News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by vjvjvjvjghv on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @07:52PM (#49824309)
France doesn't have an answer for decommissioning costs.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by himata4113 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @08:21PM (#49824556)
technically speaking they don't have to be decomissioned and when they absolutely have to be I believe at that point we will have fusion which is only 10 years away.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by adrianN on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @11:09PM (#49825741)
There is no reason to assume that fusion will be a particularly cheap power source.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by stingraycharles on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @08:27PM (#49824602)
Fusion has been 10 years away for the past 3 decades.

(I think fusion is great, by the way, but I just don’t believe any timelines at this point anymore)

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by himata4113 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @08:58PM (#49824832)
That was infact the joke, but surely by the time this would need to be decomissioned we would have fusion power right? Some reactors we operate today are older than the oldest people on the planet!
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by sarchertech on Thursday September 24, 2026 @12:03AM (#49826117)
>Some reactors we operate today are older than the oldest people on the planet!

That is not correct.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by mikestew on Thursday September 24, 2026 @12:46AM (#49826358)
Some reactors we operate today are older than the oldest people on the planet!

You might want to look that up, because I’m older than the oldest operating reactor.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by vjvjvjvjghv on Thursday September 24, 2026 @04:42AM (#49827942)
My mom is older than any reactor that’s used for power generation.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by fuzztester on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @10:33PM (#49825508)
like zeno's paradox(es).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeno_of_Elea

i like how he died. guts.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by fuzztester on Thursday September 24, 2026 @11:24PM (#49839851)
some dumbkopf hners can't even handle historical stories and simple straightforward comments on them, so they downvote.

and yet they aspire to run or work in startups. ... hee hee.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by Propelloni on Thursday September 24, 2026 @01:49AM (#49826705)
I see what you did there :D Good one, thank you!
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by rightnutwingjob on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @09:34PM (#49825093)
What are these decommissioning costs?

The reactor vessel and the primary coolant loop.

All that steel can be vitrified and stored in stainless casks somewhere fairly indefinitely.

Or just buried. It doesn’t stay reactive very long.

The rest of the site is no different to any other electricity generator, and no different really to the average industrial manufacturing plant.

Everyone likes to just say ”decommissioning costs”, without actually thinking about what any of that means.

It’s not like every nuclear power site is a Chernobyl.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by rich_sasha on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @10:53PM (#49825649)
I remember reading about coal-fired power plants specifically in Poland, which exceed the radioactivity levels for nuclear plants. This because the burnt-off coal contains small amounts of radioactive elements, which form particles and drop off near the flue.

But of course there are no norms for max radioactivity levels at a coal power plant site.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by teamonkey on Thursday September 24, 2026 @04:57AM (#49828035)
Coal plants spread radioactivity because it concentrates all the radioactive elements naturally found in the coal into ash, much of which then gets released into the air, deposited on surfaces and breathed in, which is extremely harmful.

But if decommissioned properly, most of the ash inside the building can be collected and mixed into soil and bricks at a safe concentration not far above background radiation level.

In a nuclear power plant, there is no release of radioactive materials, but it’s possible for parts of the structure to absorb radiation and become radioactive itself, and that’s much harder to deal with.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by leonidasrup on Thursday September 24, 2026 @04:00AM (#49827645)
Steel is not vitrified, only high level nuclear waste - spend nuclear fuel with highly radioactive fission products.

Steel is taken apart and measured, non-activated steel can be melted down and recycled. Activated steel has to go into storage, either low level nuclear or medium level nuclear waste.

The biggest concern for steel is cobalt. During manufacturing steel with very low cobalt content is usually used for nuclear applications, but there is still small amount of cobalt.

In reactor, under neutron radiation, stable cobalt-59 changes to cobalt-60, strong gamma ray emitter with a half-life of 5 years. So neutron activated steel has to storage for at least few decades.

When done not properly, this is a health hazard.

" Circa 1983, construction was finished of 1700 apartments in Taiwan which were built with steel contaminated with cobalt-60. About 10,000 people occupied these buildings during a 9–20 year period. On average, these people unknowingly received a radiation dose of 0.4 Sv. Some studies have found that this large group did not suffer a higher incidence of cancer mortality, as the linear no-threshold model would predict, but suffered a lower cancer mortality than the general Taiwan public. These observations support the radiation hormesis model, however other studies have found health impacts that confound the results. "

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobalt-60#Steel_contamination

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by account42 on Thursday September 24, 2026 @07:19AM (#49829053)
They have to be stored but storage isn't particularly difficult. Just don't built them into a structure where to close to people.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by leonidasrup on Thursday September 24, 2026 @10:12AM (#49830911)
They are similar to many other landfills.

