News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Karpathy's Pelican by reaperducer on Sunday August 02, 2026 @06:09PM (#49148924)
Sure, the task is not completed perfectly, but that's not the point.

Isn't it?

If the computer can't do it better than a human being, then what's the point?

Being wrong at scale is not better than being right.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by matthewfcarlson on Sunday August 02, 2026 @06:25PM (#49149050)
Many humans would struggle with this even with very good tooling (ie not writing raw svg and using illustrator). I struggle to draw a bicycle accurately. But yes, I suspect it will be diminishing returns and I doubt it will ever be perfect due to the average nature of AI but I’d like to be wrong.
Re:Karpathy's Pelican by skydhash on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:31PM (#49149864)
> Many humans would struggle with this even with very good tooling

But no ones hire random humans for things like this. You go and hire a vector artist and they will get your a very good pelican on a a bike. That's how you get things done when you can't do it.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by w4yai on Monday August 03, 2026 @08:48AM (#49155072)
> You go and hire a vector artist

Yeah, but then, you recruit the artist for $XXX - whereas you "recruit" your LLM for $0.XXX for the same task.

Of course the quality difference is huge. But sometimes you don't need that level of quality.

Also, finding a vector artist takes days of communication, payment settlement, revisions, etc.

Not always the most practical solution.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by Buttons840 on Sunday August 02, 2026 @06:57PM (#49149276)
Hugely profitable companies leak half the nation's personal data every month. Tell me more about how being wrong at scale is not valuable.
Re:Karpathy's Pelican by fwlr on Sunday August 02, 2026 @10:47PM (#49150665)
So what if it is more profitable or valuable? It is still not better. Something being more profitable/valuable does not make it better, just like something being better does not make it more profitable/valuable. Sometimes, in some pursuits, for some outputs under some circumstances, the two are correlated. In others, the two are anti-correlated.
Re:Karpathy's Pelican by kelnos on Sunday August 02, 2026 @07:16PM (#49149385)
> If the computer can't do it better than a human being, then what's the point?

It can certainly do it better than I can. Sometimes you don't have a human handy with the required skills to do something.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by nemothekid on Sunday August 02, 2026 @06:27PM (#49149071)
>If the computer can't do it better than a human being, then what's the point?

Because the benchmark wasn't testing "can an LLM draw a pelican like a human". The original article was testing the relative capabilities between LLMs. Now that LLMs can all draw pelicans all similarly, the test is less interesting as a comparative benchmark.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by reaperducer on Sunday August 02, 2026 @06:40PM (#49149171)
Trillions of dollars spent. Trillions of gigawatts consumed. And people still celebrate "Yay! We're less wrong than the other guys!"

This is what the tech industry has become?

Less of a failure is still failure.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by jryle70 on Sunday August 02, 2026 @08:12PM (#49149748)
I don't know how much money has been spent for AI, and I very much doubt you do. Do you know if more has been spent on LLM the last 9 years -- since "Attention is all you need" -- than Internet infrastructure during, say 1995 to 2004? That included the dotcom crash. Did you lament how a failure the Internet was?

LLM has progressed a lot in the last two year, judging from the pelican drawings. I personally couldn't care less about it though. I do know that I've gone from using no AI at all for coding to probably 95%. I hardly code by hand anymore. That's much more impressive and significant. Failure you said?

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by reaperducer on Sunday August 02, 2026 @10:03PM (#49150401)
I don't know how much money has been spent for AI, and I very much doubt you do.

Pick up a newspaper. Start with the Wall Street Journal. These are public companies. It's not a secret.

Re:Karpathy's Pelican by valesco on Sunday August 02, 2026 @06:57PM (#49149272)
That is the software industry. Our product is less bugged than our competitor’s.