 30, 2013 @07:55AM (#5465142)
That is an interesting perspective, and again raises the question of contingency recruiting as a model. The company is paying for the service, so I guess you could equate the company as the seller paying a commission on the price. But the buyer (candidate in your model) and agent (recruiter) are the ones trying to drive price up (higher salary), which isn't how buyers act. I don't think that mentality is really prevalent in the industry, and the analogy seems to offend technologists. If there is a better analogy, I haven't found it yet.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by DougWebb on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:51PM (#5461596)
My wife's a Realtor, so I have some insight into this. One aspect you're missing is the value of reputation, referrals, and repeat business. Going the extra mile for her clients to get them the best deal possible (which, sometimes, happens to be the offer-in-hand) has long-term consequences for getting future business. That's worth a lot more than the extra $300.

Also, "selling additional houses" isn't as easy as it sounds. There's a lot of unpaid effort involved in acquiring clients and getting to an offer, before any of the negotiation starts. Time spent negotiating and baby-sitting an existing offer at least has a high likely-hood of being paid time.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by jeremyjh on Friday March 29, 2013 @03:26PM (#5462540)
So are you saying that realtors don't on average keep their own houses on the market 10 days longer than they keep client houses? We don't need to fully understand the incentives to know they are different if we know the outcomes are different.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by pacaro on Friday March 29, 2013 @07:23PM (#5463572)
I'd love to know what the distribution of this is. If you pick a realtor at random it appears to be "worse" than not using a realtor, but what is the variance? I suspect that a good realtor is probably going to get you a better price, I'm pretty certain that a bad one won't!

When I bought my current property the seller used a listing only service and pretty much screwed up every part of the transaction that was possible to screw up (missed deadlines, filed the wrong papers, failed to show up for closing for 3 days...) - I nearly walked away, in retrospect I should have, this is basic stuff that even a sucky realtor will get right.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by kylebgorman on Friday March 29, 2013 @01:29PM (#5461830)
The post above is not saying that realtors are evil or useless, just that the standard commission schema means that a realtor's payoffs/incentives are quite different than the owner who hires the realtor.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by DougWebb on Friday March 29, 2013 @01:44PM (#5461922)
That's pretty much always the case when one person hires another person to do something. The hire-er wants to get as much work done for as little money as possible, and the hire-ee wants to get as much money as possible for each unit of work. They're polar opposites, yet this arrangement happens all of the time.

The problem with having different incentives is when one party doesn't recognize that there is a mis-alignment. If you're selling your home and you don't realize that your Realtor's time is not an endless, worthless resource at your disposal, then you may be inclined to insist on your Realtor spending endless hours of aggressive negotiation, potentially putting the offer at risk of closing at all, for an amount of additional money to you that's not really going to make much of a difference to you. (My wife's been involved in deals where one party or the other has risked a deal that's been in the works for 2-3 months over less than 0.1% of the house's value.)

Re:Why You Make Less Money by philh on Friday March 29, 2013 @02:54PM (#5462353)
0.1% of a house's value seems like a fair amount of money. I doubt it would seem strange to put a lot of effort into getting that much money, if it was framed differently.

Admittedly, not spending 2-3 months to work out another deal is worth quite a lot of money as well. But this behaviour doesn't seem obviously irrational.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by bartonfink on Friday March 29, 2013 @04:15PM (#5462793)
0.1% of a house's value is almost certainly not an appreciable amount of money. It's so low that, if the parties could not find a way to come to terms over it, the agents may swallow it themselves just to get the deal done.

For a half-million dollar home, which would be a relatively nice house for most of the country, you're talking about $500. For any party on that transaction (buyer, seller or their respective agents who each stand to make $15k on a normal 3% commission), that's not a lot of money and is almost certainly not worth arguing over if you're in all but the earliest stages of negotiation.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Friday March 29, 2013 @01:55PM (#5461995)
Reputation and referrals are my lifeblood. I have been giving things away for 15 years - mostly information, insight, tips, etc. I have contacts who ask me for career advice all the time, even when not looking for jobs, and I always take the call and try to provide honest advice. When those people are asked who to use for search, they send business my way.

I now do very little marketing to new clients or candidates - I post some jobs on my site, but very little advertising and very few cold calls. The value of acquiring a set of very specific and useful information (market rates, info on companies, etc.) and providing that to your network when asked is rewarded down the road.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by beeffective on Friday March 29, 2013 @03:29PM (#5462554)
Edit: Sorry I just noticed you are the original poster.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:49PM (#5461589)
And where engaged or retained search is most valuable is to get rid of this. Real estate agents selling their own home know that they will sell that house - they aren't competing with other agents to sell their own home, so they aren't pressured to sell quickly. When recruiters are compensated partially up front and have semi-exclusive deals with companies, it takes away the need to sell quick (force a hire). If I know I'm going to fill the slot, and I know that another recruiter isn't going slip in and take my fee, I'm not of the same cut-throat incentives to just make a deal happen. Again, good analogy with contingency recruiting.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by roel_v on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:56PM (#5461632)
Source on the real estate agents is Freakonomics (which in turn no doubt has a reference to the 'real' source).
Re:Why You Make Less Money by regerg on Saturday March 30, 2013 @12:12AM (#5464359)
> Real estate agent fees are typically 6%, equally split between buyer / seller agents.

