It's more about the level of abstraction. If AI handles 80% of the grunt work and I spend my time on architecture and reviews that's still a win
Consider the people younger than you. Who are literally shutting their brain off so AI can cheat on their essays and exams. They aren't going to be good architects or code reviewers.
There will always be proficient programmers who can read and write good as good as yourself. I have 0 reason to believe programmers coming out of University today are any less competent than when you came out of University.
They are absolutely getting worse. Ask a teacher, at any level.
If you don't know what a good or a bad approach to any problem is because you've never actually had to solve it, you can't even know what being a proficient programmer means, so how could you hope to be one?
Rational takeaway is to step back and analyse what's really happening here.
- Are we really in for a crash?
- What does it say about the culture and people's mental models that we have two radically opposing viewpoints on AI costs and people still arrive at same conclusion?
>- Are we really in for a crash?
The question you should really be asking is, is AI really overvalued, or is it so useful it justifies all the hype that surrounds it? If the former, then yes, a crash is inevitable, because we don't live in the land of make-believe. If a crash never happens then AI was not overvalued, it was valued appropriately.
I'm not sure that's something to rely on. I would be Fable 5 will be phased out and the bleeding edge will be priced up.
My desire for the latest and greatest continues on, but my need for it in order to get any value out of it at all is much, much smaller. The in-practice delta between all the versions since 4.5 have been much more subtle than, say, the models available a year before Opus 4.5 and Opus 4.5.
The bleeding edge is going to have to earn its price delta. They can't count on me wanting to upgrade just to get something halfway decent anymore.
The problem is rather, I think, that people always want to use the latest and greatest models. And that training is super expensive.
Potentially we’ll just see less new model releases.
Weird, why didn't my subscriptions decrease in price then? Oh wait..
Theoretically, there's a lot of room for marginal work where developer time isn't worth the cost for the output but tokens are cheap enough to make it worthwhile. Very little of that work ends up being customer facing though, so it isn't actually a growth opportunity for the company.
Sure, you can use AI to potentially replace software engineers, but the F500 are also terrified of not having accountability or making mistakes. They won't be firing any engineers. In that scenario, there's just no room for AI usage. If you have to be responsible for all the code, then... AI has to either manage it completely autonomously (which even Fable can't) or... humans have to be in the loop which means they still have to understand the code. The best way to understand the code is to write the code yourself. So there's no productivity gain to be had.
I'm pro-AI, but I think we're due for a big crash next year.