News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by NalNezumi on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:16AM (#49432659)
EU(or US) can't have public toilets because it's gonna get vandalized. For fun.

One thing that perplexed me endlessly during my youth living in Sweden was seeing drunk teenagers go around vandalize things for... Fun. Breaking the glass at the buss station (designed to shatter in to million pieces so you don't hurt yourself), friends enjoying graffiti, littering, throwing beer bottles on the street for fun....

During public school lunch (I only heard my friends doing it) they had "meatball war" throwing meatball at each other for fun. Justification was that school lunch taste shit so it's ok to throw food. Mind you all this was in the district with highest median earning in the entire country, not a ghetto.

Same for toilet. Just why did you need to rip off that toilet lid?

Collective ownership and responsibility is taught. In most Asian countries kids are often tasked to clean their own classroom. If someone then just destroys things for fun everyone suffers. EU/US just think that's dumb thing to teach because "eww collectivism" and even the weird conservative people going on about rules usually don't even want that.

So you have a society where race to the bottom is inevitable when it comes to caring for public utilities. "privatized profit(fun) , socialized loss" teaching starts even before economics class

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mancerayder on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:08AM (#49433384)
How is that not connected to police enforcement, though? In Europe and now the US the new generations are anti-police, anti-enforcement and generally consider authority and rules to be proof of an unjust society (X group is N percent more likely to receive a criminal summons when ..).

In the US in slow motion we could see a world in which you could go to a big chain pharmacy and retrieve your own toothpaste and shampoo. Now it's considered entirely normal to put these behind plexiglass, and to hire a security guard to stand by the door, but the guard isn't legally allowed to stop anyone or engage in any physical altercation. Because homelessness, because mental illness, because drug addiction, etc are not to be 'criminalized.'

In NYC a decree stopped the police from issuing summonses for not paying the subway fare. Because it was said to be racist. Today, tons of people, especially normal professionals - happily do not pay the fare, while the system is said to be in financial deficit.

Yet here we're discussing comparisons with Asian cultures and how they are more respectful of public space.

So, my friends, is it a cultural difference, a legal enforcement difference, or an inevitable consequence of injustice? I'm dying to understand because it's at the crux of the political divide, and I'm seeing cities getting worse in front of my eyes.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by enaaem on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:48AM (#49434056)
I cannot speak for the US, but having been in Europe and Asian countries like Japan and Korea, the simplest explanation is the difference in tolerance for petty crime, vandalism and litter. Is related to the broken window theory.

The thing is that European cities have always been kinda dirty and crime infested, and it has little to do with American culture war. I do not have an explanation for this, because you will need dig deep into history for that, but the good news is that things are overall improving. Overall crime is overall trending down. For example, the inner city of Amsterdam used to be full of junkies and now that has been almost completely cleaned up. And football Hooligans used to be a much bigger problem than they are now.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ricardobayes on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:22AM (#49434681)
That's right. We seem to have "allowed" or tolerated petty crime in most Europe. When I tell my foreign friends what kind of stuff happens in my area they always extrapolate and tell me I live in "8 mile". But it's not the case, almost everywhere in Europe has property crime (pickpocketing and burglaries), bigger stuff however is very rare.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by nobodywillobsrv on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:30PM (#49440182)
It's funny to read HN comments where people can sort of describe the problems but can't really describe the problems
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dcrazy on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:47PM (#49440391)
Then please, do everyone a favor and describe the problem.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by leansensei on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:44AM (#49445757)
Unchecked immigration, lax policing.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by Gander5739 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @05:51AM (#49446340)
Even when it was the bears, I knew it was them.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tomrod on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:27AM (#49433676)
Enforcement is an external impetus. Internal impetus are better to cultivate. I can't answer how cultures tend to differ here from my limited vantage point, so what I'm really saying is respect doesn't come by itself typically.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by x-complexity on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:43AM (#49445330)
> Enforcement is an external impetus. Internal impetus are better to cultivate.

