News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by solid_fuel on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @04:51PM (#48739034)
Here is the full text of the relevant section of the 14th:

> All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

Please point to the section where it says "this only applies if the parents are citizens".

The reading which the court affirmed is incredibly obvious. Republicans and xenophobes like to pretend it isn't, but the text is very simple.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by cco on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @05:47PM (#48739667)
The word jurisdiction is where it gets confusing. The meaning of that word does not map 1:1 to its modern usage.

To wit, if we read it as "subject to the laws of the land", then the invading army exception does not make sense, invading soldiers are subject to the laws of the United States and have been tried and convinced of violating them. Note, diplomat exception still makes sense, they _are not_ subject to the laws of the land.

So, how do you define jurisdiction in this amendment in a way that covers both invading soldiers and diplomats? I don't think it is super straightforward.

To put good faith on the table, I ultimately agree with your opinion here that birthright citizenship is settled and the vast majority of folks arguing against it are doing so in bad faith. But I also recognize the text of the amendment has holes to my eyes and could be updated for clarity.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by rayiner on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @06:00PM (#48739806)
It doesn’t cover diplomats either because courts do have jurisdiction over diplomats for certain non-criminal matter.

> vast majority of folks arguing against it are doing so in bad faith

What’s “bad faith” about it?

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by HelloMcFly on Thursday July 02, 2026 @01:14PM (#48764486)
In my view: the lack of engagement with the historical record. This topic - and the meaning and expected outcomes of the wording for the amendment - were discussed and debated as part of the open record. Senator Cowan thought the phrasing created a loophole for birthright citizenship, and the amendment creators explicitly, overtly, repeatedly agreed with his interpretation of the phrasing and defended it as deliberate policy.

As I posted elsewhere, you can read some of this for yourself: https://global.oup.com/us/companion.websites/libertyandjusti... (CTRL+F "If my friend from Pennsylvania" for a quite pertinent line).

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by solid_fuel on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @08:34PM (#48741063)
> To wit, if we read it as "subject to the laws of the land", then the invading army exception does not make sense, invading soldiers are subject to the laws of the United States and have been tried and convinced of violating them. Note, diplomat exception still makes sense, they _are not_ subject to the laws of the land.

I don't agree with your assertion here. Do you have more details on the claim that "invading soldiers [...] have been tried and convinced of violating them [US Laws]"?

As I understand it, invading soldiers are not subject to the laws of the United States nor are they protected by the bill of rights - instead they are enemy combatants and subject to military force. You don't arrest and charge active combatants, you fight them. If they surrender they become prisoners of war and would be covered under the treaties that apply to POWs, not civilian laws. They don't become citizens by surrendering.

I suspect the gray area would be around terrorists and stateless combatants, but the general principle that "people who are operating under the orders of a foreign government are not subject to the laws of the united states, but rather bound by the treaties between the US and their foreign state" would still apply.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by jkubicek on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @09:41PM (#48741450)
> I suspect the gray area would be around terrorists

Maybe this is a gray area in theory, but practically speaking I don't think it matters. The child has nothing to do with the parent's choices in life, do they deserve to be treated any differently than any other child born in the US?

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @05:13PM (#48739272)
Opposing demographic change explicitly is wrongthink, so it comes out sideways in other dimensions that in isolation appear illogical.

If opposing demographic change explicitly was allowed by the current moral programming (not accepted by the majority necessarily just an allowed opinion), I don’t think anyone would be arguing about the interpretation of this.

A lot of modern political issues follow this same pattern.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by solid_fuel on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @05:28PM (#48739453)
You're talking in circles here. Please, use your big person words. Say what you mean explicitly.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @05:39PM (#48739565)
I did say what I mean explicitly. I'm not expressing a personal view in coded language, I'm explaining my theory for the psychology behind what you mentioned.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by Supermancho on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @08:14PM (#48740918)
> I did say what I mean explicitly.

> it comes out sideways in other dimensions > current moral programming

Not one of these words holds meaning in context. If it were only the phrases, there might be some grounded message. Each word and phrase seems to be code for a concept attached to your specific mental model.

People tend not to have discussions with other people who cannot grasp what they are, or are not, saying.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Sunday July 05, 2026 @03:16PM (#48797081)
Hmm I suppose that’s fair. Another commenter did seem to understand what I’m saying, but he may have a more similar background to myself.

Coming out sideways is a common phrase in psychology land, or at least this is my impression. It refers to when a feeling cannot be expressed directly due to repression, and so the feeling comes out a different way. For example instead of feeling crushing shame about being wrong (due to past experiences of being shamed when wrong), a person gets angry at the person suggesting they are wrong, even though they are actually wrong and it wouldn’t be a big deal at that time to just admit it.

