GNOME is the mishmash of macos and, like you said, mobile design.
[1] https://x.com/claucambra/status/1466153819713191947
[2] https://gearwisdom.blog/microsoft-vs-kde-maui-trademark-disp...
* Composting with transparent windows
* Alt+TAB and task bar previews for window contents
* Soft-tiling by dragging windows to desktop borders
In the distant past, I liked the Windows UI, despite the fact that I have never seen any Windows program with a user interface as optimized for high productivity as a few of the MS-DOS programs had, even if they were restricted to the much inferior hardware of that time.
But in the last decade, whenever I had to use Windows for work related purposes I found that very unpleasant, as I felt like in a straitjacket in comparison with what I can do in Linux, when configured how I like it. To be fair, there are Linux distributions whose default configurations feel equally unpleasant for me as Windows, e.g. Ubuntu, because I do not like any default desktop configuration that I have encountered, and the unpleasantness happens when I cannot change the configuration according to my taste.
If there have been any UX innovations done after 2000, they are very well hidden because I have never seen anyone using such an innovation.
Explorer from Windows Vista onwards has the best sorting, grouping and filtering experience even today, same with Windows 8 Task Manager. You can't configure them into existence unless you write your own apps.
HIGs of the two biggest Linux desktops both flaunt harmful principles around, either by focusing on simplicity exclusively or by implying a dichotomy between power and simplicity that's almost always false. Microsoft still has the Aero guidelines on their site: https://learn.microsoft.com/windows/win32/uxguide/how-to-des...
I have no idea how is modern KDE, because I abandoned KDE due to the KDE 4 disaster. Nonetheless, KDE 3.5 was much better than Windows XP, even if its default configuration was somewhat similar.
Actually I consider KDE 3.5 the best desktop environment that I have ever seen, much better not only than the contemporaneous Windows XP, but also than the contemporaneous Mac OS X. The reason was that KDE 3.5 had an extreme customizability, so everyone could reconfigure it according to their tastes, so it no longer resembled any other desktop environment.
After KDE 4, I never had the courage to try KDE again, but I hope that it had recovered and now it is at least at the level of its past glory, if not better.
I totally hated that whole mess. It almost ruined KDE for me. The real disaster there wasn't that KDE released v4 prematurely, but that they didn't make it crystal clear to the distro maintainers (and end-users) that it was not ready for "prime time" use yet (it was basically "pre-release"/alpha quality), and the major distros of the time jumped on making it the default (forced it on everyone) when it was still basically utterly broken compared to the prior versions of KDE (which had become overall quite solid and reliable by that point).
KDE 6 is really good tho. It's so fast, works great, Dolphin is the absolute best file manager there is...
I highly recommend giving it another try, I'm super picky and modern KDE simply delivers the best and most flexible desktop experience, bar none.
Though I suppose both Microsoft and Apple are happy to receive your unpaid aid with stuffing their bottom lines.
What I see with gnomes though is that shedding the customization doesn’t actually make for a more solid project. The fact Wayland fractional scale took as long as it did to stabilize despite mostly working tells me gnome didn’t care about the real hardware that makes up the bulk of what exists in the world.
Similarly, it seems like plasma has a massive technical edge just in handling things like pipewire capture, etc. I find KDE is typically smoother and the gnome iverview animation almost always stutters regardless of the computer I use it on from discrete gpu desktops.
So I can say that it seems from my experience the gnome project has naval gazed and built a model of the computing landscape they target that is divorced from reality.
What I will praise unreservedly is the gnome circle apps and broader which are typically polished focused and attractive.
So to me gnome fails at a desktop but has managed to foster a culture around themselves that leads to solid app development.
App development for KDE is still essentially limited to C++ and janky Python.
GNOME isn't similar to Android at all. The UI very much assumes a keyboard/mouse and can't be easily used as 10-foot TV UI without a remote with an airmouse and keyboard.