News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by olalonde on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:07PM (#49336829)
This feels like a manufactured controversy. What difference does it make to me what someone does with a book after they buy it? It's effectively unavailable to me regardless of what they do. If people are really concerned about these "rare" books, they should lobby the copyright owners to release them online or print more copies.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by amiga386 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:13PM (#49336920)
What difference does it make to me if someone shoots the last bison? I wasn't getting to eat it either way.

If people are really concerned about bison, they should lobby gamekeepers to release photos of them.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_bison#/media/File:Bis...

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by ThrowawayTestr on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:51PM (#49337462)
A digital copy of a book is identical in value to a printed copy.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by amiga386 on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:34PM (#49337975)
This is entirely untrue.

Simple example:

Actual book from 1732 (rare, original, older than your country): https://blackwells.co.uk/bookshop/product/The-Compleat-City-... -- yours for £1,258.00

A scan of the same edition of that book: https://archive.org/details/bim_eighteenth-century_the-compl... -- free. Nobody's paying any money for the digital copy.

I don't think you understand the book itself is a collectible object with rarity and value, regardless of the information it contains.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by _djo_ on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:55PM (#49338234)
Plus, the physical copy of the book has additional value in terms of forensic verifiability. You can prove the originality of the text and the absence of alterations, and can easily track changes between editions.

Digital copies can be altered at whim, as the only means to provide any sort of tracking or verifiability is through another external software system that itself has to be trusted.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by TiredOfLife on Monday August 17, 2026 @10:49PM (#49340640)
NFT's
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by olalonde on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:33PM (#49337967)
Replace bison with some random animal no one's ever heard about, and photos with literal clones of the animal, and you've got a much better metaphor. Not to forget that in this world, brand new animals are created every day.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by amiga386 on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:36PM (#49338003)
If you destroy a 17th century book, you can't make another one. Eventually you destroy them all.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by olalonde on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:42PM (#49338076)
As long as digital or physical copies exist, you can. Regardless, let's be real, nobody is destroying 17th-century books. The "rare" books we're talking about here still have copyright owners who just don't bother printing new copies due to a lack of demand.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by pohl on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:09PM (#49336861)
If there’s only 3 copies in existence, and everyone on the frontier wants it in their corpus, what do you think will happen?
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by olalonde on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:19PM (#49337018)
This is a problem whether it's AI companies buying them or three random dudes. The real solution is to get the copyright owners to keep distributing copies, or to change copyright law.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by techpression on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:31PM (#49337199)
The three random dudes will probably not destroy them, quite a significant difference.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by beej71 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:42PM (#49337345)
Not only that, but some random dudes scan the books and put them in shadow libraries.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by lostmsu on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:49PM (#49337440)
If that would be the case, how come only 3 copies are left?
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by xienze on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:14PM (#49336935)
I think the term "rare" might be a bit loaded. DOES it mean "only a handful in existence" or more like "1000 copies?" And at any rate, at least by scanning the book they're theoretically making its contents available to the public. What are the other people who own these books doing besides having them sit on a shelf?
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by JohnFen on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:35PM (#49337264)
"Only a handful" is a precious or extremely rare book. 1000 copies of a book total would certainly qualify it as rare. That's not a lot of copies.

> What are the other people who own these books doing besides having them sit on a shelf?

Not destroying them. By continuing to exist, it keeps the possibility that the books will eventually go to someone else. Maybe even a library that specializes in rare books.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by xienze on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:42PM (#49337341)
> By continuing to exist, it keeps the possibility that the books will eventually go to someone else.

Good news, there's hundreds or thousands of copies that continue to exist. Anthropic, Google et al only need a single copy.

And shockingly, for all this talk of rare books, we don't see the other owners of said books stepping up and offering to have these books scanned non-destructively. I won't hold my breath for them to do so in the short or long term.

FURTHERMORE, the books aren't being scanned for no reason, they become part of new model training data. Meaning that whatever insights these books contain might be available to users in the future. Again, more valuable than all the copies rotting away on someone's bookshelf that might be scanned and made available some day.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by card_zero on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:09PM (#49337669)
It's hard to describe what happens to the book's contents, or determine whether it would be more valuable intact. Insights are the result of a person interacting with a book, they aren't like juice that can be squeezed out mechanically.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by card_zero on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:40PM (#49337319)
I care a lot about the high-illustration picture books of the 80s. Since they have ISBNs, they're presumably on the list. Does the LLM ingest the artwork? Even when it comes to text-only novels, it isn't making the experience of reading the book available.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by YetAnotherNick on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:12PM (#49336905)
> what do you think will happen?

They raise the price and print more copies?

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by ipsum2 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:13PM (#49336915)
What if the book has been out of print for 50 years? This isn't a contrived scenario, most of the rare books are like this.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by YetAnotherNick on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:17PM (#49336993)
> What if the book has been out of print for 50 years?

Same answer? They raise the price and print more copies.

You can just print even 1 copy, just the cost per print will be higher.