Moral programming I thought was self explanatory. Where do you think morality comes from? Different groups in space and time have had different moralities, and children have whatever morality they are consistently exposed to growing up. It does get complicated if they are exposed to multiple moralities simultaneously, they are still programmed but it is more of an RNG in that case (e.g. Christianity at home but progressivism at school, the apparently socially dominant flavor typically wins but not always). Our current moral programming includes a lot of aspects about race and nationalism, and so people have difficulty thinking clearly in this area and sometimes when they internally disagree with the morality they are still unable to express that disagreement directly and so it comes out sideways as awkwardly critiquing some specific language in the constitution or whatever is happening this week about it.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @06:20PM (#48740018)
I agree with the phenomenon but dont thinnk that is the case here. I know lots of people that have no issue loudly oposing demograpic change that still stumble on the issue of how to read constitutional text.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @06:47PM (#48740246)
My point is that I don't think anyone would be focusing on this particular constitutional text if the underlying reason they are focused on it were allowed to be discussed in the open. It sounds like you don't disagree with that? Do you logically agree but you feel like it must be wrong somehow? Moral programming do be like that.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @07:15PM (#48740476)
I agree that people use convouted rationalizations to justify the outcomes they want when their actual preferences are taboo to state outright. I thought you were accusing the SCOTUS of doing that, which I disagreed with.

I agree the public discussion is more charged and less coherent because some people are trying to project their taboo moral stances on to dry and boring question of textual interpretation.

That said, I think this case isnt the best example. I think there are lots of people who question if children of tourists or illegal enterants of the US should be given automatic citizenship, even without buying into demographic preferences.

[dead]
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @06:20PM (#48740015)
Why are you being so rude? Please don't put words in my mouth, that is nothing like what I believe.

My views are something like what the average American believed in 1910. Were they literally Hitler also?

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by vel0city on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @07:51PM (#48740743)
1910's America with Jim Crow segregation, pre-Womens suffrage, pretty much peak wealth inequality with robber barrons?
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by erxam on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @06:58PM (#48740335)
> My views are something like what the average American believed in 1910. Were they literally Hitler also?

That's not really a great counterpoint considering how much inspiration Nazi Germany took from the amazing levels of racism the US had. Jim Crow, miscegenation, segregation, citizenship…

The average American in 1910 wasn't a little Hitler, he was a Big Hitler. Hitler's father, even.

Good try, though, eierkuchen. I can see past you and so can everyone else.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by ceejayoz on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @06:53PM (#48740304)
America had a pretty decent sized fascist movement in the early 1900s.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @04:28AM (#48743779)
“Average”, son. Was the average American a fascist in the early 1900s?

The fascist party in the early 1900s was a fringe party. It existed and was considered a legitimate opinion, fine, but don’t act like the average American was anywhere near fascist.

What in gods name would blood and soil even mean when you’ve got Italians living next to Irish living next to Poles living next to English? You haven’t got any blood to fascism about!

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by ceejayoz on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @09:11AM (#48746163)
> You haven’t got any blood to fascism about!

Like that stops people. Hitler hardly matched his own Aryan ideal.

> Was the average American a fascist in the early 1900s? … The fascist party in the early 1900s was a fringe party.

That’s equally true about Germany. As the sibling comment notes, it’s the era of Jim Crow and the female half of the country can’t even vote.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by throwawaypath on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @11:20AM (#48748347)
America had a pretty decent sized communist movement in the early 1900s.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by solid_fuel on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @04:48PM (#48752912)
People are being rude because you're being a dumbass.

> My views are something like what the average American believed in 1910.

The question of birthright citizenship was settled law for 40 years by the 1910s, so this is - unsurprisingly - a lie.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by pfannkuchen on Sunday July 05, 2026 @07:57PM (#48799210)
My entire point in this thread has been that nobody actually cares about birthright citizenship itself and it is a vector to oppose demographic change, which itself is not an allowed discussion topic.

So, for me to hold the views of an American in 1910 on this topic, I would be opposed to non-Europeans becoming a majority in America. Where is the lie? I never said anything about being anti birthright citizenship. You sir are morally triggered and cannot think clearly in this area.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by MisterMower on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @10:24PM (#48741650)
Members of American Indian tribes were born in the United States after the 14th amendment was passed but it took an act of Congress to make them citizens. The question of jurisdiction is a very real one that isn’t nearly as cut and dry as you’re implying it to be.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by matthewdgreen on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @08:22AM (#48745552)
You're trying to impute complexity to a thing in order to achieve a goal that is not achievable. The 1866 Congress that debated the amendment understood and intended that Indian tribal nations would not be covered by the clause because they were separate nations not under the jurisdiction of US law. Here's an example of the debate [1] where they discuss it. Far from making your point, examples like this make it obvious that everyone involved in framing the amendment thought deeply about what "jurisdiction" meant, which is why you can't just assign new meaning like "yeah it means parents have to be citizens."

