News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by ramblerman on Thursday March 21, 2013 @05:54PM (#5419392)
Without tumbling deep into a flame war, I'd like to ask a sincere question. I have trouble understanding the sexism behind the remarks, and why the instigator needs to apologize (for sexism).

People get offended for all kinds of things, nobody can claim a monopoloy on that. (http://imgur.com/EX5v4 stephen fry quote)

- If they would both have been gay and talking about a homosexual topic, someone in that room would be offended.

- If they were creationists dismissing darwin, someone would be offended

- 2 women discussing ‘shades of grey’, someone would be offended.

- A dongle and forking, and Adria is offended.

To me it seems she is offended by the sexual overtones. A pruder man might be offended by that too, or many a religious man. I just don’t see the link to sexism.

I get it's lowbrow humor. It's not professional. It's probably not suited for a public event like that. The dongle joke was men comparing their 'dongles' and the suggesting they wanted to "fork" the male speaker.

How are women being put down or belittled at all here. How is it sexist?

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by IvyMike on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:16PM (#5419578)
If you assume that all women are Victorian-era pearl-clutching girls for whom anything remotely sexual is scandalous, it makes a lot more sense.

The subtext is "women must be shielded from the world".

On the other hand, for people who have actually met women raised, say, post-1940, it's pretty bizarre.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by nbouscal on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:32PM (#5421019)
This is exactly why I feel like the only person actually guilty of sexism here is Adria herself. She's belittling her own gender by acting as though women cannot be around sexual humor.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by WalterSear on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:17PM (#5419583)
She's not offended by sexual overtones, and neither is her employer. She published this joke about sexual humiliation from the same conference:

https://twitter.com/adriarichards/status/312265091791847425

And the company she was envangelising for on that twitter feed thinks that a visual joke about photocopying your genitals is not inappropriate for their jobs pages:

http://i.imgur.com/uWc8P39.png

I understand that speaker and context make all the difference, but she made a joke about sexual humiliation, and then, at the same conference, got offended by a joke conflating dongles to genitals.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by cglee on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:06PM (#5419498)
Discussions like this seem to always come back to a sense of "fairness". It's not about being fair, but about how situations make people feel.

Majority-group members tend to brush away the sensitivities of minority-group members. If you're straight, you can walk hand-in-hand with your spouse without issue. You may even be able to embrace publicly, and kiss, hug and display all kinds of PDA. Gay couples can't do that without fear of reprisal, sometimes violently.

Minority-group members are only "safe" in certain places.

At a tech conference, women are in the minority, and so crass comments about/towards women are not perceived in a safe way. It's not your buddy making a funny joke, it's the majority-group members expressing oppression.

Whether you personally agree with that is not the point; it's how minority-group members feel.

Be aware of that.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by scotty79 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:30PM (#5419665)
My country has a law about offending religion. Almost whole population is to some degree religious. So not only minorities get offended.

Recently local pop star was tried and sentenced because she said that Bible was written by heavily pissed and baked blokes and some people got offended.

Protecting the offended can be a tool for bullying people that speak their mind or behave true to themselves.

One might think that in this age of intense communication people would grow thinker skin. But Americans got more fragile instead.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by dictum on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:13PM (#5419559)
I've seen the same underlying assumption (that people should avoid accidentally offending other people even with things that aren't offensive) before.

It was when a bigot tried to explain why gay people shouldn't make public displays of their sexuality because they made him uncomfortable.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by IvyMike on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:18PM (#5419590)
> crass comments about/towards women

I think the original comment is raising the point that the comments were crass, but did not appear to be about or towards women in the slightest.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by kefka on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:37PM (#5419726)
And I've always found that self-proclaimed feminists are _always_ offended and loud about it when they are. A few I know go to the point by saying females are better and that all masculine references should be eliminated. They need to vote with their pocketbooks: don't pay for a ticket, and don't attend.

I went to a 'con recently: The Midwest RepRap festival. I heard no references to sex, sexuality, race, or anything of the sort. One sales person came around, got argumentative once we said we were not interested, and started to try to argue religion. That was perhaps, 10 minutes tops. Everybody else stayed absolutely professional about everything.

Now, the last thing I want to hear at a tech conference is another tiring sex joke. It may be funny, but that's not why I'm here.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by icebraining on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:40PM (#5420537)
I've always found that self-proclaimed feminists are _always_ offended and loud about it when they are

Have you found that to be true of male feminists as well?

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by drivebyacct2 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @09:58PM (#5420880)
Feminists are people who believe men and women should be treated equally. Nothing more, nothing less. Classifying fanatics as "feminists" and acting like all feminists acts that way is ... well... pretty damn stupid.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by nbouscal on Friday March 22, 2013 @11:55AM (#5423716)
That's actually really not accurate at all. If feminism were that simple of a concept, discussing it would be a hell of a lot easier. First off you have the whole "wave" notion, where feminism has changed dramatically over time. Second, most contemporary feminists are talking less about equality and more about diversity, and the value of alternate perspectives. As for whether fanatics get to be classified as feminists or not, it sounds like a classic No True Scotsman scenario to me.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by kefka on Friday March 22, 2013 @01:18PM (#5424222)
I try to avoid the no true Scotsman fallacy. If you say you are a feminist, I accept. But what I say stands: every self proclaimed feminist I've met always get offended at the stupidest things. One I know even had a diatribe towards Carlin about the "personhole cover" because of his insensitivity. The usual stance many in this category take is equality regarded in Animal Farm: they are just "More Equal"

<added> I live in Indiana, and had this haopen to me: I went into a car dealership, looking for a used car. Dealer walks up asking if I wanted to test drive or ask questions. Later on in negotiations, he went hardcore slimy. Along with that, said ,"You can trust me, I'm a good Christian."

