The term 'austerity' is meant to apply to a government living within its means. These days it is applied to a government with single digit debt growth instead of double-digit growth. Kind of like how eating balanced meals is now called dieting.
It's true that you can avoid unemployment by borrowing money to pay people to dig holes and fill them in again. What is also true is that, without production there is no consumption. Digging up holes and filling them in is not production, ergo, consumption will not rise.
TLDR; J.B. Say was right. Keynes was wrong.
That is to say, while his prescription may have been sound economically (I doubt it, but let's say it is for the sake of argument), politically it's just an excuse to pile on ever larger debts.
No, it is meant to apply to a government radically cutting spending during a recession.
It's true that you can avoid unemployment by borrowing money to pay people to dig holes and fill them in again. What is also true is that, without production there is no consumption. Digging up holes and filling them in is not production, ergo, consumption will not rise.
And yet Keynesian stimulus worked in Australia[1]. Australia was able to implement it properly because the Australian economy had run years of surplus budgets prior to the financial crisis.
The jibe about digging holes is disappointing and ignorant. The Australian program involved a one off payment to tax payers for immediate effect (which ended up supporting the retail sector at Christmas time), traditional infrastructure spending on "ready to go" projects (roads etc) for effect in a couple of months and a very large school building program where building usually started 6-9 months after the initial crisis. These programs were production and - more importantly - all supported employment.
TLDR; Keynesian economics works just fine when the government runs expansionary budgets when growth is needed and surpluses when growth is robust.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_fiscal_policy_response...
TLDR; Keynes advocated government spending on infrastructure (increased collective efficiency) not pointless hole filling.
You'll answer "spending money on infrastructure" but that is not good enough. Even for roads there is a point when enough is enough (imagine every square meter of the country covered in roads).
To fix the economy, you have to devise a mechanism of efficient resource allocation. Just saying "let the government decide" is not an answer.
Advocates of Keynesian spending advocate its usage for public goods and commons goods, the two known categories where "the government" is clearly more efficient than markets.
Does that mean no decisions remain in the realm of politics and everything turns into a technocratic utopia run by Economics majors? No. But that's because in any case there is no such thing as an apolitical economic policy of any kind. All of it, right down the property laws themselves, is political.
In fact, it's generally the very core of politics.
Could you give me a reference for that? I am not an expert in economics, and that claim seems very doubful to me. Unless you are saying governments are good in spending money - yes, they are (getting rid of money, I mean).
The rest of your post, I am not sure what you are going on about. Yes, property laws are political (and some countries famously got rid of them, which for now has to be considered a failure). But what does that have to do with Keynesian spending? Also I admit I am not an expert on Keynes, but I suspect that puts me on par with most other people who have an opinion on it and advocate to just print more money.
The rest of your post, I am not sure what you are going on about. Yes, property laws are political (and some countries famously got rid of them, which for now has to be considered a failure). But what does that have to do with Keynesian spending? Also I admit I am not an expert on Keynes, but I suspect that puts me on par with most other people who have an opinion on it and advocate to just print more money.
Actually, advocating printing money is not a Keynesian position, it's a Modern Monetary Theory position.
But anyway, I'm arguing against your assertion that political decisions cannot and should not be made about the economy.
The link about public goods doesn't convince me that government spending on public goods is always the best choice, see example of too many roads.
As for printing money, isn't it kind of equivalent to taking on debt?
Of course, advocates of privatization are doing the same thing: shifting the decision-making and not really proposing anything at all. Both markets and governments are voting mechanisms.
Difference is, in a market, the dollars vote, and in a government, the people vote.
Then we have to start talking about the signal/noise ratios of both mechanisms...
Of course, there is neither the perfect market nor the perfect government.
It seems to me that the potential for abuse is greater in the government, though. There is one vote every x years, and good tracking mechanisms of what is really being done don't exist yet.
Signal/noise - the difference is that in the market, participants can not simply spend other people's money. They have to come up with real money somehow, which might be a pretty strong signal.
It's understandable that regular readers of Krugman may not know this since he goes to great pains to deny the obvious on this point.
Additionally, they aren't doing "pretty well" with austerity by any honest metric. Even four years after the GFC, their GDPs are still below where they were in 2007/2008, significantly in Latvia's case. Unemployment is extremely high (From 4%/6% in 2007 to 10%/14% today) and wages have fallen.
Where is the success story here?
Lat + Est Unemployment: (https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=z8o7pt6rd5uqa6_...) Lat + Est GDP: (https://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&...)
Using 2007 as the starting year for Latvia and Estonia is kind of cherry picking. See here: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/07/the...
Note that the MR post is polite and humble, and gives fair consideration to both sides of the issue, unlike just about anything written by a certain ny times columnist.
At any rate, I was in Tallinn in June of this year, and the locals I talked to in bars and cafes were all very pessimistic about how the country was going. Maybe pessimism is just a cultural norm, but everyone that I asked felt that Estonia had gone backwards since the crash, and was still doing so...