" The four low-level waste facilities in the U.S. are Barnwell, South Carolina; Richland, Washington; Clive, Utah; and as of June 2013, Andrews County, Texas. "

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-level_waste

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by atwrk on Thursday September 24, 2026 @06:12AM (#49828527)
Have a look at this nuclear plant in Northern Germany that is in the process of being decomissioned since 1995. It's still not finished, suspected end date is now in the 2040s and is now projected to cost about 10B €. For a single plant.

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kernkraftwerk_Greifswald (you have to translate that page yourself, the English version doesn't contain the relevant information)

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by account42 on Thursday September 24, 2026 @07:16AM (#49829035)
Surely that's not because the people in power - the same people who have pushed trhough the decommissioning of these still functioning power plants - are want them to be expensive to decomission because it suits their agenda. Decomissioning costs can always be however high you want them to be but that doesn't mean that they have to be. Worst case you can just encase the whole thing in concrete until radiation levels naturally drop.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by atwrk on Thursday September 24, 2026 @08:21AM (#49829634)
Did you honestly just invent a conspiracy about some unnamed people with a hidden agenda of making nuclear look expensive by paying 10B euros for decommissioning a working plant?

Just a suggestion, but alternatively you could also accept that in reality, decomissioning actually is expensive.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by rightnutwingjob on Friday September 25, 2026 @01:52AM (#49840609)
It’s not really that much of a stretch to think this is exactly what is going on.

One state in Australia, Victoria, recently disappeared $15 billion of public funds to criminal organisations under the guise of funding a big infrastructure project.

Okay, that’s not entirely accurate. No one knows how much money disappeared, it could be up to $30 billion.

Labor-Green governments do this everywhere.

It’s entirely reasonable to suspect something similar is going on in Germany around their nuclear decommissioning.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by tialaramex on Friday September 25, 2026 @05:54AM (#49842297)
> Labor-Green governments do this everywhere

I suppose your name ("rightnutwingjob") gives it away but "Did you know crooks exist" isn't actually a proof that grand conspiracies are true.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by wolvoleo on Thursday September 24, 2026 @06:25AM (#49828622)
Yes, a lot of that is just waiting for the active parts to get less 'hot' though. But yes it's incredibly expensive and it's only going to get more so as we start caring more about pollution and proliferation.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by oatmeal1 on Wednesday September 23, 2026 @11:32PM (#49825913)
I saw a DW Planet A documentary about decommissioning a nuclear plant in Germany. They walked around the plant in some safety gear, but with their faces fully exposed and no breathing apparatus. They said the project was decades behind schedule and it was costing ten times as much as expected. The decommissioning process involved spraying water and gels on slightly radioactive materials from the factory to reduce their radioactivity to effectively zero. The process created much more radioactive material than there was in the first place, which then itself had to be dealt with. The cost of decommissioning is determined by the lobbyists for the companies that do the decommissioning. Voters have no idea what decommissioning should cost, and no one will ever question going over budget. It's a great business.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QKIaRg3SdTw

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by Moldoteck on Thursday September 24, 2026 @03:03AM (#49827218)
Now check how decommissioning is going with Isar reactors instead of soviet ones
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by Black616Angel on Thursday September 24, 2026 @04:46AM (#49827970)
Would you like to provide some context?
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by Moldoteck on Thursday September 24, 2026 @05:04AM (#49828076)
The context is that all german reactors that aren't experimental or soviet are decommissioned on operators money without state financing.

The example of isar is particularly interesting - isar 2 is one of the latest that started decommissioning but is in much more advanced state vs others. Each operator does it as they wish. If you wait a bit more, rad levels drop so it's easier to decommission with less specialized equipment

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by tancop on Thursday September 24, 2026 @12:45AM (#49826355)
Just declare that LNT is wrong and treat materials as non radioactive if they are less than half the radiation level associated with cancer. For the rest you can try and reuse them in new reactors if possible or store it in the same place as other nuclear waste.
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by mrngld on Thursday September 24, 2026 @08:02AM (#49829463)
We've got the technology to drill deep bore holes, kilometers below where water will move on any time relevant to human existence, where we could stick what small amounts of dangerous material is left.

Encapsulating the waste and burying it somewhere on an abyssal plain in the deep ocean should also be a pretty low-risk approach, the IAEA has looked into variations of that.

