News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by meialabscom on Thursday November 19, 2026 @08:12PM (#50568911)
I feel like this sort of long term thinking is not likley to happen now. Are we too focused on monetization now? I feel this is mostly the influence of VC's in "innovation".
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by robmusial on Thursday November 19, 2026 @09:24PM (#50569396)
Signal Protocol, RISC-V, WireGuard just off the top of my head are pretty major recent innovations that aren't patent encumbered. There are plenty of people doing interesting work not influenced by VC money.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by lioeters on Thursday November 19, 2026 @10:57PM (#50569960)
I read that if we didn't have public libraries and someone suggested the concept these days, it would never be built because it sounds like a socialist scheme. "Free access to books and self-education! Who does that profit?" Everyone, of course, society benefits.

But there are good examples of technology for public benefit, and the more I pay attention, I see people are making efforts in various corners, not just in technology but a variety of social activism on collective and personal level.

The Internet, the web, and personal computers were miraculous for that historical period, it liberated the creative energy of following generations. The accelerating enshittification of our present time has managed to capture a lot of that value and cultural relevance, but the cutting edge has moved on elsewhere to find fresh expression.

That is to say, I believe there is hope as long as people continue to engage with meaningful projects creating value for the commons, and even the toxic atmosphere of global exploitation may turn out to be the wake-up call and challenge to humanity to manifest social changes, including socially beneficial technological innovations, for a better future.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by miki123211 on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:14AM (#50570805)
If libraries were invented in the 21st century, it would have been by a Silicon Valley entrepreneur "disrupting the copyright monopollies" with the innovative practice of "book sharing". They would quickly be criticized by authors and journalists alike and banned by some local governments.

Libraries that required their members to pay fees did in fact exist historically. It's how many libraries in the US got started. They were private enterprises meant to make money (or at least be self-sustaining non-profits relying on a mix of donations and fees), not government-run projects.

Libraries are an obvious workaround for the western copyright system[1]. Because this system lets us share existing book copies without the permission of the author, but doesn't allow us to print new ones for free even when the capability exists, the obvious way to make books cheaper is to serially share them across many readers and have each pay the fraction of the price. This is essentially what these libraries did, with fees as a stand-in for the price sharing that simplified their operation.

[1] Yes, I'm aware that copyright isn't exactly necessary for libraries to exist; high printing costs would do it too. I do think that they would be entirely unnecessary and almost extinct (in well-functioning 21st-century democracies) if not for copyright, given our printing costs.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by lioeters on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:07AM (#50571591)
"Uber for books"
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by frankling_ on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:21AM (#50570849)
[...] but the cutting edge has moved on elsewhere to find fresh expression.

Any pointers? Been looking for these elsewheres.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by cowlevel on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:21AM (#50572674)
The pointers are necessarily not available in public, or they'd become enshittified the same way.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by nine_k on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:14AM (#50571644)
> sounds like a socialist scheme

Public libraries were invented in 1830s, and a few existed (notably Boston's), but the proliferation of tax-supported public libraries is entirely a capitalist scheme, implemented privately by Andrew Carnegie, a steelmaking magnate.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by ninjalanternshk on Friday November 20, 2026 @06:16AM (#50573116)
The most capitalist thing about capitalism is that capitalists will do anti-capitalist things if it benefits them.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by brookst on Friday November 20, 2026 @10:19AM (#50575913)
That’s not really how it works… something isn’t a capitalist policy because a capitalist person supported it.

Fire departments are 100% socialist. That does not change depending on who supports or opposes them.

Carnegie was an interesting character. Certainly a capitalist as a person, but his support of tax-funded libraries does not transform public libraries into capitalist institutions.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by xhkkffbf on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:25AM (#50577184)
Free access? Libraries aren't free. You pay taxes for them. Also, libraries don't pirate. They pay for their books.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by kstenerud on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:58AM (#50570701)
JSON, HTTP, Markdown, CSV, HTML, almost every programming language, SSH, AV1, ODF, Open protocol, Linux, POSIX, OpenGL, Wayland, Vulkan, Opus, SeaBIOS...
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by hn_submit on Friday November 20, 2026 @02:35AM (#50571366)
My favorite non-patented CS invention of all time is...(drum roll) UTF-8!!

