News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by flexie on Monday March 04, 2013 @03:12AM (#5317235)
tl;dr Danish:

Microsoft bought the Danish Navision Software (that made accounting software, now called Dynamics NAV) for roughly 10.8 billion kroner in 2002. Shortly thereafter, Microsoft sold the rights to the software to Microsoft's Irish subsidiary at a price which the Danish tax authorities think is too low. The Danish tax authorities now claims taxes amounting to 5.8 billion kroner from Microsoft based on the price they think would have been right.

It's a classical transfer pricing case.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by bfwi on Monday March 04, 2013 @03:29AM (#5317279)
The article also states that the irish subsidiary is owned by companies in Bermuda and British virgin islands, which is where the profits go.

Is it easy for Microsoft to get this money back into the US? And how?

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by vellum on Monday March 04, 2013 @05:21AM (#5317579)
They could wait around for a tax-repatriation holiday. There was one in 2004 that brought in about $312 billion. Companies paid 5% tax, instead of 35%, on all foreign revenue brought back to the states.

The theory was that companies would use that money to create jobs, but instead they bought back a lot of stock. So it's unlikely that there will be another one in the near future, unless the political winds change.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230333990457640...

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by jacquesm on Monday March 04, 2013 @05:49AM (#5317626)
What they should do instead of a holiday is simply seize assets statesside with rouhgly the same bookvalue until the money was brought in and taxed in the normal way.

That would close this loophole pdq. All this pussyfooting around just underscores that private individuals are on the hook but as a company you can do just about anything.

I don't like taxes, I disagree with plenty of them, I disagree with how they are spent. But I still pay my taxes and the fact that I pay more tax on my income (which is a very small fraction of their turn-over) than some well known multi-nationals has me seriously ticked off.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by adventured on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:15AM (#5317691)
No they shouldn't seize anything. That overseas money is not owed to the US Government and does not belong to the US Government. Taxes are only owed if you repatriate it. You're advocating theft as it is.

It's not a loophole, it would be double taxation.

If Microsoft earns $10 billion in China, they should pay taxes to China on that, not pay China + the US Government. Unless you're advocating confiscatory level taxation, of perhaps 60% to 70% on corporate profits.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by jacquesm on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:34AM (#5317731)
Microsoft never earned $10 billion in China, they sold $10 billion worth of goods to an overseas entity using a tax avoidance scheme. Different thing.

I understand that parent/daughter company relationships are hard but the only thing that matters is who holds the final holdings shares. Everything else is just window dressing and obfuscation.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by outside1234 on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:08PM (#5319157)
So by your argument, when we purchase a physical book, we should pay taxes in every locality that that book passed through.

So let's say it was manufactured in Florida, shipped from New York, and sold in California, by your logic we should be paying state taxes in Florida, New York, and California.

Is that right?

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by will_brown on Monday March 04, 2013 @01:20PM (#5319579)
>So let's say it was manufactured in Florida, shipped from New York, and sold in California, by your logic we should be paying state taxes in Florida, New York, and California.

I do not think that is an accurate example of what occurred in the article.

1. MS bought a Danish Company, (This is a taxable transaction), 2. MS then sold the assets (software) of the Danish Company to an MS subsidiary in Ireland, (This is a 2nd taxable transaction, but this is where MS "allegedly" sold the Danish Company asset at a price far below the market value effectively cheating Denmark out of taxes it would receive had the Danish Company sold its asset to an independent company)

Nevermind the obvious reasons "Why" MS engaged in the second transaction, MS is paying less taxes on the asset selling it from Ireland than in Denmark.

