News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Claude Delusion by jdw64 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:57AM (#50497534)
Whether Bill Gates is smart or not isn't my concern. I'm someone who reads his writing often, and I think his writing is worth reading. That said, on the other hand, this piece actually does contain a performative contradiction to some degree.

The theme of this piece is, in fact, "don't absolutize your own standards" — that successful people forget the contingency of their success, forget the situation and context of their judgment, and treat it as a universally correct judgment. But the problem lies in the writing itself that carries this piece's theme.

A doctor can smoke while telling a patient that smoking is bad — that's not a problem at all. The biggest contradiction in this piece is that, while warning against "absolutizing one's own standards outside one's own field," it reinforced the psychological parts without any argument or evidence. Honestly, everyone has that degree of contradiction in a homepage essay. So do I.

But separate from that, the difficulty in reading this piece is that if you're going to demand intellectual humility, you should at least be consistent within the text. You can criticize the act of reinforcing one's own standards outside one's field. The problem is that it's hard when, within the text, the author violates the very standards he set. I also tend to think this is to some degree a general human trait. Everyone has some logical leaps... it's not a bad thing, but that's how I am.

There are no comments on this comment yet.