News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by Shenglong on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:28AM (#5144070)
Just to give some numbers to this, for anyone wondering:

In 2012, Amazon made $631 million profit on over $48 billion revenue - meaning they converted a little over 1% into profit. Meanwhile, almost every other comparable company had close to 20x that. Google made about $11 billion on $48 billion, and Apple made $41 billion on $156 billion. From a purely financial perspective, it really is insane.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by necubi on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:15AM (#5144164)
You really can't compare profit margins between a retailer and a software company. Amazon books the full price of the products it sells as revenue, but must pay most of that to its suppliers, whereas the marginal cost of most of Google's products is very near 0.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by brisance on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:42AM (#5144227)
Fair enough, but even then, AMZN is doing worse than Wal-Mart.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by arethuza on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:48AM (#5144898)
I was surprised to read that Wal-Mart has had some fairly large failures in some markets - notably Germany where they gave up and lost £3 billion.

Is there any country where Amazon has tried and failed to compete?

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by suby on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:31AM (#5144840)
Walmart has to compete with whatever local stores are in your area. Amazon has to compete with every other website that sells things on the 'net.

Plus I'm under the impression that Amazon is investing more into growth at the moment than Walmart is.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by npsimons on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:18AM (#5145327)
Prime is really a killer feature. I'll find myself ordering things I never would have dreamed of buying online, or possibly at all (because I didn't know it existed). And this from someone who balked when Amazon first started selling things besides books!. Living in a small town might be a factor in this, however.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by smackfu on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:53AM (#5145512)
If you look at 3Q numbers, AMZN had 27% revenue growth, while Walmart had 4%. That's a huge difference.

(Walmart didn't announce 4Q numbers yet.)

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by laluser on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:01AM (#5144143)
You're missing the point here. Google's main business, selling ads, and Amazon's current main business, online retail, are two completely different markets. You're essentially comparing apples to oranges. The margins are lower in the space that Amazon is competing in, it doesn't make sense to compare two completely different companies.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by w0utert on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:19AM (#5144180)
Sure the margins are lower in online retail, but even then Amazon is performing abysmally, and the trend in almost all their numbers is downwards. The only reason they are still around in the first place, is sheer size. Smaller retailers would never survive on the profit margins Amazon is producing.

The thing that sticks out most from their earnings release is that the trend is clearly downward. The profit margins and net cash flow are sinking, while operating costs, number of employees, etc are rising. Added to that, their market cap/stock valuation is truly insane, which IMO is a ticking time bomb.

What this all means is that Amazon is going to get in a shitload of trouble somewhere down the road. Remember that they only made about $5 billion in profit over their complete lifetime, of which only about $1.5 billion is left after deducting losses, so in terms of cash Amazon is more or less on life support of their investors. All it takes is some relatively minor event (more focused competition, lower consumer spending, some kind of bad media attention) and their stock will tank, and the whole constellation could go down like a house of cards.

No matter how much you like Amazon and its services, it's hardly an example of a solid business if you ask me.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by zaidf on Thursday January 31, 2013 @06:43AM (#5144519)
All it takes is some relatively minor event (more focused competition, lower consumer spending, some kind of bad media attention) and their stock will tank, and the whole constellation could go down like a house of cards.

So if all it will take is a relatively minor event, why hasn't it already happened yet for a company that has been around over 15 years?

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by w0utert on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:55AM (#5144942)
I'd say 'because the market still has confidence in Amazon', which is reflected by their market cap. While market cap has no relation whatsoever to the profitability of a company, it does allow Amazon to keep investing in expanding into all the directions they are expanding in. At current valuations, they only have to add ~5M shares (on a current total of ~450M outstanding) to raise around ~$1B. This is not a free ride though, they _will_ have to be able to jack up their profits somewhere in the future, otherwise the stock will sink and they will have a hard time to keep up their strategy of expansion.

