So yeah, that is actually the one area where they’re not equivalent to dividends, tax treatment. Though that’s changed in the last twenty years as well as some dividends are no longer taxed as individual income.
https://boomersbrokeamerica.com/stock-buybacks-illegal-1982-...
https://www.investmentwatchblog.com/stock-buybacks-have-only...
Buybacks will select for frequently traded shares that have little gains, as well (this is just another way to say the above).
Ofc the elephant in the room w.r.t. capital taxation is tax advantaged retirement accounts, which have much, much higher contribution caps than was ever intended (how many people can save 80k net per year? Not many). Something like 75% of all public equity (by value) is held in advantaged accounts and exempted from capital gains taxes completely.
stock owners gain a lot more from buybacks than dividends. Juice your gains. Die. Dont pay taxes.
Buybacks likely also increase liquidity/market efficiency which is a stock owners benefit [0] (companies buy when price is low to prop it up. increase liquidity. also sort of relevant to today i was learning how the ANT greenshoe works).
Even if you do eventually sell you've basically gotten an interest free loan from the govt in deferred taxes over your hold time. that's huge.
what matters more to me is that it probably drives inequality.
100% proven to definitely decrease tax take (found different sources from about ~400-850bb 10 years). That's universal pre-k + universal childcare. Or free community college + school meals for all. OR pfml + dental and hearing in medicare.
One study [1] compared the same person same stocks > taxable v. IRAs/401ks: "Effective accrual tax rates for stocks that experience substantial appreciation are substantially below the statutory tax rate on long-term gains." e.g. lower effective tax rates/ever shrinking revenue sources
the 1% tax in IRA barely makes a dent.
This study is a triple wammy of gross [2]:
- illustrative of executives who get comp in stock seem to be more likely to make selfish short-term stock price driven decisions - use last-minute buy backs to juice earnings (prob voids the put benefit) - at the expense of R&D and re-investing for innovation
" share repurchases that increase earnings per share (EPS) is sharply higher for firms that would have just missed the EPS forecast" "EPS-motivated repurchases are associated with reductions in employment and investment"
[0] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2506671 [1] https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/00028280577501446... [2] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03044...
This isn't a buyback issue, but a step-up basis issue.
They were illegal up until 1982.