KitemanSA
KitemanSA on Hacker News
This statement is completely false. All _required_ aspects of fuel reprocessing have been demonstrated. And it has been demonstrated in two reactors with all three fissile fuels the LFTR cores are inherently stable. We have over two full-power years of experience with a LFTR core over a ~five year period
As several people have mentioned, you are confusing molten salt with liquid sodium. In a LFTR, the is no mechanism for driving the dispersal of the molten salt fuel. Therefore, no small particles and therefore the material is still in the hot cell where it is well shielded.
By the way, much of the stuff released by Fukushima will remain radioactive for hundreds of years not days, having a half life of about 30 years. But the activity maps I've seen suggest that at least the older folk should be allowed back pretty much everywhere. Pregnant women and little children, maybe should stay out of the hottest of the "red zone" hot spots. But FUD will cause them to keep folk out of the yellow zones too. Needless.
"What's the real cost of something like Fukushima?"
Maybe the better question is what will the purveyors of fear, uncertainty and doubt cause the price to be.
The cost will be negligible, at least compared to the local portion of the general quake and tsunami cost. But FUD will make the government do stupid things, like what they have already done regarding the allowable radioactivity level in food. Stupid, stupid, stupid. But that is the purveyor's purpose.
Nope, it is one of the main reasons why Thorium is not that great in typical solid fuel reactors. Lots of experience there. Processing the fuel to extract and use the U233 is rather a bothersome thing to do.
First, the government spent all that money for their own purposes. The design and construction of commercial Nuclear Power Plants has been on the user since day one. also, NPPs have been paying into a fund to handle Spent Nuclear Fuel. There is plenty of money to handle it, except that government can spend way more on anything than any rational person can imagine.
The fed gov has spent ~$16B on "renewable energy" recently. With 1/10th that money, LFTRs could have been coming off the assembly line at 100MW/day by now. And those plants could be eliminating that SNF as we speak.
Oops, make that for two full power years over a period of five years. It was after all an experiment.
Answer, yes it does. This was proven in the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment.
"Since the neutron flux in the reactor is the main variable which controls the power output it seems, that a Thorium reactor is significantly harder to control than a Uranium one." This is nonsense. LFTRs are self controlling with a significant negative coefficient. It really makes no more sense to think about putting Thorium in a solid fuel reactor than it does about using diesel in a spark ignition engine.
Which just means there will be a lot of free fuel available!
That initial charge can be the Trans-Uranics (TRUs) from spent nuclear fuel. That way we can transition into the Thorium Age while cleaning up after the Uranium Flirtation! ;)
This is only one of MANY good presentations by Sorenson and others on LFTRs and what we can do with them.
"Safety features of nuclear plants seem to dominate the cost. There are many claims about the inherent safety features of thorium Molten Salt Reactors. But those claims have yet to be proven in working prototypes." Actually, yes they have. The three main safety features have all been demonstrated.
First, the working fluid is non-volatile, no pressure nor chemical reactivity to drive dispersion of trapped gaseous fission products like Xenon and Iodine. Those were the two significant dispersed radionuclides in Fukushima.
Second, those same kind of radionuclides are removed from the salt continuously so there is not a store of them to BE dispersed.
Third, any loss of power to the reactor will passively result in a dump of the salt into a non-reactive tank where it will be passively cooled. It will be "walk away safe"!
"The Thorium fuel produces U232..." Yup, which is one of its nicest features. It means that the U233 is unlikely to be used for weapons. And since it never leaves the well shielded containment area in a LFTR, there is no hazard.
If the kettle is breached in the LFTR, the salt will probably just condense on any small break and seal it. If the break is large, the salt drains into a drain tank which is still in the shielded containment volume. No worries, mate! Oh, and since there is no significant pressure and no volatile chemicals like liquid sodium, there are no forces trying to disperse the materials. Inherently MUCH safer than any PWR or LMFR.
Scorecard
Uranium derived bombs extant ~20,000
Thorium derived bombs extant =ZERO.
The US & USSR would have been making Thorium derived weapons if it were practical. We DIDN'T. That should tell you something.
The answer, when compared to typical light water reactors is... A hell of a lot less.
First, since Thorium is a byproduct of Rare Earth Element mining and Uranium is mined specifically, there is all the mining waste that is saved.
Second, since Thorium is used up ~completely and Uranium is used only about 0.5%, you need about 200 times more raw Uranium metal than Thorium meaning even MORE mining waste.
Third, all the extra metal is RadioActive Waste.
Fourth, in making the solid fuel elements, various reactants etc. become even more RAW.
Fifth, the pellets are clad, then assembled into bundles using metal that gets irradiated and becomes ever more RAW.
Sixth, the vast majority of the fuel pellet is U238 which gets irradiated and some becomes transUranic elements, significantly more than in a LFTR.
only then do the two become ALMOST equivalent in the amount of fission products made, though even there the LFTR can be substantially more efficient at turning heat into electricity, so less fuel needs to be converted.
Oh, and most fission products decay to stability in hours, some take years, a few take a few hundred years and the rest are transmutable. It is the TRUs that represent the big storage problem. But guess what, LFTRs can burn them up too.
Not only do LFTRs not generate significant amounts of "wastes" but they can burn the problem waste from PWRs. How cool is that?!!!
What corrosion issue? It has already been shown the a combination of adding one additional alloying element to the Hastalloy N while keeping the salt slightly fluorine poor will greatly reduce the already minimal corrosion issue.
Actually, there have been two working prototypes, one that ran without significant issue for about five full power years.
FOLLOW THE NUMBERS!!!
U235 & Pu239 bombs extant ... ~20,000
U233 bombs extant ... ZERO
Seems pretty conclusive. It is MUCH easier to make bombs the way everyone always has than to put your lives on the line fiddling with U233.
Thorium in a LFTR breeds almost as well in a stable thermal spectrum reactor as U238 does in a twitchy fast spectrum reactor. And a LFTR doesn't have nearly the neutron loss mechanisms that solid fuel reactors typically do.
The same type of reactor can be used to make weapons grade Plutonium. Just ask Iran why they removed a fuel bundle from one of their reactors after just a few weeks rather than years.
Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactors were based on a design for an AIRCRAFT reactor! Talk about having to be SMALL! :)
LFTRs are not all that difficult. It is a WHOLE lot simpler than a Traveling Wave reactor!
Thorium has issues in a solid fuel reactor. The LFTR is the way to go.
Thorium is kind of like diesel, it doesn't work well in a spark ignition engine. Thorium doesn't work very well in a solid fuel reactor. Liquid Fluoride Thorium Reactors (LFTRs, pronounced "lifters") on the other hand work very nicely. All the "reasons" you mention apply to solid fuel reactors, not LFTRs. The man who invented both preferred the LFTR.