News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by JSR_FDED on Sunday June 21, 2026 @08:19PM (#48624002)
How much death and suffering does this guy have on his conscience?

I’m so curious how someone goes from being a professor to a science denier? I simply can’t imagine that journey.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by phyzix5761 on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:16AM (#48625609)
I imagine at some point, after earnestly trying to help the American people with real science, these people get tired of working thankless jobs where they're up against monstrous bureaucracy and just want to do something that benefits themselves and their families. Sadly, and in part because our society rarely rewards beneficial work the way it does exploitation, these people find the path of least resistance to be this kind of journey.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by Gud on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:30AM (#48625679)
Or perhaps he never did give a fuck?
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by xetera on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:01AM (#48626710)
This seems a lot more plausible to me
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by phyzix5761 on Monday June 22, 2026 @05:13AM (#48627734)
We take comfort in fantasizing about a black and white world and condemn others without trying to understand what drove them to act this way. If, perhaps, we could understand the underlying causes we could remove them and prevent as much evil from arising in the future. But we first have to admit that cause and effect is real and applies to human behavior.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by bluecheese452 on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:28AM (#48628279)
Dude just stop.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by hilariously on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:24AM (#48629215)
Cause? We don't care. Effect? We all are sicker and closer to the grave because these ghouls are preying on us. We don't care about the justifications for murdering the collective for personal gain, its just treason to humanity plain and simple.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by phyzix5761 on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:57PM (#48635228)
I 100% agree that this is terrible, they're doing it for personal gain, and its treason against humanity. All I'm saying is there are underlying causes that drive people to do these things. If we can understand them maybe we can change those causes so it doesn't happen again in the future. I think any sensible person would agree that a future with less of these kinds of experiences is better for everyone.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by idiotsecant on Sunday June 21, 2026 @11:56PM (#48625471)
I can definitely imagine it. It becomes so much easier to not worry about it when you have a comfortable pillow made out of lots and lots of money to rest your head on.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by pwarner on Sunday June 21, 2026 @08:55PM (#48624272)
The suffering is the point.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by dboreham on Sunday June 21, 2026 @10:33PM (#48624944)
Also interesting that there can be a giant asshole running a federal agency into the ground and I've never heard of him until now. Gives some scale to the problem. I also wonder what else is going on in government that falls below the widely reportable threshold.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by idiotsecant on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:08AM (#48625552)
It's like saying that one of the seagulls at the beach is particularly noisy.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by api on Sunday June 21, 2026 @09:02PM (#48624326)
Death and suffering are “natural.”

These people are all delusional ideologues. If reality does not match the ideology, reality must be wrong.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by bickfordb on Sunday June 21, 2026 @09:19PM (#48624450)
Results are fuzzy. He has a nice Malibu compound to go to after this lived experience
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by blindriver on Sunday June 21, 2026 @11:54PM (#48625451)
It's really weird how many in HN such as you don't like Vinay Prasad.

He is 100% data driven. He has no ideology behind any of his beliefs or decisions, it's all 100% data driven. He should be worshipped by HN but instead he is vilified because many people on HN are the ones motivated by ideology or politics.

The decision to block Moderna's application was simple, they were comparing their results against a lower-dosage flu shot which no one in that age range (65+) takes.

Moderna agreed to add a comparison for the higher dose for older patients and then the application was allowed through. Why is this bad?

The media framed it as if the FDA backtracked but that's a complete lie, Moderna modified their application because Prasad looked at the study and rejected it because it was purposefully giving itself easier goal posts. He did EXACTLY what we want, which is don't make it easier for drug companies to give us bullshit, and to make sure that the drugs are doing what they say they are.

The loss of Prasad is a real loss for Americans.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by SeanLuke on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:07AM (#48625542)
Note that Prasad didn't reject their application: he prevented Moderna from even applying. Prasad overrode a phalanx of FDA career scientists who had studied and approved Moderna's study approach and were ready to review it. He did so suddenly and without warning: the FDA up to that point had not raised any concerns about Moderna's trial protocol. He didn't cite any safety or efficacy issues.

This wasn't the only time he stepped in and overrode experts with seemingly no justification. Just the most prominent example.

I think it's good he's gone.