That was enough to get me to leave on the spot. Usually people with self-proclaimed titles are to be distrusted, or t least listened to with a very critical ear. It's also similar if I run around calling myself "Ub3r Haxx0r". Most of you would justly call BS.</added>

Then, I have also met many who fight for women to be equal with men. They usually aren't much for the labels, yet will fight ferociously for the rights to be equal. Equal pay is the big one right now, considering pay parity is apart by 20%.

Best said by a friend: when a woman hits a man, and the man hits back, and nobody gasps in astonishment, we shall be equal.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by nbouscal on Friday March 22, 2013 @03:21PM (#5425028)
Interesting how well this aligns with http://paulgraham.com/identity.html. You basically seem to be saying that you are more trusting of people who follow pg's advice in that essay, and I'm inclined to agree with you on that particular point.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by drivebyacct2 on Saturday March 23, 2013 @07:42PM (#5430336)
I sure as hell hope we can agree acting like all feminists act fanatical is harmful for this discussion all around.

Also, look up the definition of feminism.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by nawitus on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:18PM (#5419598)
"At a tech conference, women are in the minority, and so crass comments about/towards women are not perceived in a safe way."

Which didn't happen in this case.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by randallsquared on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:45PM (#5419797)
Your analogy seems to reverse about halfway through. Not being able to make lewd jokes because the majority would find them offensive doesn't seem to apply, here. If, instead, you mean that being offended is, itself, something that you can't do without causing the majority to feel offense, if you're in the minority (as Adria was), I think that this analogy may be stretching too far, or going too meta, or something. :)
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by Maxious on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:08PM (#5419519)
"Sexism" does not appear once in the blog post. So uhh there's that.

The concern with "offensive" discussions/jokes at developer conventions is it can give the sense that some people are not welcome there - if you don't like it, go somewhere else.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by aliguori on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:18PM (#5420964)
There's a feminist belief that all forms of "pornography" are inherently discriminatory toward women with pornography being a very broad concept--basically any form of sexuality not associated with love. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gloria_Steinem#Pornography

Any crude comment relating to sexuality would fall into this category. I am not attempting to justify the response here, just explaining the rationale.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by qdog on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:36PM (#5419706)
Adria stated they had been talking for a while, indicating there were previous comments.

PyCon determined the guys had said something offensive.

So, either PyCon lives in fear of Adria, or other people also found the comments to be overtly sexist/sexual.

Unless PyCon publishes an investigative report, I doubt we will get the entire story.

If you personally don't find the things they said offensive, that's fine, but they were there in a professional representation, not a personal one. If PyCon and their employer both felt the guys said something clearly outside the guidelines represented to them by PyCon, that's the issue. Whether it was about dongles or donkeys doesn't matter.

EDIT: Originally I stated PyCon removed them from the conference, as a followup pointed out this was incorrect.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by konstruktor on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:41PM (#5419756)
Wrong. http://pycon.blogspot.co.at/2013/03/pycon-response-to-inappr... " The comments that were made were in poor taste, and individuals involved agreed, apologized and no further actions were taken by the staff of PyCon 2013. No individuals were removed from the conference, no sanctions were levied."
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by qdog on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:58PM (#5419907)
Indeed. Corrected. Whether "what happens at PyCon stays at PyCon" is the right approach, I'm not so sure, but that seems to be their new guidelines.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by Steuard on Thursday March 21, 2013 @09:09PM (#5420677)
Stealing something I wrote on another thread here:

Dick jokes are perceived to be almost exclusively a part of "guy culture". Want proof? Watch how fast a group of guys making those jokes suddenly clams up and changes the topic the moment an unfamiliar woman walks up. (And when a woman joins in and shows that she's comfortable making those jokes, too, watch how glad everyone is that she can be "just one of the guys".)

So when guys at a conference routinely make dick jokes in public, that contributes to a sense that the conference is a male space. It's not a conscious thing, but it's a real thing, and it would be good for it to change. I don't know that the public shaming in this case was the right way to go about that, but I'm not sure that I have a better alternative to offer, either. (Women are all too aware that quietly saying "Please don't act that way" tends to have no impact at all, apart from the guys thinking she's a humorless busybody.)

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by cameronh90 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:03PM (#5421129)
The reason a group of men clams up when a woman walks past is because they're worried she'll take offense like Adria did. Evidence it's not exclusively part of men's culture is that when a women shows herself not to be offended, most groups of men will actively include her in those jokes.