I'm quite surprised they have been able to keep up this game for so long myself, but it's not totally crazy. Online shopping is has been growing like crazy for since Amazon started, the market today is probably at least a 100 times larger than ~10 years ago. Some day though, growth will start to level off, and looking at Amazon's earnings releases over the last 2 years or so, it seems like we're almost there. It's going to be very interesting to see what happens to Amazon when they cannot keep growing any bigger.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by zaidf on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:17PM (#5147528)
I guess I don't see your implied meaning of "relatively minor." If the market has had confidence in amazon for so many years, then wouldn't any event that causes them to lose confidence be considered the opposite of minor?
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by Evbn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @12:27PM (#5146056)
Stock price has 0 effect on the sustainability of Amazon as a business.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by Retric on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:42AM (#5144228)
What your missing is they don't pre pay for there inventory. So while revenue vs profit might make it seem like they would quickly get into trouble a 10% drop in retail sales with far less issues than a software company operating on 1% margins.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by w0utert on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:57AM (#5144258)
They might not pre-pay for the inventory, but they still have fixed costs, and they are rising, they have over 50k employees now. They _need_ to sell at huge volumes with the profit margins they are taking, otherwise they will bleed money. Some day, the fairy tale of 3000+ P/E and years of making next to no profits or even losses will be over and the stock will tank. Amazon will have a huge problem attracting funding to cover their fixed costs, they will have to fire lots and lots of employees at the expense of service and marketshare, and basically show us what the .com bubble 2.0 looks like.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by pestaa on Thursday January 31, 2013 @05:55AM (#5144394)
This prediction is insightful, but still just a prediction. However, if you state it like it's going to happen tomorrow, it is also spreading FUD.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by logn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:34AM (#5144085)
1% margins are about normal for grocery stores... just to put this perspective in perspective :)
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by anu_gupta on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:41AM (#5144103)
Amazon's Price/Earnings ratio is a quite staggering 3897.

Wal-Mart's PE ratio is 14.38. Safeway's is 9.25, Apple's is 10.35.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by logn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:58AM (#5144138)
Yet their Enterprise Value/Revenue is ~2 and Google's is ~4 and Walmart's ~2/3 (.6). Ent Value is sort of the total investment/borrowing/valuation minus cash. So Amazon does more in sales vs their company's leverage compared to Google and worse compared to Walmart.

EV/EBITDA is ~53 vs. Walmart's ~8 vs. Google's ~13. EBITDA is basically earnings but more complex ("earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, and amortization").

From what I've read there's concern Amazon is overvalued, but not what the Slate article portrays as them being some charity case, being invested in by people with ulterior motives to keep consumer prices low (I have no idea if that was even a sarcastic point or not. It's a terrible article).

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by kerno on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:15AM (#5144593)
It's pretty clearly a sarcastic point. The main thrust of the article is that Amazon appears to be given special treatment by Wall Street analysts and the investment community - everyone is banking on them being able to produce massive profits as a result of their relentless focus on growth at any cost. They can produce a loss for the quarter and have their share price rise significantly - other companies don't have the same luxury.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by Evbn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:44AM (#5145458)
Every growing company has the luxury.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by kerno on Thursday January 31, 2013 @05:35PM (#5147937)
At a Price/Earnings of 3,160.71, that is a lot of luxury.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by treeface on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:49AM (#5144124)
Which tells you how meaningful the P/E ratio is when analyzed independently.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by marvin on Thursday January 31, 2013 @05:45AM (#5144373)
At some point it needs to come down though, one way or another. Not many are going to invest in a company which is guaranteed to have a P/E of > 200 indefinitely. This would mean a very low return on investment.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by dhimes on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:01AM (#5144727)
From a practical point of view, who cares? Unless they are selling their stock to raise revenue it matters not (to them) if people are willing to "invest in" their company.

Now their investors may care, and there may be board fights and so on, but if Bezos can control that then he has some leeway to build the company he wants. It's pretty impressive, really.

And it's very intriguing what's going on in Cambridge (MA). A lot of hiring and work and what-not yet nobody seems to know what they are doing.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by Evbn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:46AM (#5145470)
Investors can't care. If they cared, the stock price would drop and take P/E with it. It fixes itself
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by maerek on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:53AM (#5145221)
That's not the correct way to analyze P/E. Looking at that number in a vacuum is nigh on meaningless. P/E is best analyzed as a relative measure within a given market (in this case, online retailers w/ no brick and mortar presence).

That said, there are exceptions to every rule. I'm not aware of any other companies that currently exhibit such a high P/E.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by marvin on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:52AM (#5145504)
What am I getting wrong, exactly? If a company is going to be a good long-term investment based on fundamentals, it needs to have a sensible P/E ratio. There are exceptions for companies that are growing or have a high probability of having higher earnings in the future. And of course a stock can make very big price movements with no change in fundamentals.

