It's not just unlikely but, in fact, impossible for the operating costs of the servers to be worth keeping on forever since no (significant) additional income will be coming in from the title after some point X.
SaaS companies have been dealing with this for years quite successfully via their "pay as you go" monthly subscriptions. This keeps the money flowing in and motivation to keep the servers on. And, better yet, it gives the consumer confidence that the service provider is going to pay attention to the product long-term, not just during launch day.
My recommendation for EA moving forward would be to move to subscription pricing for any games that operate as online-only - single- or multi-player.
Exact pricing is important as well. My initial instinct was to say that they should prorate the cost, something like $5/month but I quickly realized why this wouldn't work. Obviously most gamers are fickle and have short attention spans. 90% of buyers probably wouldn't buy month two and it wouldn't work out.
Instead, I would recommend pricing the game at something like $60 for two years. Same price and clearer value to me as a customer. Suddenly I'm not worried if they are going to shut off the servers in four years because that's not what I'm paying for today (and really never was). I'm paying for the opportunity to play this week and, if I love it, play it over and over again for two full years. Is that worth $60? Absolutely! And what about in two years? If I'm still loving it, hopefully they let me renew for another two years, maybe even at a discount. And if the game ends up sucking and nobody renews, they can turn the servers off (or throttle them down) without feeling bad.
The real risk with the current system isn't in case the game is a flop and they turn the servers off prematurely. It's actually if the game is legendary, like SimCities of past, and the passion to play keeps momentum for decades. How can EA keep the lights on?
The issue here isn't that EA is not making enough to keep the lights on. It's that EA wants to make more, and more, and more and more, and more... And is too lazy to figure out a true solution to piracy.
Nobody will pay $60 to "rent" something for 2 years. You already pay $60 to own for life.
If it were some insane price like $10, then yes. That makes a whole bunch of sense. It's the model that Netflix, Spotify, and the iTunes Store subscribes to. Saas will only work if it provides value at an extremely minimal price.
What happened with Sim City is not a failure of the Netflix, Spotify, iTunes store model. It's just that EA, as a company, is just simply blinded with so much greed to understand the way the world works today.
They have been losing money for years.
2012: $76M 2011: ($276M) 2010: ($677M) 2009: ($1088M) 2008: ($454M)
So they juuuust squeaked back into profitability last year; probably mainly due to the slowly improving economy (games are luxury items and folks are only now cringing less when they spend on them).
It's hard to know yet whether this ugly launch was actually a bad move for them; dollars don't lie and they appear to be paying enough to get some heavyweight execs.
[1]: http://investor.ea.com/sec.cfm [2]: http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ERTS/2357335259x0x590...
The jury is still out on how the economy affects video games.
It's often argued that video games perform similarly in recessions to the 'sin industries' - alcohol, cigarettes, gambling, etc. Some quick googling found plenty of articles about whether the video game industry is 'recession proof', but nothing I found unequivocal enough to cite.
While I personally understand all the costs involved and would perhaps be willing to do this (kinda like the WoW model where the game had an up-front cost plus recurring service fees), I think many would feel scammed by this model.
My question is: what is wrong with the model where single-player is totally offline, but multiplayer requires a matchmaking server that DOES validate the license? This model is already out there and works well enough (though it is 2013 and we could /probably/ figure out how to make open directory server software and/or employ P2P tech to lessen the financial burden AND increase reliability / stability / community relations...).
The bigger issue here is that American companies are trying to move us to a subscription model for /everything/, so we're always in debt and most will never truly own anything of significant value. Lease your housing, your car, your computing, your gaming, your textbooks, your cellphone, your couch, your money, etc.
Unfortunately for Maxis they obviously didn't hire any programmers who had a clue how to write scalable server code.
And the result is that they have managed to lose a lot of sales in the first few key weeks because of bad reviews.
But economically speaking, sound decision, just poorly executed.
On your last point, this is an unfortunate side effect of digital goods. In Europe we can hope for a growing political movement that this is deeply anti-consumer and will be legislated against, far more likely here than in America, but it will be hard for courts to decide where to draw a line. So ultimately I doubt it will ever happen.
