News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by goache on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @03:20PM (#50537608)
I created a web comic based on this measurement! https://randomlyunique.com/plancky/2018/roemers-speed-of-lig...
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by mkehrt on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @03:41PM (#50537886)
Thanks, this is a much clearer explanation than the article.
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by kingstnap on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @05:25PM (#50539140)
Except the explanation doesn't make any sense. A period is a period. Earth doesn't look like its spinning half as fast if you are 1 light-day away...

The real effect is actually to do with making a graph and noticing an oscillation in the phase of the orbit. In particular the cumulative phase shifts that add up as earth moves further away and the cumulative small phase shifts that add up as earth moves closer to Jupiter. This looks like a sine wave.

There are lots of these textbook simplifications that make a line fitting problem look like some magic 2 point measurement impossibility.

Like the Millikan’s oil drop experiment wasn't some magic nonsense where you figure out how to balance a single drop in mid air.

The Cavendish weighing the earth wasn't a static twist on some wire where you cannot possibly measure the torsion constant precisely enough. It involved measuring a peak to peak deflection of some small oscillation.

The Foucault rotating mirror was not magically shooting a discrete laser pulse and measuring an RPM, as it came back in the second gap it was realising that you could modulate the returning intensity as you ramped angular frequency. Fitting angular velocity against harmonic number was what gives you time of flight not a single tooth.

Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by sugarkjube on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:54AM (#50542751)
> oscillation in the phase of the orbit.

Ok, thanks for explaining, makes sense now.

Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by Modified3019 on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @04:29PM (#50538457)
Wow, what a wonderful little site. It never occurred to me that optical disks worked via constructive/destructive interference: https://randomlyunique.com/plancky/2018/how-optical-disks-wo...
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by Coeur on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:37PM (#50540328)
"Over the course of a year, Io's orbital time varied by 22 minutes".

This sentence implies that at some point in the year the time it takes for Io to do one orbit is 22 minutes longer. That's not true. This is not a good explanation comic.

What happens is that if you have a clock that is very accurate and has a drift of less than a minute for a whole year, and you measure the exact moment that Io's eclipse happens (every 42.5 hours) over a full year, you see that this moment varies over the course of a year by 22 minutes.

How can you create such an accurate clock in the 17th century? By calibrating it daily based on other daily occurring measurements of the night sky.

Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by empireofdust on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @09:17PM (#50541042)
Ok i still don’t know whats true but at least this explanation with 0 visuals was very intuitive.
[dead]
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by two_handfuls on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:29AM (#50542239)
I didn't write the original comment but perhaps a suggestion that may satisfy both of you would be to say the "apparent orbital time"? You don't need to get into the details but this way no one will think that you claim that the actual orbital period varied, only its measurement from earth.
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by jstanley on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:58AM (#50544231)
But the apparent orbital period doesn't vary by 22 minutes, the cumulative error in the orbital period reaches as much as 22 minutes.

100 laps that are all a second too long makes a cumulative error of 100 seconds but there was no lap that was 100 seconds too long.

(I actually have no idea about Io, but that's the distinction I think Coeur is trying to make).

Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by Coeur on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:41AM (#50545085)
Didn't intend to make you feel bad. I'm sorry if I offended you.

I think it's interesting that readers often believe "in the medium of comic, things are easier to understand". But it's not so by default. As a writer, it's all about first getting a good intuitive understanding yourself. And then breaking things down into easy to understand chunks that build on top of each other. Which can work in text just as well as a in sequential art.

If I used the form of comic to explain this, I would have shown a graph of time and when eclipses happened, that a scientist might make of this on earth. The graph would have expected eclipses as regular black dots, and there would be red dots with the time of the actual eclipses. And the actual eclipses sometimes line up with the expected time, and sometimes the actual eclipses are a bit late. That would have used the medium to make things clearer.

Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by camel_gopher on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @10:04PM (#50541341)
Ain’t nobody got time for that nowadays
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by raxxorraxor on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:18AM (#50543346)
I think it is still a good explanation because the context makes it clear, although on its own the statement is wrong. Perhaps you could have written "Over the course of a year, its orbit period was late by up to 22min". Phase is too technical and you would have lost a loot of readers already.
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by ant6n on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:58AM (#50544229)
I was very confused here, your phrasing would definitely help. Once understanding breaks down at the beginning, we may never get out of it.
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by quietbritishjim on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:15AM (#50545375)
Orbit period means the same thing though!

Maybe "observed orbital time" (or "apparent orbital time") would work better.

Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by raxxorraxor on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:39AM (#50545593)
True, quite difficult to explain it correctly. Perhaps substitute "late" with "shifted".
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by dustypotato on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:31AM (#50543477)
I cant stop hitting next on this site haha. Beautifully described and concise! Thank you!
Re:350 years ago, this man discovered that light has a finit... by dustypotato on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:34AM (#50543517)
Man I ask Gemini and Claude to create infographics normally but they are always so cumbersome to understand. But your comics are so intuitive