But in a long perspective, there needs to be a small ratio between what you paid for the stock and what the company earns if it is going to be a good investment. FYI I am heavily invested in Tesla Motors, which currently has an undefined/negative P/E ratio.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by maerek on Thursday January 31, 2013 @02:31PM (#5146840)
I don't disagree on seeking a sensible P/E ratio. I'm stating that in order to determine what qualifies as a sensible P/E ratio, you need to look at the industry/market the company operates in.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by _k on Thursday January 31, 2013 @11:24AM (#5145692)
Amazon is a category killer just like Wal-Mart is and if their PE ratio is 14.38, then Amazon's P/E ratio should be in that area as well. In order to avoid being placed in that category, you have to do some disruptive things. It's similar to what most web based companies do, they try to shoot for the stars and keep that momentum going. I think that explains the high P/E.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by smackfu on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:51AM (#5144917)
The numbers were silly three months ago too, but AMZN was a much better investment since then than AAPL.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by sliverstorm on Thursday January 31, 2013 @05:14AM (#5144293)
Aside from the other things that have been pointed out, IMO Amazon is still trying to grow aggressively. Most "comparable" companies have settled in to a market and an operating model. Even Google simply seems to "explore" new territory, instead of pursuing it.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by vinhboy on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:35AM (#5144089)
From a glass half full perspective. You can argue that Amazon is keeping profits in check so they can continue to offer their customers the best prices and services. But that's if you live in a world where bears fart butterflies.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by mkuhn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:40AM (#5144097)
Actually you could rather say that Amazon is reinvesting its profits to strengthen its position and reap the benefits in the future.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by simonh on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:24AM (#5144190)
How far into the future? They've been saying that for 17 years.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by muyuu on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:44AM (#5144236)
Except now they have profits and they had losses in the late 90s.

They are still expanding to new countries. Last year, for instance, they opened amazon.es and amazon.com.br which are significant markets.

I don't see what's the point in comparing revenue to profit ratios in wildly different sectors.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by simonh on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:02AM (#5144979)
>I don't see what's the point in comparing revenue to profit ratios in wildly different sectors.

That's fair, I don't buy the comparisons of Amazon with Google, Microsoft, etc either. It's also true that P/E ration can be misleading, for example even a healthy company might book a loss, or small profit from time to time for all sorts of reasons.

The problem with Amazon is that their current share price is around $250. For that to make sense, you need to believe that their earnings will rise so that this becomes a good deal. To achieve a P/E ratio of say 20 (still too high for a retailer), their earnings would need to go up about 150x. How are Amazon going to become hundreds of times more profitable than they are now?

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by darrhiggs on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:23AM (#5144614)
Is amazon.es for latin america? AFAIK .es is España, and although it's ≈45MM, it's hardly a massive market WRT latin america.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by lemma on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:12AM (#5144768)
No, it looks like it's targeted to Spain (which would make sense as far as logistics beacause they already have sites for France, Germany, Italy, and the UK).
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by muyuu on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:33AM (#5145391)
Latin America is not a single market for retail. Spain is the biggest single Spanish-speaking market for consumer products, although Mexico is growing fast.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by danieldisu on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:05AM (#5144742)
significant != massive
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by arrrg on Thursday January 31, 2013 @05:58AM (#5144400)
So, their plan is to obliterate all other retailers (I guess online and otherwise) and then to jack up prices?

From a normative perspective that honestly seems quite evil. I guess then I can be happy it hasn’t happened yet.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by yummyfajitas on Thursday January 31, 2013 @06:26AM (#5144481)
So, their plan is to obliterate all other retailers (I guess online and otherwise) and then to jack up prices?

Probably not. Historically, this has rarely worked. Once they jack up their prices, it isn't that hard for competitors to sprout up.

Amazon will have to follow the walmart model - obliterate all other retailers and keep prices low forever.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by ippisl on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:20AM (#5145075)
I think wall-mart , did,in some areas, jack up the prices after killing their main street competitors.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by 7952 on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:20AM (#5144607)
The trend is actually towards becoming a platform through Amazon Marketplace. This may be bad for the market in general, but can hardly be considered obliteration.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by crdoconnor on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:01AM (#5144141)
Also, keeping your profit margins thinner even when you don't have to gives you extra insulation from competitors.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by Evbn on Thursday January 31, 2013 @12:25PM (#5146048)
That'slleaving money on the table. Keeping margins high gives you room and bank to go lower when needed.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by btilly on Thursday January 31, 2013 @05:28AM (#5144328)
it is only insane if you do not understand how Amazon makes money.