So to change your hypothetical to more accurately reflect the article - It is more like manufacturing a book in Florida, selling it to your own company in NY, who in turn sells it to someone in Florida just to avoid charging FL Sales tax which would need to be charged by a Florida company selling to a Florida resident. Of course at first glance this seems like a smart business move, but assuming the legal analysis of the article is true, then also imagine in your hypothetical there is a law prohibiting this type of transaction to its own subsidiaries in other states to prevent the circumvention of State sales tax.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by vajrabum on Monday March 04, 2013 @01:17PM (#5319554)
A book is exactly the wrong sort of example because publishers don't generally own the rights to the book, authors do. So the argument is that if I own, manufacture, and distribute a product or service that I shouldn't be able to dodge paying taxes on it by establishing a wholly owned sham company off shore and transferring the "ownership" of some product to that sham entity and then assign all the profit to that entity thereby making it a "foreign profit" which is only taxed when repatriated. Apparently, this is going on not only with products sold outside the US but also products that never left the country. It has nothing to do with double taxation.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by Cushman on Monday March 04, 2013 @01:09PM (#5319484)
Sounds right to me. The manufacturer will pay tax in Florida, the shipping company will pay tax in New York, and the retailer will pay tax in California— all those taxes get sent down the line to me. If any of these entities are legally based out of somewhere else, I would expect them to pay tax there in addition. If the shipping company and the retailer are owned by the same entity, and they said that their revenue from shipping was $0 so they don't owe New York any tax, I'd expect New York to take a different view.

If I live in Massachusetts and earn money in New York, both states expect me to pay income tax.[0] And why shouldn't they? I'm using both of their resources.

[0] The amount paid to NY is deducted from the MA tax, down to 0. That might be different elsewhere?

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by gadders on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:09AM (#5317675)
Nah, what should happen is that governments lower their extortionate tax rates so that these avoidance measures aren't neccessary.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by wavefunction on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:56AM (#5317791)
The Laffer curve has never been shown to be true, and in fact has always been shown to be false in the real world.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by davidw on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:27AM (#5317861)
So... if it's "not true", what sort of curve would you get if you plot government revenue as a function of tax rates? The Laffer curve makes a lot of sense. What is difficult about it, and where politicians are likely to try and push their own agenda, is finding where revenues are maximized, which is a far more difficult proposition than proposing that there is a revenue curve with a high point somewhere in the middle, which makes intuitive sense.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by lukasLansky on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:51AM (#5317923)
Well, you do not get a curve, and there is no maximum.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hysteresis

Same taxes with different history of taxation yield wildly different results.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by sbmassey on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:28PM (#5319276)
It would form a curve for a given state at a given time period. Obviously you wouldn't get the exact same curve for different states and times.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by gadders on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:37AM (#5317883)
It's self-evidently true as a concept, even if the exact shape of the curve and the values aren't known.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by ubernostrum on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:56AM (#5317942)
"Taxes shouldn't be too high, and shouldn't be too low" is about the most precise statement anyone can make about the Laffer curve and still be able to have it hold up in the face of the real world.

Pardon me if I'm not bowled over by that.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by gadders on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:29AM (#5318056)
Well, given that plenty of governments seem to think taxation can be increased indefitely in order to support their "client state" of government employees, I'd say that was a valuable result.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by vidarh on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:59AM (#5318179)
If "plenty of governments" believed that, I'd expect to see far higher tax rates.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by jeltz on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:42AM (#5318106)
Since we have no clue about the shape of the curve apart from the two extremes it is a quite useless tool.

EDIT: According to the Wikipedia page some studies indicate that the maximum for the laffer curve in Sweden was about 70% tax.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by twoodfin on Monday March 04, 2013 @11:52AM (#5319062)
That's a believable number. But I also imagine that the curve flattens considerably before topping out: Sweden probably wouldn't get a lot of additional revenue out of that last 5-10% in tax rates. If you were picking the "right" level of taxation, you'd presumably want it to set it somewhere near the point where the economic cost of the taxes was equal to the benefits of the government's use of the revenue, and not at the point of maximum revenue.

A 70% marginal rate is not outrageously far from where the top bracket in California will be if Washington decides the best Social Security reform includes lifting the payroll tax cap. Today's effective top marginal rate in CA is ~52% in Fed+State income taxes and another 3.8% for the high-earner Medicare tax. If SS goes uncapped, adding another 12.4%, your $1M earner is hitting 68.2%. I'm dispensing with the accounting fantasy that the "employer-paid" portion of the tax isn't actually a tax on the worker.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by Silhouette on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:51PM (#5319385)
According to the Wikipedia page some studies indicate that the maximum for the laffer curve in Sweden was about 70% tax.