It doesn't mean we actually think it's offensive or understand why anyone would be offended.. honestly I find it kind of baffling, but nevertheless, I will watch my tongue around unfamiliar women just in case. The other thing is that the potential outcome from offending a woman is much worse than offending a man. I would hate for what I said to be misconstrued as sexual harassment, and it could potentially lose me my job if it was (as it has done for an unfortunate developer in this case).

As far as "one of the guys" goes.. I think that's a perhaps unfortunate way of phrasing a well intentioned message: you are someone we are happy to relax around. My girlfriend is a female developer and quite happily refers to herself as one of the guys and doesn't see it as a problem or sexist. What she does find a little annoying is having to reassure men that she won't be offended by their non-harassing sexual innuendos in order for them to relax around her.

There's probably not really an absolute solution to this.. people take offense at different things. It's nearly impossible to offend me, but other people are offended by the colour of the sky.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by Steuard on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:40PM (#5421244)
It feels like you're missing my point a bit here, so maybe I've been unclear. The reasons that the guys clam up aren't really the issue at all, and I'm not trying to make claims about whether dick jokes are or should be offensive to anyone.

My actual point is that in practice, whatever the reason, guys typically only make those jokes when they consider themselves to be in an environment where such jokes are welcome: what I called a "male space". So what does it imply when guys at tech conferences feel comfortable making dick jokes in public? The message that "this is a male space" comes across loud and clear to everyone who hears them: men feel a bit more comfortable making off-color jokes of their own, and women feel like outsiders.

Again, all of those implications are entirely independent of whether anyone actually finds the jokes themselves offensive, and independent of the reasons that guys typically self-censor. In this case, I rather suspect that Richards herself was not offended by the joke, but was upset that the guys were (unconsciously) sending a "male space" message simply by being willing to say it out loud.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by mlent on Thursday March 21, 2013 @10:55PM (#5421097)
According to the article I read, which could be wrong, the phrase was "I'd fork that repo." In and of itself, harmless, but said in the proper tone (don't know if it was), it would remind me of things that have been said about me. I.e. People talking about how they would do 'x' to me. Totally creepy and disturbing, right?

A phrase like that is called a 'trigger'. The same reason you don't say the n-word around a person of color, because you don't know what kind of experiences that person has associated with that. Same for rape, because you could have a victim or a rapist nearby and you don't know how it will affect them (harming or reinforcing them, respectively).

Gender, race, sexuality, and many other topics make people feel very strongly, and sometimes can cause people to dwell on those bad experiences and have the same feelings of angry/inadequacy/self-loathing/whatever that they did at first. My perspective is: I don't know how this really charged term has affected the lives of the people around me, so...maybe I'll wait to make the joke? Or I won't make it?

The dongle thing is silly to me, and the "forking" thing was immature. But that's how I could take offense at that statement. Hope that clears it up? Just my perspective. I don't know if that's how Richards felt...if she didn't, I don't know what the sexist overtones could be either.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by cameronh90 on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:15PM (#5421180)
But how can you know what someone will find to be a trigger? Someone can find almost anything offensive for some reason, or have it remind them of a bad experience. If they were being particularly graphic, of course, that would be inappropriate, but even if this was a wiggley-eyebrows wink wink nudge nudge sexual innuendo, it still seems pretty harmless (other than going against PyCon's rules which is bad). I could get offended, as a vegetarian, by someone saying they're so hungry they could eat a horse - or if I were anorexic, maybe that would be a trigger?

The alternative seems to be that we all become humourless drones, just in case any of our humour offends someone. Maybe I'm biased though, as a Brit: if we didn't have sexual innuendo, we couldn't get up in the morning (wink wink nudge nudge). It's as essential as our morning breakfast tea.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by mlent on Friday March 22, 2013 @12:59PM (#5424119)
Nah, you can't know. It's just a consideration. Obviously some things are more blatant than others. I'm just offering one possible way what was said could've been taken offensively -- not saying that I personally agree.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by ramblerman on Friday March 22, 2013 @02:39AM (#5421680)
I don't want to trivialize the power of such a trigger and the strong emotional states they may bring about. But you are arguing sensitivity and general discourse, for which I agree, these comments were misplaced.

In the underlying argument "What makes it sexist", you seem to imply if the person set off by the trigger is a woman, then the initial statement was sexist. Which is a little broad for my liking.

As for sensitivity, Imagine for a second a victim of prison rape (of which there are unfortunately many cases). I could imagine someone like that having an extremely sensitive reaction to any 'gay' word or image. Should we therefore limit the right of gays to express their affection, out of fear they might offend said people.

Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by mlent on Friday March 22, 2013 @01:01PM (#5424133)
Yeah, I can see how my post could be interpreted that way, though I didn't mean it like that. Just because a woman was offended definitely doesn't mean the statement was necessarily sexist. I'm just trying to offer one possible way they could be construed as sexist -- not to say that I agree with the interpretation personally, though.
Re:Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost by johnward on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:05PM (#5419496)
It's not sexist. It was just a childish joke. Probably inappropriate in the setting, but it got blown way out of proportion.