Internal impetus cannot be cultivated if the youth do not want or desire to be taught cultivation.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tomrod on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @05:38AM (#49446248)
Ish. Spare the rod, spoil the child type approaches haven't seemed to hold true in my experience.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by lux-lux-lux on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:25AM (#49434728)
NYC ended up spending $1,440 per dollar in fares recovered on stopping fare jumpers, which is probably why the decree came about in the first place. Is there a particular reason why you think setting gargantuan amounts of money on fire over trivial offenses makes sense?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by xp84 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:18AM (#49435649)
Capitulating to the antisocial persons by just giving up just sends a message to others that this behavior is acceptable. It moves the Overton window. Someone who used to think turnstile hopping was the kind of thing only crooks and low-lifes do sees people doing it more and more, witnesses and hears about how there are no consequences, and can't help but reframe it as more like driving 70 in a 65mph zone -- a harmless thing that "everybody does" and is totally fine. The city has enough money, and after all, Mamdani said he'll make those rich guys pay more! That'll cover my share! Meanwhile transit deteriorates severely.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by lux-lux-lux on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:48PM (#49436991)
I much prefer targeting more pressing antisocial behaviors while not excessively wasting public funds, something the Mamdani administration has been doing quite efficiently e.g. with the pied-à-terre tax. You seem angry about that, for some reason.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by xp84 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:00PM (#49439780)
Nah, I'm not really angry because I don't live in New York so it's not my problem. But no, I don't respect a politician who is demonstrably economically illiterate.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by nonford150 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:32PM (#49437608)
Not sure how you can justify the pied-a-terre tax by claiming it fights against antisocial behaviors. It just is another funding stream.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by meric_ on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:05AM (#49435436)
Because those trivial offences are a nuisance. BART spent millions implementing fare gates which so far, is at a huge loss, but it's dramatically lowered maintenance cost and crime on the transit.

Similarly stores with loss prevention guards are probably losing money, but I'd much rather that than having to click a button to unlock items, etc.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ethbr1 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:39PM (#49436842)
Loss prevention in retail is absolutely tailored to the store, in the US. Essentially, the corporate dept has a bucket of funding and chooses where / how to deploy it. So when you see {insert LP device}, there's metrics to back it up. And specifically, worse metrics than the same chain stores that don't have that device.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by lux-lux-lux on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:52PM (#49437057)
The fare gate redesign was cost-neutral; that’s the kind of solutions that should have been on the table, not setting money on fire with cop salaries.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by hansvm on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:55AM (#49435259)
Per dollar recovered or per future fare-jumped dollar prevented?
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by lux-lux-lux on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:42PM (#49436901)
Per dollar recovered. Paying law enforcement officers overtime and directing police attention away from more significant criminal behavior (as opposed to redesigning turnstiles or pursuing alternative strategies like no-fare systems) is extremely expensive and time-limited in terms of impact.

It does shovel a lot of dollars at law enforcement and let the Adams administration pretend to be tough on crime despite engaging in a lot of it, which was the actual intent.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by JuniperMesos on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:49PM (#49439622)
The sorts of people who turnstile jump are likely to commit further crimes on the public transit system that more directly affect the ordinary people trying to use it legitimately. For this reason I specifically want the police to prioritize arresting and prosecuting turnstile jumpers - it concretely improves the experience of public transit for everyone.

This is the same reason that getting rid of fare-checking is bad - the sorts of people who are kept off the transit system by enforcing a fare, are not people you want to be in an enclosed space with.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dcrazy on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:42AM (#49451093)
Corroboration: crime on BART dropped when the new harder-to-jump fare gates went in.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mancerayder on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:01PM (#49443278)
Great. So MTA raises fares and complains about not being able to meet revenue, causing the state to have to funnel more to it.

Nevermind that the economics of your argument are completely blind to the fact that the funding sources of the MTA and the NYPD are completely different.

More crazy is the downstream effects of putting up your hands and letting crimes go.

All this for what ? Social justice? Here's my counter to that - the subway is a public good, For the People a socialist would say.

