News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:13AM (#50545908)
frame drops to low 20's when anything interesting happens on screen. OUCH.

Even on PS5 Pro it's not entirely stable but the situation seems much worse on base PS5 which is what the vast majority of players will be using.

Targeting a game at 30fps in 2026 is certainly a choice, but it not even being a locked 30 is hugely disappointing.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by leetrout on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:21AM (#50545993)
This opinion (not yours, it's shared with the majority) always strikes me as odd. This isn't directed at you, just commenting here as a relevant spot in the threads.

It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware. 30 FPS is perfectly servicable. Sort of like the Louis C.K. bit about people forgetting how magical flying really is.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:34AM (#50546133)
> It's clear they built something unlike anything that has ever existed. And it's _wild_ to me they can do it with existing console hardware.

Likewise, I find this take baffling. Yes it is impressive what they managed to do, but this is first and foremost a video game, not a tech demo. Frame rate is hugely important to how it feels as a video game.

It feels to me like they optimised the game for marketing, not for gameplay. Pretty screenshots sell games, and you don't experience how the game feels to play until they already have your money.

An even more cynical take is that they knew this and it was part of the reason to not sell the game on disc: you can't resell a digital copy. This prevents the 2nd hand market from being flooded with copies from people who are disappointed with the frame rates after the honeymoon period over the pretty graphics passes.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by sheepscreek on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:59AM (#50546411)
For anyone who bought the original No Man’s Sky, would know how unplayable and buggy it was at first (but it was indie studio). Same with Cyberpunk which was from a well-funded studio. Both were eventually able to patch things up and got things to a much better place.

I believe a similar situation might be in order for GTA VI. Already plagued by so many delays, someone probably foot their foot down and said we’re going to ship the best we can on so and so date. Eventually follow it up with patches.

That’s my honest opinion.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by delichon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:25AM (#50546696)
I bought No Man's Sky on day one, and it was perfectly playable for me. But I disliked it because of the lies they told about it being multi-player, the extreme repetitiveness, and especially the nightmare scenario in which KarenBots are everywhere on every planet in every galaxy like a law of nature.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by raydev on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @02:50PM (#50551186)
We'll see what the next few days reveal as tens of millions of people will be progressing through the game, but already this looks like a far better launch than Cyberpunk.

People were sharing videos of gamebreaking bugs in Cyberpunk within hours, but for GTA6 there hasn't been much outside of weird visual eventually-correcting quirks/bugs. Pretty much everyone on Twitch is playing it right now.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by tetraodonpuffer on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:24AM (#50547420)
I'd rather a game that struggles to get to 30fps now and will be 60fps next console generation and have legs on PC to last for years (a-la crysis) than something with compromises needed to get to 60fps now and no way to scale further.

GTA comes out every decade or so, it's not like next year there will be GTA7. TBH rather than framerate I wish it focused on being less one-dimensional on playing the crime side of things, a true "sim everything" game should have allowed the two leads to become "reformed" and play on the cop side of things, if the user chose.

It is early and I'm interested if GTA6 can be played a bit more "lawfully" than GTA5 with its forced repulsive gameplay. All the effort spent on racing hopefully points in that direction, would be nice if there was taxi/ambulance gameplay again as well as stunts/jumps and so on.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by claykkari on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @11:17AM (#50548139)
100%. PS6 is just a few years away, so making GTA6 just barely playable on PS5 makes sense in the long run.
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:40PM (#50549416)
> I'd rather a game that struggles to get to 30fps now and will be 60fps next console generation

It’s a story-driven game. There’s no replay value after you finished the main story. It doesn’t really matter if they release a 60fps update in a few years time as by that time I already know the story and have no reason to play it. It would be like watching a movie you’re already seen or reading a book you’ve already read.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by gloxkiqcza on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:09PM (#50552146)
> It’s a story-driven game.

My favorite memories of playing GTA have nothing to do with the story. It's an open world game with many possibilities.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by ethbr1 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:36PM (#50554439)
That's like saying no one ever plays Morrowind after finishing the main story...
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by jswelker on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:03PM (#50549756)
"Came for the graphics . Left for the framerates."

Is this how people approach AAA gaming in 2026? Yeesh. I will stick to indie games I guess.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by PorciiVorbesc on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @02:33PM (#50550959)
>Is this how people approach AAA gaming in 2026?

When you pay big money for the HW and then big money for the game that's been cooking for 13 years, you WILL have some high expectations.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by sickofparadox on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:48AM (#50546282)
>30 FPS is perfectly servicable. It could be, if it was consistent, but the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that). The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second, so the idea that the "greatest game ever" is an interactive slideshow whenever game play gets intense is laughable.