If a retailer wants to double its revenue, there are two basic options. Double your margins. Or double your volume by cutting the time you hold inventory in half. Amazon has aggressively gone for the second approach, and is glad to cut its margin in half in return for tripling sales.

Your "comparable companies" are not in the consumer retail business. And if they tried to maintain their margins while competing head on with brick and mortar commodity retail stores, they'd go out of business.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by smackfu on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:56AM (#5145528)
Apple has also gone for the first option:

* Kindle books (especially self-published ones) should have better margins than real books. Kindle grew 70% YoY while real books only grew 5%.

* A growing chunk of their revenue is from AWS, and software-as-a-service certainly has higher margins than mail order.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by ndonnellan on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:03AM (#5144981)
What happens when states more rigorously enforce sales tax collection? Margin-be-gone?
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by ksherlock on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:28AM (#5145362)
Amazon would collect the sales tax from the consumer and remit it to the state. It has no effect on margin.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by rob08 on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:44AM (#5145456)
other than the increased cost may deter some customers
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by martinced on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:07AM (#5144750)
"If a retailer wants to double its revenue, there are two basic options. Double your margins. Or double your volume by cutting the time you hold inventory in half."

So there's an unlimited amount of buyers willing to buy and every time you cut the time you hold the inventory in half people shall buy twice as much?

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by btilly on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:53PM (#5147393)
If you take shipments in fixed sized lots, every time you double your sales rate, you've cut how long you have to hold each item in half.

Furthermore it gets better. Frequently if you have good credit, you can take a shipment, sell it, and then pay later. This gives you float that you can use for things like paying the overhead of keeping unpopular items in stock. (Remember, Amazon makes substantial money both from having things that are hard to find elsewhere, and by selling commodity items in bulk.)

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by suby on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:35AM (#5144857)
I think they cut the time inventory is held in half by charging less and not making as much per sale, but making it up by moving more inventory.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by mcherm on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:12AM (#5144764)
I just want to point out that it's not 1% of ten million dollars, it's not 1% of a Billion dollars, it's 1% of FIFTY BILLION DOLLARS!

Amazon is investing in growth right now. That's why their profits are so low. Normally, one might think that a company of Amazon's age and size ought to be through the growth stage by now, and in fact it is TRUE: Amazon has finished dominating the book industry, and really has no more room to grow.

Except that they found new markets and moved beyond books. Now they are a universal retailer of anything that can be sold on the internet. But that market (although not fully saturated yet) still isn't big enough for them, so they've also moved into making tablets for the masses. And into running server farms for the entire world. As long as they keep knocking over new markets at this rate, they don't need to show much profit.

[DISCLOSURE: I do not own Amazon stock, primarily because I think it is overpriced. So I suppose I don't completely disagree with the parent post.]

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by cube13 on Thursday January 31, 2013 @10:48AM (#5145489)
Just FYI, the $631 million number is for 2011, not 2012.

http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=AMZN&annual

2012 appears that it's going to be a net loss, because of their horrible Q3 numbers.

http://finance.yahoo.com/q/is?s=AMZN

If I were an investor in Amazon, I would definitely be worried at this point. Even though revenue is up sharply, Amazon doesn't appear to be making a consistent profit at all-their net income was down 50% from 2010 in 2011, even though they had a ~33% increase in revenue.

Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by _k on Thursday January 31, 2013 @11:09AM (#5145599)
If I'm not mistaken, they do have 5 billion in cash and cash equivalents. ( I don't know where that came from, equity or net income in the previous years ? ) So they can keep this going for 18 more years. And then they can start selling their offices.
Re:Amazon Profits Fall 45 Percent, Still the Most Amazing Co... by batgaijin on Thursday January 31, 2013 @03:43AM (#5144108)
But isn't spending on infrastructure improvements cut into the reported profits?

Considering how much Amazon is spending to consistently update their infrastructure, I wouldn't be surprised.