So you encourage stealing from The People.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by jquery on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:21AM (#49434657)
>the guard isn't legally allowed to stop anyone or engage in any physical altercation

This is false. In California the guard can use non-deadly force to detain a suspected shoplifter. Retailers may have a company policy telling guards and employees not to physically confront shoplifters, because that introduces escalation risk, litigation risk, and risk of injury. It’s simply cheaper to let the item go, in many cases. I’ve read that Target will strategically do this until a person steals enough that it becomes a felony, and then release the hounds.

> In NYC a decree stopped the police from issuing summonses for not paying the subway fare. Because it was said to be racist. Today, tons of people, especially normal professionals - happily do not pay the fare, while the system is said to be in financial deficit.

I’m not sure where you get your information from, but I suggest you reconsider your sources, because this is also false (not the deficit, but a decree stopping police from issuing summons): https://www.nyc.gov/assets/nypd/downloads/excel/analysis_and...

I assume you are referring to a 2018 policy reform. Your concerns are debunked here: https://www.manhattanda.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Fare-...

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tremon on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:13PM (#49441981)
You cannot have police enforcement for petty misdemeanors like those, that's way too expensive. The only means-appropriate correction is social enforcement (i.e. norms and values), but too many people think that society is other peoples' problem. That's one of the downsides of a hyper-individualist society.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by dominicl on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:09AM (#49433404)
+1 Based on my perception of being raised in Germany but have lived in Asia for quite some time this is a deep cultural issue in the west. Concepts such as the German 1968 "Macht kaputt was euch kaputt macht" (break what breaks you), 'civil disobedience' but even "Sabotage" born during the industrial revolution as a workers uprising are all deeply embedded culturally. Not all of them I would like to give up, but it's hard to draw the line.

Finally Vandalism is the worst part of it, but mind you it's named after the Vandals a German tribe after they sacked and looted Rome their oppressors captial.

They say young animals learn survival through playful fights. Maybe western youth learns about freedom through throwing meatballs.

I really don't know but would love to read more about this topic.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by mapt on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:11AM (#49433418)
Opsec permitting, how long ago was this?

While I'm sure The Youth as a group were never terribly respectful in these countries, social media clout (and the influencer's rise as the only apparently secure profession and for teens the only symbol of a social leadership caste) totally changed the equation regarding motivations. This culminated in the 2021-2022 school year "Devious Licks Challenge", a bathroom destruction tiktok trend which is straight out of Bruce Sterling's Zeitgeist.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by RajT88 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:36AM (#49433827)
> EU(or US) can't have public toilets because it's gonna get vandalized. For fun.

Kids vandalize shit in the US for the hell of it.

You'll even see graffiti in really hard to reach places where forget the danger of it, it's hard to even understand how they hell they got up there and could still make something legible (like really tall bridges with nothing to stand on underneath).

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tech2 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:27PM (#49451800)
Historically that was always part of the bragging rights. The harder to reach, or more risky location, the higher the cred for having achieved it.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by ajsnigrutin on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:41AM (#49433932)
It's not collectivism, it's the "no consequences" thing.

"back in my time" in what used to be yugoslavia, it was perfectly acceptable for an adult to slap/hit a kid who caused problem or was destroying stuff, if a dad had to come to school because the kid did something bad, that was a horrible punishment, plus no leaving the room after, no toys, no bike, no outside play, no nothing for some time.

Now? Parents protect their idiot vandal kids, threathen the school with lawyers, even if cops bring home a kid selling like weed and vomiting red wine, the parents will blame everything else except their little sunshine.

Even academically, kids can't read anymore, and we just push them on, no repeating and losing years, no nothing, here's a "2" (passing grade), go to next year, and after a few more pushes, you'll be someone elses problem, illiterate or not.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by oogali on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:53AM (#49434172)
I remember this “time” in my US classroom where we were all punished with if one person damaged classroom property (or worse, school property) but no one was willing to speak up and tell on the offender.

I have similar stories from our local neighborhoods where another parent might yell at you but the tales of your exploits made it home before you did. And there consequences waiting for you.

It’s a matter of timeline, not country.

