News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by martythemaniak on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @10:47PM (#4946195)
Pretty much proving today's field of Economics to be a bunch of quackery.

In every respectable field of study there are certain basic scientific expectations - supporting your positions with evidence and data, reversing your views when your theory has been disproved etc. At the onset of the 2008 crisis, some people very accurately predicted the type of crisis it was (a financial panic) and recommended policies that were tested and proven to work. The mainstream camp however, thought otherwise and most of the world followed their advice.

With 4 years of data we now know who was right and who was wrong, and yet that has done almost nothing in the field of Economics. Few high profile economists have reversed their deeply flawed views and the views of those baked by data and correct predictions are still not taken seriously. It's as if the LHC found the Higgs, yet most physicists still denying it exists - the situation really is THAT absurd.

Economics is deeply corrupted by politics and the financial interests of its practitioners. If the quacks and charlatans aren't purged soon, the either field will be discredited. You can't practice alchemy or voodoo and expect people to treat you like a scientist.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by brc on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:54AM (#4946596)
Indeed it is odd that many people can agree the best way forwards for GM was to give the shareholders a total loss and the bondholders a severe haircut. But when it comes time for a country to do the same thing - everyone disagrees and says what is needed is for the original bondholders to be made whole by issuing new debt. There is not some miracle line where obvious solutions jump over to being wrong based on size. Defaulting on payments is a scalable strategy, from the underwater home owner to the overly-indebted bank to the hopelessly over-borrowed national government. It's not pleasant for anyone involved, but confronting the problem is far better than trying to sweep it under the carpet.

There has arisen a pervasive myth that only debtors should lose when creditors are unable to keep a loan performing. For sure, the rights of the creditor exceed that of the debtor, but it's plain wrong to expect a creditor not to suffer losses when extensive bad loans are found.

The problem is that, by being locked into the Euro, Ireland was unable to use the shock-absorber of a floating exchange rate. People rightly dumped their Icelandic currency, because they got burnt. The Icelandic people lost a lot of wealth. The Icelandic government rightly stripped the banks of their independence. But now the decks are cleared and people can get back to working and being productive, and getting their economy growing again.

Why people will continue to insist that the best measure for an indebted government is to borrow more money and hope for a miracle of growth to fix the payments is beyond me.

The only result from drunkenness is a hangover. You can resume drinking to postpone the symptoms, but they will always arrive, and the further you push it out, the worse it gets.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by justincormack on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:37AM (#4946794)
Ireland is in the EU and it was the EU that apparently decided that losses for senior bank debt holders were not going to happen. This is because of externalities it would probably have bankrupted most banks due to increased borrowing costs and upset the cosy setup where most government debt is funded by banks in southern Europe. But it was not Ireland's problem and Ireland should have made other countries pay to bail out the bond holders.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by disgruntledphd2 on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:10AM (#4946967)
Ah now, that is somewhat true and also somewhat false.

I lived in Ireland for most of this period, and really what caused the problem was the blanket bank guarentee which was introduced against the advice of Goldman Sachs. More specifically, the attempt to save a bank known then as Anglo Irish Bank (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo_Irish_Bank).

Now, Anglo Irish really only lent for construction development, and were majorly tied up with the ruling political party of the time, Fianna Fail.

This bank was not systematically important, but they were politically important. The government put approx 30 bn into this bank, and tried to pass it off as a loan. Eurostat, quite rightly said no, you'll never get this money back, and ordered Ireland to count it as debt in 2010. This spiked the irish debt levels, spooked the markets and led to the bailout of Ireland by the IMF and EU.

The worst part is, even though the agreement with these external bodies was to cut costs everywhere (in profession such as law, accountancy and medicine) the brunt of the cuts have so far fallen on poor people.

If one could go back to September 2008, a blanket guarenetee had not been issued and Anglo had been allowed to go bust, then ireland would be in a very different position.

That being said, Irish people appear to be taking austerity quite well, and given the demographics, will probably recover over the next ten years. This all could have been avoided, and while the EU certainly didn't want banks to fail, the majority of the problems were caused by Irish political corruption.

The worst part is, the party responsible for this will be back in power within ten years, where they will have a fourth shot at bankrupting the country. Ireland, my country, has serious issues with stupid governance which is mostly disguised by the willingness of the people to work hard and ignore the stupidity.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eliasmacpherson on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:56AM (#4947066)
https://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0716/banks-business.html

It was Merrill Lynch, not Goldman Sachs. Goldman Sachs role in the guarantee is murky, several ex members of their staff have been associated with the events, e.g. Geithner, who it is claimed torpedoed efforts to default on bank debt.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by patrickk on Thursday December 20, 2012 @06:58AM (#4947229)
Timothy Geithner really screwed Ireland. He was probably under a lot of pressure to maintain the illusion that banking debt was more secure than it actually was in that time period (along with his colleagues in the ECB), but it was still no excuse for the Irish Government to bow to the external pressure. My generation will be paying for this mistake for decades. The correct move was to "do an Iceland" and wipe out the unsustainable bank debt.

Here's one article (not the best source but there are others available):

http://www.irishcentral.com/story/roots/the_american_in_irel...

And another: http://www.businessinsider.com/morgan-kelly-irish-default-20...

And here's the story of how a dodgy deal lead to the former (now deceased) Irish Minister of Finance enacting the blanket bank guarantee (this single meeting is the reason the country is so screwed):

http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2011/03/michael-...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by chalst on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:02AM (#4946950)
Ireland really could have chosen to let some banks fail. There was a lot of pressure from countries that were trying to pretend their banking sectors were healthier than they were (esp. Germany), but several people then on the Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee (e.g., Willem Buiter) said it was a mistake for Ireland to guarantee all creditors.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by patrickk on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:04AM (#4947243)
> Ireland really could have chosen to let some banks fail.

And the funny thing is the Irish Government still could wipe out the bank bondholders (with no repercussions apart from a ding to our credit rating for a few years).

