Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next?
by takluyver on Sunday March 24, 2013 @07:47PM
(#5434405)
It also has citation tracking, alerts and journal metrics. Admittedly tracking citations is somewhat like tracking links for pagerank, but it must take a bit of effort - it's not just a regular search constrained to journal databases.
As a regular user of Google Scholar, I hope you're right about the recruitment & morale purposes. But I've heard several people making a similar argument against killing Reader - it serves a demographic that Google might especially want to keep on side. That didn't appear to stop them.
Re:With Google Reader gone, is Google Scholar next?
by aheilbut on Sunday March 24, 2013 @11:21PM
(#5435210)
It must have taken a lot of effort, and/or licensing agreements with publishers or the existing citation indexes.
Scholar is mostly search. Reader was a lot of things: search (like google news) sync engine, social network (like G+), a complex web app etc. It's probably a lot easier to have someone on the search team maintain scholar than it was to maintain reader and it doesn't conflict (yet) with G+.
Given how many of their famous employees were poached from academia, scholar is probably worth keeping for recruitment purposes alone. Not to mention employee morale.