News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Claude Delusion by jdw64 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:26AM (#50497268)
There's something I find difficult when reading this piece. The thing is, I've been making a living as a programmer and I'm now in my seventh year, but programming wasn't actually my major. I majored in computational physics in university, jumped into programming on that basis, and taught myself programming. So does that mean I have no right to make up programming problems and ask questions? I mean, couldn't Bill Gates have studied biology hard and understood things outside his own field too?

Or is the theme of the piece that one ought to have epistemic humility?

But the thing is, this piece itself also makes claims about psychology, power theory, and human nature to some degree, which is ironic. But that can't be it. Because this piece has no epistemic humility in it.

Then, if we demand according to what this piece says, in the end it comes down to "no one can test AI outside the major they studied in university" — but honestly, isn't it just a matter of buying the textbooks and papers and testing AI with them?

It's a slightly difficult problem.

Re:The Claude Delusion by okasaki on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:30AM (#50497288)
Do you think aging billionaires "study things hard"? Or just talk to a lot of people and have a very surface level understanding?
Re:The Claude Delusion by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:38AM (#50497360)
[delayed]
Re:The Claude Delusion by LtdJorge on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:48AM (#50497458)
These kind of people are where they are because they become completely obsessed with a topic, so I can believe he studied hard, if he was obsessed with it.
Re:The Claude Delusion by danaris on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:36AM (#50505801)
Bullshit.

These kind of people are where they are because they got lucky and exploited a lot of people.

Bill Gates made his fortune gaining and enforcing an illegal monopoly.

Re:The Claude Delusion by okasaki on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:21PM (#50510314)
Downvoted because that's the dream of most HN users.
Re:The Claude Delusion by DennisP on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:48AM (#50497463)
Depends on the billionaires. Some, including Gates and Buffett, are introverts who've spent a lifetime doing lots of reading. I doubt they suddenly turned into non-reading extroverts.

But they do get to spend as much time as they like talking with leading experts in any field. I have a hard time seeing that as a disadvantage.

Re:The Claude Delusion by jdw64 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:57AM (#50497534)
Whether Bill Gates is smart or not isn't my concern. I'm someone who reads his writing often, and I think his writing is worth reading. That said, on the other hand, this piece actually does contain a performative contradiction to some degree.

The theme of this piece is, in fact, "don't absolutize your own standards" — that successful people forget the contingency of their success, forget the situation and context of their judgment, and treat it as a universally correct judgment. But the problem lies in the writing itself that carries this piece's theme.

A doctor can smoke while telling a patient that smoking is bad — that's not a problem at all. The biggest contradiction in this piece is that, while warning against "absolutizing one's own standards outside one's own field," it reinforced the psychological parts without any argument or evidence. Honestly, everyone has that degree of contradiction in a homepage essay. So do I.

But separate from that, the difficulty in reading this piece is that if you're going to demand intellectual humility, you should at least be consistent within the text. You can criticize the act of reinforcing one's own standards outside one's field. The problem is that it's hard when, within the text, the author violates the very standards he set. I also tend to think this is to some degree a general human trait. Everyone has some logical leaps... it's not a bad thing, but that's how I am.

Re:The Claude Delusion by murkt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:33AM (#50497319)
For sure, Bill Gates didn’t study biology for four years in college and doesn’t have diploma. How come he can now ask questions about biology after being envolved in the field for fifteen (or how many) years? Get off biology’s lawn.

Also, Dunning-Kruger effect doesn’t exist. It’s autocorrelation.

Re:The Claude Delusion by sporadicism on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:48AM (#50497460)
> does that mean I have no right to make up programming problems and ask questions?

Of course not, but that's not what's being argued. If you believed you could authoritatively declare what AI is or is not, that would be different, though.

> couldn't Bill Gates have studied biology hard and understood things outside his own field too?

Yes but he would still be a dilettante. Belief to the contrary is more likely to be an indication of engineer's disease.

Re:The Claude Delusion by jdw64 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:05AM (#50497597)
To be honest with you, I don't understand why you rate this piece so highly. This piece basically shows a strong self-contradiction. If it's due to human writing having self-contradiction, then this piece would be human. If that's the case, I think AI writing is better.

The point of the matter is that the intellectual humility the author of this piece advocates isn't present in this piece. What papers are cited for the psychological claims the author of this piece makes? Of course, there's no need to do that in a blog essay. But the target of this piece's criticism is the absolutization of one's own standards and epistemic humility, and the problem is that this piece also commits that contradiction. This is a matter of the piece's level. I respect the intellectual aesthetics of people who like this kind of writing, but it's not my taste.

Re:The Claude Delusion by jason_oster on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:37PM (#50499536)
Well said. I don't believe the author has any credentials or accolades in psychology or sociology, but they certainly have strong opinions on how other people should form opinions.

What I am seeing in the article is an unchecked case of cognitive dissonance. That's just the overwhelming sense I get. You identified it as self-contradiction. The reason I label it cognitive dissonance is that the author is arguing against something that they themselves are projecting; that subject matter experts in one domain are overconfident in another.

This article's self-fulfilling prophecy is that it will one day be used as an argument from authority, if it hasn't already.

Re:The Claude Delusion by dolmen on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:19PM (#50503987)
Definitely the best critique of the blog post!

I see biases claims against billg can be applied against the post author.

Re:The Claude Delusion by neutronicus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:53AM (#50497502)
The underlying thesis is that real power should be reserved for people with philosophy degrees