Of course, being able to land on runways gave the Space Shuttle more choices for emergency landings than needing a chopsticks catcher.
That said, the Space Shuttle holds records for the most humans killed in spaceflight, and the most expensive cost per kilogram to LEO.
I don't think this is happening with the current design. If there's a human version of Starship, it would have to have meet some safety standards. Namely abort options on launch and safe failure modes on return. I can see a Starship with a classic pod on top, but no way this design carries humans from/to earth.
In particular, because the shuttle used an all-but-obsolete terminal guidance system, called Microwave Landing System (MLS).
While MLS was intended to be the "next generation" instrument landing system (to replace VHF ILS approaches) for the entire national airspace system, MLS was basically only ever installed at a few runways intended as Shuttle abort locations, and Shuttle was basically the only aircraft that used it (aside from some other NASA test aircraft used to validate MLS approaches, and a couple other one-off airports).
It's a shame, too, because MLS is pretty technically interesting, allows other-than-straight-in approaches, and offers horizontal, vertical and high-precision distance guidance all in one package.
But the point is that Shuttle had very slim margins, so the fact that it landed horizontally very explicitly did not mean it could land "anywhere": It required an MLS approach. The plan for situations where an MLS runway was not available was to have astronauts bail out at altitude.
Space Shuttle was a compromised design from the beginning. They originally wanted the Space Shuttle booster to also have wings and return to launch site (with a crew!). But they couldn't afford to develop two new vehicles, so they compromised by making the external tank as cheap as possible and adding solid rockets (which led to the Challenger disaster).
But their biggest mistake was having the engines on the orbiter (so they could be recovered) but not the fuel tank. That meant the orbiter had to hang on the side of the external tank, which made it vulnerable to foam strikes (leading to the Columbia disaster).
Landing with wings is aesthetically pleasing (compared to tower catches) but consider the waste: You have to boost the weight of the wings, landing gear, etc. all the way to orbit and then bring it all the way back. It's much more efficient to just bring fuel and use that for landing. And if your guidance is accurate enough, a pinpoint landing means you can land on the launch tower and not worry about landing legs.
Then there was pressure to make use of solid propellants to amortize their use with military uses, not to mention pushing for Shuttle carrying all payloads for the US.
This together created the dangerous and expensive design tHat was STS.
... but a lot of those were set in 1968 - 73, when relationships between the US and Soviet Union were very different than the late 80s.
Given the development and operational timelines, it wasn't a bad bet to cover needing that military capability, had things turned out differently between the two superpowers.
I don't think the period is entirely declassified? If it ever will be
Given they launch in full view of many people, not from behind a fake mayan temple in the middle of the rain forrest.
Challenger blew because the joint was designed to always be in compression--but it went into tension during the twang. After the headlines they paid attention and fixed it.
Shuttle always started the main engines for a few seconds (wasting fuel) to make sure the engines worked before lighting the solids. But there were many engine-out scenarios after the solids were lit that would result in loss-of-crew.
But tjis was IIRC used on single stick ICBMs and won't be really applicable for anything more delicate.
And the whole dispersed engine system of the Shuttle made any sort of engine out quite dangerous due to imbalanced thrust. When the engines are all right next to each other it's much more resilient against the failure of one, but the Shuttle would be in trouble if it lost any of it's three legs.
Incidentally, presence of perchlorates is also one of the main concerns with martian soil.
At least a hydrogen or methane explosion is quite clean, even cleaner than kerosene.
> Then there was pressure to make use of solid propellants
As far as I remember the decision was based on development costs (like most decisions).
Starship doesn't have that - and so it can be much more optimized for it's purpose. It's basically tanks with a cargo bay and control surfaces, while the shuttle had to toss it's tanks away every flight.
Also some in the Soviet leadership were very scared the shuttle could carry nukes clandestinely, then during an ostensibly routine mission change inclination using its wings and decapitate Moscow with no prior warning.
Until each side accumulated enough ICBM nukes that it was clear mutually-assured destruction would dominate.
Wings are useless in a vacuum.
But if you could pull it off (and Soviets apparently beleived it was possible) you have an unique capability not really available to regular satellites l, where low orbit quick plane changes are basically impossible with any realistically available delta-v.
An adaptable retropulsive landing system, by contrast, is fit for duty just about anywhere. In the long run you'd just need the atmospheric/planetary specs, a flat hard surface somewhere, and it'd be able to come down on it safely.
Seems like the same design principles that goes into Starship could create a version with more aerodynamic surface.
Is the idea that Starhship will be considered safe enough for human crews?