>they can do it with existing console hardware I don't think they can, and they should have lowered fidelity so people could actually play the game.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:20AM (#50546646)
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second

What is noticeable depends on size of screen and how fast things are moving across the screen. Anything up to about 10,000 FPS can be noticeable for very fast movement.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by croon on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:03AM (#50547139)
> The human eye only recognizes smooth motion at 17 frames a second

I'm sure this means something, but I can certainly tell the difference between 60 and 100fps, or LEDs without capacitors, and I'm by no means an aberration, and we are talking about the context of games on a screen.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by vunderba on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:20AM (#50547390)
I think they're trying to say that below 17 frames per second, you start to perceive the individual frames, and it no longer feels like a continuous animation.

But yeah, there's a huge difference between 30 and 60 frames per second in a video game.

You could do an A/B comparison of Breath of the Wild, which was locked at 30 frames per second, and the same game running on an emulator with a patch to bring it up to 60 frames per second, and anyone with reasonable visual acuity would instantly be able to tell the difference.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by sickofparadox on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:59AM (#50547902)
That was my meaning, thank you. I should have said "only begins to recognize continuous motion".
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by letmevoteplease on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:30AM (#50547511)
"the parent comment was just saying how any interaction drops the rate to 20 (and likely below even that)"

Digital Foundry says the PS5 Pro is "near flawless 30 FPS" and he played for 50 hours without seeing a single dip, but he was able to make it drop to 24 by trying to cause as much chaos as possible. The standard PS5 gets small dips to 26-28 doing normal things like driving, again falling to 24 during chaos. XBox Series X is similar to standard PS5 while XBox Series S seems a little worse dipping to 19 during chaos.

https://youtu.be/qsBU0bcpONA?t=2839

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by on_the_train on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:49AM (#50547770)
But it's not 30 fps
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by ProfessorLayton on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:04PM (#50551392)
Ocarina of Time (N64) is one of the most beloved video games of all time. It targeted 20fps (And barely achieved that).

The Switch 2 remake is 3x that, but high FPS is not a prerequisite for being a masterpiece.

That being said, sometimes a fixed FPS is a gameplay requirement. Smash Bros has always targeted 60FPS since the N64 days.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by mostlysimilar on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:22PM (#50551626)
> Ocarina of Time (N64) is one of the most beloved video games of all time. It targeted 20fps (And barely achieved that).

That was 1998. This is 2026.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by ProfessorLayton on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:31PM (#50551742)
Ok? Is your point that GTA 6 won't be one of the most loved games without hitting a frame rate target higher than 30FPS?
Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by Aaargh20318 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:54PM (#50551999)
> Ocarina of Time (N64) is one of the most beloved video games of all time. It targeted 20fps (And barely achieved that).

I played OOT on a 24” CRT back then. I’m playing on a 83” OLED now. Low frame rates look worse the bigger the screen gets. Motion resolution also gets worse at low frame rates on a sample-and-hold display.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by ProfessorLayton on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:19PM (#50552252)
Movies are typically filmed at 24FPS and are shown in screens much bigger than your 83" OLED. Games like GTA 6 are definitely going for a cinematic look, so it's a fair comparison, and the gameplay itself was designed around the targeted FPS.

I'll also add that I too enjoy higher FPS sometimes, but it's not an absolute requirement for every piece of media. Movies at 48/60FPS do no look great IMO.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by tmpz22 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:31PM (#50551731)
1) Stable 30 FPS is not the same as fluctuating 30 FPS (which could mean semifrequent drops to < 10 FPS). Video games are designed and expected to run at stable 30, 60, or higher FPS, unlike movies which are shot and edited for a much lower frame rate both by design and consumer expectations. GTA6 being alleged to fluctuate below 30 FPS misses consumer expectations for a game that a) has been in development for well over 10+ years and b) sets a new price ceiling for video games at $80 retail.

2) Most of the world does not have access to premium hardware to begin with. In India for example a PS5 Digital is about $750 USD equivalent, with a median salary of ~$4,000 USD that is way beyond the median spending ranges. My favorite example is FIFA who still releases new versions of FIFA and other games targeting the PS4 and even PS3 markets so that it may be accessible in South America. If Rockstar can't meet expectations on premium hardware, how will they ever make their game accessible to the other continents in the world?

3) Hardware and memory prices are through the roof right now. Software optimization becomes much more important as a result.

Re:GTA 6 Review: It Is a Masterpiece by b0rtb0rt on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:49PM (#50554008)
some of us are old enough to remember when frame rate drops meant you were in the middle of a serious boss fight and shit was going down, it was almost a positive thing back then