Many people don't appreciate the amount of DRAM and disk memory saved by this brilliant invention. In the 90's Unicode (16-bit) was all the rage. But it required double the amount of storage for text which was mostly ASCII.

The inventors should receive a Turing award (if they haven't already).

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by nine_k on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:01AM (#50571543)
The design of UTF-8 is by Ken Thompson and Rob Pike; the former actually has received the Turing Award (for other work).
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by hn_submit on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:09AM (#50571601)
For his work on C and Unix no doubt.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by hobo123 on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:16AM (#50572631)
I love that they just invented UTF8 while working on Plan 9 because they didn't like UTF16.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by trashb on Friday November 20, 2026 @08:25AM (#50574332)
legend has it was designed on a placemat in a New Jersey diner and implemented in a day.

https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~mgk25/ucs/utf-8-history.txt

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by coldpie on Friday November 20, 2026 @10:15AM (#50575830)
When I first learned how UTF-8 encoding works (to fix a text rendering bug in Wine) I was blown away. It's such a beautiful and simple encoding and it manages to be backwards-compatible with the most important encoding that existed before it. What an accomplishment.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by hn_submit on Friday November 20, 2026 @03:07AM (#50571585)
Protocols are a dime a dozen. Every competent developer could make one up just by mixing and matching things.

And RISC-V was originally an educational ISA which got out of hand and found traction in the commercial sector. Primarily because China feared getting locked-out of American and European ISAs.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by throawayonthe on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:06AM (#50572057)
at least for the signal protocol it doesn't really apply, not at all something 'every' competent developer could make by mixing and matching things.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by hn_submit on Friday November 20, 2026 @08:50AM (#50574623)
And why's that? I could easily come up with a comparable encryption protocol just by using different ciphers, hashes etc.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by keeda on Friday November 20, 2026 @11:50AM (#50577717)
I would say the difference is in the high-level structure of the protocol and the guarantees it provides. You’re right that once the structure is established the components could be fungible, but depending on what guarantees are being promised, coming up with the structure can be very non-trivial.

Like, in security there are a zillion ways your protocol could be compromised even if there are no bugs in the code. I’m not familiar with the Signal protocol at all, but I do know the combination of guarantees it provides were unmatched until it came along.

On the flip side “protocol” is a broad term, encompassing even a basic file format or a message between a client and server (hence “protobufs”!) where the only guarantee is “you will find this data at this location.” Those indeed are a dime a dozen, but they’re on the simpler end of the spectrum.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by hn_submit on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:23PM (#50579411)
There's nothing special about the Signal protocol, except (maybe) the Double Ratchet mechanism which is merely a way to generate ephemeral message keys using hash functions.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by euroderf on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:12AM (#50572110)
Is USB-C patent-encumbered ? It finally rid the world of serial and parallel ports. A local maximum of nirvana.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by cowlevel on Friday November 20, 2026 @05:20AM (#50572664)
I'm not sure but don't forget it's illegal because trademarks to say your product has a USB port, unless you're a paying member of the USB-IF and it's been compatibility tested.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by jbmchuck on Thursday November 19, 2026 @10:34PM (#50569826)
Yup. Now it would be called a moat.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by wmf on Thursday November 19, 2026 @11:06PM (#50570030)
I think people appreciate the power of free and open standards much more now than in previous decades. Companies have shifted to more subtle forms of monetization than just making everything proprietary.
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by miki123211 on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:17AM (#50570824)
Open standards have much better network effects, and so they're generally favored by the market.

Companies would prefer for their standards to be proprietary, but open standards products often do better than proprietary ones, because of said network effects.

This is not always true; sometimes the open standard and the required interoperability hampers innovation, hence why most enterprised moved off of standards-based Cisco products to Slack and Zoom.

Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by abofh on Thursday November 19, 2026 @11:29PM (#50570178)
Well, exactly. His boss wasn't measuring him by patents
Re:Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented by ares623 on Friday November 20, 2026 @01:16AM (#50570817)
Yes. The "open web" would be considered an abject failure of maximizing revenue and shareholder value.