On the other hand, the introduction of a 50% income tax rate in the UK didn't work very well[1]. It caused more than £10B of income to be shifted to an earlier year, and in the end raised only a modest fraction of the predicted extra tax revenues. It looks like a few people in government failed to notice that almost everyone who has enough income to pay that kind of tax rate in the first place also has the ability to choose when they formally realize that income, and many of the wealthiest also have the ability to choose where they formally receive the income as well.

[1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-17465733

The newish top tax rate here is coming down to 45% in April 2013, after the new government finished figuring out how much of a poison chalice they had been left by the previous one. Unfortunately, this causes problems of its own, as they are now predicting a multi-billion pound shortfall in tax revenues for 2012-2013 as wealthy folk do the opposite and defer their income to take advantage of the reduced rate. Obviously they're hoping that greater tax revenues in later years will make up for that.

Worse than these individual disruptions over a relatively short period, though, is the fact that successive governments have made it very clear that they can and will mess around significantly with tax rates for high earners, which in turn creates an incentive for any big earner to talk to tax experts and either take part in legal tax avoidance schemes or at least minimise how much income they wind up with on paper in any given year until they're convinced that it's the most tax-efficient time for a while to take it and then grab the lot at (what they hope will be) a minimum rate.

At least we're not in France, where the government seem to think they can slap a 75% tax rate on the wealthy and not suffer horrendous consequences to their already business-hostile economic and political landscape...

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by sgift on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:30AM (#5317867)
Even if the Laffer curve is true (see the comment by wavefunction) no one knows where the maximum revenue point is. Look at "Empirical data" in the Wikipedia article: There are many possible values for "optimal tax rate" and companies have many options to play the system, e.g. always hold back enough money that there is justification for a lower tax rate.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by gadders on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:46AM (#5317908)
No, nobody knows what the exact shape of the curve is, but governments should bear in mind when screwing more cash out of companies and people in order to fund pork barrell projects.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by Cushman on Monday March 04, 2013 @01:20PM (#5319583)
It takes a certain perspective to look at the world today and say that governments are screwing cash out of companies.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by gadders on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @04:20AM (#5323689)
Starbucks, Google, Amazon - not so much.

"Mom and Pop" restaurants, mechanics, cleaning companies, etc etc - yep./

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by vajrabum on Monday March 04, 2013 @01:20PM (#5319576)
Given that company's minimize their tax liability any amount of tax over zero is going to be enough to induce them to such shenanigans.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by cpursley on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:56AM (#5317790)
Companies don't pay taxes even if they do. Their customers do through increased pricing.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by eurleif on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:01AM (#5317804)
Individuals don't pay taxes even if they do. The companies they buy from do through reduced sales.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by Retric on Monday March 04, 2013 @10:02AM (#5318472)
You mean cost 1.8 trillion? At some point shareholders want here money back so companies have little choice in the long term. Until then it's reasonable to keep an offshore buffer which they refill after a tax holiday.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by prostoalex on Monday March 04, 2013 @04:15AM (#5317406)
Unless it's immediately distributed as dividend or used for acquisition, the money would be subject to US corporate taxes.

Microsoft actually borrows in the US http://www.smartmoney.com/invest/bonds/what-s-behind-microso... as it's not in shareholders' best interests to initiate a money transfer to a US account.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by drucken on Monday March 04, 2013 @03:55AM (#5317343)
If you mean the cash, why would they need to get these funds back?

Earnings are posted from the group. Credit lines and capital market borrowing similarly have limited ties to jurisdiction. Regulatory filings can be arranged to not post detailed transfer pricing information.

If they ever want to pay a dividend, the cash they have on hand for on-going concerns should more than cover it. Where it does not, they can have it "loaned" from the foreign subsidiaries and gain even more tax efficiencies...

Otherwise, much of the time, they can just leave it in control of Bermudan and Irish accounts; at least, until debt-ridden, revenue-starved, middle-class squeezed Western governments start moaning a little too loudly and the tax accountants and lawyers prepare to roll out the next tax avoidance schemes down the closest tax haven rabbit holes!

