News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by TillE on Thursday March 07, 2013 @03:49PM (#5340133)
Oh, there's a reason. Like Diablo III, the point is that it's effectively impossible to crack. With enough processing offloaded to the server, would-be pirates need to write something that's almost a whole new game.

This is the future that big videogame companies are rushing to embrace, one where customers do not and cannot own games, merely rent them for an uncertain period. Indies and smaller studios with Kickstarter funding are going to continue eating a bigger part of their lunch.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by bearmf on Thursday March 07, 2013 @03:52PM (#5340159)
The irony is that it is not only impossible to crack, it is now impossible to play as well. Unplayable games are impossible to crack, but this does not make them any less absurd. DRM has come to its logical and absurd conclusion, it seems.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by fusiongyro on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:24PM (#5340372)
It worked out the same way with music. For a short time the labels were experimenting with selling CDs that weren't actually audio CDs, but had been damaged in various ways to make them unplayable on a computer. The result of that experiment speaks for itself. Hopefully it will play out the same way here.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by mmatants on Thursday March 07, 2013 @05:02PM (#5340635)
The result is that we are increasingly switching to renting our music via services like Rdio and Spotify.

And I can't say that this trend is all bad. I know what I pay for (temporary access), and I'm OK with that.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by fusiongyro on Thursday March 07, 2013 @05:13PM (#5340704)
Apple seems to still be doing alright selling digital music, and they voluntarily stopped using DRM.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by pwthornton on Thursday March 07, 2013 @05:49PM (#5340901)
Apple didn't voluntarily stop using DRM; they convinced the labels to stop requiring it. Piracy isn't Apple's concern, but the user experience is.

This is in service of saying that DRM isn't in the user's best interest and even big companies that care about user experience don't like DRM. Apple didn't ship DRM on its OSes when they were DVD based either. Yes they probably lost some sales due to piracy, but not having to deal with serial numbers is big for users.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by ariwilson on Thursday March 07, 2013 @06:20PM (#5341067)
No, Amazon stopped using DRM to have a competitive advantage versus Apple, the music companies went along because it gave them a real competitor to iTunes, and eventually Apple managed to renegotiate their contracts so they could also remove the DRM.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by arrrg on Thursday March 07, 2013 @07:14PM (#5341316)
Juicy, juicy revisionist history!
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by hatcravat on Friday March 08, 2013 @05:28AM (#5342774)
>they convinced the labels to stop requiring it.

Are you sure it wasn't the other way around? People were building huge libraries of music that only worked on Apple products (iPods and iTunes) around the time the labels allowed Amazon to start selling DRM-free MP3s. Apple would have gained an enormous amount of leverage if the labels had allowed that to continue: "Oh, you won't accept our terms? Well, then your product won't be playable on 90% [0] of portable music devices [1] and won't be available in the largest online music store (and your competitors' will be)! I hope not all your artists have left by next fiscal quarter." For all he talked amount it, I'm not convinced that Steve Jobs ever wanted to see the iTunes Music Store go DRM-free.

The market penetration of iPods meant that only path forward for the labels was one that allowed people to listen to music on their iPods. The only way to do that was selling DRM-free MP3s or protected AAC files. As a bonus, DRM-free MP3s worked on all the cheap flash-based players (which always had greater deployment than any of the DRM-compatible players from Sony and Microsoft).

[0] A number generated by my PRNG (posterior random number generator). But the iPod Classic really does have an absurd share of the >64GB market (probably declining now that you can get tablets and phones with 128GB of flash). [1] Don't forget that Apple has only ever supported their own DRM. Protected AAC files play on Apple devices and only Apple devices. Apple devices support only protected AAC and DRM-free formats.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by simonh on Friday March 08, 2013 @08:12AM (#5343210)
>>they convinced the labels to stop requiring it. > >Are you sure it wasn't the other way around?

You must have missed this. A Steve Jobs classic. Music industry execs have confirmed Apple was behind the move away from DRM.

http://www.apple.com/uk/hotnews/thoughtsonmusic/

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by networked on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:04PM (#5340236)
>Like Diablo III, the point is that it's effectively impossible to crack. With enough processing offloaded to the server, would-be pirates need to write something that's almost a whole new game.

I agree that this is a strong deterrent but given how even MMORPG servers have been reversed engineered [1] it's not impossible. If SimCity proves as enduring and as desirable as WoW we may well see it coupled with a LinCity-NG-derived [2] backend or similar.

Edit: That said, a powerful stimulus for the development of MMO server emulators was that players dissatisfied with the official servers' community simple couldn't run their own server how they'd like it for whom they like. I assume that the new SimCity is designed to be a far less community-oriented experience and people in control of the neighboring cities are largely replaceable from a player's perspective.

[1] See http://www.runuo.com/, http://www.galaxiesreborn.com/, https://launchpad.net/aurora-runescape-server-emulator, http://arcemu.org/, etc. Note how many of those are community FOSS projects, even though running them with an official client is almost always a ToS violation.