I'm not sure it counts as a 'sound decision' if you take a very risky option that hasn't panned out well for competitors in the same market on the premise that if you beat the odds, you'll get a bit more money.
I think EA underestimated the cost of their "always on" DRM, and didn't adequately assess the risk against the payoff - and now have taken a business hit from it.
For example, literally no one I know that I used to play Sim City with for hundreds of hours as a kid purchased this game - precisely because of EAs decisions regarding always on DRM and their history with Spore design. They've effectively driven away over a dozen people in their 20s, perfectly willing to fork over $70-100 on a game they like. (Or $200 or $300 or $1000 on a really good game they like; I'm looking at you table-top guide books, trading card games, and minifigures.)
I consider that exactly the opposite of 'sound decisions'.
tl;dr: You have to assess the risk that you're going to poorly execute your choice to make a 'sound decision'; I'm not sure EA did.
You aren't going to pirate Sim City 5.
This is the future of gaming. Companies are just going to avoid all the grief of piracy and weird DRM by either moving to locked-down platforms (iOS and consoles) or into games that have essential online components.
It's a classic prisoner's dilemma. I'd love to by a game and install it on my PC without it taking things over, and the publishers would love to write that and not worry about DRM. But we can't get that because each of us doesn't trust the other party to defect.
Then I guess I won't be gaming anymore. Not that I do much now, and I've mostly quit for other unrelated reasons, but if is the future of gaming, you can count me, and I'm sure many others, out.
I used to game a lot. I used to spend a not insignificant amount of money on games. If the publishers want to basically steal my money and call me the thief, then they can forget about having me as a customer.
What is most curious though, is whether or not this new world order is stable long term. Other creative works publishers like movie studios or musicians, can capture the long tail of revenue for their products long after the initial 'rush' but for game studios and other 'active' products there is this continual draw on the host companies resources to keep servers alive or what not. So eventually keeping a game 'alive' starts generating negative money. And killing a game generates negative customer sentiment. So the combination might overwhelm the business model.
Only time will tell.
Then we have all the really great indie games coming out, like the successor to Dungeon Keeper Series[2] that looks good enough to be AAA (though no where near the price range), but is crowd funded. We also have a great alternative to Blizzard's Diablo with Torchlight. Some studios will go the way of EA and others I think will be the opposing side. Who will win though I think is up for debate, but I prefer to be optimistic.
[1] http://www.firingsquad.com/games/Firing_Points_Consolitis/
When a game nears that point, the publishers can theoretically push a patch that removes the "must be online" components and/or allows connection to self-run servers, so the community can keep it alive.
I'm aware of a few companies actually doing something like this. Years ago, Parallax/Outrage/Volition (of the Descent series) went out of their way to give the community the assets they'd need to keep the series alive.
http://www.joystiq.com/2012/06/20/dragon-age-legends-no-long...
My guess is for "cult favorites" after some period of time they'll just push out a patch that removes the DRM and turn the servers off. Then it's just a question of losing multiplayer.
Let me compare to DotA2 which I play a lot. It's exclusively multiplayer and thus needs an internet connection, yet it's free to play. How much have I spent on it? At this point at least $75+ dollars. THIS IS THE FUTURE OF GAMING.
Valve has the right model. I know valve didn't create the F2P model but it has implemented it the best as far as I know. They have pulled more money out of me giving me a free game then they would have made if they sold me 60+ copy.
EA should of just given out free copies of SimCity. Given out free copies with enough features to keep me entertained without the need to spend money. Then releasing toolsets for modders to create items; resell them to us for profit.
The DLC will surely be created but based on how EA conducts DLC in The Sims 3, I expect expensive expansions and stuffer packs.
Freemium versus pay-up-front are both flavors of that.
Do we know that SimCity "flopped"? It's gotten lots of people angry at it, but that's not at all the same as not making money.
I can't find a better example of F2P models out there, even my beloved Planetside 2 has some pretty big issues with how its model applies to gameplay.
