News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by carbocation on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:14AM (#5356793)
The identified structures look no more nor less "lifelike" than other random bits found in the rock (image is here [1]).

As far as I can tell, this evidence doesn't even begin to scratch at the surface of information needed to demonstrate or even really suggest that these were ever living organisms.

The nail in the coffin, for me, is the fact that this is set to be published in the Journal of Cosmology, a publication of questionable repute [2].

[1] https://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_Cosmology

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by radio4fan on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:01AM (#5357120)
Absolutely. It would be great it was true, but it's almost certainly not.

Images like this are effectively Rorschach tests. Sure, they may look like xenofossils to astrobiologists, but there are no doubt people to whom they look like their grandmother lying in a pool of blood...

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by riggins on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:03PM (#5357551)
It would be great it was true

Extraterrestrial life would be great? I'm not sure. I think the 2 most likely scenarios are: 1. ET would be far less evolved 2. ET would be far more evolved

#1 wouldn't be terribly interesting. So what about #2. What would that be like?

Well, we have some relevant experience from planet earth.

How do humans view/treat organisms that are far less evolved ... like bugs?

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:27PM (#5357754)
How do humans view/treat organisms that are far less evolved ... like bugs?

Any time someone says something like this, that's proof that they don't actually understand evolution.

Bugs have been evolving for exactly as long as we have. Bugs outnumber us, outweigh us, and there are ridiculously more types of them than there are of all kinds of vertebrate life.

We have been able to achieve an undue impact on our environment. But bugs are not less evolved than we are.

Let me add to the surprises. Most fish are evolved from air breathing animals. Our eyes contain a trivial design mistakes that an octopus does not. And we are more closely related to a goldfish than either is to a shark.

If any of this comes as a surprise, then you have confirmed my comment that you don't actually understand evolution.

Edit: Originally I said "land-dwelling" instead of "air-breathing". I do not know of direct evidence about land dwelling, however the swim bladder is believed to be evolved from a lung.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by schiffern on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:20PM (#5358163)
>Bugs have been evolving for exactly as long as we have.

Even more importantly, bugs have been through many more generations than we have. If anything it is the bugs that are "more evolved".

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:50PM (#5358396)
It turns out that evolutionary change doesn't so much depend on how many generations there have been (because things tend to be well enough adapted to their environment that obvious changes don't help much), but rather on how much their environment has changed around them.

That said, the amazing diversity of beetles suggests that some types of bugs have indeed been changing rapidly.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by schiffern on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:18PM (#5358617)
Of course. Number of generations is merely one step less irrelevant than the amount of time that has passed.

As with most things there is a nearly tower of progressively more accurate statements that could be made.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by hnriot on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:51PM (#5358414)
I think it may be more accurate to say, life has been evolving for the same amount of time. Since bugs predate anything even resembling a human by a colossal amount of millennia.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by darkchasma on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:39PM (#5358312)
I feel you have been given some misinformation. Most aquatic mammals evolved from land based mammals, but the fishes have been evolving from fishes for as long as we have a fossil record for. The Osteichthyes or bony fished (Tuna, Salmon) evolved from Chondrichthyes cartilaginous fishes(Sharks, Rays), but none of these evolved from land based animals.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:47PM (#5358376)
See edit.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by darkchasma on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:29PM (#5358695)
I believe you still have that backwards.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by tokenadult on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:05PM (#5358057)
Most fish are evolved from land-dwelling animals

I wanted to check your source for this proposition, because after I upvoted your comment on other grounds, I wasn't completely sure that this squares with what I have read about evolution.

For example, this link

http://dinosaurs.about.com/od/otherprehistoriclife/a/prehist...

is to the contrary, suggesting that most fish living today had ancestors that were aquatic.

AFTER EDIT: To acknowledge your kind reply, I wondered if that was what you were getting at. To me, "land dwelling" implies, among other key behaviors, breeding and laying eggs on land. By contrast, "air breathing" would be a term unambiguous for what you meant, and still surprising to most readers.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:45PM (#5358361)
The swim bladder is a modified lung: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swim_bladder#Evolution

Wikipedia claims that this is thought to have evolved as a survival method in oxygen poor water. My understanding had been that this was because their ancestors, however briefly, were adapted to survive out of the water. If only as well as today's lungfish.

