News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by randyrand on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @04:35PM (#49174712)
Right. But are $200K worth of extra sensors actually worth it or are 10+ cameras already safe enough?

This article makes no attempt to answer the actual meat of the question.

Ultimately, people will vote with their wallet.

p.s. I wonder if you could prevent glare by placing an LCD-like device in front of the lens dynamically blocking out the sun.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by wasabi991011 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:07PM (#49175169)
Where did you get $200k worth of extra sensors?

Also, contrary to your statement, the article directly addresses the meat if the question:

> The disagreement is whether “good enough to help a human drive” ever becomes “good enough to remove the human,” and his answer is no, because the sensing tops out before you get the last few nines.

> Now, Tesla would point to its active Robotaxi service as an example of “removing the human”, but Dolgov also said that camera-only is also good for a demo, and that’s basically what Tesla’s Robotaxi service is right now.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by Animats on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:09PM (#49175182)
LIDAR units are nowhere near that expensive. Even ten years ago, the Velodyne top of car units only cost about $80,000.

The short range ones, found at vehicle corners and on the rear, are now around $200 - $1500. The long range car-top unit is still expensive, around $10,000, and that's dropping. The whole sensor suite on a Waymo is probably under US$20,000 right now. If that.

The future direction for automotive seems to be more car-top sensors with narrower fields of view that add up to a full circle. Only the one that looks ahead needs 300m range.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by parl_match on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:17PM (#49175301)
Current estimates put the Ojai sensor cost between $15k and $30k. My inclination is that there is confusion between BOM and constructed cost.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by curuinor on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @04:41PM (#49174804)
Article has a paragraph about how lidar is rapidly getting cheaper, so the camera comparison is only temporary

Dolgov also pushed back on the one knock that camera-only fans always reach for: cost. Waymo is on its sixth generation of hardware, and he said each generation has drastically cut the price. Betting against sensors like lidar on today’s prices, he warned, means betting on “a number that has a fairly short shelf life.”

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by dgrin91 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @04:51PM (#49174958)
Thats the million (billion? trillion?) dollar question. Will it get cheap enough? Will it get cheap enough to put on 100 million+ vehicles and be competitive with cameras? I honestly don't know the answer, but I haven't seen strong evidence to point to yes.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by parl_match on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:18PM (#49175308)
> Will it get cheap enough?

An Ojai costs less than a mid tier luxury vehicle. Is that not cheap enough?

And the price is only coming down.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by senordevnyc on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:03PM (#49175102)
It’s already there.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by tqi on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @04:52PM (#49174976)
"Ultimately, people will vote with their wallet"

Seems like a bad way to legislate this, since everyone else on the roads pays the price for cut rate self driving

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by randyrand on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @06:37PM (#49176228)
If your goal is to make roads safer then making self driving more expensive and harder to afford will have the opposite effect.

* with prerequisite that "safer than the avg human" is the minimum bar for any system.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ls612 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:03PM (#49175111)
If 2x Mk 1 eyeballs are good enough then I figure cameras can get there too. Or are we going to outlaw that as well because of competitive incentives of Waymo?
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by 9dev on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:11PM (#49175215)
Do you have any conception of how massively, incomprehensibly, extremely superior our sensory system is to any kind of camera-based computer vision we can make?
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ls612 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:17PM (#49175286)
In terms of dynamic range and color space? Yes absolutely. But for driving you don't really need a huge color space and for dynamic range you can just use separate cameras for daytime and nighttime.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by 9dev on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @02:46AM (#49179384)
You're again thinking in terms of image sensors, which is not representative of what your body is able to do. For example, your brain processes signals from all your senses combined, which allows prioritisation of things that trigger multiple senses at once. It also applies pattern matching against millions of years of evolution's worth of information about danger.

But much more importantly, there is all sorts of post-processing happening that is so weird and complex and really a little decoupled from the raw visual information that it's futile to try and compare that to any digital operation you're thinking of in terms of cameras: If you were to look at a still captured from your eyes, you'd see an upside-down image that's only sharp in the very center of the image, blurry and desaturated pretty much everywhere else, grossly so in the corners, with several big black or blurry spots all over.

From that perspective, eyes are awful really. Yet still, your brain manages to turn the stereoscopic vision into a spatial representation, calculate the movement and keep track of other objects relative to you, fill in areas you can't actually see, detect things moving in your peripherals, highlight things of importance, and so much more.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ls612 on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @10:31PM (#49191733)
What senses do you need for driving besides sight and sound? All of the rest of this is just saying "the human brain has a well trained model for objects moving around in meatspace", the replication of which is literally the research project that all autonomous driving companies are trying to solve.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by bigtex88 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:17PM (#49175300)
Tesla fanboys aren't known for logic or rigorous thinking.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by site-packages1 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:28PM (#49175423)
Hi, Elon! Big fan of the Wiki page about your list of predictions for autonomous driving: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_predictions_for_autono...
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ls612 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:29PM (#49175443)
I wish I were as rich as Elon but alas I'm just an ordinary person who appreciates more than one company competing to deploy autonomous driving technology. Appreciate the vitriol though, it tells me a lot about you as a person.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by site-packages1 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:30PM (#49175458)
Excuse me did you just call me a highly corrosive acid made from sulfur dioxide? Reported.

edit: I also want to point out that the fanboys conflate documented evidence in wikipedia of things EM has said with vitriol. It's like when people get banned on social media for hate speech for quoting something the POTUS said.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by tqi on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @06:00PM (#49175808)
Well yeah, have you seen how badly some of you people drive?
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ls612 on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @06:26PM (#49176088)
Even the average human ends up with about 1 fatality every 100 million miles and 1 serious injury every 10 million miles. The typical person will drive somewhere in the six figures of miles in their lifetime.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by tqi on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @10:19AM (#49183316)
What's your point?
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ls612 on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @10:33PM (#49191746)
To point out that even your average human with 2 Mk. 1 eyeballs is not that awful at driving. We can absolutely do better with computers but the baseline is reasonably high.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ed_balls on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:02PM (#49175099)
> Ultimately, people will vote with their wallet.

