News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by edgarvaldes on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:26PM (#50567358)
Isn't the legal profession a "protected" one, that is, a practice that requires a certified professional?
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by dotancohen on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:46PM (#50567609)
Yes, but now each certified professional can handle an order of magnitude more clients. Either the client base grows, or 90% of the attorneys will be out of work.

Worst case scenario: a little bit of both.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by karmakurtisaani on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:58PM (#50567751)
Maybe legal representation becomes more affordable, as it should be.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by atmavatar on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:17PM (#50568479)
I'll inject a little glimmer of hope: perhaps it will aid perennially overworked public defenders in handling their case loads, helping to ease one of the greater injustices against those without means to hire their own private lawyers.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by throwaway63467 on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:04AM (#50572036)
It will just create more work as people will sue more, already now courts get flooded with AI generated slop, AI even eagerly recommends this and helps people to submit docs as well.

I see it in my job as well in privacy, I can review more stuff so in theory it saves me time but I get 5-10 more cases to work on so in the end it’s more work.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by LtWorf on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:32AM (#50572268)
Criminal and civil isn't the same.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by singleshot_ on Friday November 20, 2026 @10:06AM (#50575685)
(Unfortunately,) civil defendants don't get free lawyers.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by dragonwriter on Friday November 20, 2026 @12:14PM (#50578241)
Perenially overworked public defenders are an active policy choice by governments in allocating resources to the function. Which is why the parts of the same governments supporting prosecution are not equally resource-starved.

Technology doesn't change the political reasons one function is relatively deprioritized compared to the other.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by dotancohen on Friday November 20, 2026 @07:25PM (#50584366)

  > overworked public defenders
Are the public prosecutors overworked as well? Who sets the budget for each?
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by wooger on Friday November 20, 2026 @04:45AM (#50572379)
All the trainee / junior lawyers who spend their first N years reviewing casefiles and doing donkey work are no longer needed (unless things aren't digitised).

An AI can write a letter in legal wording threatening stuff for free.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by a34729t on Friday November 20, 2026 @02:51PM (#50580881)
A very high profile aquaintance recently said "Harvey is cheaper and better than an Associate". That is very grim for everybody not coming out of a top 3 law school.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by singleshot_ on Friday November 20, 2026 @10:04AM (#50575666)
No, we can't. Most of our job involves understanding what's the most important and least important part of someone else's life and then negotiating that point. When you are ready to turn that job over to a computer I suggest you do so, so I can retire.

This is interspersed with some amount of document creation and text analysis which, I acknowledge, goes considerably faster with LLM support. It is by far not anywhere near the majority of the work. If you think I can go from 100 clients to 1000 clients you are overestimating the part of my job that involves computers.

There is a 0% chance I am in the weird 10% of lawyers, to the other part of your point.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by sl0wbrainRot on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:48PM (#50567633)
Having been through the civil court process this year, it can absolutely be automated.

Have all parties provide access to bank and email, whatever accounts court wants data from...

AI summarizes it. Judiciary can skip hearings and review.

They don't really take the oral side of things seriously anymore. 100% felt like an empty formality.

Constitutions usually only define Executive, Judiciary, Legislative type roles. The protections you mean are just laws that can change

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by kvdveer on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:55PM (#50567718)
I think you're missing the purpose of all these processes. They're not there to ensure a fair trail (that could be done far more efficiently), They're there to prove beyond reasonable doubts that the process is fair to all those involved.

This is not a role a black box AI can fill right now. Not because of any missing capability, but because of missing public trust.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by sl0wbrainRot on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:03PM (#50567813)
I think that's the verbatim copy paste of the philosophy but not tethered to reality

At least in my experience

The case I was a part was very much cut and dry law, based on finances and contracts; no doubts as the digital records were right there

Lawyers in the case just parroted almost verbatim stuff you would hear off Law & Order. Outside court they coached us to feign ignorance. The judges know this as they were lawyers before being judges

Some family court stuff might need human intervention but that should be medical experts and such who submit their findings straight to court.

Lawyers will manipulate knowledge of available records and evidence to fake reasonable doubt and they don't always get caught.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by matheusmoreira on Thursday November 19, 2026 @05:54PM (#50567708)
Yes, and those credentials are literally the only things that are stopping AIs from making inroads into their field.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by dist-epoch on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:02PM (#50567799)
Laws change all the time.

Taxi driver used to be a "protected" profession.

Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by edgarvaldes on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:51PM (#50568283)
It seems to me that the branches of government (the ones capable of enacting a change of this magnitude) are more closely intertwined with law firms than with taxi drivers, at least at the federal level. The incentives just aren't there. I suppose time will tell.
Re:AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's ... by dist-epoch on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:09PM (#50568420)
The top partners remain, all the rest are fired and replaced by AIs. Seems like a win to me.