By the late 1990s, I started to see said teachers pushing kids along as to 1) not deal with them again, and 2) pressure from district/state to not have as many failing students a.k.a. optimizing for the metric.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by MisterTea on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:59AM (#49434274)
Bathrooms aren't always closed because of vandalizing. NYC public schools lacked bathrooms and stall doors -- the various heroin epidemics saw to that. Schools closed boys bathrooms and removed stall doors to discourage drug use.

In 1994 my public HS had ONE boys bathroom with no stall doors across from the lunchroom where a public school guard sat and watched. The girls had one on every floor. Had to take a dump? pray no one was in one of three stalls and put your book bag on your lap. My brother went to Brooklyn Tech and had the same missing stall door issue though had more bathrooms.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by alistairSH on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:24PM (#49436605)
That's not the norm across the US (thought it might have been for urban areas).

I went to public high school in the same era in the northern VA suburbs and we had bathrooms available. With doors even. In our 3-building campus, there were at least 6 full sets of bathrooms that I remember (so there were probably more), plus two sets of locker rooms which had toilets.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by everdrive on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:25PM (#49436620)
>-- the various heroin epidemics saw to that.

But hey, it's walkable!

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by serf on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:03AM (#49434346)
I don't disagree with your points, but have you ever considered it strange that you're unable to relate to why someone would want to do something for fun?

you answer your own perplexity by yourself in the same sentence; they do it for fun. I know this because I was a shithead vandal teenager, and I did it for two reasons , 1) fun at the moment and 2) to impress my peers and sex partners.

I think the frustrations of youth are undersold here, and I think the expectation of "You're born, now conform to being a cog in this machine that you had nothing to do with or necessarily any interest in." is also somewhat fundamentally flawed, even if the kids have nice bathrooms due to their own efforts to shit in.

a society that repairs itself and allows a certain level of vandalism is better, I think. It allows for the rebellious youth to get through these psychological phases without much possibility of a misstep that allows them to throw themselves into incarceration for life, it offers leeway for personal growth, and it doesn't pin them into programs that they hate and wouldn't integrate into, anyway.

Tell me, how does the whole 'kids take care of their own bathrooms' thing work out for bullies?

answer: they love it. They don't have to work. Asia hasn't solved the bullying thing yet even with their perceived perfect unitary social one-ness.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by NalNezumi on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:20AM (#49434641)
I don't disagree to your points, but Asia (Japan specifically for me, since I had the opportunity to attend both school system) have vandalism and delinquent just the same as America/Europe.

They just showed their delinquency very differently. Some weird form of "honor among thieves/不良/yakuza" deal, which mostly meant they were aggressive, hanged out late (loitering around convenience store asian squatting with a cigarette in their hand) and driving around in loud bikes and fight each other. Breaking public things was a rare overstep.

So I still don't get it no. There are many ways to have "delinquent fun" so to say, so why at one place the same need is put out on public things vs the other place it is taken out on... Each other(?) is a mystery to me.

>Tell me, how does the whole 'kids take care of their own bathrooms' thing work out for bullies?

This is the most predictable counter argument I get when the public responsibility in school in Asia is brought up, and it sounds fair on the surface on it but it is a red herring; bullying exist independent of collectivism or individualism nor collective responsibility or not, and neither address it, and neither is anyone claiming it addresses bullying.

And no bully don't usually love it. Because there's something called a teacher that checks in if everyone is doing their part and if a malicious actor is not, they get reprimanded. This is ofc not perfect and doesn't solve "teachers pet/favoritism" issue, but it does its job of teaching the students that "if everyone collaborate, one can circumvent race to the bottom Nash equilibrium when no one cleans the room." which I would say is a much better systemic approach than "idk individualism, things are shit because we are too lazy to think about responsibilities nor systemic way to uphold some trust in social settings"

"If your system is built on the assumption of every actor acting ideally, that's a broken system."

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tempfile on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:57AM (#49435301)
> have you ever considered it strange that you're unable to relate to why someone would want to do something for fun?