In fact publishers getting some profit on the tail end of books is the best thing that could happen to authors and publishing industry.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by ipsum2 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:30PM (#49337195)
Do you understand that many of these publishers do not have the original copy anymore, and may have gone out of business entirely? 50 years ago text was not backed up to the cloud.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by YetAnotherNick on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:23PM (#49337841)
If there are very few copies and no one wants to even spend $100 to scan it, likely the book wont be bought by anyone in any case and it would rot/thrown away in another 50 years if AI companies had not digitized it.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by greycol on Monday August 17, 2026 @08:09PM (#49339458)
Which is what has happened over time now that humanity has the ability to digitize them. The problem arises when we are purposefully picking books where we know those scans aren't yet available and purposefully destroying them. There'd be less outrage if any of these companies made statements about guaranteeing the survival of the scans they are taking and the release or planned guaridanship in the case they can no longer maintain the data.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by YetAnotherNick on Tuesday August 18, 2026 @06:17PM (#49353554)
Who is digitizing the books which are rare? Isn't it even more valuable to digitize for them now that they have new buyer which can pay 100s of times more.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by greycol on Wednesday August 19, 2026 @04:25PM (#49366749)
Anna's Archive is a controversial example with that as a stated goal. But more to the point most of the people doing it aren't seeking to profit from digitizing these books so the 'monetary value' of them is not the yard stick or motivator. A higher monetary value could actually make it harder for these projects as they can rely on donations of books or even waiting for someone who wants a book they bought so they can spend that on the next one (which is less useful if the next one on your list was bought to destroy by the same person who bought the book you finished scanning).

They're often books tied to a region, i.e. stories about a local fisherman's life and how they overcame adapting a boat to local feedstock, or the engineering that went into building the local train station. That's to say they can have little value to those outside the area but are still a rich read for locals, tourists, and those who move to the region or have a love for a place. I expect we'll see a concerted effort to organise to get these kind of book sent to regional mueseums for scanning now that people are aware they are actively being destroyed and they realise the timeline isn't how long the book can last.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by ipsum2 on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:40PM (#49338042)
Sorry, that "just-so" explanation is not how the world works.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by KPGv2 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:22PM (#49337060)
> They raise the price and print more copies?

How? Like, do you think a book published 100 years ago has a digital file sitting around a publishing house that might even exist anymore? Re-publishig of old books are often based on scans (the originals were literally pressed into paper by metal, not printed off hard drives), and if the books don't exist, they can't re-scan.

I own some antique Japanese books that have very few copies in existence. You couldn't get them re-printed if you want to if the physical book didn't exist anymore. For a few books, I've actually purchased incredibly high-quality scans that cost me hundreds of dollars because to produce the re-issues, people had to go to museums with high-powered cameras to photograph the pages under supervision of a curator. There's no digital file to print from the publisher. If those books were gone, there's no bringing them back.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by chomp on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:14PM (#49336928)
You are not understanding how the market works. Rarity and value do not always correlate with demand. Otherwise I have some beanie babies to sell.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by ipsum2 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:31PM (#49337209)
I doubt that your beanie babies are very rare.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by Tangurena2 on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:58PM (#49337542)
If there are only 3 copies, then each copy is going to cost thousands of dollars.

Sample:

> Thou shalt commit adultery.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_Bible

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by declan_roberts on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:09PM (#49336855)
It's better value to me that someone is digitizing and training with books then they just languish somewhere in perpetuity.
Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by hansmayer on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:09PM (#49336862)
> What difference does it make to me

It's the scale that matters as first, and secondly, most people don't shred their books after reading them once or twice. This is just beyond words.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by Ataraxic on Monday August 17, 2026 @04:24PM (#49337085)
> What difference does it make to me what someone does with a book after they buy it?

I think this is a bit of a myopic take. It's like saying it's my property I can do what I want, yet there exists designated historic homes or neighborhoods that are deemed to have cultural value where modifications do in fact need to be approved.

I'm with you on the "rare" part. If people are thinking about 70+ year old documents or ancient manuscripts, I doubt that's what AI is being trained on and is being destroyed, but it's reasonable that people find _that_ idea distasteful.

You can say it's manufactured but if these companies ignore this criticism, it's just another way AI companies are committed to losing the public.

Re:AirTag reveals Amazon is trashing rare books to train AI by BeetleB on Monday August 17, 2026 @05:04PM (#49337612)
> It's like saying it's my property I can do what I want, yet there exists designated historic homes or neighborhoods that are deemed to have cultural value where modifications do in fact need to be approved.

Yes, and when you buy them with that designation, you know what you're getting into. The problem occurs when you already own it, and some group is trying to get it labeled as historic, which will add to your burden and limit what you can do with it.

When I was in a small town, this was actually weaponized. A hotel owner was trying to get another hotel categorized as "historic" and had rallied a lot of people behind his cause. He had a case - the hotel did have some claim to being the "first" in some category or other. But really, he was doing it because it was a competitor. The "historic" hotel owner had to spend a lot of money to fight the cause, because being labeled historic would prevent him from performing various upgrades, making the hotel less attractive to customers (he was already not getting many customers).