My understanding may be wrong. But still, most fishes today are descended from air-breathing ancestors.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by Dn_Ab on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:12PM (#5358585)
I think you're nitpicking. The good kind (good information in there) but still nitting. Developed, intellectually, culturally and so on is clearly what he meant.

Reading the wiki link, it looks like sharks do not have this feature since there was a divergence prior to this. What this says to me is they probably were water dwelling but for some reason developed lungs (a short stint on land and went on to find their true calling in the water)? Or they could have started out mostly in shallow water or spent a lot of time near the surface.

>>>> EDIT More searching suggests that the picture is quite murky.

The swim bladder and lungs of aquatic and terrestrial organisms arose independently from a common primordial “respiratory pharynx” but not from each other...If there is commonality among these diverse respiratory processes, it is that all levels of organization, from molecular signaling to structure to function, co-evolve progressively, and optimize an existing gas-exchange framework.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2895359/

<<<<

Also, surprise is trivially true given unknown data even if it properly fits one's model since no one follows all deductions of a model to generate all data. Plus, the brain tends to compartmentalize.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by base698 on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:39PM (#5357858)
And if he would like an overview of evolution An Ancestor's Tale would be a great book to pickup. www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/061861916X/ref=redir_mdp_mobile/185-0865240-1556308
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by riggins on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:55PM (#5357985)
Any time someone says something like this, that's proof that they don't actually understand evolution.

I won't be snarky. I'll just point out that evolution has multiple meanings and I think that it's obvious from context that in this case I'm using 'evolved' as shorthand for more intelligent/advanced/sophisticated.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:41PM (#5358330)
> I'll just point out that evolution has multiple meanings and I think that it's obvious from context that in this case I'm using 'evolved' as shorthand for more intelligent/advanced/sophisticated.

Yes, but that's not what evolution means. Natural selection chooses the fittest genotype, not the "more advanced". The idea that evolution progresses from simple to complex is a myth -- a persistent myth, but a myth nevertheless.

Evolution isn't a program with a specific outcome, it's a blind algorithm that chooses the fittest genotype at every turn. If the "fittest" genotype is a cockroach, for example after a nuclear war, that's the outcome. Evolution doesn't care about our tastes because nature doesn't care about our tastes.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by riggins on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:55PM (#5358452)
that's not what evolution means.

Biological evolution is only one of many meanings of the word evolution. (I promise, I'm aware that bugs have been biologically evolving for longer than humans.)

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/evolution?s=t

1. any process of formation or growth; development: the evolution of a language; the evolution of the airplane.

2.a product of such development; something evolved: The exploration of space is the evolution of decades of research.

3.Biology . change in the gene pool of a population from generation to generation by such processes as mutation, natural selection, and genetic drift.

4. a process of gradual, peaceful, progressive change or development, as in social or economic structure or institutions.

5.a motion incomplete in itself, but combining with coordinated motions to produce a single action, as in a machine.

Just do a google search for 'spiritually evolved', 'evolved beings', 'evolved man' ... you'll see what I mean.

as I said, thought it was clear from context.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @03:24AM (#5360694)
Whoa, hold on, In a technical or scientific discussion, you don't want to rely on a dictionary. Dictionaries, contrary to common belief, do not define words -- instead, they dispassionately describe how people choose to use words. If a word use makes no sense, that doesn't matter as long as the use is widespread. This is why "literally" and "figuratively" are ... wait for it ... synonyms.

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/literally

1. : in a literal sense or manner : actually <took the remark literally> <was literally insane>

2. : in effect : virtually <will literally turn the world upside down to combat cruelty or injustice — Norman Cousins>

Read more here: http://arachnoid.com/wrong/index.html#Dictionary

> ... as I said, thought it was clear from context.

Not in any kind of serious discussion, with pretensions of accuracy.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by riggins on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @11:15AM (#5362325)
it never occurred to me that a discussion on an internet bulletin board about whether space aliens are likely to be hostile was a 'technical or scientific discussion'.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @05:41PM (#5365111)
Yes, but it did establish a context for use of the word "evolution" -- the biological one.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by fusiongyro on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:50PM (#5358401)
Isn't that exactly the problem? The relationship between intelligence and duration-of-evolution is not direct and linear.