Here is another article with more graphs explaining this point: http://blogs.cfr.org/geographics/2012/07/02/postcrisis/ -- though you will find some debate in the comments.
LOL! I wish we had that "extremely high" unemployment in Spain. By the way, we're an even better example of austerity not working.
Had Japan done a Iceland-style cleanout, they would probably be still striking fear into the hearts of governments and corporates everywhere.
Because the Icelandic government declined to act as insurer for those deposits, the insolvency of them was seen as an effective write off of national indebtedness to other sovereigns.
Agree it's not the same thing though.
So, yeah, Estonia might be doing fine by some short-term metrics, but in the long term austerity measures have done irreparable harm.
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2012/12/kyle-bass...
Oh please. The idea that you can spend your way out of debt has been shown to be disastrous over and over, and yet like the Marxist "scientists" before them these Neo-Keynesians are going to claim everything is peachy until even the slowest among us can see they're wrong (and not scientists, either). But like any good faith healer they'll say "You didn't do it hard enough". Does that sound familiar?
In the short run austerity is painful. In the long run it's the only option, and putting off the pain only makes it worse when you're out of options. Either you do it honestly by cutting expenditures, or you do it the normal way by printing money.
The idea you can derive globally applicable lessons from a country the size of Cleveland is a bit daft.
The idea is not that you can spend your way out of debt, that would be silly. The idea is that you can and should spend money to compensate for lack of demand in a recession, because the markets overshoot. Once you are out of recession, you must pay back the debt.
So austerity when the economy is good, spending when it is bad. Anti-cyclical government behavior.
Austerity in a recession is pro-cyclical. As was predicted and Greece (for example) has shown, a government cannot save itself out of debt in a recession, because tanking the economy at a crucial time like that makes the debt worse (as percent of GDP, and that's the crucial number in terms of ability to repay).
Update:
I am German, "living within your means" is sort of part of my DNA, and not living within your means is going to cause problems. But timing does matter!
In the UK it seems that 'nasty' parties that advocate spending cuts in the good times get voted out of office, and replaced by parties that increase spending.
So it becomes less a question of economics and more one of politics. For the moment Germany might see "living within your means" part of the DNA, but few other countries do. And I imagine that, as Germany gets further integrated with the rest of Europe, that kind of thinking will be weakened.
Precisely. And all the western countries have been guilty of this, the only difference is that of degree. Which is why debt has generally only crept up and politics has slowly but surely ceded sovereignty to the banks, especially in Europe where new currency is apparently only created via commercial banks (unlike the US, which just prints it).
"And I imagine that, as Germany gets further integrated with the rest of Europe, that kind of thinking will be weakened."
As far as I can tell that's the current political struggle, especially between the North and South.
The "normal way" is much much better than deflationary expenditure cutting. Deflation increases the debt burden in real terms.
The underlying reason governments are following austerity is because protecting old people's benefits & pensions (the people on the credit side of the debt, i.e. claims on future production) is more important than growing the economy for young people, because that's how the votes are structured in the economies that matter (Germany in Europe). Politics and demographics are pro-austerity, not economists.
And anybody who lived through the Carter years understands high inflation is something to be avoided at all costs. It's not a stimulant to the economy, it's a drag. Companies don't know what the real return on their money will be so they don't make investments.
>Politics and demographics are pro-austerity, not economists.
Nonsense. Politics is very, very, very anti-austerity. Governments do not get smaller without a major upheaval. Look at the UK, where you hear much wailing and gnashing of teeth over "austerity" that's simply a tiny cut in the rate of growth of the budget.
Borrowing in order to increase sales (taxes in the case of governments) or to decrease costs (increase economic efficiency, spending on infrastructure and the like) is a good idea; both companies and governments do this all the time. Borrowing to spend frivolously is a bad idea no matter who you are.
[1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/apr/25/eurozone-cris...
It can be a good idea if the economic activity that results covers the cost of borrowing. But that's not an easy thing to determine, and any rational start to the process tends to get warped by political reality. The fetish for infrastructure spending results in, for example, rail projects that lose ¥32 for every ¥1 they take in:
http://spikejapan.wordpress.com/2012/05/20/minispike-the-end...
And everyone who remembers the Great Depression says the same thing about deflationary spirals.
Well, Ireland, Spain, Portugal, Greece, etc don't either.
In most areas of science bad ideas don't disappear, it is just that those who support them die and ideas with some evidentiary support become the new norm.
After the response to the 70's oil shocks economists knew that austerity didn't work. Unfortunately measures that are known to work are a political minefield, so those "economists" who don't support it get a lot of support from politicians who don't support it either.
In some ways it is similar to evolution or climate change. You can find "scientists" who deny them both. Economics is worse though, because it is so closely tied to politics.
Incidentally, Krugman has been writing about Iceland since 2010[1].
[1] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/06/30/the-icelandic-po...