News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by da_n on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:03PM (#5434468)
At this point Google has proven it only wants to focus on profitable ventures or those that tie into Google +. Any service/data aggregation that Google is solely depended on should be considered at risk of closure at any time, and such closure should not come as a surprise. Personally I am moving away from Google except for only the least valuable services; my email, calendar and everything else are moving elsewhere to paid services. It is the end of the age of innocence for Google.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by jarcoal on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:37PM (#5434571)
Google makes a lot of money on Gmail/Calendar (http://www.google.com/enterprise/apps/business/), so they are very unlikely to go away.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by psbp on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:24PM (#5434535)
Wouldn't it make more sense to not pay for your email, calendar and everything else and wait until Google warns you and gives you months to migrate all of your data to a competing service?
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by da_n on Sunday March 24, 2013 @09:17PM (#5434730)
I don't argue with that logic. But it isn't that I believe they will close down email/calendar, they have just made me re-consider how much of my critical online services I have invested in them, and I no longer trust them with something I believe is very valuable, my time and my data. With Reader, now I need to re-invest my time into finding another service. That sounds entitled, but there has been an exchange between me and Google all this time, I have used their services, of which they had many historically, and they have thrown ads at me and harvested my data. They still make money out of me despite me not being the one paying them. Now, they have decided that they want to cut out all the periphery services which they deem unprofitable. Ironically, the periphery 'unprofitable' services they are cutting were the only things that kept me using them, getting rid of Reader is essentially the last straw, I want a healthier relationship when it comes to my critical online services going forward, Google now offers me very little incentive to stay so invested in them. They will still get my money from Play Store, I will still use YouTube, but I no longer will be using them for essential services.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by niggler on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:32PM (#5434552)
"until Google warns you and gives you months to migrate all of your data to a competing service"

That's a big assumption. Google could axe a service tomorrow with no notice (which apple has a tendency of doing)

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by MetricMike on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:35PM (#5434564)
But they typically haven't. They've had an excellent track record so far of giving reasonable notice.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by choko on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:23PM (#5434964)
Just because you are moving to other services doesn't mean that those services will be around forever either. Short of running your own servers, you really can't be sure any service you subscribe to will be around indefinitely. That is the nature of online services.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by da_n on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:25PM (#5435234)
I get that and I agree. I guess the key is to ensure any service you move to has an export functionality and should be standards based. I also believe that using multiple services, each of which is built around a core service, be it email, file sync, RSS (not sure who yet) is going to be far less likely to drop that product like Google are doing, unless they just go out off business.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by streptomycin on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:27PM (#5434331)
“Usage has declined.” Come on. That is very weak. It may have done so but that is like saying it is a cold Winter so global warming isn’t true.

I don't understand the analogy, unless we are supposed to assume that there is some very large and natural cyclic pattern in Google Reader usage?

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by Xcelerate on Sunday March 24, 2013 @09:35PM (#5434801)
He's saying that one data point doesn't indicate a trend.

...but I'm guessing you knew that.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mjn on Sunday March 24, 2013 @06:29PM (#5434086)
In CS, CiteSeer/CiteSeerX still has quite a bit of usage, though it's been losing users to Google Scholar due to the latter's wider coverage and better search. A shutdown of Google Scholar would likely inject fresh interest. Also, its code and data are all under open licenses, so a third party could jumpstart their own fork if they don't like the way the primary developers are overseeing it.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mhluongo on Sunday March 24, 2013 @06:44PM (#5434147)
We're trying to provide a better interface for searching computer science at http://scholr.ly. I'd love your feedback.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by tinco on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:58PM (#5434449)
Hi, I tried a search for "model based testing" and the results seem not to be of very high quality. Are you lacking sources?

Also, it's not possible to discern high-quality from low-quality papers in any way. As a graduate student, I weed out what I should read by reading the titles+abstracts in the order of the amount of citations. Citation amount maybe isn't the most optimal indicator of quality but it is a strong one.

In order of importance: Scope (does it cover all journals?), Quality (how do I know if something's worth reading), Speed (I noticed your search runs a little on the slow side).

Other than that the site looks great, I'd certainly switch if you would get the basics down :)

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mhluongo on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:06PM (#5434899)
Hm, right now we've got the same coverage as CiteSeerX (where most of our data comes from), and are working on expanding. What sources do you particularly think are lacking?