In response to your assertion, it seems to me that with our advances in medicine it doesn't look likely that we're going to evolve greater intelligence. I would expect any species that evolves our level of intelligence will take an interest in medicine and arrive at basically the same steady state. So I'm going to make a completely unsupportable and useless from-first-principles prediction that intelligent life elsewhere in the cosmos will be approximately as intelligent as us.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:13PM (#5358588)
The belief that humans have arrived at a plateau and no longer are subject to evolution is also evidence that you do not understand evolution.

I assure you, homo sapiens is under great evolutionary pressure to evolve an effective response to birth control.

It is also worth noting that it is suspected that our large brains mostly reached their present size to enable us to be more effective in interacting with each other. As long as we would prefer to not wind up alone on Saturday night, we'll be under pressure to better figure out how to get other humans to do what we want them to do. There is no upper limit to how much intelligence could be brought to bear on that problem.

(Though in practice I believe that we'll build machines smarter than us, which will improve far more rapidly than we could ever hope to.)

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by fusiongyro on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:24PM (#5359904)
So, your counterargument is that birth control and Saturday Night Fever will have a bigger effect on the evolutionary process than enabling people with congenital diseases to reproduce, and that, moreover, this will somehow continue to produce increases in intelligence at the same rate as we experienced going from ape to human?

I'm not claiming evolution is finished. I'm claiming it is affected and I don't see compelling pressure to select for ever-greater intelligence. Even if I found your argument compelling, you're hardly talking about the same kind of intelligence as the GP. Intelligence is one of those squishy things that resists good formal definition.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @01:40AM (#5360423)
I am not trying to predict the future. I am merely saying that evolution isn't done, and the presence of medicine and a high quality of life doesn't change the basic equation of "survival of the fittest".

And intelligence is selected for for reasons that are not addressed by modern medicine.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by hnriot on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:48PM (#5358390)
"design mistake"

there is no design[er]

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by hnriot on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @12:17AM (#5360118)
Down voted for this??? I thought the hn community was smarte than that. Hands up then that disagrees with the scientific community??? Ok, now please leave this forum. Or at least prefix your username with something like creationist_<user> so I can know whom to ignore :) wake up, it's the 21st century, the era of superstition and myth has passed and unless we want to return to the dark ages we need to foster forward thinking philosophies and not mire ourselves in the flat earth era of thinking.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by themstheones on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:23PM (#5357713)
Comparing amounts of evolution isn't really valid. This implies that evolution has a directional trend, but it does not. Humanity wasn't the goal of evolution. Given a different climate 10 or 15 thousand year ago, things could have been a lot different. Neanderthals could have won out, or both our species could have gone extinct.

I think a better, and similar, comparison would be of intelligence. We treat less intelligent animals quite poorly for the most part. Hopefully the correlation between empathy and intelligence is universal and not just a trend among humans.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:50PM (#5358406)
> Hopefully the correlation between empathy and intelligence is universal and not just a trend among humans.

I hate to rain on your parade, but empathy and intelligence are selected only insofar as it supports survival and procreation -- only to the degree that it supports natural selection.

Empathy and intelligence are just neutral terms in a complex equation by which natural selection chooses the fittest genotype. They have no special standing, and a fair reading of human and natural history shows that, overall, they're not correlated with the survival of the species that possesses it.

Evidence? Count the number, or the biomass if you prefer, of the species that survive in a brainless, ruthless manner. Compare to those whose fitness is enhanced by empathy and intelligence. And remember that overall we can't be included in the intelligent, empathic column, at least not when we're doing our best to survive.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by btilly on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:06PM (#5358543)
The best-informed speculation of today says that within the last 150,000 years (different methods give different dates, the Toba supervolcano is often fingered as a culprit) we went through a population bottleneck with as few as a thousand people alive.

This evolutionary episode would have been a period of rapid adaptation, and amusingly is suspected to have been when our ancestors acquired a tendency towards religious belief. (We are the only known hominid with things like burial rites.)

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by ecto on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:17PM (#5357672)
You are assuming that a highly evolved lifeform would act like us humans, barely out of the trees socially and spiritually. You may be right. However there are many people I know that wouldn't hurt a bug.