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by lifeisstillgood on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:17AM (#5317839)
This is one that bothers me - UK government is chairing the G20 and is pushing "fixing international corporate taxation"

It's popular amoungst all the member nations, but there seems to be absolutely no clue what to actually do

If anyone has a suggestion there are a lot of people waiting to listen ?

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by vellum on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:02AM (#5317954)
>UK government is chairing the G20 and is pushing "fixing international corporate taxation"

That's rich, considering London is one of the biggest tax havens around.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2007/jul/08/tax.business1

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday March 05, 2013 @03:56AM (#5323627)
Every western government has off shore havens they give a nod and wink to - but it's this very prisoners dilemma that the G8 etc want to solve.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by Silhouette on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:57PM (#5319413)
Did you realise that the article you linked was from 2007?

I think it's safe to say that the political and economic landscape has changed a little since then.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by vellum on Monday March 04, 2013 @02:13PM (#5320067)
I looked around and they still have non-domicile rule. Since 2008, they added an annual £30,000 fee, but that's nothing if you're rich.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/world/london-is-a-magne... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_the_United_Kingdom1...

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by arethuza on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:21AM (#5317844)
Might be an idea for the UK to close down all of the offshore tax havens we control first before asking others to do the same....
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by eurleif on Monday March 04, 2013 @07:24AM (#5317855)
Seems like it might be kind of a prisoner's dilemma situation: the best outcome is if everyone shuts down their tax havens, but you're individually worse off if you shut down yours and the other players don't, so no one wants to do it.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by gadders on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:35AM (#5318078)
It's popular amongst the member governments. They're always after more money to waste.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by skywalk on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:22AM (#5318023)
classic double irish setup: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by subsystem on Monday March 04, 2013 @04:51AM (#5317506)
According to themselves they "spend it overseas".

http://www.winamericacampaign.org/

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by jobu on Monday March 04, 2013 @03:56AM (#5317347)
Much of it comes back as invesments in US businesses, real estate, and stock markets by these foreign subsidiaries. I don't think they're actually able to bring it back into the parent companies in the US, but with good accountants and lawyers it wouldn't surprise me.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by wilfra on Monday March 04, 2013 @05:24AM (#5317585)
Not without paying taxes on it. Companies like Apple, Facebook and Google have many billions of dollars in foreign banks which they aren't bringing back because they'd have to pay huge tax bills if they did. There has been a lot of pressure on the government for awhile to allow a 'holiday' where this money could be brought back tax-free temporarily, but nothing has happened yet.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by OGinparadise on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:11AM (#5317679)
Is it easy for Microsoft to get this money back into the US? And how?

Well, that's not something you want to do to Denmark, they are a member of EU and can make MS's life miserable. Plus, MS has so many assets, all over the world. They can contest it, appeal but then will pay.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by Charlesmigli on Monday March 04, 2013 @04:17AM (#5317416)
Thanks a lot for the traduction. This summary has been added to tldr.io, see here http://tldr.io/tldrs/5134660e28b6ae385b0000de/microsoft-owes...
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by pdovy on Monday March 04, 2013 @09:21AM (#5318272)
How is it that the initial (2002-2013 interest excluded) tax bill is 5 billion kroner, when the acquisition cost was only 10.8 billion kroner? Is the tax rate really that high? I understand that the tax is not on the acquisition itself but rather the transfer of the rights, but surely the market value of those rights should be less than the market value of the entire company at the same point in time.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by oellegaard on Monday March 04, 2013 @09:35AM (#5318349)
In Denmark the company taxation is 25%, but it is very likely that a large part of the amount is a fine for doing it, although this is just a guess.

Furthermore, when you value a company it could be that their assets are extremely high, but they at the same time have high liabilites. This (although I do not know if it was the case), could lead to a lower price for the company, than the market value of the product.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by jonascopenhagen on Monday March 04, 2013 @10:26AM (#5318608)
> In Denmark the company taxation is 25%

Soon to be 22%.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by tanzam75 on Monday March 04, 2013 @03:45PM (#5320784)
Google Translate says that Microsoft underpriced Navision software by 11 billion kroner in the "previous income year," and owes 5.8 billion kroner in taxes on that!? That sounds like an income tax dispute on annual earnings.