This is long obsolete. Only a fool pays more than 4% these days.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by yellow on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:16PM (#5461421)
Same logic with Real Estate agents. My friend's agent tried to get him to sell his house with every low-ball offer that came in...
Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:30PM (#5461484)
I certainly see that as an issue. I've written here before about how the recruiting industry could change, and my business model addresses that at least a bit. For one, almost all of my clients pay me flat fees up front, which is why I'm willing/able to advertise for them (as opposed to contingency recruiters doing free PR).

I'm also transparent with my candidates. If they have two offers and my fees are different with the two clients, I think it's my duty to let the candidate know so they can make an informed decision if they feel I am showing any hint of bias towards one client (of course the difference in fee is usually nominal at best).

Being retained or engaged by a client, as opposed to contingency, really minimizes the incentive to encourage a bad deal for either side in the transaction. I know I'm going to get my fee eventually, so I don't need to try to talk both sides into a marriage that isn't good for either.

The real estate example is a very good analogy for most contingency recruiting models though.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by the_watcher on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:30PM (#5461480)
Only a bad real estate agent would do this. Their commission is percentage based, so a good agent will try to get you the most possible for your home. Also, it's unconventional, by try an agent who is open to dual-agent sales (represents both the buyer and seller). Their interest in that case is to get the most fair deal to each party.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by potatolicious on Friday March 29, 2013 @12:39PM (#5461533)
> "Their commission is percentage based, so a good agent will try to get you the most possible for your home."

That discounts the value of time. If it takes, say, 40 hours of work to sell your home for $300K, and another 40 hours of negotiations to bump that to $400K, it is not in the realtor's interest to pursue the $100K - he/she can simply pursue another $300K sale in the same time.

A commission based structure tends to have weird cliffs like this subject to the details of the field.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by btian on Friday March 29, 2013 @01:04PM (#5461675)
+1. Freakonomics a chapter on this topic.
Re:Why You Make Less Money by regerg on Saturday March 30, 2013 @12:10AM (#5464354)
Letting a recruited negotiate for you is horrible. They have no interest in getting you a great salary. They say things like "just so I know the ballpark, how much do you need to pay your bills?" and then they will tell the hiring manager exactly what your minimum is, just to close a deal.

Recruiters are good for one thing: to make introductions. Good recruiters are good for that, and deserve the SALES commission for their SALES job. Recruiters aren't your lawyer.

Get two job offers, auction yourself off. That's how you negotiate.

Re:Why You Make Less Money by fecak on Saturday March 30, 2013 @08:17AM (#5465183)
I would disagree on this. This is the second comment about having no interest in salary, and that seems to be a fairly serious misconception about most recruiting.

I'm not sure where you are located, but in the US most recruiting is done on a contingency basis, meaning a fee is paid only if a hire is made. That fee is almost always based on a percentage of the employee's starting salary (could include bonus as well). Fees have a wide range, but during my career I have seen them everywhere between 15 and 33%.

The counter argument is that contingency recruiters want to close the deal, otherwise they don't get paid at all. Is the easiest way to close a deal, and to make sure the deal stays closed (see "counteroffer"), to get the candidate his/her minimum acceptable level? No. You are doing both parties a disservice if you do that.

You are doing the candidate a disservice by only trying to achieve the minimum. You are doing the client a disservice because although they may get the hire, the deal is not as secure as it would be at a higher number (again, see counteroffer), and if your goal as a recruiter s to help clients both attract and retain (key is retain) talent, they are better off paying a bit more to make the hire happy on start and less likely to be poached by someone else.

If I know a candidate's minimum, achieved via some proxy ('Dave, I'll accept at 120 and start May 15', it is fulfilling to call that candidate and say 'Remember when you said I could accept at 120? Well I got you 128. Congrats!' Happens all the time, and feels good every time for the candidate. On the other end, I'm coaching clients about retention and not just getting someone on board.

The biggest benefit to a recruiter (or any intermediary) in negotiations is a buffer. I've seen candidates do some incredibly dumb things in negotiation, such as asking for 150% of what they really are worth and expect to get, just to 'start off negotiations' - as if this were a good tactic. What happens if the recruiter isn't there as a buffer? The candidate makes the proposal, and the company says no thanks and let's just pretend we never met.

Other side is a client will call and say 'your candidate was making 80 at the last job? I'll go as high as 90, but offer 60 just do see the reaction.' My response would be 'the reaction is going to be an annoyed candidate who now feels lots of time has been wasted. Lets not screw around, get serious about this.'

Without a buffer, neither of these deals happen, yet both parties were willing to accept the terms of he other. If you think this is rare, you haven't been involved in enough deals with enough people yet.