Nope, you need a regulatory approval, insurance etc. Self driving cars need to be 10x the average driver. So the trillion dollar question is when Lidar will meet all requirements and when camera-only.

1) Both in 2028

2) lidar in 2030 and cameras in 2035

3) Gov will require lidar for full self driving

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by otterley on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:28PM (#49175428)
> Self driving cars need to be 10x the average driver.

Why? So long as they're insured and their owners can be held criminally liable for injuries just as a human driver would be, why does the bar have to be higher?

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by kube-system on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:42PM (#49175594)
Because driving risk is far from evenly distributed. If a self-driving car drives like an average human driver, for responsible drivers, this would mean incurring more risk by getting into one.

A huge portion of the risk of human drivers is due to confounding human factors like negligence, distraction, medical issues, fatigue, etc. Responsible drivers can take most of these factors into their own hands -- not driving while sleepy, not driving drunk, not using their cell phone. These people don't want a vehicle

A better comparison would be comparing the capability of a self-driving car to the skill of a human driver driving under ideal circumstances of health/responsibility/etc.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by otterley on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @08:23PM (#49177080)
We don't measure aggregate risk by discarding a part of the population, even if it's the poorer-performing part.

Even today, you cannot fully avoid this risk: when you get into a vehicle driven by a stranger, you don't know a priori whether the driver is excellent or average. Ideally customer feedback weeds out poor drivers and reduces accident rates, but I'm not privy to data that would prove or disprove whether that actually happens - especially because new drivers join the pool every day.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by kube-system on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @08:57AM (#49182209)
We absolutely can and do mitigate these risks when getting into vehicles driven by strangers: professional drivers typically have higher standards for driving history, and people can physically observe whether a friend/etc is drunk/distracted/etc.

But besides that, the people who are in the socioeconomic demographic to buy an expensive self driving car overlap with the demographic that have lower driving risk. For them, the self-driving car is more dangerous than driving themselves.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by otterley on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @12:44PM (#49185358)
That suggests the comparative bar should be "professional driver," which is perhaps somewhat higher than "average driver" (1.5x? 2x?) but not 10x higher.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by kube-system on Wednesday August 05, 2026 @02:06PM (#49186574)
That sounds reasonable for a practical general regulatory standard.

For a personal standard, it is reasonable that an individual purchaser may use their own risk profile as that standard... as many of the risks involved are not random but can be controlled through choice or are inherently personal. For example, about half of all traffic deaths are due to drowsy or drunk driving.

Accident risk for any given driver is highly distributed. For someone making a marginal choice to purchase a car, the choice they are faced with is choosing between the safety profile of a self-driving car and their own personal risk profile.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by ed_balls on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:59PM (#49175786)
1) Marketing and PR - people fear self driving cars

2) Politics - loss of jobs and urge to ban them - there needs to be a counterargument

3) Government does mandate a lot of safety features. Just insure it wont fly as this is number one risk for everybody.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by foxyv on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @04:55PM (#49175023)
Personally I would rather vote to ban them if they aren't safe enough. If car makers want to cheap out at the expense of public safety they should go to prison for the people they kill.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by randyrand on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @06:49PM (#49176347)
It's not car makers. It's car buyers. When a car buyer cannot afford self driving they'll just drive themselves.

The bar should be safer than a human and as affordable as possible.

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by afavour on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:07PM (#49175161)
Which is why we need strong regulation. People shouldn’t be able to vote with their wallet when other peoples lives are at stake.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by parl_match on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:16PM (#49175274)
> But are $200K worth of extra sensors actually worth it

Of course not!

So, you may be surprised to find that Waymo's sensor package doesn't cost $200k. Whoops!

Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by senordevnyc on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:02PM (#49175100)
You’re like 2-3 orders of magnitude off on your cost there.
Re:Waymo Waymo CEO explains why Tesla's camera-only self-dri... by FireBeyond on Tuesday August 04, 2026 @05:27PM (#49175413)
> I wonder if you could prevent glare by placing an LCD-like device in front of the lens dynamically blocking out the sun.

Elon has already lied, on an investor call, about how such things are not necessary - he referenced how "Tesla cameras can count photons", as a reason why they were not affected by fog, rain, or snow.

Except, no they can't, and they never will be able to. Not the cameras in any Tesla now (and even then). It's a completely different type of camera (and it would do effectively nothing useful from a visualization perspective, let alone functional camera for human viewing). And even if they changed the camera, or added some, well, you can't count photos if you're not in an enclosed space (you know, like the open road).

This is where Elon gets really dangerous, in my mind, he knows enough to be dangerous, he knows what to say that convinces the layperson, or investor, passes the initial sniff test only to dramatically fall over when you investigate.