[dead]
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by Arainach on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:48AM (#48625809)
> Don't create accounts routinely. HN is a community—users should have an identity that others can relate to.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by awakeasleep on Sunday June 21, 2026 @11:57PM (#48625477)
Is there a similar story behind that huntingtons therapy?
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by idiotsecant on Monday June 22, 2026 @12:07AM (#48625541)
He's the opposite of data driven. Moderna did in fact include several studies together encompassing over 40 thousand patients over a diverse demographic group. In fact, they designed the study program only after the approval of the FDA was already given for it. It's a perfectly normal drug trial. This guy wanted his name in headlines and so he decided to just go ahead with 'vaccine bad' against the will of literally every expert the FDA employs to make these recommendations.

This guy got fired for a good reason - he's an idiot.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by OrvalWintermute on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:30AM (#48626066)
There is a huge amount of Ad Hominem vitriol directed at him currently on HN, and as someone that is vaccine skeptical for a number of reasons, this is seeming a bit like an echo chamber.

When did asking for better evidence, or bringing up side effects, or Absolute Risk, suddenly become things that we cannot discuss on HN?

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by kstrauser on Monday June 22, 2026 @01:38AM (#48626138)
1. That's not what ad hominem means. You can legitimately criticize people for their actions. All I see here are people saying his actions are wrong and incongruous with fact-based science.

2. There's nothing whatsoever wrong about asking questions. It becomes wrong when refusing to listen to the answers and dismissing all the ones you don't like because you don't like the person saying them. Ironically, that's ad hominem.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by antirealist on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:47AM (#48627045)
I think there are two parts of this issue. One is does the vaccine work. The other is should the govt prevent people from having it.

Scepticism is healthy, and I don't begrudge you your scepticism. The scientific consensus can be wrong, especially for issues like this where debates get heated.

But I think that's an argument for 'let people do what they want' rather than 'prevent them from doing what mainstream science seems to think is the best action'.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by joxdosba on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:05AM (#48626746)
> and as someone that is vaccine skeptical for a number of reasons

Your point of view is not legitimate, and you deserve to be ridiculed wherever you go.

> When did asking for better evidence, or bringing up side effects, or Absolute Risk, suddenly become things that we cannot discuss on HN?

Because vaccine skeptics do not engage honestly on these things, they wouldn’t be vaccine skeptics if they did.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by boxed on Monday June 22, 2026 @03:21AM (#48626861)
Vaccine skepticism is on the same level as flat earthism. This is not an insult to your person, but this is the reality of the science. Trading a 0.1 micromort risk once for a 1000 micromort risk over your lifetime is a crazy good deal. Put another way: that's trading ~6 minutes for ~24 days of life. You do that for every vaccine. Some vaccines have worse trades depending on your situation, and some are far better trades.

Look at these stats: https://boxed.github.io/micromort/?q=vaccine&scale=log&sel=v...

Note the LOG scale! You can switch to a linear scale, but then you can't even see there are multiple vaccine adverse risk data points, as they all collapse to one dot compared the the huge risks of the diseases they prevent.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by modo_mario on Monday June 22, 2026 @04:11AM (#48627241)
>Trading a 0.1 micromort risk once for a 1000 micromort risk

I think like with that person that found their cancer to have some dna from an mrna vaccine in it the issue is when the prominent messaging is that there is no 0.1 micromort risk. There is no risk whatsoever and everyone who says so is a looney. Immediately you'll have thousands who say i told you so and harden their conviction.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by fabian2k on Monday June 22, 2026 @04:37AM (#48627444)
The COVID19 vaccines were the most-discussed vaccines ever. And there was an enormous amount of coverage for the potential side effects. Recommendations were adjusted based on new data.

There was also bad communication on the topic, often when politicians got involved or due to outdated information continued to be repeated. But there certainly was a lot of public discussion about the risks of the vaccines, they were simply vastly outnumbered by the benefits of the vaccines.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by boxed on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:38AM (#48628345)
It didn't help that the AstraZeneca vaccine was fairly bad all things considered. At roughly 3 micromort according to the latest data it's quite a lot of risk for a modern vaccine actually. Now, compared to getting Covid it's still better. Even for a 10 year old the covid risk is ~20 micromort and we don't recommend vaccines for that group. Which seems a bit bonkers when you consider that trading 20 for 3 is clearly a good choice, it's just that anti-vaccine loonies make politicians scared out of their minds, so they will rather have lots of kids dying than a few kids dying from vaccines.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by modo_mario on Monday June 22, 2026 @08:41AM (#48629379)
I suspect the issue is in part also just selfishness.