The real issue is they lack the political will to look bad to the EC, ECB and Merkel. It's a fucking joke. The Irish taxpayer will be paying for this disaster for decades. If we didn't have the sovereign debt burden, the country would be doing pretty ok, as exports in Ireland are doing reasonably well given the anemic global economy.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 20, 2012 @04:34AM (#4946887)
There has arisen a pervasive myth that only debtors should lose when creditors are unable to keep a loan performing. For sure, the rights of the creditor exceed that of the debtor, but it's plain wrong to expect a creditor not to suffer losses when extensive bad loans are found.

I would say: morally, the creditor has greater rights, but economically, the debtor must have greater rights. When a guarantee exists that creditors will always be made whole no matter what must be done, debt-slavery becomes possible and profitable.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by mpweiher on Thursday December 20, 2012 @06:07AM (#4947094)
Interest rates should then also be fixed to central bank AAA rates...no risk, no fun.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by paulsutter on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:39AM (#4946431)
Could someone help me out why this Middlebrow Dismissive Comment has been voted up? It contains no information, takes no position, and merely lobs cynical derision at everyone.

Marty's other comment in this thread was cogent and interesting, comparing Iceland's actions to earlier crises Sweden and Argentina. But this comment, useless.

What am I missing here?

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eupharis on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:57AM (#4946475)
It makes a great deal of statements, and does take positions. Factual positions no less. For example:

"At the onset of the 2008 crisis, some people very accurately predicted the type of crisis it was (a financial panic) and recommended policies that were tested and proven to work."

Position taken. Factual assertion made. Is this true or false?

"The mainstream camp however, thought otherwise and most of the world followed their advice."

Position taken. Factual assertion made. Is this true or false?

"With 4 years of data we now know who was right and who was wrong"

Position taken. Factual assertion made. Is this true or false?

"Few high profile economists have reversed their deeply flawed views and the views of those baked by data and correct predictions are still not taken seriously. "

Position taken. Factual assertion made. Is this true or false?

"Economics is deeply corrupted by politics and the financial interests of its practitioners."

Position taken. Factual assertion made. Is this true or false?

Everything I have seen over the past few years indicates to me his assertions are true. In particular the case of Iceland and Ireland.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by paulsutter on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:05AM (#4946490)
"some people" recommended "policies that were tested and proven to work"? -- What people, what policies? What position has been taken?

"mainstream camp thought otherwise" - otherwise to what?

"and followed their advice" - Really? So how is it that Ireland and the US and Iceland all responded very differently, if everyone followed the same flawed advice?

"we know who was right and wrong" - Much to my own surprise, we see that most of the solutions have worked to some degree, and the widely predicted great disaster has not occurred. Really the jury is still out.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by kds on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:37AM (#4946793)
There is a book, "Freefall: America, Free Markets, and the Sinking of the World Economy"(2010), by Joseph Stiglitz - an economist of Nobel prize fame and former Chief Economist of the World Bank, who very early saw the coming of the global crisis and was laughed at in 2005-2006 for his opinion, esp. at a then held Davos summit.

In his book he elaborates deeply - but accessibly for "laymen" - what went wrong, how it could be fixed, but against whose interests in US the ideal public policy solution would have been, and so why just a dubious set of half-measures were taken, by whom, and how it might all worsen as situation in the near future.

So far, for the period from 2010 to 2012, what he claims and predicts seems right and rings true to me.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by ChuckMcM on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:32AM (#4946559)
Well the writing is somewhat turgid in its use of nominalizations and the passive voice but that really doesn't mean its saying nothing. It just makes it a bit harder to read.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by michaelt on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:21AM (#4947556)
When I read martythemaniak's comment with its talk of "some people", "the mainstream camp" and "high profile economists" it's unclear who these groups are.

Monetarists? Keynesians? Advocates of lower government spending? Advocates of tax increases to cut government debt? Or tax cuts to spur growth? Advocates of higher government spending? Spending on bailouts? Countercyclical government spending on infrastructure projects? Academic economists at universities, who don't put their money where their mouth is? Big city financiers, who got us into this mess? Government economist-politicians, who have to be perpetually upbeat to try to keep the market confident? 'The Stock Market' which isn't even a person? Bloggers and columnists? Advocates of lower interest rates? Higher interest rates? Republicans? Democrats?

Needless to say, as I didn't know who was being talked about I couldn't derive much meaning from martythemaniak's comment.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by ChuckMcM on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:49PM (#4949230)
I don't disagree with you, it is a sloppy way to write, but quite common when the writer has a lot of emotion and not a lot of patience to go cite the specific conversations.

So lets take one example and work through it, martythemaniak's wrote:

"At the onset of the 2008 crisis, some people very accurately predicted the type of crisis it was (a financial panic) and recommended policies that were tested and proven to work."

Using the search terms "Iceland Bank Reform" lead me to a whitepaper [1] from Mercatus which goes into great detail about the controversy around the decision to eliminate debt, it cites several economists and papers, both from the time period and the present looking back. A similar search for "Ireland banking crisis" leads to a similar set of papers where people discuss how to pull Ireland out of the mud.

So what does this say about Marty's writing style? and our reading of it? Well it says Marty throws out his emotional angst over this (perhaps he advocated the debt canceling path for Ireland, I don't know) with his comment that "some people" recommended things known to work, clearly at least a few of those people were advising the Icelandic government as they implemented those ideas. If we're engaged readers we do our own legwork, we can attach names to those people. It's more work for us, and perhaps less satisfying that way.

The comment was accused of not saying "anything" when in fact it did say things. What it did not do was to lay out evidence for the claims made, Further, the use of the passive voice made pulling out the information which would help the reader research the claims more difficult.

So there are at least three things going on here, one an emotional rant from someone who believed in strategies that Iceland implemented, but were widely criticized in other economies, feeling vindicated. Second, a quickly thrown together narrative about the tunnel vision which lead to this situation. And finally, a turgid writing style which imposes an unnecessary burden on the reader trying to understand the meaning or substance behind the rant.

