News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by pton_xd on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:37PM (#48835678)
I don't understand the EU's position on privacy. On the one hand, they enacted GDPR to give you control over access to your personal data.

On the other, they need access to all of your data.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by joe463369 on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:29PM (#48836362)
The unquestioned view in certain circles - including here - is that when the EU/UK does something that chips away at people's online privacy, there's un ulterior motive.

It's entirely possible that politicians just want to do something about CSAM and young people having their mind twisted by social media. The electorate do seem to be keen on some sort of action.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by budududuroiu on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @04:17PM (#48836908)
Other governments across the Channel also want to protect children online, while at the same time dismissing thousands of reports of grooming, for fear of being labelled "racist".
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by vlian2088 on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:57PM (#48836679)
>It's entirely possible that politicians just want to do something about CSAM

except that honest-to-God child rapists get extremely lenient sentences in Western Europe and rarely (if ever) get deported afterwards.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by joe463369 on Thursday July 09, 2026 @03:01PM (#48850833)
> except that honest-to-God child rapists get extremely lenient sentences in Western Europe and rarely (if ever) get deported afterwards.

Where would you imagine western European rapists could be deported to? Presumably Fred West, Jimmy Savile, Ted Heath, Gary Glitter, Richard Huckle, Ian Watkins, Stewart Hall and Fred Talbot need to be sent back to Pakistan or similar where they learnt their wicked ways. You daft get

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by MaKey on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @05:06PM (#48837427)
This is being heavily pushed by certain actors so it's not just politicians wanting to do something about CSAM: https://balkaninsight.com/2023/09/25/who-benefits-inside-the...

Many abuse survivors and youth advocates strongly oppose Chat Control; here is one voice detailing why: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/why-i-dont-support-privacy-in...

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by laylower on Thursday July 09, 2026 @05:46AM (#48843344)
Ban social media then, don't scan everyone's info. We know it's going to end up in the US. They can't claim to be working for the European project if the implement legislation that entrenches US majors and goes against the interest of their citizens.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by 0dayz on Friday July 10, 2026 @04:17AM (#48857206)
I don't doubt it sort of by why then go through these bizarre loops and secrecy, etc.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by munk-a on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:43PM (#48835748)
The EU's position on privacy seems pretty consistent to me - they're against your data being monetized by private entities but not against building governmental tools to monitor private entities.

In good faith this could be summarized as "Personal data should be used for public safety but not for profit" - but that philosophy is definitely a strong contrast with the basic American philosophy towards civil liberties.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by watwut on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:53PM (#48835894)
> basic American philosophy towards civil liberties.

Errrr, america does not look like country that cares about that. It does care about liberties of rich companies tho.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by inigyou on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:59PM (#48835983)
Exactly, that is the American philosophy being referenced.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by Puts on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:59PM (#48836708)
The thing is that according to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights privacy and the right to private communication is a basic human right. And GDPR was literally enacted to enforce this human right.

Now one basic principle of democracy is that supreme courts are superior to the people in power. Someone needs to watch the lawmakers so to say. Because it could actually be that the European commission enacts laws that are illegal. And Chat Control 2.0 could actually be illegal because it violates the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. However, somebody has to take them to The Court of Justice of the European Union to test it.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by arjie on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:46PM (#48836574)
It seems fairly consistent, doesn't it? CC 2.0 is that the government must be able to access things, and GDPR has a legal basis exemption that is defacto used every time by government entities. The general idea is that private parties cannot consent to things to each other but that residents of a place consent to being governed by the government. e.g. you can't consent to having someone jail you; but you also can't opt out of jail by the government.

Personally, the politics of Europe is really not for me, but I can see why others might find it attractive. In the end, history will show us which path is adaptive.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by ggirelli on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:41PM (#48835719)
Not "access to ALL of your data". Also, as confusing as it might be, it is in the nature of EU (at least IMHO) to not have a clear position over multiple legislatures.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by varispeed on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:42PM (#48836527)
This is a wedge.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by inigyou on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:45PM (#48835779)
The one that passed doesn't give them access to anything. It is different from the scary one.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by mhitza on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:44PM (#48835764)
Maybe big tech weren't good a lobbying bureaucrats against GDPR but got better at lobbying in the EU for this. There's also been a slight shift towards authoritarianism in the last decade, which naturally love the possibilities of stricter communication control.

