News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by raverbashing on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:49AM (#5357028)
"The nail in the coffin, for me, is the fact that this is set to be published in the Journal of Cosmology, a publication of questionable repute [2]."

So it's ok to go Ad Hominem against anything that contradicts our current knowledge? Ok, got it

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by tokenadult on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:56AM (#5357080)
No, it's that an extraordinary claim that would revolutionize our understanding of the universe would be likely to be published in a high-impact journal, if it is backed up by enough evidence to survive review in that journal. When the principal investigator of a study is someone who has to publish in his own journal,

http://journalofcosmology.com/Contents11.html

(Wickramasinghe is "Executive Editor, Astrobiology" for the Journal of Cosmology)

then you can see for yourself a bad sign about the strength of evidence for the paper.

See

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Identifying_reliable_...

for more details on identifying reliable sources.

AFTER EDIT:

The group blog Retraction Watch

http://retractionwatch.wordpress.com/

is an excellent glimpse into the world of scientific publishing, and shows how many low-ranking journals there are that are hard up for content. I think I learned about this interesting blog from another HN participant a year or two ago.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by raverbashing on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:11AM (#5357174)
The article should stand (or not) on its merits, regardless of the journal of publication (or other medium)

Of course I trust Nature more than, let's say "Bob's Journal about science stuff"

But sometimes even articles in Nature have been printed elsewhere first, (like a 'beta test' for the article - peer review nevertheless), usually in journals specific from the field (clarification below)

The "Identifying reliable sources" page is a Wikipedia policy, it has some good insights, but it is biased towards Wikipedia, see for example "Articles should rely on secondary sources whenever possible. For example, a review article, monograph, or textbook is better than a primary research paper"

Edit: Yes, journals usually don't accept content published elsewhere, my bad.

What happens is that, yes, you can't republish something 100% equal to something published elsewhere. (eg: http://www.ieee.org/documents/top10faq.pdf ) but while the research progresses you provide more detailed papers or focus on different areas of research

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by carbocation on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:16AM (#5357205)
> But sometimes even articles in Nature have been printed elsewhere first, (like a 'beta test' for the article - peer review nevertheless), usually in journals specific from the field.

Not true. Republishing already-published work is specifically disallowed by Nature and most high impact journals. Doing so merits a retraction.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by carbocation on Monday March 11, 2013 @10:54AM (#5357068)
> So it's ok to go Ad Hominem against anything that contradicts our current knowledge? Ok, got it

The whole point of scientific journals is to change our current knowledge, so that's not really a fair criticism of my dismissal.

Read even just the Wikipedia article and you'll see that this journal has several issues: (1) the quality of its peer review is questionable; (2) it appears to promote fringe views; (3) it has been widely criticized by the scientific community.

So yes, after criticizing the research itself, I also dug around and discovered problems with the journal it was being published in. I don't see anything wrong with doing so. Had the data looked less bogus I probably wouldn't have been suspicious enough to investigate the source.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by raverbashing on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:19AM (#5357233)
"So yes, after criticizing the research itself"

Your point was that these features look as similar as other features and hence they should be the same.

Now, the given article really reads like a press release more than anything, but I don't remember if the original article had something else on the picture.

What I would think is that (but I am not sure) since these are electron microscope pictures, you can get a composition analysis of the sample from the microscope, hence being able to differentiate the features.

And no, I'm not taking this research too seriously as well, I just find it funny that some people jump at it and seem to dismiss it at first sight.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by trentlott on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:11AM (#5357173)
Their previous paper[1], and will only take about five to ten minutes to read, and gives you a pretty good idea what the level of this "journal" is.

Phil Plaitt also has a pretty good critique[2], but if you have the background, reading that paper should be enough to at least make you squint hard at their "science". There's a reason that people don't take the group seriously, and it's not fear from the establishment or whatever nonsense.

[1] http://journalofcosmology.com/JOC21/PolonnaruwaRRRR.pdf

[2] http://www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2013/01/15/life_in_...

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by jahewson on Monday March 11, 2013 @12:35PM (#5357833)
It's not an ad hominem to suggest that a piece of unconventional research is unlikely to be correct because it is published in a disreputable journal. Academia is all about reputation, and the standing of various journals.

If they had sufficient evidence to back up their claims then they would be on the cover of Nature. Unfortunately for them, actual Science requires peer-reviewed evidence. Publishing in your own journal does not count. It's a huge red flag.

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by arrrg on Monday March 11, 2013 @02:07PM (#5358548)
If you are not an expert in the field, it will be very hard if not impossible for you to judge a scientific article on its merits.

In that light, looking at where something was published makes total sense. It’s a completely valid mechanism for non-experts to separate the crap from the good stuff. (Even experts, given all the stuff that is published all the time, have no time to read and evaluate everything on its merits. Increasing efficiency by centralizing that task and not forcing every scientist to do it all the time is more or less the purpose of journals.)

Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by lutusp on Monday March 11, 2013 @01:54PM (#5358440)
No, that's only a comment on the care taken with the norms of scientific discipline. Anyone can get an astrology paper published, just not in a reputable, refereed journal.
Re:Astrobiologists Find Ancient Fossils in Meteorite Fragments by eksith on Monday March 11, 2013 @11:00AM (#5357107)
It doesn't have the same reputation as New Scientist, but I'm taking it with some cautious optimism. I'm still reading the original report to filter through any embellishments etc... While structures alone may not provide conclusive evidence, perhaps the composition will.

The name Anil Samaranayake caught my eye, since he's the the director of the Colombo Medical Research Institute.