[1] http://mercatus.org/publication/iceland-and-ireland-banking-...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by rictic on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:22AM (#4946755)
Perhaps to someone sufficiently well versed in the field and its recent history, including who said what and when, the innuendo could be clearly read. I'd venture to guess that most readers could not; I certainly couldn't.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eupharis on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:31AM (#4946558)
Good. Now we are getting somewhere. I too would love it if OP (or I guess in this case OC) elaborated on these points.

EDIT: Ok I see we are both editing the temper down some ;) I will refrain from my other comments, which were rather unhelpful.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by anigbrowl on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:09AM (#4946498)
Don't quit your day job. Style is no substitute for substance.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by forgottenpaswrd on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:02AM (#4947238)
"Could someone help me out why this Middlebrow Dismissive Comment has been voted up?"

Because is it a view obviously shared by a lot of the smart people in HN.

"It contains no information, takes no position, and merely lobs cynical derision at everyone."

It contains information: That people in the economics field had been corrupted by politics and financial interest, witch is absolutely true.

Money mainly from financial elites goes to fund elite Universities in the US, and so most Ph. D need to think in a certain way for getting their position, the people that control central banks need to lie and deceive every single day, and even the Nobel price of Economics is a farce, created by central banks in order to influence people into believing their propaganda economics is scientific.

Look at the "memorial" in the name. It is not a real Nobel price as so many real scientist Nobel price winners have complained about. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Memorial_Prize_in_Economi...

I know quite a few good economists, but none of them are in great positions of power. If they are they act like really stupid ones(because they have to, if they know something is going to lose value they can't talk about it), so people that believe in them and lose most of their savings are angry at them, what is completely understandable.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by S4M on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:59AM (#4947071)
So after the Middlebrow Dismissive Comments we gonna have the Middlebrow Dismissive Comment alerts? Would it be dismissive, the GP was at least about the article, while your comment (and so mine) simply spoils the discussion.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by mcantelon on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:48AM (#4946455)
It would indicate that others share his lack of faith in mainstream Western economics.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by nl on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @11:53PM (#4946332)
There are two groups of economists: scientists who predicted that austerity wouldn't work and would make things worse, and quarks (aka the Chicago school) who recommended it.

In most areas of science bad ideas don't disappear, it is just that those who support them die and ideas with some evidentiary support become the new norm.

After the response to the 70's oil shocks economists knew that austerity didn't work. Unfortunately measures that are known to work are a political minefield, so those "economists" who don't support it get a lot of support from politicians who don't support it either.

In some ways it is similar to evolution or climate change. You can find "scientists" who deny them both. Economics is worse though, because it is so closely tied to politics.

Incidentally, Krugman has been writing about Iceland since 2010[1].

[1] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/06/30/the-icelandic-po...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by brc on Thursday December 20, 2012 @02:05AM (#4946618)
No economist calls themselves a scientist. They call themselves economists.

The term 'austerity' is meant to apply to a government living within its means. These days it is applied to a government with single digit debt growth instead of double-digit growth. Kind of like how eating balanced meals is now called dieting.

It's true that you can avoid unemployment by borrowing money to pay people to dig holes and fill them in again. What is also true is that, without production there is no consumption. Digging up holes and filling them in is not production, ergo, consumption will not rise.

TLDR; J.B. Say was right. Keynes was wrong.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @04:08AM (#4946848)
Nobody knows if Keynes was right - he advocated going into debt during recessions and then paying off the debt in periods of growth. The problem is the way large groups of people vote governments take on debt during recessions... and then take on even more debt during periods of growth.

That is to say, while his prescription may have been sound economically (I doubt it, but let's say it is for the sake of argument), politically it's just an excuse to pile on ever larger debts.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by nl on Thursday December 20, 2012 @09:51AM (#4947955)
The term 'austerity' is meant to apply to a government living within its means.

No, it is meant to apply to a government radically cutting spending during a recession.

It's true that you can avoid unemployment by borrowing money to pay people to dig holes and fill them in again. What is also true is that, without production there is no consumption. Digging up holes and filling them in is not production, ergo, consumption will not rise.

And yet Keynesian stimulus worked in Australia[1]. Australia was able to implement it properly because the Australian economy had run years of surplus budgets prior to the financial crisis.

The jibe about digging holes is disappointing and ignorant. The Australian program involved a one off payment to tax payers for immediate effect (which ended up supporting the retail sector at Christmas time), traditional infrastructure spending on "ready to go" projects (roads etc) for effect in a couple of months and a very large school building program where building usually started 6-9 months after the initial crisis. These programs were production and - more importantly - all supported employment.

TLDR; Keynesian economics works just fine when the government runs expansionary budgets when growth is needed and surpluses when growth is robust.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_fiscal_policy_response...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tankenmate on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:14AM (#4946736)
And yet all the countries that have slashed government spending and backstopped private debt have also taken a nose dive in GDP. Eppur si muove.

TLDR; Keynes advocated government spending on infrastructure (increased collective efficiency) not pointless hole filling.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:53AM (#4947062)
Here is why this government spending recommendation is just a head fake: assuming the economy can be in a functional state at all, it is obviously true that if the government would spend money on the right things, it could create a functional economy. The real problem of economics however is resource allocation, or in this case, what should the government spend the money on. The proponents of government spending don't give any details - they don't solve the problem at all. They just market themselves as prophets by spouting trivial truths (spending money on the right things is good).

You'll answer "spending money on infrastructure" but that is not good enough. Even for roads there is a point when enough is enough (imagine every square meter of the country covered in roads).

To fix the economy, you have to devise a mechanism of efficient resource allocation. Just saying "let the government decide" is not an answer.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:25AM (#4947304)
Put simply, you are outright lying.

Advocates of Keynesian spending advocate its usage for public goods and commons goods, the two known categories where "the government" is clearly more efficient than markets.