That 20 is in large part the kid that was brought into the hospital too late if at all. The kid that might have had astma or what have you.

The 3 is potentially yours or one in your family or friend group or community. It is a government mandated death and you might already distrust the gov.

A tragic event vs an authoritarian death inflicted upon you from that perspective.

My grandma is a scientist presumably very familiar with all this stuff but when her partner (not my grandpa) died from a bloodcloth shortly after getting an vaccine she also veered into that territory.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by boxed on Monday June 22, 2026 @11:06AM (#48631226)
> It is a government mandated death and you might already distrust the gov.

Well.. no. It was a government RECOMMENDED death at the most.

In fact, it's even more stupid. Sweden for example were so deadly afraid of anti-vaxxers that they threw away tens of thousands of doses of AstraZenecas vaccine. The one with 2 deaths per million. At the time it was estimated at 5 per million. Sweden has a population of 10 million. So if we instantly vaccinated the entire population we would see 2 deaths. While this decision to throw away doses was done we lost tens per day. And the government didn't allow those who understood math to take this if they wanted. No. They mandated the deaths. THOSE deaths WERE mandated. For real.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by modo_mario on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @10:46AM (#48660780)
Oh I know but disease is an abstract entity one can't directly address with scorn, to be held liable for direct action, etc. The government is and inaction draws less attention.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by boxed on Thursday June 25, 2026 @02:54AM (#48669890)
Ok? But there was no moral outrage from anyone except me when the Swedish government unilaterally made this medical decision that statistically killed a lot of people. So obviously that idea that the government is held liable isn't really true either.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by boxed on Monday June 22, 2026 @06:34AM (#48628319)
> There is no risk whatsoever and everyone who says so is a looney.

No. Lying about the risks is what got us in this mess. There IS a risk. It's just crazy low. https://boxed.github.io/micromort/?q=vaccine&scale=log These are the real risks. Yellow Fever vaccine is the worst with ~7 micromort risk. That's roughly your baseline risk just by living for 7 hours. It's not a lot, but saying it's zero is false, and lying about shit is how you radicalize people.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by AlexeyBelov on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @01:43AM (#48655637)
> Vaccine skepticism is on the same level as flat earthism

Their bio: "Christian // Father // Husband // Veteran"

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by oatmeal1 on Monday June 22, 2026 @02:31AM (#48626517)
The toxicity leveled when there is a difference of opinion between scientists is astounding.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by no-name-here on Monday June 22, 2026 @05:11AM (#48627717)
Is it reasonable to describe this as a “difference of opinion between scientists”? Per the OP article:

* it was a Trump political appointee who had made a “shocking” decision to not even review the vaccine

* it was despite the objections of the subject matter experts and career scientists

* it was despite the submitted study results being exactly what the FDA had previously approved

* the vote to go the opposite direction of him was unanimous

I mean sure, you could find an odd scientist who doesn't believe in something that 99.999% of scientists agree on, appoint them as the political head of an agency to overrule the 99.999% of scientists, and call that a “difference of opinion between scientists”, but…

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by oatmeal1 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:31AM (#48640720)
You identify the potential bias of only one side here. The revolving door between regulators and industry introduces potential biases of others in the opposite direction.

If Prasad approved of the trial design and later decided it was insufficient then I would see things differently.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by jmye on Monday June 22, 2026 @09:08AM (#48629649)
This is not a "difference of opinion" and framing it as such is intentionally and egregiously dishonest.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by oatmeal1 on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:32AM (#48640724)
More histrionics.
Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by jmye on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:20AM (#48646467)
Ah, you're one of those - any disagreement and all you can do is complain about the other person's emotional state. Did you think you were saying something to add value, here? Did you think this was a cutting, insightful comment?

Come on, make your buddies proud, "umadbro" me, next.

Re:FDA advisors unanimously vote to approve Moderna's mRNA a... by jfengel on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @03:36PM (#48650207)
How much death and suffering does this guy have on his conscience?

His what now?