Like someone else said, I think it's all expensive because some people want it to be.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by Moldoteck on Thursday September 24, 2026 @03:02AM (#49827206)
Why people spread such bullshit statements? Take Germany which enacted EARLY phaseout, yet all it's reactors are decommissioned on operator money except experimental and soviet units
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by leonidasrup on Thursday September 24, 2026 @03:29AM (#49827423)
" EDF Group assumes sole financial responsibility for decommissioning power plants. The cost is factored into operation from the start and included in the price of the kilowatt-hour. It is re-assessed every three years to take account of changing technical and financial assumptions, as required by law. "

https://www.edf.fr/en/the-edf-group/producing-a-climate-frie...

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by ZeroGravitas on Thursday September 24, 2026 @04:54AM (#49828015)
The 100% state owned EDF group take sole responsibility for the finances? What a relief for the taxpayers of France...

But at least the cost is factored in from the start. Those costs often double during construction but at least we know the decommissioning costs are factored into the fake numbers they use to get approval to start builds.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by leonidasrup on Thursday September 24, 2026 @05:40AM (#49828323)
Taxpayers of UK are supporting wind energy producers using CfDs (Contracts for Difference).

UK Eighth Allocation Round are from 20 July to 7 August 2026, Offshore wind £113 /MWh, Onshore wind (>5 MW) £92/MWh

UK Government also awarded a CfD to Hinkley Point C nuclear power station, set at £92.50/MWh for a 35 year period.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contracts_for_Difference_(UK_e...

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by ZeroGravitas on Thursday September 24, 2026 @05:54AM (#49828416)
You've quoted strike prices at the time, adjusted for inflation Hinckley is the most expensive of the three you quote. And it lasts nearly twice as long.

In fact this nuclear plant was the first use of CfD.

It's a great scheme because it (in theory) prevents cost blowouts being added to energy prices. Good incentives to get things built quickly and cheaply.

The actual price for Hinclkey is roughly a third higher than the CfD and that extra cost should be borne by the French taxpayers via EDF.

In reality they shifted some costs onto the next nuclear plant instead, working around the CfD and foisting the excess costs back onto the British tax/billpayer.

Obviously they refused to use CfD for the next UK nuclear plant because unlike wind power, they have no faith in it being completed anywhere near on budget. And if they bid the real cost it wouldn't get built in the first place.

So now UK taxpayers are paying in advance for a decade to get new nuclear built with no cap on cost.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by tialaramex on Friday September 25, 2026 @05:28AM (#49842109)
> You've quoted strike prices at the time

Technically I think the Hinkley prices are what we'd call £2012 [if we could easily write a subscript here I would use that for 2012] that is, they are prices in the Pound Sterling as it was at some fixed point in the year 2012 and so when paid in the CfD contract they'd be adjusted for inflation.

All the early CfD prices were in £2012, whereas those newer CfDs have strike prices in £2024 which is about 40% more money in real terms. You can see this notation in the linked Wiki page.

So, if we adjust all the prices to £2024 that price for Hinkley is about £130 per MWh whereas Solar farms are £75, onshore Wind is £92, off-shore Wind is £113

Except, that's not really what's going on either because those AR8 prices are what's called "Administrative Strike Prices". AR8 like all the other allocation rounds is a reverse auction whose results we won't know for months, and those are the start prices in the auction, if you want to win and you're not the only bidder you will need to come lower. Maybe your competitor says they can do solar for £72, but you stared at your loan sheet and projected sunlight over the next decade and dared to say £71.50, you win that contract. But the strike price is now £71.50 not £75 per MWh. Your competitor might still build their solar farm, but at market prices not the guaranteed £71.50 per MWh you've contracted for. Maybe they get lucky - this summer the CfD "subsidy" for Solar farms paid us back many millions of pounds, because electricity prices were high and the subsidy is effectively a fixed price. Of course this doesn't cancel the hundreds of millions we spend subsidising Drax, but that's a completely different discussion.

Edited to add: Just like a conventional auction there may be no bidders at the start price. Unlike some low stakes auctions you might have seen in person or on TV they don't offer again with a better price, the auction just fails. This happened for offshore wind in AR5 a few years back, the government wanted to pay no more than £44 per MWh in £2012 for offshore wind energy -- cheaper than solar, so the firms who build wind farms looked at their costs and said "No thanks" and there were zero bids that round, and a subsequent government increased the ASP for AR6 wind and got bids at much more realistic prices.

Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by schainks on Thursday September 24, 2026 @03:41AM (#49827497)
And the world leaders don't have an answer for the cost to keep our atmosphere habitable due to using fossil fuels as hard as possible?
Re:Italian parliament votes for return to nuclear energy by MentalM on Thursday September 24, 2026 @07:35AM (#49829214)
> using fossil fuels as hard as possible?

All the data showing that it is still free. There is no cost, generally anthropogenic climate change is increasing the habitability of our atmosphere.