What a bizarre extrapolation. They just don't see why smashing up bus stops is fun. Maybe you can answer, what's fun about it? I don't get it either. I was a teenager once, I don't see why destroying things that are useful for everyone (including you) would be fun.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by kelseyfrog on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:45AM (#49436073)
It's fair game. In short, it reads like, "I don't understand the motivations behind this behavior, and here's what needs to happen to stop it."

If you want to change something, understanding it is a very good first step. Usually it means you're on the path toward finding a cure rather than simply treating symptoms.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tempfile on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:14AM (#49445563)
Of course understanding is a good first step. However the onus is I think on the antisocial one to explain themselves. Of course I did ask exactly what you suggested, and they didn't reply. So maybe just stopping them without understanding would be ok in this case.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by kelseyfrog on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:53AM (#49450253)
I think the onus is on the one who wants to enact change, but I'm curious how you came to prefer sorting it by sociability.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by tempfile on Thursday August 27, 2026 @05:24AM (#49461963)
"the one who wants to enact change" is not really meaningful. They want to change the working bus stop into a smashed bus stop. I want to change the people who smash bus stops into people who don't smash bus stops. I don't think the abstract framing is helping you to think about it (or helping me to understand you).

My feeling about this is very simple. I think the position "I want to smash up public infrastructure to impress my sexual partners" is destructive and immoral. I don't see any reason we should allow it to happen. If someone wants to do that, I think we should punish them. I am not sympathetic to that position at all. Why do you think I should be? That's all I'm asking.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by CrimsonCape on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:17PM (#49437391)
I do think it's closely related to women, because like you say, girls go for runabouts. Girls think the communal farm hippie is romantic, the satan-woshipping metal band member is romantic, the (2000s) kid rock punk trailer trash is romantic. Girls who have looks but are born poor seem to have no choice but encourage it. Murphy's law rules: if it's stupid (breaking windows) but it works (she likes me), it isn't stupid.

I feel like society kinda ran out of rebelliousness with kid rock and then rap culture (late 2000s Jay-Z, Chris Brown). It seems to have dried up. Modern lookmaxxing and gym rat culture, travel vlog, influencers are now the cool kids, van-life and nomadic travel are the new stick-it-to-the-man.

Young people are going to look at Ukraine and realize that flower power and stick-it-to-the-man are utterly bizarre. Who in Ukraine is doing the John Lennon routine? John Lennon's message is totally bizarre now.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by parineum on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @12:35PM (#49436784)
> EU/US just think that's dumb thing to teach because "eww collectivism" and even the weird conservative people going on about rules usually don't even want that.

It's interesting to me to call out conservatives here as they are typically the ones touting community responsibilities through social norms. Despite the socialism (non-derogotarily) lean of the left, I would still consider them more individualistic, socially.

The two groups differ in their enforcement of collectivism (socially or legally) not their aversion/inclination to it. We are a social species, after all.

I think you'd find less graffiti in a rural bathroom than a large city bathroom.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by samus on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:02PM (#49437206)
> I think you'd find less graffiti in a rural bathroom than a large city bathroom.

IMHO that's purely due to differences in population density.

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by parineum on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:44PM (#49437763)
I'm not sure that matters so much, a toilet can only handle so much traffic. I suspect a wal-mart bathroom sees similar traffic, regardless of location.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by samus on Sunday August 30, 2026 @11:12AM (#49499400)
Wal-Mart has a direct, strong financial motivation to maintain that public bathroom: Customers that have to leave because they have to go to the toilet will buy less things.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by SubmarineClub on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:59PM (#49441263)
Yup, drive to any town a few miles outside a city and the bathrooms will be nice and clean, drug stores won’t have everything locked up, cafes and gas stations don’t have all their bathrooms locked up with keypads.

Hmmm…remind me again why I should trust ‘team blue’ with running my city?

Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by charcircuit on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:13PM (#49437355)
The US has public toilets.
Re:Where Did All the Public Bathrooms Go? by SirMaster on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:57PM (#49439749)
Yeah I don't get this, there are plentiful public toilets all over the US.