If others followed this model, free to play would not be given anywhere close to the bad name it typically conveys.
I'm tempted to believe that due to the simulation grunt work being done server-side. But people also said the same thing about WoW and Starcraft II, yet you can easily play either of those for free with fully functioning multiplayer (just not on Battle.net).
Am I misunderstanding what you mean by saves? That seems pretty important to me.
At times this wouldn't work and I would lose my progress, but I'm willing to attribute that to the fact that it was supposed to be a rare case backup mechanism, rather than the necessary crutch it is currently.
I made my statement based upon my experiences playing. For one, I played the game for 3 hours disconnected from the servers - I knew my progress wouldn't be saved but I just wanted to play. It seemed to work fine aside from region play and that my progress wasn't saved.
Another time I lost my internet connection for 15 minutes. I continued to play. When I got it back, it claimed it re-sync'd my game with the server. As a test I logged out and back in and it all looked the same.
Maybe there is some simulation on the server side. But it doesn't seem necessary based upon my experiences playing the game.
If there's interest in it, it'll be done. The connections will be sniffed and reproduced and/or the online component will just be cracked out entirely, but if somebody wants to do it it will ultimately be done.
I doubt SimCity 2013 is going to develop such a cult following to allow for these kinds of cracks.
My thoughts exactly; Giant Bomb's hour-long video review was pretty telling of the issues in the game that a lot of people just haven't been able to deal with yet. Problems that are only around because so much time was spent trying to implement the multiplayer aspect rather than focusing on the core gameplay itself.
I want a new SimCity game just as badly as everyone else, but at this point I'm looking towards other offerings in this space - hopefully by smaller companies - to hold the torch (any suggestions here would be excellent).
they are getting much of my monies
EDIT: Don't remember which thread i found it in, so here are the posts that may have been the one that I found the kickstarter link in:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5343788 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5341070
flat out lie. there are multiple well run servers that often outperform the legit ones.
this is also true for all games with server emulation or otherwise private servers, they work well and often exactly the same as their legit counterparts.
If you speak from 'experience', then I would suggest you didn't try hard enough to find a decent server.
either way, don't exaggerate and lie to make a point. make the fucking point and leave it at that.
It's a future, but not the only one. There could be crowdfunded open source games, for example.
http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/wasteland-2 http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/obsidian/project-eternit... http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inxile/torment-tides-of-... http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/70755535/dead-state-the-... http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/redthread/dreamfall-chap...
The future of gaming has a few alternatives that look very promising and they're all DRM free.
These games are developed on open PC systems, so that's always going to be around too... your predictions for the future look hazy.
Where piracy is rampant?
That just means we'll be moving even more towards not having software that runs just on my hardware.
PC game piracy at one point was fairly mainstream, but then installing PC games at all ceased to become mainstream.
Music and porn piracy is mainstream; streaming services sort of prevent that, at the cost of destroying revenue for creators/distributors. Movie/TV are probably at the tipping point (youtube and netflix helped a lot).
Constantly advertised in every free buy&sell paper constitutes mainstream, even if you don't like it.
>but then installing PC games at all ceased to become mainstream.
The number of people installing PC games has steadily increased. Maybe posting "facts" that are the opposite of reality isn't a great base for an argument.
I don't know why a game publisher wouldn't want to sell new copies of old games forever, like you can do with movies in the good new days.
That's the part that concerns me the most. I still install (and play) lots of old games on every computer I own -- King's Quest VI, C&C: Red Alert, Worms: Armageddon, etc. And who could live without the console classics like Goldeneye or Ocarina of Time? All you have to do is pull out the disc (or cartridge), pop it in, and play.
We still don't know exactly what will happen with this new generation of games that consumers are merely "renting" from companies like EA, but piracy seems to be our only guaranteed method of preserving them. What happens if you want to play Battlefield 3 again 10 years from now? You might be able to access it IFF:
There's not much history to base this speculation on yet, but what little we do have shows that that's an extremely unlikely scenario. If there's any chance to preserve the games we're playing now, it's probably up to us to make it happen.