Does that mean no decisions remain in the realm of politics and everything turns into a technocratic utopia run by Economics majors? No. But that's because in any case there is no such thing as an apolitical economic policy of any kind. All of it, right down the property laws themselves, is political.

In fact, it's generally the very core of politics.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:29AM (#4947328)
"public goods and commons goods, the two known categories where "the government" is clearly more efficient than markets."

Could you give me a reference for that? I am not an expert in economics, and that claim seems very doubful to me. Unless you are saying governments are good in spending money - yes, they are (getting rid of money, I mean).

The rest of your post, I am not sure what you are going on about. Yes, property laws are political (and some countries famously got rid of them, which for now has to be considered a failure). But what does that have to do with Keynesian spending? Also I admit I am not an expert on Keynes, but I suspect that puts me on par with most other people who have an opinion on it and advocate to just print more money.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:18AM (#4947544)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_goods

The rest of your post, I am not sure what you are going on about. Yes, property laws are political (and some countries famously got rid of them, which for now has to be considered a failure). But what does that have to do with Keynesian spending? Also I admit I am not an expert on Keynes, but I suspect that puts me on par with most other people who have an opinion on it and advocate to just print more money.

Actually, advocating printing money is not a Keynesian position, it's a Modern Monetary Theory position.

But anyway, I'm arguing against your assertion that political decisions cannot and should not be made about the economy.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @09:09AM (#4947748)
I did not make that assertion, what I said is that the advocates of government spending only shift the burden of decision making and don't really propose anything at all. Or in other words, the claim "government spending can fix the economy" is trivially true but useless.

The link about public goods doesn't convince me that government spending on public goods is always the best choice, see example of too many roads.

As for printing money, isn't it kind of equivalent to taking on debt?

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 20, 2012 @11:14AM (#4948396)
what I said is that the advocates of government spending only shift the burden of decision making and don't really propose anything at all.

Of course, advocates of privatization are doing the same thing: shifting the decision-making and not really proposing anything at all. Both markets and governments are voting mechanisms.

Difference is, in a market, the dollars vote, and in a government, the people vote.

Then we have to start talking about the signal/noise ratios of both mechanisms...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:26PM (#4949763)
Markets are a mechanism for allocating resources.

Of course, there is neither the perfect market nor the perfect government.

It seems to me that the potential for abuse is greater in the government, though. There is one vote every x years, and good tracking mechanisms of what is really being done don't exist yet.

Signal/noise - the difference is that in the market, participants can not simply spend other people's money. They have to come up with real money somehow, which might be a pretty strong signal.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tomp on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:20AM (#4946749)
Actually, austerity means the government using a lot of it's money to bail out failing banks and other private institutions and then saying it has no more money for the people and social services.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by othermaciej on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:36AM (#4946563)
Estonia and Latvia are doing pretty well with austerity: <http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-07-19/krugmenistan...;

It's understandable that regular readers of Krugman may not know this since he goes to great pains to deny the obvious on this point.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by mikeyouse on Thursday December 20, 2012 @02:20AM (#4946652)
I think you missed the point of that whole exercise... Latvia and Estonia have tiny, almost insignificant economies, literally smaller than 49/50 US states. The lessons there are clearly not applicable to the US, or if you prefer, policies for the US shouldn't be applied to either of them.

Additionally, they aren't doing "pretty well" with austerity by any honest metric. Even four years after the GFC, their GDPs are still below where they were in 2007/2008, significantly in Latvia's case. Unemployment is extremely high (From 4%/6% in 2007 to 10%/14% today) and wages have fallen.

Where is the success story here?

Lat + Est Unemployment: (https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=z8o7pt6rd5uqa6_...) Lat + Est GDP: (https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&...)

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by othermaciej on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:12AM (#4946733)
Iceland is much smaller than either, yet it is the poster child for this thread.

Using 2007 as the starting year for Latvia and Estonia is kind of cherry picking. See here: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/07/the...

Note that the MR post is polite and humble, and gives fair consideration to both sides of the issue, unlike just about anything written by a certain ny times columnist.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by demallien on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:43AM (#4947635)
Is it cherry-picking? I don't feel that it is. That GDP graph shows a normal moderate growth from 2000 right through to the crash. There was the slightest of upticks in the last year before the crash, but hardly enough to qualify as a boom. Which means that it is entirely fair to categorize Estonia's economic performance as normal just before the crash, and pretty lousy since.

At any rate, I was in Tallinn in June of this year, and the locals I talked to in bars and cafes were all very pessimistic about how the country was going. Maybe pessimism is just a cultural norm, but everyone that I asked felt that Estonia had gone backwards since the crash, and was still doing so...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by othermaciej on Friday December 21, 2012 @04:16AM (#4952065)
If you look at the graph with the longer time horizon, you can see that Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia had stronger growth pre-crisis, a bigger bubble, a bigger collapse from the bubble, and a stronger recovery from the performance trough. Only by measuring by performance from their GDP peak do they look bad, and it's not obvious why this is the natural measure of recovery policies. You would think performance from the trough of the crisis or from some neutral pre-crisis point would be more relevant.

Here is another article with more graphs explaining this point: http://blogs.cfr.org/geographics/2012/07/02/postcrisis/ -- though you will find some debate in the comments.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by narag on Thursday December 20, 2012 @06:43AM (#4947191)
Unemployment is extremely high (From 4%/6% in 2007 to 10%/14% today)

LOL! I wish we had that "extremely high" unemployment in Spain. By the way, we're an even better example of austerity not working.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by bragh on Friday December 21, 2012 @05:34AM (#4952204)
It's not even the real unemployment number, because that unemployment only counts the registed unemployed (who are registered at the Employment Office and receiving financial aid for job-seeking). The actual number of unemployed and people working without taxes is much higher (how much higher, nobody knows).
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:47AM (#4947049)
Yet Krugman derives his ideology from a tiny babysitting ring that didn't print enough money. Even smaller sample than Estonia...
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by brc on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:59AM (#4946608)
I'm glad you were the one to point out that Krugman has become so fixated with denying the obvious that it has become embarrassing. Continually pointing out that Japan hasn't get gone broke isn't much of a defense when their economy - once the envy of the world - has completed two decades of stagnation and shows no signs of recovery.

