News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by A_D_E_P_T on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:21AM (#49683194)
> Their results favour a scenario in which the young Sun engulfed a super-Earth around 5–10 times the mass of Earth

Given the state of the early solar system, it would be surprising if the Sun didn't swallow a lot of metallic and carbonaceous rocks and pebbles. But it seems unclear to me how the researchers would distinguish between one super-Earth and >10^10 smaller rocks? Chemically I feel the two would be largely the same.

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by cfiggers on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:23AM (#49683209)
That's easy, they'll check whether there's one big fingerprint vs >10^10 little tiny fingerprints and conclude accordingly \j
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by amelius on Sunday September 13, 2026 @09:35AM (#49683858)
Not if the EU has a say about it. Those rocks and pebbles have a right to privacy and fingerprinting is off the table.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by snovv_crash on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:09PM (#49685559)
You sound bitter about this.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by hydrogen7800 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @09:44AM (#49683945)
>But it seems unclear to me how the researchers would distinguish between one super-Earth and >10^10 smaller rocks?

I have a similar feeling when life on earth is suggested to be "alien", arriving via debris in the solar system as the earth formed. Isn't everything in the solar system coalesced from the same debris?

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by tracerbulletx on Sunday September 13, 2026 @12:10PM (#49685573)
That always felt like a deus ex machina answer to me too. We don't know exactly how abiogenesis happened on earth so some people just like to cut off the chain of causation with the idea of, "it was seeded"... but then how did abiogenesis happen elsewhere?

I don't think that's a very popular theory among anyone who knows what they're talking though.

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by dredmorbius on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:36PM (#49688416)
A hypothesis I'd seen (from the "aliens" guy, Abraham "Avi" Loeb, at Harvard) is that early in the evolution of the Universe everything was roughly in the Goldilocks zone (warm enough for liquid water, not so hot as to generate steam, not so cold as to result in ice), and ... more dense. If life more-or-less inevitably arises under such circumstances, then there's some credence to the argument that life might have arisen in many parts of the Universe, potentially hybernating in some sort of spore / inactive form, until rocky planets arose later. But we have no specific proof of this, and it seems strongly plausible that life could instead have arisen independently on individual planets and/or moons.

See this thread: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37850997>.

From which:

Kurzgesagt did a video on the concept: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOiGEI9pQBs>.

Avi Loeb, "The habitable epoch of the early Universe". International Journal of Astrobiology, vol. 13, 4."

<https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journa...>

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by jojobas on Sunday September 13, 2026 @09:50AM (#49684019)
The life-bearing debris would have to arrive quite some time after formation of Earth, as it was molten. Surviving atmospheric entry is hard, surviving after landing in lava is impossible.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by hydrogen7800 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:15AM (#49684260)
I was going to expand on my comment about the difference between alien and non-alien being a difference only in time. It's all from the same stuff.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by post-it on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:32AM (#49684434)
It makes a difference to our understanding of the conditions under which life can form.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by BurningFrog on Sunday September 13, 2026 @05:50PM (#49689074)
If life-bearing debris exists, it would surely be floating around the galaxy forever.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by ahazred8ta on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:03PM (#49686769)
Same thing with people who naively believe that amino acids can only be formed in space and can only be brought to Earth in asteroids, as opposed to forming *ON* Earth.

Our current best guess is a geothermal vent in a high phosphorus 'soda lake' like the one in Canada. https://www.science.org/content/article/unusual-soda-lakes-m...

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by jjk166 on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:04PM (#49686788)
Well if we found current or fossil life with a common ancestor on other bodies it would certainly demonstrate that it arrived via debris; whereas if we find life with no common ancestor or find no evidence of life at all that would reject the hypothesis. It wouldn't necessarily answer which body was the original birthplace, but for the purposes of modelling, whether life happened to start here is a much less impactful question than whether life had to start here. If all life here started here, then life had to develop quickly; if we could potentially descend from stuff in the pre-solar system debris field that could add billions of years to the clock, and makes interstellar panspermia highly plausible.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by bell-cot on Sunday September 13, 2026 @09:29AM (#49683787)
This, but how do they rule out the extra stuff landing in the sun much earlier - when the solar system was still a pre-solar nebula, and which bits would end up where (sun vs. planets vs. whatever) was far from settled?
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by omnicognate on Sunday September 13, 2026 @08:26AM (#49683241)
> Researchers also found that such a world could survive its passage through the Sun's outer layers while losing very little mass, which suggests that planets may leave detectable fingerprints inside their host stars long after they have disappeared.

So I guess the large size would have permitted it to smuggle stuff into the core that would have just vaporised in the corona if carried by many smaller objects?

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by monster_truck on Sunday September 13, 2026 @10:06AM (#49684155)
Sounds reasonable to me.

But also what the fuck happens to the core of such a planet when that happens?

We aren't actually sure what gave our core the spin it has, right? I'm not fully awake yet but I think it's plain where I'm going with this.

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by andrewflnr on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:30PM (#49686368)
It's not plain to me where you're going. But the answer about the core of a planet engulfed by the sun is that it vaporizes eventually, just not right away.
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by frutiger on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:00PM (#49686736)
> We aren't actually sure what gave our core the spin it has, right?

We are, it’s from the conservation of angular momentum. The material that made our planet also had a non-zero angular momentum.

Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by monster_truck on Sunday September 13, 2026 @04:05PM (#49688117)
No we aren't. That's a theory that barely fits the lower bound of what we estimate the spin of the core to be
Re:'Fingerprints' inside the Sun could reveal if it once swa... by andrewflnr on Sunday September 13, 2026 @01:27PM (#49686334)
I don't fully follow (not being an astrophysicist), but it seems like the depth of the metallic material within the star matters a lot for their model. A planet can "bury" it (their word) a lot deeper than small rocks by physically sinking in before it gets destroyed. Sections 4.2 and 4.5 (among others I assume) in the actual paper linked above talk about this stuff.