Tangentially, #1 would be incredibly interesting to many people. We (the general public) have no definite indications that we /aren't/ on the only rock in the Universe with life, and #1 would hold great consequences.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by codeulike on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:30PM (#5357777)
Agreed, #1 would still be earth-shaking. At the moment, we're the only life we know of. Finding evidence of extraterrestial microbes in the same solar system would suggest a much higher probability for life all over the galaxy.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by Xion on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:03PM (#5358033)
> #1 wouldn't be terribly interesting.

The scary implication of #1 is that it updates our probability for long-term survival and becoming a technologically advanced, space-faring species: by _lowering_ it. That's because it pushes the potential Great Filter [1] closer to our present condition and increasing the odds that it's actually somewhere in our future.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_filter

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by Arelius on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:14PM (#5358118)
Though, statistically, if you push the "the great filter" closer to our present condition, don't you actually push the bulk of the probable filter events to before our present condition, events which are evidently not true in our case, and actually _raise_ our probability of long-term survival?
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by Xion on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @07:53AM (#5361262)
Remember that you still need to explain the Fermi paradox [1]. If you apply the above logic to life & civilizations in general, you conclude that it's actually quite likely for them to survive long enough and become widespread. Yet, our experience contradicts that assertion, for we don't know any other race at even comparable level of technical development

Of course, this (i.e. civilization quickly become extinct) is just one possible resolution to the paradox, but the arguably simplest one. If the actual reason(s) we don't see advanced life are different, the Great filter hypothesis holds less water. We don't know that yet, though.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by Arelius on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @01:54PM (#5363600)
I've always thought the fact that the vast open spaces in the universe is really quite sufficient to explain the fermi paradox
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by ignostic on Tuesday March 12, 2013 @01:55AM (#5360476)
I don't know. We actually seem to have a pretty strong affinity for other forms of life. I can't imagine any other animal on earth preserving dumber animals they could potentially eat. We like other animals - especially those with faces and discernible intelligence.

Now you might say that this is irrelevant. Just because we like other animals doesn't mean the aliens will. This is a good point, except that it completely invalidates the premise put forth of "experience from planet earth."

I have to believe that any organism sophisticated enough to find us would be amazed. They may be far more advanced, but seeing the lifelessness of space and the complexity of our civilization, anything with a shred of intelligence would be at least intrigued. Speculating on their nature and disposition is meaningless and arbitrary at this point.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by tripzilch on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:20PM (#5357694)
Bugs are going to eat us all, one day.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by cleis on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:44PM (#5357901)
My whole family was in Buenos Aires
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:53PM (#5358426)
I don't think many will get this reference to Starship Troopers, a rather good film in spite of its reliance on endless gore.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by jlgreco on Monday March 11, 2013 @03:35PM (#5359094)
A good book also, despite its senselessly piled on militarism. Strangely quite the opposite of the film in that regard.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by raverbashing on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:49AM (#5357028)
"The nail in the coffin, for me, is the fact that this is set to be published in the Journal of Cosmology, a publication of questionable repute [2]."

So it's ok to go Ad Hominem against anything that contradicts our current knowledge? Ok, got it

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by tokenadult on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:56AM (#5357080)
No, it's that an extraordinary claim that would revolutionize our understanding of the universe would be likely to be published in a high-impact journal, if it is backed up by enough evidence to survive review in that journal. When the principal investigator of a study is someone who has to publish in his own journal,

http://journalofcosmology.com/Contents11.html

(Wickramasinghe is "Executive Editor, Astrobiology" for the Journal of Cosmology)

then you can see for yourself a bad sign about the strength of evidence for the paper.

See

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Identifying_reliable_...

for more details on identifying reliable sources.

AFTER EDIT:

The group blog Retraction Watch

http://retractionwatch.wordpress.com/

is an excellent glimpse into the world of scientific publishing, and shows how many low-ranking journals there are that are hard up for content. I think I learned about this interesting blog from another HN participant a year or two ago.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by raverbashing on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:11AM (#5357174)
The article should stand (or not) on its merits, regardless of the journal of publication (or other medium)

Of course I trust Nature more than, let's say "Bob's Journal about science stuff"

But sometimes even articles in Nature have been printed elsewhere first, (like a 'beta test' for the article - peer review nevertheless), usually in journals specific from the field (clarification below)

The "Identifying reliable sources" page is a Wikipedia policy, it has some good insights, but it is biased towards Wikipedia, see for example "Articles should rely on secondary sources whenever possible. For example, a review article, monograph, or textbook is better than a primary research paper"

Edit: Yes, journals usually don't accept content published elsewhere, my bad.