[2] http://lincity-ng.berlios.de/wiki/index.php/Main_Page

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by sirclueless on Thursday March 07, 2013 @11:51PM (#5342132)
It's not the engine that needs to be reverse engineered. It's the balance and legitimacy. If you offload all the RNG and cause equipment to be controlled by a central entity, then it becomes both opaque and a single-point-of-failure. People know EVERYTHING about Diablo 2 drops, because you have the machine logic right there. Not true about, say, World of Warcraft, where people know a lot of macro statistics about drop rates and so on through crowd-sourced data gathering, but they don't know a lot of things, like boss pathing rules and event scripting.

Running a private server for a MMO has a ton of fundamental barriers. 1) Players don't get timely balance updates. 2) Players have no confidence that admins won't hack/give away items/cause crazy events etc. (Central point of authority = central point of corruption. Even if there don't happen to be any game-breakingly generous admins on a server, you can't signal that reliably to potential players.) 3) Servers may disappear. Since info is central, but private servers may fold under takedown notices, owners running out of money, technical problems, lack of other players, or anything else, players can't have trust that their time spent will have lasting rewards. Credibility is almost impossible to build.

Basically, by making games reliant on a central authority, you force the element of trust and credibility into the picture. Usually the only server with any credibility is the one run by the game company itself, since ideally you can trust that their actions will be in the best long-term interests of their game and audience. (EA in particular lost that trust a long time ago, I haven't bought a game of theirs in a LONG time. But Valve, or Blizzard, and even Ubisoft to a lesser extent still have that credibility.)

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by networked on Thursday March 07, 2013 @10:38PM (#5341964)
I've got to point out that my previous remark about a LinCity-NG back end was made half-jokingly and now that I've noticed that's not really obvious it's too late to go back and edit the comment. The difference between how your city is represented in SimCity 2000, 3000 and 4, on which LinCity-NG is based, and the new SimCity is quite profound and I thought I'd explain it further.

First, the new layout engine finally allows you to construct roads at arbitrary angles and not just along the axes. This makes it fundamentally incompatible with the old grid-based map format used in SimCity since version one with few alternations [1]. Then there's the agent model of economics [2], a change from previous games' broad statistical model, that seems to be deeply integrated with the game's visualization.

[1] The biggest change was likely the introduction of varying terrain height in SimCity 2000.

[2] The developers give a brief explanation in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tz-UGPRilUE. Looks like they've done some pretty interesting things with it.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by ececconi on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:04PM (#5340237)
How much of D3's processing is done offloaded? Are there any articles online that I could read about this?
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by flixic on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:13PM (#5340308)
Map generation, some enemy AI, and most frustratingly: combat action outcomes.

My story was the same as numerous other players: started playing hardcore, died not because of a mistake, but because of lag (internet lagged for a few seconds, that was enough for monsters to kill me, when internet came back moments later I was told I died).

At that moment I decided not give ANY more money to Blizzard, and closed my WoW membership.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by vyrotek on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:08PM (#5340267)
Originally they told us quite a bit of logic was done on their servers. But then they announced that Diablo 3 would be playable offline on the PlayStation 4. Now I don't know what to believe. Could it be it was all just talk to stop us from trying?
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by gambiting on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:44PM (#5340500)
No, item drops are actually done on a server, to guarantee fair drops for everyone(you can sell them for real money, so you would rather make sure nobody just adds an item worth $$$ to their inventory). PS4 won't be connected to the Auction House, so most likely it will include just its own, internal version of the server that will generate item drops.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by reitzensteinm on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:22PM (#5340355)
The servers are almost certainly running from the same source base as the client. Swapping out who-does-what, compared to a console port, is trivial.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by signed0 on Thursday March 07, 2013 @04:23PM (#5340367)
Or that the PS4 version is the first variant that has enough functionality built in for it to be playable offline.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by querulous on Thursday March 07, 2013 @06:10PM (#5341025)
they're probably just running the server code on the ps4 alongside the client. it's easier to secure there
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by cdi on Friday March 08, 2013 @04:35AM (#5342661)
>effectively impossible to crack.

hack into their servers, steal binaries of game server, modify client to work with local server.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by betterunix on Thursday March 07, 2013 @07:13PM (#5341312)
"With enough processing offloaded to the server, would-be pirates need to write something that's almost a whole new game."

Sure, and with sufficient bandwidth and computational power you could actually hide all the game logic using a secure computation protocol. Only a complete idiot would do that for something as performance-intensive as a video game.

The problem here is that we do not have reliable or fast Internet connections. As soon as your connection has a burp, or you get hit with some bufferbloat, or half your neighborhood starts streaming the Super Bowl in 1080p, your game starts to play worse. What EA failed to realize here is that the best way to make money in games is to offer a superior online gaming platform, not to try to sell individual games as products. Microsoft figured that out with XBox Live a long time ago.

Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by cryptoz on Thursday March 07, 2013 @03:53PM (#5340162)
I meant no 'gameplay' reason - I know that they have a financial reason to do this, or that they think they do, at least. If they lose enough sales and get enough hate, that removes even the financial reason that they thought they had for doing this. So perhaps, hopefully, maybe, they'll choose to stop doing it.
Re:Amazon stops selling Sim City V over game issues by scotty79 on Friday March 08, 2013 @12:01AM (#5342153)
Then when company goes belly up games die. Like Hellgate London multiplayer.