We've talked quite a bit internally about whether to include citations counts. It's a tough call, but until we're happier with our scoring it might make sense to help bolster result reputation.

Thanks for the feedback!

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by tinco on Tuesday March 26, 2013 @03:37AM (#5441805)
Hey no problem :) I'm just a student so I'm not researching a particular field at the moment, the Model Based Testing paper I was looking for I had to read for a course.

I just wouldn't use your site as long as I feel _any_ journal is missing, since google does not give me that feeling.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mjn on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:10PM (#5434262)
Looks interesting! My biggest initial dislike is that the author-profile data seems extremely messy. For example, looking up my supervisor, who has a fairly unique name, his publications are split across a full 10 separate profiles: http://scholr.ly/results/?q=michael+mateas&x=0&y=0&#...

It realize it's a rather tricky problem to fix, since not every pair of identical names is actually the same person. Doing a vanity-search on myself (http://scholr.ly/results/?q=mark+j.+nelson&x=0&y=0&#...), there are 5 profiles with precisely the same way of writing the name ("Mark J. Nelson"), but only 2 of those are me.

If that data were cleaner it'd really increase the usefulness of the profiles. May take quite a bit of magic, though.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mhluongo on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:03PM (#5434889)
It does take some magic. Luckily there's been quite a bit of work done of the topic (eg, Lise Getoor & co http://scholr.ly/person/5486566/lise-getoor)- we should show some serious improvements soon.

In the meantime, I'll manually merge those profiles you've pointed out :) Thanks for taking the time!

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mhluongo on Monday March 25, 2013 @09:57AM (#5436957)
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by kragen on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:12PM (#5434267)
I had no idea CiteSeer data was open! Thank you!
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mjn on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:13PM (#5434276)
Looking closer, it's under a cc-by-nc-sa license, so can't be used by commercial forks (and therefore isn't Free by the FSF or Debian definitions). But it's available for research purposes, or for use by noncommercial forks.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by JustARandomGuy on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:35PM (#5434566)
I'm expecting Google Code to be shut down sooner or later. It hasn't received any new features for years; for instance, GitHub, BitBucket and Sourceforge have the ability to set a custom domain and Google Code has never implemented it, despite this 5+ year old issue: https://code.google.com/p/support/issues/detail?id=1222

Google has also been moving their code examples and open source to Github ( https://github.com/googlecloudplatform ), and completely ignoring their in house open source hosting.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by niggler on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:41PM (#5434586)
I wouldn't be surprised if many of those people came to google through an acquisition or other means (I took a very cursory scan but couldn't find a contributor that identified as working for google out of mountain view)
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by lrei on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:35PM (#5434362)
Doubt it.

Scholar is mostly search. Reader was a lot of things: search (like google news) sync engine, social network (like G+), a complex web app etc. It's probably a lot easier to have someone on the search team maintain scholar than it was to maintain reader and it doesn't conflict (yet) with G+.

Given how many of their famous employees were poached from academia, scholar is probably worth keeping for recruitment purposes alone. Not to mention employee morale.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by takluyver on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:47PM (#5434405)
It also has citation tracking, alerts and journal metrics. Admittedly tracking citations is somewhat like tracking links for pagerank, but it must take a bit of effort - it's not just a regular search constrained to journal databases.

As a regular user of Google Scholar, I hope you're right about the recruitment & morale purposes. But I've heard several people making a similar argument against killing Reader - it serves a demographic that Google might especially want to keep on side. That didn't appear to stop them.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by aheilbut on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:21PM (#5435210)
It must have taken a lot of effort, and/or licensing agreements with publishers or the existing citation indexes.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by rm999 on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:08PM (#5434478)
I think you could make the same arguments about Google Code Search, which google shut down. It was a search, and the kind of service that would appeal to many of Google'e employees.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by fatjokes on Sunday March 24, 2013 @10:03PM (#5434890)
I disagree. Of all companies, Google actively engages academia and works hard to maintain ties (e.g., faculty summits, research grants, etc.) They have a lot of collaborations and want to foster good relations so that good students will be sent their way. It's been a largely successful effort.