I don't understand Danish, I can't figure this out.

The thing is, it's unlikely that Microsoft managed to underreport 11 billion kroner in profits. From what I've read, Navision showed only modest growth, just one in a series of multibillion-dollar acquisitions by Microsoft that failed to work out.

Until 2006, Navision was part of Microsoft Business Solutions, which was a breakeven operation at best. The homegrown CRM product exploded in popularity, while the acquired ERP products stagnated. Since CRM is wildly profitable, the only way for Business Solutions to have operated at breakeven was for the ERP products to lose money.

Given the poor historical performance, it would take quite the turnaround for Microsoft to have made 11 billion kroner = $1.92 billion on Navision in 2012.

I wonder if the Danish tax authority is attempting to apply Microsoft's overall profit margin to calculate a transfer price for Navision? That would really add insult to injury when it comes to Microsoft's sorry history of acquisitions.

Sources:

(1) "... their market share in their CRM software has increased but their share in ERP has decreased." http://www.technoreporter.com/technology/software/microsoft-...

(2) "Contrary to the downward trend for its four enterprise resource planning (ERP) brethren, the Microsoft Dynamics CRM product (although still only a fraction of the overall Dynamics revenue) grew significantly in revenue year over year and surpassed the one-million-users mark in 2009." http://blog.technologyevaluation.com/blog/2010/02/15/microso...

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by mckoss on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:32PM (#5319297)
I think the article said $10 billion dollars - not kroner for the acquisition (or $60 billion kroner).

This sort of tax avoidance feel unethical to me - you have 600 employees in Denmark developing this software, but all the profits are being booked in a tax haven. Microsoft should have to move the developers to Bermuda or Ireland if they want to avoid the Danish tax.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by raverbashing on Monday March 04, 2013 @05:01AM (#5317531)
For reference, 1 Danish Krone == 0.17 USD today
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by arethuza on Monday March 04, 2013 @04:39AM (#5317478)
They also made what is now Dynamics AX - which is Microsoft's high end ERP application.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by goggles99 on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:20AM (#5317702)
Wow, 5.8 billion on sale of what was originally a 10.8 billion purchase? That sounds steep.

This sound like a political trial though based on Denmark wanting to keep outsiders away from it's businesses and sour grapes Denmark has against MS because they moved the business to Ireland.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by jbri on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:23AM (#5317709)
"Moved the business to Ireland" doesn't (usually) mean that business has actually moved - operating as a subsidiary of a holding company in Ireland is almost always a pure tax dodge.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by fleitz on Monday March 04, 2013 @12:22PM (#5319232)
I find it ironic that the avoidance scheme MS, GOOG, and APPL employ for European profits is called a double dutch irish sandwich.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by flexie on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:57AM (#5317793)
Granted it sounds high, given that the corporate tax rate was 30 percent 10 years ago. I truly don't believe it's politically motivated, though. I could say a lot of bad things about the Danish tax system, and I do so all the time, but the Danish tax authorities are not known to be corrupt. It might be due to subsequent transactions that the article doesn't mention. Also, since the limitation period is around 5 years in this type of cases, the case may have been going on for several years. It's not possible to say from the article.
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by loeg on Monday March 04, 2013 @06:48AM (#5317770)
I think the 5.8 billion may include late-payment surcharges, given that this happened in 2002 (11 years is a lot of interest).
Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by kmfrk on Monday March 04, 2013 @09:45AM (#5318394)
You need to adjust for inflation for one.

$1,000 in 2002 correspond to $1,280 in 2013 (+28%) as an example.

You are comparing 5.8 billion 2013-kroner with 10.8 billion 2002-kroner.

Re:Microsoft owes Denmark $1B in taxes by belorn on Monday March 04, 2013 @08:39AM (#5318093)
We do not know what the number is based on, as the article do not say so. It might be that the company sale is declared invalid, and any product sales made afterward is thus under danish law. Or it could be taxes of the 10.8 billion purchase but with an increased cost thanks to it now being several year later.