News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday October 23, 2026 @09:29AM (#50208687)
The web as we know it was never securable. LLMs made it obvious. We made a wrong turn somewhere back around JavaScript. Eventually we'll get fed up with the quick fixes and design something better. I don't blame the LLMs for this. I blame whoever made that wrong turn back in the 90's (and us, for not turning around sooner).
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by vanviegen on Friday October 23, 2026 @09:54AM (#50209034)
You're blaming JavaScript? The language that succeeded at delivering fully sandboxed rich client-side applications better than any other tech? With the worst incidents generally being 'just' various forms of fingerprinting?

Or, if you're thinking server-side JavaScript: would the web have been more secure running PHP and Python?

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday October 23, 2026 @11:54AM (#50211049)
The language that made it normal to blindly run code that you found lying around on some page? Elsewhere we'd call that a remote code execution exploit. JavaScript just calls it another day at the office.

And it's not fully sandboxed. It betrays its user all the time by abusing unrestricted access to the network, or activating browser functionality that most of us would disable if we could.

I'm not saying it's THE bad decision, but it is the product of a generation of thinkers who were not thinking about threats the way we do now. If we were to go back in time and have the opportunity to do it differently, I think we would take that opportunity.

But we don't actually need a time machine. We can just accept some sunk costs and move forward anyhow.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by ifwinterco on Friday October 23, 2026 @12:07PM (#50211261)
Blindly running client side code (within a very carefully designed sandbox) is necessary for the modern web to operate, and people like the modern web.

We aren't going back to a page refresh every time you want to update something any time soon

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday October 23, 2026 @01:35PM (#50212597)
Are you sure people like the modern web? It's increasingly used as a weapon against them. I don't know anybody under 20 who likes the modern web. As for the others, I think its more about nostalgia.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by icedchai on Friday October 23, 2026 @05:51PM (#50215867)
The tech that made the old web still exists. Everything is a GET, a form POST, and needs a page reload. You can still use tables for layout like it's 1996.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday October 23, 2026 @08:28PM (#50217182)
1. I'm not proposing the users go back and live in the past. I'm proposing that we, the technologists, go back to the drawing board as it existed at that time and build a different future.

2. I'm not going to feel safe if I go make a web site that works that way. I'm going to feel safe if my bank does.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by no-name-here on Saturday October 24, 2026 @12:26AM (#50218361)
> Are you sure people like the modern web?

People will often claim to dislike something, even though they would dislike the alternative even more (and they might even be actively choosing against the alternative). Pay more attention to what people’s actions reveal than what they claim.

(This happens not just in tech.)

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by pwdisswordfishq on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:56AM (#50219126)
In other news, anyone who has ever claimed to want to quit smoking is lying.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by no-name-here on Saturday October 24, 2026 @06:46AM (#50220004)
I guess the far closer(/better?) analogy would be something like people saying they dislike the ad-supported model for newspaper websites, YouTube, etc. However, many of those sites offer (or even heavily promote) options to get rid of the ads. (A number of the highest-regarded newspapers still even offer print versions too.)
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by cowlevel on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:12AM (#50222048)
YouTube is currently getting sued because if you pay to remove ads you still get ads
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by olyjohn on Saturday October 24, 2026 @05:40PM (#50225637)
I don't think they do. They've been taught to use Apps because all of the web-versions of popular things have been crippled and broken.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by BoxwoodSeed on Friday October 23, 2026 @04:45PM (#50215084)
People do? I loathe the modern web.

Give me a https://motherfuckingwebsite.com/ instead.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by pwdisswordfishq on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:02AM (#50219150)
I would take a page refresh that takes two seconds over waiting half a minute for a page to "hydrate"
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by saltcured on Friday October 23, 2026 @03:13PM (#50213967)
To be fair, Java applets and the Flash plugin socialized that before Javascript tried to walk us back from the edge just a bit.

And before that, whatever Microsoft "macro" or embedded code variant was popular that week in all those document formats...

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by JKCalhoun on Friday October 23, 2026 @09:56AM (#50209065)
Perhaps the web was more secure when it wasn't running anything—just serving up static web pages?
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by vanviegen on Friday October 23, 2026 @01:35PM (#50212590)
Sure. It was also a lot less functional.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by preg_match on Friday October 23, 2026 @04:54PM (#50215189)
Kind of, but in practice not really. Sure, something like a photo editor would never be possible in Web 1.0.

But 99% of web applications are forms and displaying stuff. All JS accomplished is making it look prettier and enhanced tracking.

I mean, Facebook, my bank, Amazon… these can all be created with no client side code. It would be a lot of refreshes, but it can be done.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by __MatrixMan__ on Friday October 23, 2026 @06:01PM (#50215964)
A declarative approach would go a long way. Like, I'm not evaluating restaurants on the basis of their website quality, so why not have a restaurant browser and they can all just expose data according to some common schema. Same this with banks. Same thing with most things.

If you want a wildly interactive art experience, just load the appropriate browser for that.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by pwdisswordfishq on Saturday October 24, 2026 @04:14AM (#50219206)
Because restaurants don't want businesses like DoorFash to scrape it.
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by __MatrixMan__ on Saturday October 24, 2026 @11:00AM (#50221923)
Is that at all effective? If you want the data to be publicly available, you have no choice but to make it publicly available. Whatever inconvenience a heavily JavaScript experience can add to motivated scrapers is just not significant.

I think it's just a keeping-up-with-the-jonses sort of thing: If the restaurant down the street has a flashy website then I guess we need one too. Having restaurants in competition over the quality if their website is a negative sum game because it distracts them from the food.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by no-name-here on Saturday October 24, 2026 @01:53AM (#50218647)
> I mean, Facebook, my bank, Amazon… these can all be created with no client side code. It would be a lot of refreshes, but it can be done.

HN could too - perhaps the biggest use on HN is not refreshing when up (or down) voting something. YouTube could do something similar - refreshing when 'liking' a video or getting more comments. But would you really find those to be a better experience for you? Even on actions that HN does refresh on, such as 'Next page', or submitting a comment, HN doesn't freeze sorts, so posts and/or comments you didn't see will often invisibly end up before the new location HN sent you to (or posts/comments you already saw earlier in the list now showing up "again" later in the list).

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by lloeki on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:15AM (#50218958)
You can have the buttons in iframes and have that POST and refresh.

Not saying that's exactly what should be done, but an example that there may be another way than full-on generic code execution wrapping XHR.

Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by no-name-here on Saturday October 24, 2026 @03:36AM (#50219040)
Ah, so I guess the idea is that this page (with its ~200 comments) would have ~200 iframes added to it?
Re:Is this the new cyber normal? by lloeki on Monday October 26, 2026 @06:44AM (#50241730)
As an experiment to prove the idea holds water by making it work today with existing tech, yes.

As what an actual, safe, efficient implementation, of course not.

The point is there could have been a "dynamic HTML" alternate timeline where you could have had interactive pages for 90% of use cases without executing full blown generic computation arbitrary code on the client device.

But worse is better won and now we get insane trackers and cryptominers at every turn because the web can't degrade to exist without JS massaging DOMs.