Had Japan done a Iceland-style cleanout, they would probably be still striking fear into the hearts of governments and corporates everywhere.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by gregsq on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:29AM (#4946777)
Except for one complication. Japan's public debt is largely owed to it's own citizens, such a large proportion being internal debt. Even if they defaulted on the external component, they'd still have a problem of the type Iceland could avoid. Iceland wrote off banking debt, which was something like 70% of their external debt.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by twoodfin on Thursday December 20, 2012 @06:46AM (#4947198)
I don't think the term you want is "write off". Creditors write off debt. Borrowers default.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by gregsq on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:21AM (#4947555)
You're right, my language was imprecise, and I'm conflating two events. The Icelandic government declined to recapitalize failing banks, even when under enormous pressure to do so by the UK government and others. The pressure you may know was partly due to various local government bodies and other institutions having deposits with Icelandic banks.

Because the Icelandic government declined to act as insurer for those deposits, the insolvency of them was seen as an effective write off of national indebtedness to other sovereigns.

Agree it's not the same thing though.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by twoodfin on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:54AM (#4947673)
No problem. I just get worried that people hear about corporations or nations "writing off" debt and wonder why the system is rigged so they can't "write off" their own debts. Of course you can, as long as those debts are owed to you and not by you.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by bragh on Thursday December 20, 2012 @02:33AM (#4946680)
OK, it's true that by some metrics (government debt for example), Estonia is doing pretty well. But Estonia's private sector debt (personal loans) is still over the top and is actually killing the workforce right now. Because of these loans, the wages aren't rising, even though the cost of living is thanks to joining the euro zone. http://statistikaamet.wordpress.com/2011/05/27/eestist-valja... (Estonia's department of statistics blog) has statistics about the year 2010, where the graph shows the most dominant age group of emigrants are men in the age of 25-29 and most people leave the country because of high unemployment. That's men and women leaving in their best working age, most of whom will never return.

So, yeah, Estonia might be doing fine by some short-term metrics, but in the long term austerity measures have done irreparable harm.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by othermaciej on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:14AM (#4946741)
I don't think we have entered the long term yet, so how can you so confidently say what the long term effects are?
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:46AM (#4946581)
Yes, and Japan, the country he's held out as a great Keynesian success in the past, is going over the falls right before our eyes:

http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/12/kyle-bass...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:55AM (#4946471)
>There are two groups of economists: scientists who predicted that austerity wouldn't work and would make things worse, and quarks (aka the Chicago school) who recommended it.

Oh please. The idea that you can spend your way out of debt has been shown to be disastrous over and over, and yet like the Marxist "scientists" before them these Neo-Keynesians are going to claim everything is peachy until even the slowest among us can see they're wrong (and not scientists, either). But like any good faith healer they'll say "You didn't do it hard enough". Does that sound familiar?

In the short run austerity is painful. In the long run it's the only option, and putting off the pain only makes it worse when you're out of options. Either you do it honestly by cutting expenditures, or you do it the normal way by printing money.

The idea you can derive globally applicable lessons from a country the size of Cleveland is a bit daft.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by mpweiher on Thursday December 20, 2012 @04:46AM (#4946907)
"The idea that you can spend your way out of debt has been shown to be disastrous over and over,"

The idea is not that you can spend your way out of debt, that would be silly. The idea is that you can and should spend money to compensate for lack of demand in a recession, because the markets overshoot. Once you are out of recession, you must pay back the debt.

So austerity when the economy is good, spending when it is bad. Anti-cyclical government behavior.

Austerity in a recession is pro-cyclical. As was predicted and Greece (for example) has shown, a government cannot save itself out of debt in a recession, because tanking the economy at a crucial time like that makes the debt worse (as percent of GDP, and that's the crucial number in terms of ability to repay).

Update:

I am German, "living within your means" is sort of part of my DNA, and not living within your means is going to cause problems. But timing does matter!

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by treerock on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:54AM (#4947434)
Totally agree. But then the question becomes, what do you do when countries actually increase spending and debt when the economy is good, and therefore have nothing to spend when the bad times arrive. The main distinction between Iceland and Ireland is that Iceland can print its own money.

In the UK it seems that 'nasty' parties that advocate spending cuts in the good times get voted out of office, and replaced by parties that increase spending.

So it becomes less a question of economics and more one of politics. For the moment Germany might see "living within your means" part of the DNA, but few other countries do. And I imagine that, as Germany gets further integrated with the rest of Europe, that kind of thinking will be weakened.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by mpweiher on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:19PM (#4948748)
"But then the question becomes, what do you do when countries actually increase spending and debt when the economy is good, and therefore have nothing to spend when the bad times arrive." "So it becomes less a question of economics and more one of politics."

Precisely. And all the western countries have been guilty of this, the only difference is that of degree. Which is why debt has generally only crept up and politics has slowly but surely ceded sovereignty to the banks, especially in Europe where new currency is apparently only created via commercial banks (unlike the US, which just prints it).

"And I imagine that, as Germany gets further integrated with the rest of Europe, that kind of thinking will be weakened."

As far as I can tell that's the current political struggle, especially between the North and South.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by barrkel on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:26AM (#4946547)
If Cleveland had its own currency, you could derive globally applicable lessons. But it doesn't.

The "normal way" is much much better than deflationary expenditure cutting. Deflation increases the debt burden in real terms.