Scholar is a vital tool for a lot of members of academia, not to mention Google's own research and research-heavy engineering groups. A lot of faculty---particularly young faculty and PhD students---actively maintain profiles on scholar and use it to track their own publications and citations. The minor cost of keeping it running is a small price to pay, relative to the bad blood it would generate within the research community if it is shut down.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by kragen on Sunday March 24, 2013 @06:23PM (#5434056)
For some time, I was keeping a collection of items like this under the tag "decentralization-stories" at http://del.icio.us/kragen/decentralization-stories. Of course this was deleted.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by scw on Sunday March 24, 2013 @06:43PM (#5434145)
Why was it deleted? But yes, that does illustrate the issue.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by kragen on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:08PM (#5434254)
I declined to accept the new, abusive user agreement terms of the new Delicious management.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by gojomo on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:21PM (#5434526)
I don't remember the new ToS being that bad... but did you perchance export to a private backup or alternate service (like Pinboard)?
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by kragen on Monday March 25, 2013 @02:57AM (#5435817)
Yes, I have backups. And I've been adding to them since then; I even wrote a browser extension to do it with. I just haven't put them online again. :(
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by jkldotio on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:11PM (#5434488)
Google has stated before they think of themselves as working on an AI. Like Google's scanning of books, reading all the academic articles isn't for popular consumption but for their knowledge engine. Think of IBM's medical engine. Zero chance they will stop scanning them, and a very low chance they will shut it down for the public.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by Lost_BiomedE on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:49PM (#5434414)
I would bet it will be google charts, which would be a shame. They 'renew' its existence every year and have said they will give a year warning. I am currently building a site with it but will start looking into a backup for migration, if things go well.

The only reason it might survive is that google still uses it for google finance.

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by azov on Sunday March 24, 2013 @09:48PM (#5434846)
Charts are also powering Google docs, so they are probably safe in the near future.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by dysoco on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:25PM (#5434324)
I wonder when they will kill Google Earth, we have Google Maps and with WebGL I think Google Earth is pointless.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by arb99 on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:39PM (#5434377)
they license it out so less chance of Google Earth being shut down http://www.google.co.uk/earth/media/licensing.html
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by jccalhoun on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:39PM (#5434577)
I really Google Scholar doesn't go away. While there are other academic search sites, most of them seems to be science-focused. As someone in the humanities, I don't find these to be useful. The university library has lots of database searches but they pretty uniformly stink. MS Academic search is ok but it still doesn't really have much humanities stuff, and other places like deepdyve.com can't stack up to google's search accuracy.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by yamalight on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:04PM (#5434226)
Microsoft Academic Search is quite much better anyways
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mjn on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:12PM (#5434269)
I like its interface better, but find its coverage, at least in my area (AI) to be so much worse than Google Scholar that I rarely use it. New articles sometimes don't show up for years, and inconsistently.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by yamalight on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:32PM (#5434347)
Hm.. That's curious. Works pretty much fine for SemWeb stuff
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by mjn on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:58PM (#5434450)
I hadn't checked in a while, but some spot-checking right now suggests it may depend on whether you care about conferences (which in my area are important). Seems to do a better job on journals, but to be 2-3 years out of date on conferences.

For example, it doesn't seem to have indexed much from ICML since 2010 (though, curiously, it indexes exactly 3 papers from ICML 2011): http://academic.research.microsoft.com/Conference/35/icml-in...

Similar story for AAAI: http://academic.research.microsoft.com/Conference/251/aaai-n...

One thing that's neat about GS is that it has a negative lag instead: it's already indexing papers from a bunch of conferences that haven't happened yet, and whose proceedings aren't officially out. It finds the versions that authors post on their own webpages, or in their institutional repositories, almost as soon as they're posted. For example, you can already read a good portion of the CHI 2013 proceedings if you search on the ISBN: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=%22978-1-4503-...

Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by yamalight on Monday March 25, 2013 @05:51AM (#5436237)
Hm. That's quite sad. It does much better job with SemWeb conferences. Though small ones are still not there, yeah. Hopefully they'll improve :)
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next? by rpgmaker on Sunday March 24, 2013 @08:50PM (#5434624)
I still believe that Google will reverse course on this greader issue...