Children protection and russian propaganda are the tried and tested covers at enforcing age verification, message scanning, and probably any future pan-european surveillance network.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by coldtea on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:27PM (#48836343)
There's no position on privacy. They make whatever laws the corporate laws and elites like, and that furthers their own bureucratic reach. GDPR is a good way to create a "compliance moat" against smaller players, and to give the EU bureucrats more power.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by bossyTeacher on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:02PM (#48836020)
It is simple. GDPR is aimed at private entities misusing your data. Keyword private.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by spwa4 on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:27PM (#48836345)
Not even that. The government outsources a lot of their functions, so a LOT of organizations have access to extremely private data, where necessary.

For example, Palantir gets access to "large and diverse (government) databases with Dutch citizens’ data for analysis" (including mental health treatment data) under the GPDR to help police in the Netherlands do terror investigations (from 2012 to 2019). I'm sure you can appreciate the wisdom and privacy-enhancement in that just as much as me!

There are large lists of private organizations that get access to government data about citizens ... every country has multiple (public and secret ones).

Oh, they also "failed to mention" this to parliament, and this was only discovered after a journalist got a tipoff and requested financial data about the deal ... for about 5 years. Of course, there was never even the slightest investigation into this.

https://nltimes.nl/2025/08/22/dutch-police-also-use-controve...

(paywalled) https://www.volkskrant.nl/tech/ook-nederlandse-politie-gebru...

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:44PM (#48835768)
I think the position can best be approximated as "companies should not be able to do this, but you should trust your government to do this to you". (That's a bad position that needs to be defeated every time it arises, but it's a consistent position.)
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by sscaryterry on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:51PM (#48835859)
Given the choice of trust between, lets say Amazon/Meta/Google and the EU (or some European government), 9 times out of 10, the EU is the lesser evil.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by Cider9986 on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:08PM (#48836096)
You don't have to use Amazon/Meta/Google. You have to use the government.

Let's not forget that these are the people and laws that are supposed to represent and help you, not the other way around. While private companies have no such obligation.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by sscaryterry on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:14PM (#48836173)
Amazon/Meta/Google is sometimes required, nobody in the real world can get away from that.

> supposed to represent and help you, not the other way around. While private companies have no such obligation.

Exactly my point.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by vrganj on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:19PM (#48836250)
I've moved countries 5 times in my life. I still haven't been able to fully degoogle.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by liveoneggs on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:26PM (#48836322)
For now none of Amazon, Meta, or Google can jail you or legally do violence on you, separate you from your family, etc. Your sense of threat is extremely miscalibrated.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by sscaryterry on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:33PM (#48836408)
Not really. I know what you are playing at. The probability of the government being vindictive towards a single family, whilst not truly zero, is for almost all practical purposes zero.

The probability of a (my or your) child enduring harmful content, perpetuated and enabled by Meta/Google (in particular) is almost a certainty.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @02:56PM (#48835956)
We are not required to pick amongst evils. We could, in fact, say private chats are private and end to end encryption is sacrosanct.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by sscaryterry on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:15PM (#48836182)
If you are purist and you don't live in the real world with real evils. I don't want pedophiles to have privacy.
Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by john_strinlai on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:19PM (#48836241)
>I don't want pedophiles to have privacy.

that is why police already have access to mechanisms to remove privacy from people suspected of being a pedophile.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by sscaryterry on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:34PM (#48836427)
The existing mechanisms are inadequate or not fit for 2026. Hence this discussion.

You are agreeing with me :)

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by john_strinlai on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:35PM (#48836432)
>You are agreeing with me :)

i am absolutely not :)

you want to provide unfettered warrantless access to all of your communications. ive been fighting against that sort of thing for approaching 40 years now.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by sscaryterry on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @04:06PM (#48836781)
> have access to mechanisms to remove privacy from people suspected of being a pedophile

I don't understand that part then. You can't break open E2EE by willing it open.

Right now, if I wanted a new account, I walk into any supermarket, spend a quid, and I've got a burner, with WhatsApp.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by john_strinlai on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @04:08PM (#48836811)
>I don't understand that part then. You can't break open E2EE by willing it open.

the mechanism to remove privacy from suspects is typically called a warrant.

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by BoingBoomTschak on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @04:07PM (#48836801)
After Epstein, Hollywood and decades earlier Dutroux, you'd think people like you would have wizened.

For fuck's sake, my country's entire media/intellectual class protected an avowed and even boasting pedophile during his entire life! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabriel_Matzneff

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by john_strinlai on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @03:16PM (#48836205)
what a crazy turning of the tides to see this comment in the gray.

i suppose the times have changed from when most people on the internet were cypherphunk. now it's common to see people say "i have nothing to hide, please scan all of my communications", unironically invoking "please think of the children".

Re:EU now one step away from reviving private message scanni... by nurumaik on Wednesday July 08, 2026 @09:30PM (#48839812)
Very clear position: they want absolute control over both companies and citizens