When you get to situations like Fukushima or BP, this breaks down. The real economic cost of a nuclear disaster can stretch into the trillion dollar range when you factor in not just cleanup and direct compensation, but disruption of life.[1] A private company could never compensate the public for such costs, and as a result a private company has no incentive to exercise caution proportional to the risk weighted cost, but rather only an incentive to exercise care proportional to the risk weighted expected payout.
Of course the flip side of this is that the potential cost of disaster being so high blinds people to the fact that the probability of disaster is low. So the regulation tends towards more stifling than warranted.
[1] What's the real cost of something like Fukushima? Is it just the cost of cleanup? The cost of paying for destroyed houses? The cost of paying the families of people killed? It is partly that, but it's a lot more in fact. Consider: what would I have to pay you to get you to live in an emergency shelter for six months? Disaster payouts almost never compensate for cleanup and health bills much less for disruption to one's routine, but in economic terms it's a very real cost.
The PR: West denouncing nuclear and retiring nuclear capacity ahead of time -> flight of investment from nuclear -> replace with coal/peat/etc -> climate badness.
And the thorium folks, much as I love them, do themselves a disservice by not addressing the fuel cycle problem. If a uranium 'water' reactor leaks the radio-isotopes in the water decay rapidly, and are easily blocked by modest shielding. So that steam that escapes into the big containment dome? Well its radioactive initially but a couple of days later its not. This is not true is U233, a necessary byproduct of a thorium reactor fuel cell and present in the molten sodium leaks out. As sodium reacts violently with water, and molten sodium leak will cause an explosion and disperse highly dangerous, and difficult to shield U233 contaminated with U233 [1]
So when a thorium reactor does have a problem, it will be very serious very quickly. Not a lot of understanding on how to protect against that yet.
Radioactivity is dominated by short-lived fission products, not U-233/U-232 and company. U-232 is very radioactive, yes; but in a nuclear reactor, there exist vicious things far more radioactive than that. (Note that U-232 is a trace contaminant, but fission products are present in bulk amounts. U-232 is highlighted only because it's impossible to separate from U-233, a point of theoretical (and meaningless) debate involving nuclear weapons. Otherwise it's unimportant.)
My understanding of the danger in the thorium fuel cycle and the U232 specifically is the energy of its gamma radiation which is difficult to shield.
It's of no importance in nuclear reactors, because there there rest vastly greater amounts of vastly more radioactive monsters.
The reason people talk about U-232 is this confusing debate about nuclear weapons -- there's a weak (I think spurious) argument that thorium is weapons-resistant, because the U-232 gamma radiation makes it difficult to machine/work with weapons cores. It's really not relevant to molten-salt reactors.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remote_manipulator
[1] proof by photo: https://inlportal.inl.gov/portal/server.pt?open=514&objI...
Yes, that's right. That's why the "debate" is spurious.
By the way, much of the stuff released by Fukushima will remain radioactive for hundreds of years not days, having a half life of about 30 years. But the activity maps I've seen suggest that at least the older folk should be allowed back pretty much everywhere. Pregnant women and little children, maybe should stay out of the hottest of the "red zone" hot spots. But FUD will cause them to keep folk out of the yellow zones too. Needless.
i think the trick is to find an angle into the business that doesn't involve govt approval up front. some aspect of the problem that can be solved to show momentum, without hitting regulations. maybe the chemistry side of things?
I would think that the best path forward on this would be for the DOE to setup similar milestones w/ large cash rewards. Private companies compete on getting to those milestones with oversight by the appropriate regulatory bodies. Then once through the initial milestones the company could actually build a small scale reactor, make money on it, then build a large scale and really make some money.
Not saying it is going to happen, but that is MORE likely to happen than the DOE building this kind of reactor themselves.
The civilian nuclear industry has regulatory lead times measured in decades, and has a mindset heavily tied to the risks posed by solid-fueled reactors. For that reason, the military may in fact be the only opportunity for a company to develop liquid fueled reactors.
The 350 million dollar question is why the government has to be the sole source of funding. Obviously the cost is very high, the regulations are very intense, but where are the VCs willing to tackle this kind of "startup" (in reality it would likely be more of a public/private partnership). It's a longer view with higher cost but the payoff could be massive. Big innovation isn't going to happen if it requires congress to agree on supporting it for 10-20 years.