I really urge you to read the original debate. It isn't like the handwritten notes we get from the 1700s; it's typewritten and the Senators are so thoughtful and utterly precise about what they meant. It's ELI12.

[1] https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc30867/m1/12...

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by dnemmers on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @12:45PM (#48749679)
Have you read through that link?

I'm not taking a side here, but it injects a couple more words that could imply something else:

[Mr. Howard] (Sen. from MI)

"This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory as what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States.

This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of embassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons.

It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States."

(Apologies for any typos as this was hand written.)

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by matthewdgreen on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @03:20PM (#48751856)
What are the confusing words? You gave a quote that sums up the long-accepted understanding of who's exempt from the citizenship clause:

"This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of embassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons."

They don't mention Indian tribes in that quote, but they mention it elsewhere. Seems completely clear to me.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by dnemmers on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @01:07PM (#48750041)
An additional section from the page provided that I found odd:

[Mr. Cowan] (Sen from PA)

"So far as the courts and the administration of the laws are concerned, I have supposed that every human being within their jurisdiction was in one sense of the word a citizen, that is, a person entitled to protection; but in so far as the right to hold property, particularity the right to acquire title to real estate, was concerned, that was a subject entirely within the control of the States.

It has been so considered in the state of Pennsylvania; and aliens and those who acknowledge no other allegiance, either to the State, or to the General Government, may be limited and circumscribed in that manner.

I have supposed, further, that it was essential to the existence of society itself, and particularly essential to the existence of a free State, that it should have the power, not only of declaring who should exercise political power within its boundaries, but that if it were overrun by another and a different race, it would have the right to absolutely expel them."

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by dnemmers on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @02:02PM (#48750834)
I kept reading pages, and there's plenty of other questionable conclusions:

[Mr. Conness] (Sen. CA)

(Acclaimed for his pro-Chinese immigration views.

Wiki: "In the Senate debate on the 14th Amendment, Conness said “We are entirely ready to accept the provision proposed in this constitutional amendment, that the children begotten of Chinese parents in California … shall be citizens.”

from the link:

"Now, I will say, for the benefit of my friend, that he may know something about the Chinese in future, that this portion of our population, namely, the children of Mongolian parentage, born in California, is very small indeed, and never promises to be large, notwithstanding our near neighborhood to the Celestial land. The habits of those people, and their religion, appear to demand that they all return to their own country at some time or other, either alive or dead. There are, perhaps, in California today about forty thousand Chinese--from forty to forty-five thousand. Those persons return invariably, while others take their places, and, as I before observed, if they do not return alive their bones are carefully gathered up and sent back to the Flowery Land. It is not an unusual circumstance that the clipper ships trading between San Francisco and China carry at a time three or four hundred human remains of these Chinese. When interred in our State they are not interred deep in the earth, but laid very near the surface, and then mounds of earth are laid over them, so that the process of dis-interment is very easy. That is their habit and custom; and as soon as they are fit for transmission to their own country they are taken up with great regularly and sent there. None of the bones are allowed to remain. They will return, then, either living or dead. "

(Sadly the site is now offline.)

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by matthewdgreen on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @03:19PM (#48751843)
There's nothing terribly confusing here. In fact it's a helpful set of quotes. This is one Senator saying "hey, second-generation Chinese immigrants will be citizens. And that's fine because I don't think there will be too many of them."
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by MisterMower on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @04:16PM (#48752539)
Can you link to the portion of the debate where everyone agreed on what “under the jurisdiction of” means?

The issue was contentious then as it is now. They wouldn’t have spilled so much ink on the topic if it wasn’t. Your link is proving my point.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by matthewdgreen on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @05:37PM (#48753473)
Sure, I already did explain it. They explicitly said that "not under the jurisdiction" would cover children belonging to Indian tribes, the children of ambassadors, and they discussed the need to be able to expel occupying armies. Someone said "what about the kids of Chinese people" and the sponsors said "yep, if we adopt this language they'll get to be citizens too".

None of it's complicated. You could read this as an 8th grader and have no doubt what they were trying to do.

Most of the discussion was of the form "hey, could we add an exception to exclude even more people from citizenship" and then the sponsors would say something like, "yes, we agree that those people aren't excluded under the current language; that adding extra language could exclude those people; and that we don't want to exclude those people or change the language." And then Congress voted for the language exactly as it was originally proposed.

Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by jhhh on Tuesday June 30, 2026 @10:44PM (#48741724)
What in the dissenting opinions definition of jurisdiction did you disagree with?
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi... by whateveracct on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @02:08AM (#48742881)
literally on the tin