The underlying reason governments are following austerity is because protecting old people's benefits & pensions (the people on the credit side of the debt, i.e. claims on future production) is more important than growing the economy for young people, because that's how the votes are structured in the economies that matter (Germany in Europe). Politics and demographics are pro-austerity, not economists.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:43AM (#4946576)
Going into endless debt does not grow economies any more than running up your credit cards makes you wealthier. It just gives you the illusion of growth. If you want to see where this leads look at what happens in Japan over the next 12 to 18 months.

And anybody who lived through the Carter years understands high inflation is something to be avoided at all costs. It's not a stimulant to the economy, it's a drag. Companies don't know what the real return on their money will be so they don't make investments.

>Politics and demographics are pro-austerity, not economists.

Nonsense. Politics is very, very, very anti-austerity. Governments do not get smaller without a major upheaval. Look at the UK, where you hear much wailing and gnashing of teeth over "austerity" that's simply a tiny cut in the rate of growth of the budget.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tankenmate on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:26AM (#4946770)
Projected cuts of 10% next year on top of the already in the pipeline cuts of 25% would be difficult to sell as "a tiny cut in the _rate of growth_ of the budget". The cuts to government capital expenditure has been largely the cause for the contraction in the construction [1], which has in turn contributed to the UK going back into recession.

Borrowing in order to increase sales (taxes in the case of governments) or to decrease costs (increase economic efficiency, spending on infrastructure and the like) is a good idea; both companies and governments do this all the time. Borrowing to spend frivolously is a bad idea no matter who you are.

[1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/apr/25/eurozone-cris...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @04:02AM (#4946843)
>Borrowing in order to increase sales (taxes in the case of governments) or to decrease costs (increase economic efficiency, spending on infrastructure and the like) is a good idea

It can be a good idea if the economic activity that results covers the cost of borrowing. But that's not an easy thing to determine, and any rational start to the process tends to get warped by political reality. The fetish for infrastructure spending results in, for example, rail projects that lose ¥32 for every ¥1 they take in:

http://spikejapan.wordpress.com/2012/05/20/minispike-the-end...

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 20, 2012 @04:39AM (#4946896)
And anybody who lived through the Carter years understands high inflation is something to be avoided at all costs. It's not a stimulant to the economy, it's a drag.

And everyone who remembers the Great Depression says the same thing about deflationary spirals.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:16PM (#4950416)
I would rather see a depression than runaway inflation.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by firlefans on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:00AM (#4947466)
...we may have very few humans left of that era
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by icebraining on Thursday December 20, 2012 @06:10AM (#4947102)
If Cleveland had its own currency, you could derive globally applicable lessons. But it doesn't.

Well, Ireland, Spain, Portugal, Greece, etc don't either.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by EliRivers on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:44AM (#4947386)
Iceland does, and they used it to sort themselves out.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:46AM (#4947048)
The scary thing about Krugman is that his whole ideology seems to depend on that example of one babysitting exchange ring that didn't print enough money and therefore couldn't trade. It's an interesting story, but I wouldn't simply translate it to whole economies of nations. I can think of a lots of other factors that might have made the babysitting ring fail.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by gizmo on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @11:56PM (#4946337)
> The mainstream camp however, thought otherwise and most of the world followed their advice.

Not the mainstream -- a vocal minority. Ordinary Macro 101 textbooks predicted the consequences of the policies in the the US and Europe pretty accurately.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by cynicalkane on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:22AM (#4946398)
This. If you look at the right ideas of Macro 101, the success rate is pretty high. Bailouts, demand-side policy, properly applied monetary stimulus, expectations management and confidence. If you look at famous wrong ideas, their failure rate has been pretty high. Austerity, strong currencies, lazy ZIRP stimulus, do-nothing policy, inflation paranoia. What is true in macro before the recession has become more true. The econ pundits who focused on these Macro 101 truths have been mostly right, with the monetary guys being perhaps a little more right than the fiscal stimulus guys. This should not be surprising as the things that are "true" in econ are such by virtue of hundreds of years of examination and highly reasonable philosophy, which anyone who's bothered to study econ would know.

Most people who say "econ is not a science" have had little to no experience with people who conduct economics as a science. I understand the cargo-cultists and pundits are much louder voices, but someone good at "science" shouldn't lazily examine the most shallow voices and use that to conclude deep things about a field of study.

There's cargo cult science, and then there's cargo cult scientific criticism.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tsotha on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:22PM (#4950442)
>This. If you look at the right ideas of Macro 101, the success rate is pretty high. Bailouts, demand-side policy, properly applied monetary stimulus, expectations management and confidence.

This is ridiculous. Economies recover from recessions and "Macro 101" people claim victory. But economies recover from recessions if you do nothing. Or you implement austerity measures.

>Most people who say "econ is not a science" have had little to no experience with people who conduct economics as a science.

People who "conduct economics as a science" have little or no connection to reality. They have grossly oversimplified models that fail to make meaningful predictions and congratulate themselves on the accuracy of their models in the complete absence of evidence.

Talk about cargo cult science. Economics isn't a science. It's just a way to fit the world into your political template.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by dingfeng_quek on Saturday December 22, 2012 @10:16AM (#4956721)
Perhaps your economy won't recover to its former glory, like the way Japan's didn't. Then you'll have at least one first-hand empirical data point, even if you're unable to learn from observing others.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by freshhawk on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:01AM (#4946351)
I think you are mistaken only in assuming that economists don't know this. It's blatantly obvious as soon as you learn about the philosophy of science.

The problem is that economic decisions still need to be made and "confidence" actually is a big factor in how markets react to news.

Since you can't start doing science in economics at this point then you better look to your preferred economic philosophy for some pointers and rules of thumb. And you god damn better make sure people have confidence in you (since it literally makes things work better and because then you get less blame for mistakes).

Since the creation of a fake Nobel prize in Economics to borrow some of that sweet sweet confidence people have in Physics and Chemistry it's been seen as an image problem. A branding problem.

It's very Straussian I suppose, in that "the masses must be lied to for their own good, rulers need to show strength and project confidence" kind of way.