What happens is that, yes, you can't republish something 100% equal to something published elsewhere. (eg: http://www.ieee.org/documents/top10faq.pdf ) but while the research progresses you provide more detailed papers or focus on different areas of research

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by carbocation on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:16AM (#5357205)
> But sometimes even articles in Nature have been printed elsewhere first, (like a 'beta test' for the article - peer review nevertheless), usually in journals specific from the field.

Not true. Republishing already-published work is specifically disallowed by Nature and most high impact journals. Doing so merits a retraction.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by carbocation on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:54AM (#5357068)
> So it's ok to go Ad Hominem against anything that contradicts our current knowledge? Ok, got it

The whole point of scientific journals is to change our current knowledge, so that's not really a fair criticism of my dismissal.

Read even just the Wikipedia article and you'll see that this journal has several issues: (1) the quality of its peer review is questionable; (2) it appears to promote fringe views; (3) it has been widely criticized by the scientific community.

So yes, after criticizing the research itself, I also dug around and discovered problems with the journal it was being published in. I don't see anything wrong with doing so. Had the data looked less bogus I probably wouldn't have been suspicious enough to investigate the source.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by raverbashing on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:19AM (#5357233)
"So yes, after criticizing the research itself"

Your point was that these features look as similar as other features and hence they should be the same.

Now, the given article really reads like a press release more than anything, but I don't remember if the original article had something else on the picture.

What I would think is that (but I am not sure) since these are electron microscope pictures, you can get a composition analysis of the sample from the microscope, hence being able to differentiate the features.

And no, I'm not taking this research too seriously as well, I just find it funny that some people jump at it and seem to dismiss it at first sight.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by trentlott on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:11AM (#5357173)
Their previous paper[1], and will only take about five to ten minutes to read, and gives you a pretty good idea what the level of this "journal" is.

Phil Plaitt also has a pretty good critique[2], but if you have the background, reading that paper should be enough to at least make you squint hard at their "science". There's a reason that people don't take the group seriously, and it's not fear from the establishment or whatever nonsense.

[1] http://journalofcosmology.com/JOC21/PolonnaruwaRRRR.pdf

[2] http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2013/01/15/life_in_...

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by jahewson on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:35PM (#5357833)
It's not an ad hominem to suggest that a piece of unconventional research is unlikely to be correct because it is published in a disreputable journal. Academia is all about reputation, and the standing of various journals.

If they had sufficient evidence to back up their claims then they would be on the cover of Nature. Unfortunately for them, actual Science requires peer-reviewed evidence. Publishing in your own journal does not count. It's a huge red flag.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by arrrg on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:07PM (#5358548)
If you are not an expert in the field, it will be very hard if not impossible for you to judge a scientific article on its merits.

In that light, looking at where something was published makes total sense. It’s a completely valid mechanism for non-experts to separate the crap from the good stuff. (Even experts, given all the stuff that is published all the time, have no time to read and evaluate everything on its merits. Increasing efficiency by centralizing that task and not forcing every scientist to do it all the time is more or less the purpose of journals.)

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:54PM (#5358440)
No, that's only a comment on the care taken with the norms of scientific discipline. Anyone can get an astrology paper published, just not in a reputable, refereed journal.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by eksith on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:00AM (#5357107)
It doesn't have the same reputation as New Scientist, but I'm taking it with some cautious optimism. I'm still reading the original report to filter through any embellishments etc... While structures alone may not provide conclusive evidence, perhaps the composition will.

The name Anil Samaranayake caught my eye, since he's the the director of the Colombo Medical Research Institute.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by tripzilch on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:26PM (#5357739)
> published in the Journal of Cosmology, a publication of questionable repute [2].

Well, at least their publications are not behind a paywall, free for download:

http://arxiv.org/abs/1303.1845

so anyone can check the believability of this research themselves!

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by bargl on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:20AM (#5357242)
I think the biggest thing for me is that it hasn't been verified by multiple studies... I tend to look for a broader acceptance than in one place. Then it's really a debate, this is just a cool finding that needs to be peer reviewed.

So I'd say it's too early to pull out the nails or the coffin, it is just an unverified theory right now. Those are a dime a dozen.