The accusations of "genocide", which started on the day of the attack by genocide, before there even was an Israeli response, are the most egregious case of victim/perpretrator reversal in recent history.
https://www.samharris.org/blog/the-bright-line-between-good-...
As everyone expected, collateral damage in Gaza has convinced much of the world that Israel is the real aggressor here. Of course, many on the Left began saying this before Israel had dropped a single bomb, at a moment when it was clear that Hamas had committed atrocities of a sort that one scarcely imagines possible in the modern world. The fact that millions of people can’t do the moral arithmetic here, or have confidently produced the wrong answer, is itself an enormous problem for open societies everywhere—because this should not have been confusing. Hamas took a sadistic pleasure in torturing and killing noncombatants that should have made it instantly clear, to everyone, certainly everyone on a college campus, that jihadist groups like Hamas are the permanent enemies of civilization.
Another:
https://x.com/RoyKAltman/status/2114406605949395078
Reproduced here:
What Israel did in Gaza may well go down in history as the most humane and precise urban warfare environment the world has ever known—the very opposite of genocide.
The entire purpose of a genocide is to push civilians into the killing zone.
Think about what happened in the Holocaust, where children in line at Auschwitz were given bars of soap, where inside of the gas chambers there were fake shower heads.
What was the point?
It was to trick and induce civilians to get in to the killing zone so that you could kill more of them more efficiently over time.
Israel has done the very opposite—warning civilians and then manning humanitarian corridors with its own soldiers, risking its own sons’ and daughters’ lives to ensure that civilians get out of the killing zone.
We see two remarkable things in Gaza.
First, according to preeminent urban warfare scholars like John Spencer, Richard Kemp, and Andrew Fox, Israel has the lowest militant-to-civilian kill ratio in the history of urban warfare.
Genocides have extreme civilian-to-militant kill ratios. Hundred, thousand, ten thousand-to-one. That’s the point of a genocide.
Here we have a militant-to-civilian kill ratio of may be two-to-one—not consistent not just with law of war violations—but much less with genocide.
Second, and more importantly, all genocidal regimes get better over time at killing civilians.
Again, think about the Holocaust. The Nazis started with firing squads killing 20, 30, 50 people at a time and realized that was too inefficient. Then they got these vans and filled them with exhaust pipes, and they would kill more people. And they said, “We’re never going to get to six million killing them this way.” That led them to construct these massive gas chambers and crematoria—the architecture of true genocide—to kill thousands and thousands of people cheaply and efficiently a day.
Israel has done the opposite.
Even if you believe Hamas’ numbers, the scale of civilian death in Gaza went down over time. Israel got better and better and spent hundreds of millions of shekels learning how to become more efficient at preserving innocent Palestinians’ lives.
Again, the very opposite of genocide.
I have no motivation to label what they are doing as "genocide", but this seems flatly untrue. I'm a little astonished to see this degree of speech about such a complicated issue on HN (it brings to mind Trump's absurdist word choices).
What I wrote is true. Yet even somewhat reasonable people have been so convinced of the opposite of the truth that they consider even the most obvious facts that dispute The Narrative as so beyond-the-pale as to be not even worthy of consideration, never mind discussion.
https://www.newsweek.com/israel-implemented-more-measures-pr...
https://www.newsweek.com/israel-has-created-new-standard-urb...
And in fact they are being criticized by other armed forces for setting standards that are impossible for others to reach.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_casualty_ratio
Gaza war: 60% – 80% civilian casualties
Bosnian War (which included broadly recognized genocide): 40% civilian casualties
Russo-Ukrainian War: ~15% – 25% civilian casualties.
But sure, go off.
> And in fact they are being criticized by other armed forces for setting standards that are impossible for others to reach.
Which ones, North Korea's? Got a cite?
https://press.un.org/en/2022/sc14904.doc.htm
The 60%-80% for Gaza are incorrect by Hamas's own figure.
> During the 1990s, claims that civilians accounted for around 90% of casualties in modern warfare became widespread. This figure has been widely doubted, and research has found little to no evidence that 90% of casualties are civilians. The 2005 Human Security Report called it a "myth" and instead suggested that 30–60% of fatalities from conflicts in 2002 were civilians. Likewise, the International Committee of the Red Cross estimated in 1999, that between 30 and 65% of conflict casualties were civilians.
I'm not really going to address the wall of text you wrote because none of it is relevant to the legal definition of genocide.
Except ad-hominms.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Graham's_Hierarchy_of_Dis...
It takes what could be a serious discussion about how to resolve the conflict and how to relieve the humanitarian crisis in Gaza - and turns it into a semantic argument with no real substance to it.
It seems so counter-productive to their own cause that I legitimately don't understand it - unless it's just a fun way for them to bleat against Israel without actually trying to solve anything.
Isn't it obvious?
Hamas have been very vocal and direct about their strategy: they know they can't defeat Israel militarily. The purpose of the attack of October 7th and its utter bestiality was to force Israel into a strong response, and then use that response to try and remove international support for Israel (and less openly: scupper the upcoming deal with Saudi Arabia, which their Iranian masters are terrified about).
That's one reason Hamas not just don't care about civilian Palestinian casualties, they actually try hard to maximize civilian Palestinian casualties. Again, this is not a big secret, they are quite open about it and their conduct confirms it.
It also explains one reason Israel is so incredibly meticulous about minimizing Palestinian casualties, and also very, very good at it.
The vocal accusations of genocide are part of this Hamas strategy, and also classic Kremlin propaganda: always accuse the other side of what you yourself are about to do, or want to do. Hamas's genocidal intent against Israel is also no secret: it's in their charter.
Of course, it is also an old anti-Semitic trope.
I don't understand Westerners - especially so-called progressive or liberal Westerners - who buy in to the propaganda and insist on using the word against their own supposed interests. Even if they believe it, it's apparent that it's counterproductive to their purported cause of helping Palestinians (as opposed to Hamas, whose goal is turning public opinion against Israel).
Hmm...I think Hamas doesn't call them "useful idiots" without a reason.
The most absurd example still being "Queers for Palestine".
You are lying which isn't not uncommon for Zionists. I listed a number of prominent historians specialising in genocide studies and I'm leaving it to you to pick one and refute their justification for why Israel's conduct in Gaza is genocide. Legal definition of genocide which you claim to understand includes five criteria and none of what you wrote above directly addressed any of them. Israeli actions in Gaza meet at least four out of five:
"Genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
[x] Killing members of the group
[x] Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group
[x] Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part
[x] Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group
[ ] Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group"
The counter is in the very piece you quoted:
...with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group,...
All of the actions occur in "normal" armed conflicts. Which is why intent is crucial.
There is no intent.
Unlike Hamas, which proudly announces it wants to eliminate all Jews.
Here's an article by Lee Mordechai discussing the intent: https://bearing-witness.com/appendix-1-why-genocide-18-6-24/
South Africa's case in ICJ has even more references.
Also, a quote that resonated with me regarding genocide :
The Israelis probably could, but they don't. The Palestinians can't, but if they could they wouldn't hesitate.
Because it is genocide.