It's definitely gotten out of hand in my opinion, so little effort going towards moving economics towards science and so much on religious arguments when all sides know they can't really model or predict anything.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by cynicalkane on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:44AM (#4946443)
The opinion that the Nobel Prize in Economics is a "fake" prize is not shared by the Nobel Foundation, which treats it as equal to Nobel's prizes and awards them in the same way, with the same people, by the same criteria as the other science prizes. They differ only in name as they were named after different benefactors. I wish people would stop saying this. On the other hand, it's a sure sign you don't know what you're talking about.

http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economics/

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by freshhawk on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:00PM (#4949614)
True, using "fake" was just to be pejorative. It is not one of the original Nobel prizes, it doesn't fit the original prize philosophy of Alfred Nobel but it is the only non-Nobel prize that is officially associated with the Nobel Foundation.

The same people (Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences) also award the Crafoord Prize as well as others, but only the Economics one put "Nobel" in the name and the fact that this was done to improve the image of Economics is just history.

I don't think you're being accurate to say they differ "only in name". There is plenty of controversy about the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel being called "The Nobel Prize in Economics". The Nobel family doesn't like their name being attached to it since it wasn't Alfred Nobel that created it. Hayek was given the prize and stated that he, if he had been asked, would have advised against it because "the Nobel Prize confers on an individual an authority which in economics no man ought to possess... This does not matter in the natural sciences. Here the influence exercised by an individual is chiefly an influence on his fellow experts; and they will soon cut him down to size if he exceeds his competence. But the influence of the economist that mainly matters is an influence over laymen: politicians, journalists, civil servants and the public generally". I like that quote because it nicely encapsulates the difference in the fields of hard science and economics and the different effects of this kind of prize.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Joeri on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:37AM (#4947032)
Just like you can reliably model a gas but not its particles, i think you can reliably model a crowd but not its individuals. To me economics is the science of predicting the interactions of crowds.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by freshhawk on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:09PM (#4949669)
It aspires to be and everyone certainly hopes it will be, the behavioural economics crowd thinks they are headed towards that certainly. Their argument that the reason for the lack of predictive power in economics is the reliance on models that assume individuals are rational actors seems to have a lot of merit.

At the moment the techniques available and the predictive power puts it far down the spectruum that has the hard sciences on one side and pseudoscience on the other with the soft/social sciences in the middle.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by ryanmolden on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @11:27PM (#4946276)
>With 4 years of data we now know who was right and who was wrong

Do we? I think at best you could argue that what was done was wrong, that doesn't imply the other alternative was right. There exists more than two possible courses of action and thus we can't simply anoint one as right and the other as wrong, they could in fact both be wrong. I think that is one big problem with macro-economics as a science, you can't really have controlled experiments whereby we try each of N hypothesis in turn, controlling externalities, and see which yields the most accurate outcome vis-a-vis the predictions that that hypothesis made. Even repeating what worked N years ago isn't a guarantee of anything, since it is highly unlikely that all the confounding variables are the same.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by martythemaniak on Thursday December 20, 2012 @12:00AM (#4946348)
You seem to be implying that because economists can't run clean experiments like physicists, they can't prove or disprove anything, they can't tell us what happened and they certainly can't guide us. At this point I have to ask, how is your view of economics different from theology? What is the point of such a useless field of study?

Of course, economics can be useful. Economists have a ton of data and a wide variety of tools with which to conduct their study, and while they can't achieve the purity of physics, economics can still be a valid and useful field of study. The problem isn't economics itself, but practitioners whose views are clouded by politics, ego and money.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by tolmasky on Thursday December 20, 2012 @04:51AM (#4946921)
> You seem to be implying that because economists can't run clean experiments like physicists, they can't prove or disprove anything, they can't tell us what happened and they certainly can't guide us.

This is exactly correct. Just because we don't have the means to do the kinds of experiments we want, doesn't mean we get to change the definition of proof. And if you do, you certainly shouldn't call it science. If there was no good way to do a falsifiable experiment in physics we wouldn't say "oh we have a lot of data though, so i guess we should just look at the correlations and assume causation in this case". The question would simply remain open, perhaps indefinitely. This is the most frustrating thing about discussing economics with anyone: if you're truly honest, you should admit that you can pluck examples in history to prove just about anything. Each side will say "oh that's not comparable because ____". And you know what, they're right! Since no two situations are the same, we rely on our "gut" to tell us what variables, despite being different, "didn't really influence or matter". The idea that you can for example draw any conclusions about economic policy from the 50s, a ridiculously unique time where all the production of the world except the US was more or less destroyed, is absurd. The idea that you can look at the effect of ONE policy in Germany, a country of different size, culture, laws, and other policies, and say the same would happen here is equally crazy. It's data sure, but not particularly useful data if you are honest about the science of it. Those techniques would get you laughed out of any other scientific field.

> At this point I have to ask, how is your view of economics different from theology? What is the point of such a useless field of study?

My view (I am not the op), is that yes, most people who believe in macro economics principles are closer to theologists than scientists. It is indeed quite possibly a useless field of study, given that there are huge disagreements and it doesn't even matter because a politician will usually do something completely based on the next election or special interests anyways, so even if we did know for sure it wouldn't matter. ( a funny article by mr Krugman himself on this: http://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/07/opinion/reckonings-a-rent-... )

Now, there are alternative forms of establishing knowledge other than science (for example there are no experiments in math, and math isnt science), and you can argue that the position "I don't know" can be a very wise one and an economic policy all in itself. But the idea that "doing x will for sure do y" is silly, ESPECIALLY since a timeframe is rarely ever attached to it.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Someone on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:58PM (#4949941)
If there was no good way to do a falsifiable experiment in physics we wouldn't say "oh we have a lot of data though, so i guess we should just look at the correlations and assume causation in this case". The question would simply remain open, perhaps indefinitely

What do you think of astronomy? Science, or should we wait for the development of experimental astronomy (yes, I know a lot of it is based on experimentally based physics, but none of that gets tested at interstellar distances, objects the size of stars, etc)

What about Kepler, and Newton with his laws of gravitation? Science, or did it only become science once we had machinery to measure gravity?

