Using it inside the clean room is more of an issue.
You lose that if you use an LLM which was trained on the original expression.
>To keep the clean room clean, you'd need to use an LLM which you could prove had never seen the original.
In this true though? It seems the jury is out on whether or not LLM outputs are considered “new” or not legally speaking.
Not exactly, and that's an unhelpful way to think about it. Copyright law, technically speaking, DGAF about whether you are using an LLM or not. Yes, there has been a lot of talk about whether LLM outputs qualify for copyright protection. And the answer isn't completely straightforward, but the ultimate answer doesn't have anything to do with LLMs -- the law requires a certain modicum of human creativity to qualify for copyright protection. So the real legal answer is that it depends less on whether you are using an LLM and more about how you as a human are using it. That line isn't well litigated yet -- but in general, if you want a copyright, you need to be ready to explain how human creativity was involved -- that's, by definition, the only thing copyright protects.
BUT, this doesn't matter at all in this situation, we're not questioning the copyright protection status of the LLM output, we're questioning whether it violates someone else's IP.
The point of clean room reverse engineering is a defense to prove you could not have violated IP rights of others (not just copyright, but also trade secrets, and patents). The entire point of the exercise is that the implementation team has never seen the original work, so it is impossible for them to have copied the expression. They only could have come to it coincidentally by implementing the idea in the same way. This protects you from a copyright lawsuit because copyright only protects expression, not ideas.
LLMs, are proven to possess the capability to reproduce expression: exhibited as overfitting and/or memorization. So, to form the same defense with an LLM, you'd have to prove that the LLM couldn't possibly be overfitting or repeating from memory. And the best way to do that is to do it the same way it is done with humans: you need to ensure they never saw (i.e. wasn't trained on) the subject of the reverse engineering.
I think that’s a bit of an undeserved framing personally
The law neither allows nor disallows clean room reverse engineering. Clean room reverse engineering enables a defendant to logically prove they have not copied the any protected expression, because the implementers have never seen any protected expression.
I disagree. The WINE project settled all this reverse engineering legal nonsense a long time ago. They can file all the suits they want but they will just get dismissed.
The threats of Synaptics are dangerous only because they claim patent infringement, for which it does not matter whether reverse engineering was clean or not.
I think you're exactly right that the western would would continue to innovate without patents. I think what you're missing is that the rent-seeking would continue as normal, simply by using trade secrets, obfuscation, services-models, etc.
Patents was supposed to be a tool to enable competition, but does the reverse now - and it is holding as back as society. We should move away from it. Especially and specifically when it comes to vague, loose ideas just like the GP post says here.
Like when you looked at all the confusing and unwanted "2-in-1" and hybrid computer designs the thing you looked at was that they twisted themselves into pretzels to include... a trackpad! For most applications other than "working on an airplane" a true tablet with a bluetooth keyboard and mouse is so preferable but for various reasons the industry never showed it to you.
Not something everyone values unfortunately.