I think economists can do science, but their subject is much harder/less anemable to the scientific method than e.g. physics. Because of that, their results are less spectacular then those of physicists (psychologists, similarly, have a harder time than physicists applying the scientific method)

Also, that is harder to discriminate between true and false theories makes it easier for 'crackpots' to make a living in those fields.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by dreamdu5t on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @11:34PM (#4946290)
You can't test hypothesis with no control group and no way to falsify theories. Comparing economics to physics is absurd.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by jrogers65 on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:38AM (#4947033)
There has been a silent revolution in the last few decades which has resulted in a new branch of mathematics called Chaos Theory.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory

It happens to be quite capable of making a science out of traditionally difficult to understand subjects such as economics, psychology and sociology.

https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:naTCJqLey4QJ:...

The comparison would have been absurd last century, not so much today.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by fijal on Thursday December 20, 2012 @07:24AM (#4947302)
How about astrophysics? Climate science? We don't always get a whole lot of experiments to do, sometimes one.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by mtgx on Thursday December 20, 2012 @03:57AM (#4946833)
The funny thing is that the "mainstream economists" should have been discredited since the crisis started. Because none of them was able to predict the crisis, because all of them pushed for the policies that led to that crisis. So of course they weren't going to cry disaster when they proposed it. I remember them being blamed for a while, but in the end nothing has changed.
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by Tichy on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:44AM (#4947043)
The fun thing with economic predictions: make enough of them, and some of them are bound to come true. The whole fond business seems to dwell on that, publishing lists of successful predictors by the end of the year. Research has shown that the successes are actually just random, but by cherry picking the success stories you can create a nice story for advertising.

In any case, it would be interesting to get more references from you (who predicted what, and what are the suggested steps).

I think there are always a lot of people predicting doom for the near future. Every now and then they are bound to be right, but it doesn't prove anything.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by jvvlimme on Thursday December 20, 2012 @05:35AM (#4947028)
It is true. John B. Clarck and Edwin Seligman (two leading figures in the development of the Neo Classical Economy) sold out in the late 1800's to the wealthiest of the day and transformed the science of economics into something that is as reliable in predicting the economy and offering solutions as your average fortune teller.

The rich industrialists of the 19th century made sure that the universities (on whos board they sat) taught only the flawed neo-classical economy so entire generations of young minds were corrupted.

It's thanks to Seligman by the way that we are all paying taxes on the labor we perform while the act of speculation (which destablizes the economy) remains largely un(der)taxed.

Economists should go back to basics: Smith, Ricardo, Mill, George, ... and rebuild their field as a true science.

I invite everyone to read "The Corruption of Economics" by Mason Gaffney for the full story.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by kfk on Thursday December 20, 2012 @08:12AM (#4947516)
There are lots of economists, and I believe is the majority, that actually kept advising to let the banks fail.

Economics is a deep and complex field of science, I urge you to get a better grasp of it before doing such shallow statements.

Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by dxbydt on Thursday December 20, 2012 @01:02AM (#4946485)
are you saying the only value of econ is its predictive value or the lack thereof ? if some PL hotshot predicts that 10 years from now imperative languages will go the way of the dodo, must we mock his particular prediction or his field in general? shaw is supposed to have quipped "If all economists were laid end to end, they would not reach a conclusion." - but some actually see that bug as a feature. disagreement in social science != quackery
Re:The economic return of Iceland has proved that the joke w... by martinced on Thursday December 20, 2012 @09:59AM (#4947995)
You are right when you say the economics is deeply corrupted by politics. At least mainstrean economics.

The problem is one of propaganda first and foremost: the only thing that is widely thaught in universities and that we keep hearing all the times is Keynes.

The problem is: Keynesianism is totally unable to predict anything further than two or three years. It also inevitably leads to the country defaulting. There's no other way. There never has been any other way for a country run under the Keynesian dogma.

I'll give an example: before the first euro even circulated there have been economists (of course non-Keynesian ones) who predicted the very exact scenario that happened to the eurozone 13 years later. Too many houses in Spain, too many industries in Germany, too many public servants in France and as well the default of Greece and Spain (Greece is going to default again btw and Spain is going to eventually default too).

These were quite impressive "predictions" for some. For others it was simply about applying what Friedman has been telling since forever.

That's the problem: Keynesianism can only predict up to two or three years in advance and that at the cost of sinking the country.

But Keynesianism is precisely what politicians wants to hear: they take it as a free ticket allowing them to create an always bigger public sector (and hence they can feel always more and more "important").

The result? Deeply corrupted economists that happily sing the only song that politicians want to hear.

The non-Keynesian economists who precisely predicted the mess we're in today? Nobody is listening to them (well I am for my positions, because it nets me a lot of money but not a single politican want to listen to them).

This is really a sad state of affair and it shall stay like that as long as the fraud that Keynesianism is is going to be taught in universities as if it was the holy gospel.

Note that the disciples of Friedman who predicted Spain and Greece's defaults did not just say: "Spain and Greece are eventually going to default". They did predict precisely the mechanism, over a decade and a half, that would lead to the defaults. They were already right for Greece and the future is going to prove them correct again.

Note that since then they've explained why there's no way on earth Greece is ever going to repay its debt and that inevitably Greece would default again.

While the Keynesians are all wrong and keep telling us that more public debt is going to solve all the eurozone issues.

The problem is that once countries reach about 100% of public debt (which they inevitably do when run under the Keynesian dogma), there's simply no way out using Keynesian tactics.

So, yup, to me Keynesianism is an utter failure and it's going to get uglier and uglier.

You don't want to be jobless in Greece today.

The fact is: Friedman disciples predicted precisely that in 1999. Keynesians didn't.